Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Assisted suicide offered to homeless people in Canada

296 replies

gnarlynarwhal · 20/12/2023 15:07

I came across an article online about this earlier today and I’m shocked this is seen as acceptable by so many people in Canada. It’s advertised on the tv over there as if it’s a perfectly acceptable thing to do. The National Post is claiming that one third of Canadians think that it’s perfectly acceptable to approve medical assistance in dying ‘MAID’ to healthy people purely because they are impoverished. I find it really saddening.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 20/12/2023 15:52

flapjackfairy · 20/12/2023 15:32

And how long will it be before they are allowing relatives to make the decision for relatives with dementia or disabilities. And how many older people will be coerced into it by unscrupulous relatives?
That is why I am firmly against making it legal because the boundaries will be pushed further and further .

I guess it's so much easier to watch the mother you dearly loved, die slowly and painfully for weeks due to the shit "palliative" care we have in Scotland

BertieBotts · 20/12/2023 15:49

I tried to look for info on how the poll takers were recruited, it wasn't available anywhere. It just said 1000 respondents matched demographically to Canada as a whole using census data.

But for example it would probably make a difference to how people respond if you had recruited participants from say mumsnet vs reddit.

penjil · 20/12/2023 15:49

ReTrainTheBrain · 20/12/2023 15:14

Wouldn't it be better to access support for whatever was driving them to think suicide is the answer?

Well, it doesn't really exist, does it?

Same as in the UK, it's only token gestures as there isn't the budget for anything more.

BethDuttonsTwin · 20/12/2023 15:48

VickyEadieofThigh · 20/12/2023 15:08

I grow ever more disgusted by what I hear of Canada.

This. All under the monstrous Trudeau. I was told right here on MN that it was all Twitter nonsense when I mentioned this, note they’re also trying to allow teenagers to use MAiD too. I also spoke of the man in is fifties who says he’s a woman and is allowed to compete in swimming competitions and change with teenage girls. Also that multiple First Nations communities STILL live under boil water advisories with no end in sight. All these dismissed as unimportant Twitter hype too.

I was in a relationship with a Man who is First Nation Canadian, living and working in the UK. He used to call Canada “God’s Country!” whenever he spoke of it. He is in despair at the state of it now.

Lulubo1 · 20/12/2023 15:48

Canada is a cesspit right now. Doesn't help that Trudeau is prime minister. I used to live in Canada and DH is a born and raised Canadian. Honestly, the way Canada has gone downhill so fast makes me so glad we had our DD here and not there. You couldn't pay me to go back!! When I worked in downtown Toronto, I regularly saw commuters come out Union Station and then literally step OVER homeless people on the street. Disgusting behaviour. It's got even worse now 😞

AnonnyMouseDave · 20/12/2023 15:47

Skimm · 20/12/2023 15:12

Thats why I don't agree with assisted suicide at all.

The boundaries of what becomes acceptable gets pushed and people start looking at who is an asset and who is a drain on society.

A lot of 'for the greater good' like HotFuzz.

I used to be 100% in favour, but Canada is doing an incredible job of convincing me that I could not have been more wrong.

AgnesX · 20/12/2023 15:47

OhmygodDont · 20/12/2023 15:12

If someone’s wants to die they should be legally allowed to die. Don’t care if they have 2mil in the bank or 2p if they want to end their life they should be allowed to access the help required to do so.

It used to be that suicides were labelled as " of unsound mind" when cause of death was determined and I do genuinely think that someone's mental health must be compromised in some way to want to die if there's no good reason.

It's the thin end of the wedge....ooo, let's make life so shit for groups of people that we don't care for that they'll want to do it voluntarily.🙄

ScholesPanda · 20/12/2023 15:47

This is terrible. 'They shoot horses don't they?'

periodiclabel · 20/12/2023 15:47

OFGS, a minority say it's a good idea if people want it, it's not being pushed as mandatory - it's an idea that's being floated in an opinion poll!

FlibbedyFlobbedyFloo · 20/12/2023 15:46

Belgium allows euthanasia and I think its rules are fairly sensible. In essence:

  • The patient must be legally competent and conscious at the moment of making the request.
  • The patient must request euthanasia on two separate occasions, in writing.
  • The patient must be suffering from an incurable disease or mental illness, and have no other treatment options.
  • The patient must be experiencing unbearable suffering, either physically or psychologically.
Being homeless, or depressed wouldn't fit these criteria, thank goodness
Staniam · 20/12/2023 15:43

OhmygodDont · 20/12/2023 15:12

If someone’s wants to die they should be legally allowed to die. Don’t care if they have 2mil in the bank or 2p if they want to end their life they should be allowed to access the help required to do so.

And you seriously can't see any issues with that? Any downstream consequences? Any unintended side effects?

BertieBotts · 20/12/2023 15:43

Assisted suicide needs to be medical reasons. Not social problems.

I totally agree with this.

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 20/12/2023 15:43

I’m in Canada, certainly not seen any TV ads, the Gauthier story is twisted and I sense this one is as well.

TruJay · 20/12/2023 15:42

Christ! I bet there’d be a nice little check box for them to harvest donate their organs too!
Of course no one should be advocating assisted death because of homelessness/poverty, what’s the world coming to?!

I grew up in poverty, I certainly didn’t want my mum, my siblings and I putting down! And as a PP mentioned I’ve also had a bought of depression, definitely wasn’t in the right frame of mind to decide I’d be better off dead. I would never have the life and family I have now and that is unthinkable.

How could anyone think that someone else’s life is worth so little that although they’re perfectly healthy just because they’re having a shit time in life that they should be dead instead 🤯

BertieBotts · 20/12/2023 15:42

Here is an article which presents the same information in a much less alarmist way, for example. Instead of "NEARLY A THIRD!!!!" it says "Less than a third". And the overall tone is about there being a divided view whereas the article linked in the OP seems to suggest everyone is just fine with it.

https://www.timescolonist.com/opinion/canadians-remain-divided-about-medical-assistance-in-dying-poll-finds-6949611

Canadians remain divided about medical assistance in dying, poll finds

Next month, Canada will mark seven years since the successful passage of Bill C-14, which legalized medical assistance in dying across the country.

https://www.timescolonist.com/opinion/canadians-remain-divided-about-medical-assistance-in-dying-poll-finds-6949611

BombaySamphire · 20/12/2023 15:39

ComtesseDeSpair · 20/12/2023 15:15

I agree with this. We should all have the right to choose how and when we die, without having to have other people decide that we don’t know our own minds and don’t have a good enough reason. If somebody doesn’t think their life is worth living because of their living circumstances, who is anyone else to force them to continue on?

Edited

Well, the opposite of state sanctioned and assisted suicide is not “being forced to carry on”, is it? 🤔

Comedycook · 20/12/2023 15:39

Skimm · 20/12/2023 15:12

Thats why I don't agree with assisted suicide at all.

The boundaries of what becomes acceptable gets pushed and people start looking at who is an asset and who is a drain on society.

A lot of 'for the greater good' like HotFuzz.

Agree.

I'm totally against it. Whilst, in theory I can understand people feeling so desperate or having such a poor quality of life, that they wish to do it and feel like they should be able to make that decision for themselves. In reality I fear it is a system which would very quickly become open to abuse and a widening of the criteria.

IHS · 20/12/2023 15:38

The Tories would be wetting themselves with excitement. Imagine. They could actually get rid of all the poor people 🙄

BibbleandSqwauk · 20/12/2023 15:38

I think this is a topic that needs an absolute case by case approach and nuance. Prue Leith did an excellent documentary on ch4 recently with her son who is anti. She is pro. They went to Canada and saw examples of the best practice and worrying social factors being brought in.
Having nursed a friend through final stage cancer who cried every time she woke up because she didn't want to, I am in favour if it, but agree there will always be a danger of it being used wrongly and we need to have grown up discussions about it, not blanket assertions either way.

Nonplusultra · 20/12/2023 15:38

These are the kinds of reasons I would oppose assisted suicide. Yet I don’t think I will ever get over the horror of watching a beloved parent dying naturally in hospital.

BertieBotts · 20/12/2023 15:37

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/12/2023 15:30

Like many of the issues we are facing, this transcends right- and left-wing. That's why it's normally a conscience vote for politicians.

Why people believe that reading or considering all sources is a bad thing is beyond me. I've read all sorts of dreadful things in pursuit of understanding and measured thought. Just believing what the Guardian tells me to believe isn't good enough any more.

I agree, my point was to be aware of bias. And there is a left/right lean on the issue of assisted suicide - right wing tend to be anti it or claim it's being used for spurious reasons, whereas left wing tend to be pro or claim it's only ever used for good. The reality is generally somewhere in the middle.

Iwishiwasasilentnight · 20/12/2023 15:36

The research says 27%. It’s in a poll with lots of questions. I wondering what the result would have been if just that question was asked.

OhmygodDont · 20/12/2023 15:36

The article isn’t about forcing anyone or anything it’s an opinion poll.

People where asked if they would support it being allowed for X reason or Y reason people answered. Its not an actual oh your homeless here swallow this.

For some people it doesn’t matter how much you help them, they will always end up back on the streets because they cannot cope with a “normal” life. If they want to decide to die that’s their choice and it should be up to them.

A lot of people if given the option of a nice calm peaceful death would take it who wouldn’t do a traumatising suicide attempt. It doesn’t mean those people want to be alive or are happy to be alive or want to be fixed they just can’t bring themselves to actually have to kill themselves leaving someone to unexpectedly find them or cause their death.

DyslexicPoster · 20/12/2023 15:33

I feel its a bit grim and reflects badly on their society.

Also no one can block / force anyone who wants to take their own life not to do so. I know so many people who have ( sometimes on Total whim it seems) killed themselves easily in seconds. The tie between life and death is very easily severed.

However this is offering up the option to vulnerable people who it might not have occurred too. I think if someone had offered death to my eldest before he was 16 he would have chosen assisted death. Doesn't mean its OK. Doesn't mean it's forcibly removing the option of death by not being on offer. He's vulnerable. Death should never be a viable solution to a shirty situation.

My life's hard with 4 kids with sen, I could offered my out too. Then what happens to my kids? They are the burdon, do they get offered out too?

Assisted suicide needs to be medical reasons. Not social problems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread