Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted suicide offered to homeless people in Canada

296 replies

gnarlynarwhal · 20/12/2023 15:07

I came across an article online about this earlier today and I’m shocked this is seen as acceptable by so many people in Canada. It’s advertised on the tv over there as if it’s a perfectly acceptable thing to do. The National Post is claiming that one third of Canadians think that it’s perfectly acceptable to approve medical assistance in dying ‘MAID’ to healthy people purely because they are impoverished. I find it really saddening.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 20/12/2023 20:47

gnarlynarwhal · 20/12/2023 20:40

When I was in my teens I had suicidal thoughts a lot of the time. I couldn’t see a future where I would be happy. Today my life is completely different. I live in a beautiful home, have a loving husband and two beautiful children.

What frightens me is that there might be another teenager at some point in the future who is given a medically assisted death who would have eventually overcome those dark thoughts like I did. I think I could be comfortable with assisted suicide if someone is in agonising unrelenting pain but only where there are strict checks in place to make sure it is their choice, for their own benefit and not under the influence or for the benefit of others.

Edited

The human brain doesn’t finish developing until mid 20s so I would hope that in the absence of a terminal illness there would be a minimum age.

GuessItsANameChange · 20/12/2023 20:46

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 20/12/2023 20:42

one third of Canadians think that it’s perfectly acceptable to approve medical assistance in dying ‘MAID’ to healthy people purely because they are impoverished.

Without having read the study I'd imagine that a lot of those people just believe that MAID should be offered to everyone, rather than specifically poor people.

Your instincts are correct.

Even ignoring that 27/28% is not a third-

20% of people think that it should be open to anyone, for any reason.

Only 7-8% dont agree that it should be open to everyone but do think that homelessness or poverty would be sufficient reason.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 20/12/2023 20:45

PostmansKnock · 20/12/2023 15:27

My uncle, my mother's brother is Canadian. He emigrated there when he was twenty one and now he is eighty three. He is an amazing man, a scientist who has worked on cures for cancer amongst other things.

Now, he lives in fear of being 'put down' as he calls it. If you don't have enough money to support yourself in old age the government will offer you it. What he is worried about is something like breaking a hip and ending up in hospital and one of his adult children agreeing to it. It's horrifying.

That seems quite irrational of him.

Even if his children are monsters would who happily have him killed, this would require an actual dr taking the word of a patient's child, and then killing their patient.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 20/12/2023 20:42

one third of Canadians think that it’s perfectly acceptable to approve medical assistance in dying ‘MAID’ to healthy people purely because they are impoverished.

Without having read the study I'd imagine that a lot of those people just believe that MAID should be offered to everyone, rather than specifically poor people.

gnarlynarwhal · 20/12/2023 20:40

heyheyheyy · 20/12/2023 20:32

To be honest I’m in two minds about this. People should get support to not be in poverty or suffer from homelessness, the government should support that and help them with their mental health as it’s obviously stressful. However equally if someone (anyone not just specifically struggling) wants to commit suicide then where is the line drawn, do they need a diagnosis of a terminal illness for example? It’s weird to state assisted suicide is okay in some scenarios and not others as people have agency over their own decisions. It’s either accepted or completely not accepted imo, grey areas don’t help anyone

When I was in my teens I had suicidal thoughts a lot of the time. I couldn’t see a future where I would be happy. Today my life is completely different. I live in a beautiful home, have a loving husband and two beautiful children.

What frightens me is that there might be another teenager at some point in the future who is given a medically assisted death who would have eventually overcome those dark thoughts like I did. I think I could be comfortable with assisted suicide if someone is in agonising unrelenting pain but only where there are strict checks in place to make sure it is their choice, for their own benefit and not under the influence or for the benefit of others.

OP posts:
Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 20/12/2023 20:34

Canuckduck · 20/12/2023 19:58

As has been mentioned there are a lot of untruths on this thread as there has been on various other Canada & MAID threads. As stated in the original article this was a poll of 1000 people over the course of 2 days. Not sure it’s fully representative of the 35 million people who live here.

I believe there’s also a link to the huge increase in MAID but it still amounts to 11 000 cases, again with a population of 35 m.

I live in Canada and personally know of one person who accessed MAID. They chose to do this before becoming severely disabled from Parkinson’s disease. Their family was sad but in agreement and they passed peacefully.

All this being said, we do have a homelessness issue. Some of this is due an influx of asylum seekers, some due to opioid crisis/ addiction, some due to cost of living. There needs to be a new strategy on this as there are increasingly desperate, sick people on the streets in freezing weather. If I was homeless, addicted and physically sick I may choose MAID too. Which is awful.

I think two main things are crucial;

  1. having a trauma informed society. Trauma (including childhood trauma/abuse etc) is one of the key factors in people becoming addicted and a key cause in mental health difficulties. Services need to be front loaded. We need to spend more in the early years than we do in later years, but it’s the other way round.
  2. Address the causes of inequality
heyheyheyy · 20/12/2023 20:32

To be honest I’m in two minds about this. People should get support to not be in poverty or suffer from homelessness, the government should support that and help them with their mental health as it’s obviously stressful. However equally if someone (anyone not just specifically struggling) wants to commit suicide then where is the line drawn, do they need a diagnosis of a terminal illness for example? It’s weird to state assisted suicide is okay in some scenarios and not others as people have agency over their own decisions. It’s either accepted or completely not accepted imo, grey areas don’t help anyone

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 20/12/2023 20:28

GuessItsANameChange · 20/12/2023 20:18

Two things that are true:

  • Canada needs to tackle its widespread poverty and homelessness issues;

  • Based on this thread, the UK needs massive investment to promote better literacy.

Literacy? What have people misread?

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 20/12/2023 20:27

SpecialCharacters · 20/12/2023 17:13

I can’t speak to what articles you have or may not have read but:

  • currently, only terminally ill people are eligible for assisted suicide in Canada;

  • eligibility is to be expanded, likely next year (unless it’s further delayed), to include people who have a “grievous and irremediable medical condition” (which could include a serious and untreatable mental health condition).

That plainly would not have applied to your circumstances.

So who decides what can’t be further shifted? Because with mental health, if it’s medics then that is unacceptable. The medical model is rubbish at understanding mental health and none of the diagnoses stand up to rigorous scientific scrutiny. I know plenty of psychiatrists that think that. The evidence base on talking therapies is constantly growing so what is available at point A will not be the same 10 years later at point B. I work in mental health and there is always hope. I’ve seen people come through the most horrendous situations.

GuessItsANameChange · 20/12/2023 20:18

Two things that are true:

  • Canada needs to tackle its widespread poverty and homelessness issues;

  • Based on this thread, the UK needs massive investment to promote better literacy.

KrisAkabusi · 20/12/2023 20:17

bonzaitree · 20/12/2023 20:03

This is genuinely chilling. Absolutely horrifying policy. And in a country like Canada! You don’t expect it there. Has the whiff of genocide about it.

Have you only read the OP or the many responses debunking it?

kittensinthekitchen · 20/12/2023 20:13

bonzaitree · 20/12/2023 20:03

This is genuinely chilling. Absolutely horrifying policy. And in a country like Canada! You don’t expect it there. Has the whiff of genocide about it.

🙄🙄

Make sure and tell all your Facebook friends hun

HappyHealthy23 · 20/12/2023 20:13

onceuponasnowflake · 20/12/2023 17:49

I'm not homeless and I'd take this option if it was available. I think it should be available to all for whatever reason they want. Why should you be forced to stay alive if you don't want to be?

This is odd. Nobody is being forced to stay alive. Anyone can off themselves any time they feel like it, if they are physically capable of doing so. I could be dead within the next hour if I so wished.
The only thing we don't currently have is the option to medically-assisted suicide. But most people don't need to be medically assisted to do that.

Dutch1e · 20/12/2023 20:09

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 20:04

Which policy @bonzaitree ?

I'm guessing the non-existent policy that might possibly perhaps allow poor & terminal people to access the same level of dignity in death that is now sometimes afforded to housed/wealthier patients.

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 20:04

Which policy @bonzaitree ?

bonzaitree · 20/12/2023 20:03

This is genuinely chilling. Absolutely horrifying policy. And in a country like Canada! You don’t expect it there. Has the whiff of genocide about it.

Dutch1e · 20/12/2023 20:03

2jacqi · 20/12/2023 15:21

@gnarlynarwhal this is exactly what will happen here in UK is the euthanasia law is passed!!! you are all warned! people in countries which have passed this law can demand euthanasia for depression nowadays. the countries cannot stop it because it then has to be the same law for everyone! equality!!

Hello from one of those countries.

Your comment reads like a Facebook boomer meme from artists who enjoy Clipart exclamation marks.

Feel free to ask questions about how dignified dying can be legislated but I'd appreciate you dropping the froth first.

Canuckduck · 20/12/2023 19:58

As has been mentioned there are a lot of untruths on this thread as there has been on various other Canada & MAID threads. As stated in the original article this was a poll of 1000 people over the course of 2 days. Not sure it’s fully representative of the 35 million people who live here.

I believe there’s also a link to the huge increase in MAID but it still amounts to 11 000 cases, again with a population of 35 m.

I live in Canada and personally know of one person who accessed MAID. They chose to do this before becoming severely disabled from Parkinson’s disease. Their family was sad but in agreement and they passed peacefully.

All this being said, we do have a homelessness issue. Some of this is due an influx of asylum seekers, some due to opioid crisis/ addiction, some due to cost of living. There needs to be a new strategy on this as there are increasingly desperate, sick people on the streets in freezing weather. If I was homeless, addicted and physically sick I may choose MAID too. Which is awful.

GuessItsANameChange · 20/12/2023 19:51

Notwithstanding euthanasia laws, Canada’s social safety net is abysmal. It is a very capitalist country (I dare say, dragged down by neighbouring the US) and there is rampant homelessness in some regions.

Itslegitimatesalvage · 20/12/2023 19:43

Neverpostagain · 20/12/2023 19:39

Anyone should be able to obtain a medically assisted death for whatever reason they choose. Their body their choice. Same as abortion. No one has any right to tell me or anyone else that I must continue with my life (or my pregnancy)

With no safeguards? You do realise that we would see hundreds of elderly vulnerable people putting themselves forward for not because their children have convinced them that’s it’s for the best, before the inheritance has to go on care fees.

Neverpostagain · 20/12/2023 19:39

Anyone should be able to obtain a medically assisted death for whatever reason they choose. Their body their choice. Same as abortion. No one has any right to tell me or anyone else that I must continue with my life (or my pregnancy)

Crispedia · 20/12/2023 19:34

KrisAkabusi · 20/12/2023 19:24

Posted already on this page alone, several times elsewhere in the thread, and still a load of bollocks. She doesn't have a letter proving it happened, admits she lied when she said she did, and the person that she says offered it had as much right to do so I as I do i.e. none!

Sorry didn’t see. These still stand though:

”Amir Farsoud, 54, applied for Canada's controversial medical assistance in dying program, known as MAID, after the house where he lives was put on the market

Farsoud lives with debilitating, untreatable back pain, which allowed him to qualify for MAID

It wasn't his pain that drove Farsoud's decision, but rather his prospects of homelessness after Canada's social services failed to provide him support

Farsoud received one of the two doctor signatures required to be accepted by the MAID program, and expected to be euthanized this month

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11441995/Canadian-man-facing-eviction-accepted-countrys-controversial-legal-EUTHANASIA-program.html

“We’re hearing about people who are choosing medical assistance in dying or thinking about it more because they don’t have money to live.”
Dr. Dosani is a palliative care physician and Assistant Professor in the Department of Family & Community Medicine at the University of Toronto.
“People are living in abject poverty when they’re on social assistance, in almost every province and territory across Canada.”

“But the legalization of MAiD has brought to the fore some disturbing moral calculations, particularly with its expansion in 2019 to include individuals whose deaths aren’t “reasonably foreseeable.” This change opened the floodgates for people with disabilities to apply to die rather than survive on meager benefits.”

I’ve come to realize that euthanasia in Canada represents the cynical endgame of social provisioning within the brutal logic of late-stage capitalism — we’ll starve you of the funding you need to live a dignified life, demand you pay back pandemic aid you applied for in good faith, and if you don’t like it, well, why don’t you just kill yourself?

The problem with my previous perspective was that it held individual choices as sacrosanct. But people don’t make individual decisions in a vacuum. They’re the product of social circumstances, which are often out of their control.”
https://jacobin.com/2023/01/canada-medically-assisted-dying-poverty-disability-eugenics-euthanasia

The Problems With Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying Policy

Canada’s Medical Assistance in Dying program seemed like a step forward for choice and dignity. But it is beginning to look like a dystopian end run around the cost of providing social welfare that can beat back the deprivations that make life unbearab...

https://jacobin.com/2023/01/canada-medically-assisted-dying-poverty-disability-eugenics-euthanasia

Justfinking · 20/12/2023 19:30

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 20/12/2023 18:59

Absolutely. I think people should have a choice. If I want to die because I am sick or sad or because I have addiction issues or life is a shitty endless cycle of work with an impoverished retirement on the horizon. It should be my choice.

Lots of people who suffer will choose to live given the option but it’s a safety net for those who feel it’s too much of a struggle to go on.

I agree so much with this. It's actually similar to people who are anti-abortion, yet do nothing themselves to take in and care for unwanted children.

KrisAkabusi · 20/12/2023 19:24

Crispedia · 20/12/2023 19:10

Canada’s MAID program sounds extremely worrying.

“A Paralympic army veteran told stunned lawmakers in Canada when she claimed that a government official had offered to give her euthanisia equipment while fighting to have a wheelchair lift installed in her home.
Retired corporal Christine Gauthier, who competed at the 2016 Rio de Janeiro Paralympics, testified on Thursday that the unnamed veterans affairs case worker had offered in writing to provide her with a medically-assisted dying device, the CBC reported.

“I have a letter saying that if you’re so desperate, madam, we can offer you MAID, medical assistance in dying,” Ms Gauthier, 52, told a House of Commons veterans affairs committee, according to the CBC.”

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/christine-gauthier-paralympian-euthanasia-canada-b2238319.html

  • Amir Farsoud, 54, applied for Canada's controversial medical assistance in dying program, known as MAID, after the house where he lives was put on the market
  • Farsoud lives with debilitating, untreatable back pain, which allowed him to qualify for MAID
  • It wasn't his pain that drove Farsoud's decision, but rather his prospects of homelessness after Canada's social services failed to provide him support
  • Farsoud received one of the two doctor signatures required to be accepted by the MAID program, and expected to be euthanized this month

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11441995/Canadian-man-facing-eviction-accepted-countrys-controversial-legal-EUTHANASIA-program.html

“We’re hearing about people who are choosing medical assistance in dying or thinking about it more because they don’t have money to live.”
Dr. Dosani is a palliative care physician and Assistant Professor in the Department of Family & Community Medicine at the University of Toronto.
“People are living in abject poverty when they’re on social assistance, in almost every province and territory across Canada.”

“But the legalization of MAiD has brought to the fore some disturbing moral calculations, particularly with its expansion in 2019 to include individuals whose deaths aren’t “reasonably foreseeable.” This change opened the floodgates for people with disabilities to apply to die rather than survive on meager benefits.

I’ve come to realize that euthanasia in Canada represents the cynical endgame of social provisioning within the brutal logic of late-stage capitalism — we’ll starve you of the funding you need to live a dignified life, demand you pay back pandemic aid you applied for in good faith, and if you don’t like it, well, why don’t you just kill yourself?

The problem with my previous perspective was that it held individual choices as sacrosanct. But people don’t make individual decisions in a vacuum. They’re the product of social circumstances, which are often out of their control.”
https://jacobin.com/2023/01/canada-medically-assisted-dying-poverty-disability-eugenics-euthanasia

Edited

Posted already on this page alone, several times elsewhere in the thread, and still a load of bollocks. She doesn't have a letter proving it happened, admits she lied when she said she did, and the person that she says offered it had as much right to do so I as I do i.e. none!

Crispedia · 20/12/2023 19:10

Canada’s MAID program sounds extremely worrying.

“A Paralympic army veteran told stunned lawmakers in Canada when she claimed that a government official had offered to give her euthanisia equipment while fighting to have a wheelchair lift installed in her home.
Retired corporal Christine Gauthier, who competed at the 2016 Rio de Janeiro Paralympics, testified on Thursday that the unnamed veterans affairs case worker had offered in writing to provide her with a medically-assisted dying device, the CBC reported.

“I have a letter saying that if you’re so desperate, madam, we can offer you MAID, medical assistance in dying,” Ms Gauthier, 52, told a House of Commons veterans affairs committee, according to the CBC.”

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/christine-gauthier-paralympian-euthanasia-canada-b2238319.html

  • Amir Farsoud, 54, applied for Canada's controversial medical assistance in dying program, known as MAID, after the house where he lives was put on the market
  • Farsoud lives with debilitating, untreatable back pain, which allowed him to qualify for MAID
  • It wasn't his pain that drove Farsoud's decision, but rather his prospects of homelessness after Canada's social services failed to provide him support
  • Farsoud received one of the two doctor signatures required to be accepted by the MAID program, and expected to be euthanized this month

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11441995/Canadian-man-facing-eviction-accepted-countrys-controversial-legal-EUTHANASIA-program.html

“We’re hearing about people who are choosing medical assistance in dying or thinking about it more because they don’t have money to live.”
Dr. Dosani is a palliative care physician and Assistant Professor in the Department of Family & Community Medicine at the University of Toronto.
“People are living in abject poverty when they’re on social assistance, in almost every province and territory across Canada.”

“But the legalization of MAiD has brought to the fore some disturbing moral calculations, particularly with its expansion in 2019 to include individuals whose deaths aren’t “reasonably foreseeable.” This change opened the floodgates for people with disabilities to apply to die rather than survive on meager benefits.

I’ve come to realize that euthanasia in Canada represents the cynical endgame of social provisioning within the brutal logic of late-stage capitalism — we’ll starve you of the funding you need to live a dignified life, demand you pay back pandemic aid you applied for in good faith, and if you don’t like it, well, why don’t you just kill yourself?

The problem with my previous perspective was that it held individual choices as sacrosanct. But people don’t make individual decisions in a vacuum. They’re the product of social circumstances, which are often out of their control.”
https://jacobin.com/2023/01/canada-medically-assisted-dying-poverty-disability-eugenics-euthanasia

Paralympian claims Canada offered to euthanise her when she asked for a stairlift

‘I have a letter saying that if you’re so desperate, madam, we can offer you... medical assistance in dying,’ Christine Gauthier told a Canadian veterans affairs committee

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/christine-gauthier-paralympian-euthanasia-canada-b2238319.html