Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this too much food for 5 people on Xmas day?

393 replies

Hoiz · 20/12/2023 15:55

Breakfast
Pret frozen croissants
Cinnamon rolls
Coffee
Bucks Fizz

Houer D'oeuvres
Pigs in blanket (American style)
Chorizo and Scallops
Salmon and Cod Roe Blinis
Garlic Prawns
Caeser Salad skewer

Main Meal
Stuffed Chicken Joint
Roast Potatoes
Mash
Dauphinoise Potatoes
Honey Carrots
Bacon and Broccoli
Parsnips
Brussel Sprouts
Cabbage
Pigs in blanket
Stuffing balls
Yorkshire pudding
Onion Gravy
Plain Gravy

Dessert
Sticky Toffee Pudding and Ice cream
Xmas Pudding
Yule Log
Cheese Platter
Mince Pies

Dinner
Leftovers

Drinks
Champagne
Wine
Bucks Fizz
Spicy Margharitas

Someone in the group is insisting on a starter but they have agreed to taking responsibility. TBC.

This will all be homemade (apart from pastries in morning and ice cream) so it’s a lot of work - 2 main people doing it. A third person will likely pitch in a fair amount.

Is it a normal amount of food? First year hosting but any less would not be what my family is used to. But I’m doing a lot more homemade stuff whereas in previous years some of the snack stuff and desserts would be M and S.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Retiredfromearlyyears · 21/12/2023 20:13

Wowed! What time is dinner?? That's a lot of food for 5 people. That will feed you all again on Boxing Day! Enjoy but don't overdo it.

PatienceOfEngels · 21/12/2023 20:11

That is a lot of food (and work) for 5 people.

I'd cut to one type of potato, 3 veg, 1 gravy, no Yorkies for your main.
5 different hors d'œuvres seems OTT, just pick 2 or do a proper starter.
2 dessert choices instead of 5.
Maybe use the hor d'oevres for tea with a cheese plate and one dessert.

Lincslady53 · 21/12/2023 20:02

Yes, that is too much. If you invite me and DH we will help with the surplus. 😁

Jeannie88 · 21/12/2023 19:50

We do 3 courses and that's more than enough! Perhaps you could cut down the amount of servings, just too much food and stress so yes, this is wonderful but unnecessary IMO. X

Ilovecleaning · 21/12/2023 19:45

Sounds great. I like to make sure people have plenty to eat. I can’t stand offering miserly little portions. It’s Christmas so give them a feast. And your guests will have plenty to nibble on later - pigs in blanket, cold turkey etc..

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 21/12/2023 19:36

5 of us this year. Normal breakfasts. Roast beef with yorkies, roast potatoes, carrots, parsnips, sprouts & pancetta, cabbage, broccoli and cauliflower cheese. Gravy, obviously. 2x dessert options, one homemade one bought. Sandwiches for tea. Picky bits about if anyone wants it.

Yours sounds delicious but too much work for 5 people.

inappropriateraspberry · 21/12/2023 19:30

All of us saying how much good that is - what if she is only planning to make a cereal bowl of each food? Then we'd be disappointed 😆!

GeeEss · 21/12/2023 19:27

Not much meat for 5 unless the chicken is a capon. Too many veg. I’d skip the canapés if you’re eating breakfast and dinner is 1:30. Sounds good though.

August1980 · 21/12/2023 19:25

Hmm. How lovely you are. This is really nice to cater for everyone’s likes. It might be a bit much but I get extra greedy on Christmas Day and eat stuff I won’t normally eat. Is it waste you are worried about… I could be around in flash…

Lovemusic82 · 21/12/2023 19:24

SharonEllis · 21/12/2023 19:14

I can't imagine making, or eating all that. Or even having room in my kitchen (& I have a pretty big kitchen) I love Christmas dinner and the beauty of it is its a simple meal, following time honoured tradition where focussing on fewer dishes means they are more likely to be cooked to perfection. Over complicating it is unnecessary in my view.

It’s more than what we eat over the whole week. I can’t imagine having to cook all that in one day, I would spend most of the day in the kitchen rather than enjoying time with family, also the washing up 😬.

SharonEllis · 21/12/2023 19:14

I can't imagine making, or eating all that. Or even having room in my kitchen (& I have a pretty big kitchen) I love Christmas dinner and the beauty of it is its a simple meal, following time honoured tradition where focussing on fewer dishes means they are more likely to be cooked to perfection. Over complicating it is unnecessary in my view.

FluffyRabbitGal · 21/12/2023 18:47

This all sounds delicious, but it’s much too much! We’re a family of big appetites but this would last an absolute minimum of 3 days, if not longer!!

DragonMama3 · 21/12/2023 18:43

That's a lot of food. Some very similar in style

willWillSmithsmith · 21/12/2023 18:24

I never do starters as it’s just too much food for us to eat. There will be just four of us this year (the smallest I’ve had for years) and it will just be Christmas dinner and dessert for who wants it (choice of any of the sweet stuff we have). I stopped making cakes etc myself a few years ago though. Now I just treat us to nice things from M&S. I just have no more blood, sweat or tears to give, M&S do all the work now 🙂

The food does sound very good but far more than I would be offering on the day.

Grammarnut · 21/12/2023 18:23

If you are sticking even with your revised menu I suggest all five of you cook. And do you have enough oven space? And there isn't enough meat for five people, you need beef or ham as well. If you eat about three (traditional for Christmas dinner) then the bready breakfast should all have gone. Don't have the hors d'oevres.

lemmein · 21/12/2023 18:15

I think it sounds lovely OP, you are a grand host!

Id probably move the hors d'oeuvres to early evening, or cut them out completely - it's not too much in total, it's just too much in a short space of time.

Grammarnut · 21/12/2023 18:14

madeinmanc · 20/12/2023 18:08

As per a previous poster, ditching the cabbage is a good call because you have Brussels sprouts and because no-one wants reheated cabbage.

Bubble and squeak on Boxing Day morning? With that number of potatoes it's perfectly possible. Could add bacon and make it colcannon.

Skyelils · 21/12/2023 18:12

Don’t think she asked for a spelling lesson don’t be unkind

inappropriateraspberry · 21/12/2023 18:06

Mylifesadrama · 21/12/2023 17:52

To be honest there are a lot of people who are even struggling to feed there family this Christmas and you are going on about hors d'oeuvres etc etc. All sounds very show off listing your menu and your trivial problem!! Get a grip and look at what’s happening in the real world! Seriously who gives a monkey back side about whether you are feeding too much!! Maybe give your extras to the local homeless organisation!

And there are lots of people who aren't struggling and want to spoil their friends and family with good food & drink, and be good hosts.
Yes, there is lots of awful, awful things happening around the world - there always are, but why should that mean we have to martyr our own lives? We can still enjoy Christmas as well as help others, protest, donate to charity etc.

Grammarnut · 21/12/2023 18:06

Mylifesadrama · 21/12/2023 17:52

To be honest there are a lot of people who are even struggling to feed there family this Christmas and you are going on about hors d'oeuvres etc etc. All sounds very show off listing your menu and your trivial problem!! Get a grip and look at what’s happening in the real world! Seriously who gives a monkey back side about whether you are feeding too much!! Maybe give your extras to the local homeless organisation!

Rather a parsimonious and unfriendly comment. My DB-in-Law and his DSs and DDs spend Christmas Day serving lunch to the homeless - I only know because someone casually mentioned it at a wedding, they do not broadcast it. Eat what you want for Christmas Day but do not spend all day cooking, it's not what it's about.

changeme4this · 21/12/2023 18:05

Sounds lovely but I think you are putting too much pressure on yourself.

I love the idea of buffet presentation though, people pick what they would like to eat.

I’ve spread our meals out from Christmas Eve to Boxing Day if that helps with your quantities…

Grammarnut · 21/12/2023 18:00

That would probably feed ten, apart from the chicken joint (?) which isn't enough. But why do all this? Mind, the breakfast is easier than a full English, which I will do (but only for two, though I have done it for more - the trick is to keep everything warm). Other than that, too many puddings. A Christmas pudding and an alternative is enough + cheese before or after the pudding - most of those desserts will be left over and no-one will want to eat them. If you must make a Yule Log (a roulade? That's rather fiddly) I'd have it for tea, with (bought) mince pies. I would also use bought croissants that can be quickly heated rather than having to put the Pret ones in the oven and cook them - it's easier. From what you list you and someone else are going to spend all day cooking, serving, and clearing up. Don't do it.
I am going to a meal for twenty (step-son and partner, his sons and daughter, their partners and my DH's 6 great-grandchildren) and everyone is pitching in (I lumbered myself with parsnips, unfortunately, luckily not ringing for Christmas morning!) so no-one is entirely burdened - DSS and his DSs will cook all meat e.g. beef, lamb, turkey etc. Serve yourself (not children, obv) rather than carved and plated or passed round the table (everything gets cold) and a choice of puddings none of which will be home-made. Drinks will be wine, prosecco, various spirits, etc along with some non-alcohol beer, wine and gin, fruit juice etc. Buck's Fizz is a waste of time IMO.
If you must have this lot then have the veg frozen (there is no difference between a frozen sprout and a freshish one, except peeling it), buy in the puddings and mince pies and anything else you want. Also, have lots of hot gravy - it makes sure that everything else remains hot. Cut the hors d'oevre entirely - have them on Boxing Day if you like and they are arriving via someone else - and have a jug of cream for the desserts. Have a Christmas, not a cooking fest, and enjoy it rather than be worn to a frazzle (which you will be doing this lot).

Mynewnameis · 21/12/2023 17:56

Halve it.

SaraJaneb · 21/12/2023 17:56

It would only be too much if you were forcing people to eat. Leftovers in our house usually get eaten on boxing day. Better to have enough than too little. If we all wrote down what we ate on Christmas day most of us would think it was too much so you shouldn't worry.

Mylifesadrama · 21/12/2023 17:52

To be honest there are a lot of people who are even struggling to feed there family this Christmas and you are going on about hors d'oeuvres etc etc. All sounds very show off listing your menu and your trivial problem!! Get a grip and look at what’s happening in the real world! Seriously who gives a monkey back side about whether you are feeding too much!! Maybe give your extras to the local homeless organisation!