Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this too much food for 5 people on Xmas day?

393 replies

Hoiz · 20/12/2023 15:55

Breakfast
Pret frozen croissants
Cinnamon rolls
Coffee
Bucks Fizz

Houer D'oeuvres
Pigs in blanket (American style)
Chorizo and Scallops
Salmon and Cod Roe Blinis
Garlic Prawns
Caeser Salad skewer

Main Meal
Stuffed Chicken Joint
Roast Potatoes
Mash
Dauphinoise Potatoes
Honey Carrots
Bacon and Broccoli
Parsnips
Brussel Sprouts
Cabbage
Pigs in blanket
Stuffing balls
Yorkshire pudding
Onion Gravy
Plain Gravy

Dessert
Sticky Toffee Pudding and Ice cream
Xmas Pudding
Yule Log
Cheese Platter
Mince Pies

Dinner
Leftovers

Drinks
Champagne
Wine
Bucks Fizz
Spicy Margharitas

Someone in the group is insisting on a starter but they have agreed to taking responsibility. TBC.

This will all be homemade (apart from pastries in morning and ice cream) so it’s a lot of work - 2 main people doing it. A third person will likely pitch in a fair amount.

Is it a normal amount of food? First year hosting but any less would not be what my family is used to. But I’m doing a lot more homemade stuff whereas in previous years some of the snack stuff and desserts would be M and S.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ilovecleaning · 22/12/2023 04:25

Hoiz · 22/12/2023 00:36

Also think it’s a bit mean spirited of posters pointing out that people are struggling and it’s inappropriate to “show off”.

Trust me, we have struggled.

After my dad had his 2nd stroke we lost our family business. My siblings and I used to hide from bailiffs. My grandmother blamed my dad’s stroke on paying for my brother’s school fees - imagine the guilt we all felt. For many years we went without. A solid 8 years of hell. My mother had a breakdown. At 15 we became the parents.

Now we are all doing well we enjoy these times immensely. I’ll still say out aloud how grateful I am for central heating. When things were bad my parents couldn’t afford a plumber. Radiators were ornamental for many years.

”Mean-spirited “ is some Mumsnetters’ default mode so it’s best to ignore them. Don’t rise to the bait. But there are plenty of MNs who are nice and offer sensible and sympathetic advice. You are NOT showing off. 3 different potatoes sounds a lot 😄 - but go for it! I like the traditional British 2 kinds of potato at the meal which some find OTT.
An Aussie acquaintance once said “why do you Brits serve TWO kinds of potatoes? I don’t get it!” I told her she didn’t have to “get it”, she just had to eat it 😂. Merry Christmas. I wish I were coming to your house . 🦃

AnImaginaryCat · 22/12/2023 04:20

I am enjoying the posters fretting that the chicken joint won't be enough for five. Can't help feeling that there's probably enough other food items on offer to make up for the horrifying lack of chicken.

I can't help picturing you as Monica from friends OP. I wasn't a regular viewer but I'm sure I've seen an episode where she drives herself insane trying to make every dish everyone attending the Christmas dinner wants. (Possibly it's Thanksgiving dinner.)

That comparison is evidently colouring my opinion and making me think your quote anxious about how appreciated everything will be. So question is will you be OK if the four other people attending don't eat most of whats on offer? If someone has filled up on breakfast and hors d"oeuvres and mince pies, so just isn't hungry when the lunch is served so eats nothing - will you be fine about that?

What if the dish you've made especially for one person goes completely untouched because that person is full?

What's the plan for the huge amount of left overs? (Realistically that is - can't imagine anyone wanting a dinner as you have planned for them!)

It does all sound delicious but it's a lot of food for one day!

WandaWonder · 22/12/2023 03:06

I am a very big eater but the main seems to much to be able to enjoy each bit really

too much variety and it would feel like eating it for the sake of it

HOWEVER overall the whole thing sounds amazing and wondering if you deliver

ScremeEggs · 22/12/2023 03:03

You lost me at dinner and I got confused, it is 3am and I need to go bed lol
Dinner is at lunch time, I was like fuck ME all that's a lot of food for midday lol
It's your tea, not dinner if it's your evening meal 😁

coxesorangepippin · 22/12/2023 02:52

Good for you op, sounds like you've got a great attitude, enjoy 🎄

WGACA · 22/12/2023 00:54

Let us know how it goes!

Lovethatforyou · 22/12/2023 00:39

Sounds lovely but a lot of work and too excessive/too much choice.

I’m cooking for 5. Breakfast is bacon sandwiches; croissants; fresh fruit and yoghurt; coffee; bucks fizz

Lunch served approx 2pm. No starter.
Roast chicken, pork, yorkshires, roast potatoes, carrots, sprouts, honeyed parsnips, onion stuffing, pigs in blankets, gravy.

Dessert - pavlova and STP options :)

Hoiz · 22/12/2023 00:36

Also think it’s a bit mean spirited of posters pointing out that people are struggling and it’s inappropriate to “show off”.

Trust me, we have struggled.

After my dad had his 2nd stroke we lost our family business. My siblings and I used to hide from bailiffs. My grandmother blamed my dad’s stroke on paying for my brother’s school fees - imagine the guilt we all felt. For many years we went without. A solid 8 years of hell. My mother had a breakdown. At 15 we became the parents.

Now we are all doing well we enjoy these times immensely. I’ll still say out aloud how grateful I am for central heating. When things were bad my parents couldn’t afford a plumber. Radiators were ornamental for many years.

OP posts:
Hoiz · 22/12/2023 00:26

I honestly don’t see it being too much work.

I’ve already measured out the ingredients for my sticky toffee pudding. They just need to be bung together at some point in the afternoon on Xmas day. The Yule log will be made on the 23rd. Measured ingredients are in sandwich bags waiting for me.

Veg prep will be done on Xmas eve with music and fizz (sis and I will no doubt rock out to ABBA with the dog). Sis can easily bash out her chicken in Xmas morning.

The Hors Doeuvres are more assembling than cooking.

I’ll do the dauphinoise at some point on Xmas Eve along with fresh mince pies (filling is done)

Im actually bored and have already been tempted to make some of the dishes but holding off as don’t want the food to spoil.

I’m off work with no kids and have a dog that passes out after a 40 minute walk. Not much going on during the day tbh!

OP posts:
Atsocta · 21/12/2023 23:51

And definitely much too much for 5 🤪send some to me 😃

Atsocta · 21/12/2023 23:49

Nooo garlic prawns will spoil taste buds 😱

mollyfolk · 21/12/2023 23:21

I’d cut to one starter, 2 potatoes, cut a veg, cut one of the desserts at least. Looks amazing, I’m just thinking of the cooks! I really wish I was coming to your house.

LeggyLegsEleven · 21/12/2023 23:15

I wouldn’t bother with mince pies after a massive meal. I don’t think they fit.

Also I find too many different veg offerings get lost. Im personally now just do sprouts and parsnips. I’d only do another if people didn’t like them.

Im also not a fan of starters or whatever at Christmas. Personally a big meal and a pudding suits me fine. A few bits to pick when you are waiting is fine. Anything more just spoils it. It is such a big meal it’s just unnecessary.

pollymere · 21/12/2023 23:10

Way too much veg. Just have sprouts and possibly one other such as parsnips. It's the thing that always seems to not get eaten.

Mumof3confused · 21/12/2023 23:01

of you want to spend all day cooking, fine. I’d just get nuts, olives, crisps and dips to allow yourself some time to actually talk to your guests. Also nobody needs all those desserts after all that food.

hellsBells246 · 21/12/2023 22:57

I'd get rid of the hors d'oeuvres, and buy puddings - or make one in advance. It looks like a huge amount of work!

caringcarer · 21/12/2023 22:51

I'd get rid of the garlic dish also dolphinois potatoes, roast and mash is fine. I'd cut out one of the heavy desserts like Xmas pudding/sticky toffee pudding and add something lighter like a fresh lemon cheesecake.

WhatNoUsername · 21/12/2023 22:44

I forgot pigs in blankets!!

WhatNoUsername · 21/12/2023 22:42

Also agree that you really don't need three types of potato! Roast potato is the king of potatoes, no other potato is needed! Plus mash and dauphinoise are too filling in an already very filling meal.

Here's what we cook for a full Christmas dinner:

Turkey
Sage and onion stuffing
Peas
Parsnips in maple syrup and mustard
Carrots in thyme roasted
Roast potatoes
Red cabbage in apple juice
Shallots roasted
Sweet potato roasted
Brussels in pancetta
Gravy

And that is more than enough. We always have tons left over.

WhatNoUsername · 21/12/2023 22:35

Personally I wouldn't bother with Houer D'oeuvres or a starter. Christmas dinner is already too much food usually that we have to have a break before pudding! Plus you pick on chocolates and other Christmas bits and bobs all day on top of the served food. We do breakfast then have the dinner late afternoon. Break for pudding then that's us. We don't usually have anything else although we always have in bread and salads etc in case anyone does feel hungry in the evening.

madeinmanc · 21/12/2023 21:50

I see the potato controversy rages on! 🤣 The OP has decided already on the potato situation.

GUARDIAN1 · 21/12/2023 21:33

I would cut it down to 2 kinds of potato (we actually have just roast potatoed with any roast dinner, including Christmas although this year we're having lasagne for Christmas lunch). Also, 3 types of veg is plenty. I'd offer a choice of 2 desserts. The mince pies can be kept for later on.

PeaceGoodMercutio · 21/12/2023 20:44

I am a greedy, hefty woman and that is far too much food.

Thedig · 21/12/2023 20:34

Looks amazing can I come?

Seriously, though it seems too much, and very stressful for you. Why not simplify it a bit, and enjoy the day yourself. I think I’d be a nervous wreck prepping all that! ,

Notmyfandango · 21/12/2023 20:31

If you really want to make that much food and not be left with left overs, that will take a week to get through I suggest staggering your courses throughout the day. We do this and it is much nicer and more leisurely. So we do hor derves as starters around 1.00 pm then we take a break - go for a walk or open presents etc then have our main course after the Kings speech, around 3.30pm then return to the lounge for present opening and games and then have our dessert about 6.00 pm and then cheese board and left overs around 8pm. It works really well for us.