Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend didn't get me anything I wanted for Christmas-aibu to be a bit annoyed?

86 replies

sinkorahink · 20/12/2023 15:45

Well not annoyed but I bit meh
Anyway me and good friend decided this year instead of buying each other random stuff we might not like -to buy each other things that we wanted.
We set a £50 budget
She sent over the things she wanted (a purse ,hat and glove set)
I sent her the two things I wanted (also a purse and some ear rings )
I bought her the exact things she wanted
We met today and did the gift opening
Before I opened mine she said -
"I didn't get you the things you asked for,I found these and thought you would like them"

It was a jewellery organiser and a stationary set.

Aibu to be a bit meh about it?

OP posts:
LoveBeingAMum555 · 28/12/2023 10:42

If buying each other specific gifts to a set budget makes you both happy then there is nothing wrong with that. However clearly it hasn't worked this year and I actually think YANBU because she has not done what you agreed.

You definitely need a rethink for next year but assuming that she is a good friend otherwise I would try to just move on from it and go and buy the things you wanted if you can afford to.

lovelysmile · 28/12/2023 10:28

I dislike waste and clutter. To mitigate this my friend and I agreed last year to do the same as you did. Set price limits and a list of items (that way its still can be a bit of guesswork to which one you will get)

We both don't have family or big Christmas gatherings, so a nice way to pop some cheer and a little event in our calendars. We agreed to choose items that can be got easily online as she doesn't drive.

I, like you, got the items off the list for her and I added one extra as I had won a really fancy and expensive day away for two at a super luxury event so added the invitation.

She got me a plastic Henry hoover gift set (because I like cleaning !?!)
Some Turkish delight mixed gift set (I cant stand Turkish delight but she was adamant that I loved it & she had seen me have it before)
A plain, slightly warped, thin wood chopping board
Two second hand books on WW2 (Not an interest of mine at all)
A chipped teapot that sits in a cup set in a lurid 1970's brown and orange

It was very obvious she had just gone into a charity shop and just picked 'stuff' rather than a single thing from the list.

I was secretly pleased when, just after we unwrapped the presents, the organiser of the day away emailed me changed the event date. It happened to be changed to a date she was on holiday abroad. She was really upset, understandably it was a great event with lots of VIP events and freebies added, so got really pushy that I should not accept the change in dates so that she she still could attend. (I found out later that she had called them to voice how upset she was and could they move the date - as she wasn't the winner they refused to speak to her thank goodness)

I took a family friend instead and we had a fantastic time.

She was delighted in the presents she received and suggested in September this year we do the same (and said she expected another day away to be included because she missed out through no fault of her own). She was very baffled when I said no.

The whole thing opened my eyes to the fact that recently she had to move to a more remote location and being as she doesn't drive I have been doing a lot for her and i think I've slipped from being a friend to a 'taxi and service provider'. I gone back and looked over the last six months of texts and every single one from her is asking 'how are you' followed by a request for a lift or favour.

annnnd while I have typed this up shes texted with a breezy hello, how was Christmas? also, am I going to the NY party at **? If i grab her early we could eat then get dolled up with some music and into the party mood. (in other words can I pick her up, feed her and take her - then either let her doss at mine or take her home)

Sigh.

willWillSmithsmith · 28/12/2023 10:16

As adults I simply don’t see the point of this gift giving. You both spend £50 on each other and you end up with something you don’t even want or asked for. Just what is the point? If you must exchange gifts then have a much smaller budget (£10-15) and make the gift a surprise (with low expectations). Swapping £50 gifts is just madness.

BeaRF75 · 28/12/2023 10:10

I do also agree with the idea of pooling the money for a dinner, theatre trip, night out or whatever. That is much more common with adults, and gives you a treat to look forward to.

BeaRF75 · 28/12/2023 10:08

In my world, friends don't give each other lists and budgets. It seems pointless. If you know your friend well, you give her something you think she would like, and vice versa. The values of the items won't always match, but that's fine. Maybe try being more spontaneous in future?

bakingmummy21 · 28/12/2023 10:03

How about in future you do a nice lunch or dinner / night out together rather than just essentially swapping money or things of the same value? If she’s a good friend the I’m sure that would be appreciated by both of you.

SmileyClare · 28/12/2023 08:42

Obviously if you think this way of exchanging gifts is “pointless and transactional” then you don’t agree to it. 🤔

I think more people should have adult conversations with family and friends about what they would like and how much they should spend- and stop pretending that gifts are magical symbols that reflect how much people know and love you.

It would avoid all the disappointment and waste..all the piles of stuff ending up in landfill after Christmas, and all the posters on here sobbing upstairs on Boxing Day because their husband bought them a spice rack.

The reality is that if an adult wants something (at any other time of the year) they buy it for themselves if they can afford to.
That makes the task of buying a surprise gift that is useful and coveted by the receiver a pretty impossible task- you either a) take a gamble or b) cancel all presents between adults

I thought most adults set some sort of budget and ask each other for ideas at Christmas?
I have 3 sisters and we all do this- it works well. Dh and I go for transactional presents on a equal budget too.

UsingChangeofName · 28/12/2023 00:57

I agree with most. It seems a bit of a pointless transaction.
Why not just meet up for lunch, and, if you want a purse, go out and buy yourself a purse that you like ? Confused

Charlize43 · 28/12/2023 00:50

A stationary set, I assume she means notelets and envelopes with some floral of 'pretty' design on them, maybe with a pen included - that is particularly awful!

Who would want that? Most people send emails, wassups, or texts these days to bother writing letters. I suspect it was given to her and she's re-gifted it to you.

I think you have every right to be pissed off - moreso as she got exactly what she wanted but didn't want to spend any money on you. Ask for the receipts and tell her you'd like to get what you asked for.

Then come back and tell us.

Mentaldays · 28/12/2023 00:38

I would be really upset if I was in your situation. She reneged on the deal and left you feeling foolish and disappointed.

NO WAY would I be doing any gifts in the future, she deliberately gave you rubbish you don’t need. I bet you wish you’d just said forget it at the time and taken the things you’d bought back and told her you actually feel the stationary etc were more suited to her. ( or keep it and regift to her next year 😂)

SmileyClare · 28/12/2023 00:08

Judging by the “worst present” threads on here, it would save a lot of despair, offence and money if adults dropped all the sentimental stuff about expecting a present with love and soul in it and started being frank about a) what they’d like and b) what they can both afford.

It works well if you both agree (and stick to it) - it’s still fun and Christmassy to exchange gifts just without all the angst of pretending you like something you don’t or worse- offending your friend by asking for the receipt.

Raspberrymoon49 · 27/12/2023 23:38

Why bother if you’ve already instructed someone on what to buy you, it’s soulless

SmileyClare · 27/12/2023 23:37

Canisaysomething · 27/12/2023 22:17

You literally sent ideas to each other of specific items you wanted? That isn’t how gifts work. There’s zero thought and sentiment involved in that. You may as well have spent £50 on some groceries and loo roll for each other.

She obviously twigged how transactional your suggestion was and couldn’t bring herself to go through with it.

Meh gifts like that can work just fine if you both agree and set a budget. Both have still gone out and located the wanted gift, wrapped it nicely and presented it over some drinks and a meet up.
Theres no rule book on how Christmas presents “work”

Im not sentimental about Christmas gifts and hate surprises.
If you don’t want a transaction or can’t afford a budget then don’t agree to one.

Couldn't bring herself to stick to it?
It seems more like she got the lovely cashmere scarf set she wanted for the price of a regifted set of envelopes and flowery paper that she got from the office Secret Santa.

Beautiful3 · 27/12/2023 23:36

I'd.message saying, "Thank.you for the present. Just to.let you know I'm not doing presents next year, so please don't buy me anything. I'd rather we use the money to go out for drinks and a meal instead."

Charlize43 · 27/12/2023 22:52

I would scrap the presents next year and maybe agree to treat yourselves to an afternoon of cocktails or a nice meal instead. As others have pointed out, it seems very transactional: You give me X, and I'll give you Y.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/12/2023 22:32

15PiecesOfFlair · 20/12/2023 19:22

Because it's nice to be given a gift, even nicer if it's something you want?

When it's conditional on you buying a specific item of the same value?

See, I don't consider that to be inherently a "nice" thing. But as I said, I feel I'm very different from others in this regard.

Bully for you for being so altruistic you would never be disappointed with a shit gift given because the person felt obliged and not because they had put genuine thought or love into it. Are you the type that accepts that your husband is just shit at gifts when you get another ironing board cover for Xmas?

I'm brave enough to say that at Christmas, when there is a well-worn expectation of gift exchanges, I would be a bit upset if my best friend gave me something I didn't want and was clearly from her 're-gift' pile, esp when in discussion we'd decided on a £50 limit. Would I say something? No. But I might suggest that next year we don't do gifts at all.

Canisaysomething · 27/12/2023 22:17

You literally sent ideas to each other of specific items you wanted? That isn’t how gifts work. There’s zero thought and sentiment involved in that. You may as well have spent £50 on some groceries and loo roll for each other.

She obviously twigged how transactional your suggestion was and couldn’t bring herself to go through with it.

Northernladdette · 27/12/2023 22:17

*Stationery set 😂😂

gamerchick · 27/12/2023 21:44

No way she's spent any money OP.

Sack off the gift thing next year. Have a night out instead.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 27/12/2023 21:40

AIstolemylunch · 20/12/2023 15:50

I think adults buying other adults Christmas presents is ludicrous, and even more so if theyre not family. But I appreciate that could be an extreme position.

Well, if adults, other than family, didn't buy other adults presents I would never get a present! What is so "ludicrous" about it?🙁

Geepee71 · 27/12/2023 21:35

I'd ask her for the receipts to change them.

They are going to gather dust and you'll feel resentment everytime you see them.

If she's regifted then she'll need to explain or front it out. Otherwise she gets them back for her birthday.

I'd not be very impressed and would feel really hurt, I'd be looking for sub-text which may or may not be there.

OffTheWall90 · 27/12/2023 21:22

Go for a meal together next time and use the money you would have for presents

Mary46 · 20/12/2023 21:07

Stop it going forward. I find people just buy me rubbish too and recycled crap for Jan birthday too lol. I rather buy my own now

SmileyClare · 20/12/2023 21:05

A lot of present exchanges between adults at Christmas are transactional. So what? It’s fun to give presents and open them even if you could have gone and bought it yourself!

I want to give family and friends something they want.

I think it’s pointless giving a friend something they don’t like or need. They either pretend they like it or there’s an awkward conversation asking for a receipt.

My dh and I agree a budget and tell each other what we want. I thought most couples do?
We haven’t got money to waste guessing what the other wants.
More often than not, it’s misjudged when we’ve tried to surprise each other.

We leave the surprises for the kids.

RowanMayfair · 20/12/2023 20:15

YANBU but honestly what a pointless exercise. Ditch the gifts next year.