Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think this school policy is ridiculous

771 replies

sadbutdontknowwhy · 20/12/2023 11:50

Secondary school
DS15 has had his phone confiscated for the 3rd time this term.
Absolutely fine, he shouldn't have had it out so deserves the punishment
However, they won't give it back to him at 3.15. A parent has to go and collect it.
Tried to explain that 1, it means one of us leaving work, and 2, he needs it to access the gym straight after school, and 3, it his property but they won't budge. It stays with school until a parent can collect
In no way am I kicking off about the confiscation, but I'm fuming I'm also being punished as well!
Arghhhhh. Rant over.

OP posts:
Fancycheese · 22/12/2023 01:45

I feel so sorry for teachers. Funnily enough the school does not exist to make your life easier and more convenient. It’s your son you need to talk to, not strangers on the internet.

Jumpingthruhoops · 22/12/2023 01:30

Catza · 20/12/2023 11:55

Invoice the school for your time off work.

This! Sorry, but it's not up to teachers to 'teach the parent a lesson'. Fair enough, the teacher was right to confiscate the phone during lesson time, if those are the rules.

But once the lesson - and indeed the school day - are over, they should rightfully return the child's personal property to the child. It's not theirs to keep hold of. And it's certainly not theirs to use to hold the child and/or the parent to ransom.

This idea of 'Do this and you'll get your property back'. There's a name for that sort of thing...

stomachameleon · 21/12/2023 19:03

@WearyAuldWumman I Don't believe for a second the op will do anything. The narrative is already the teacher is targeting him.... the one teacher.... and I see nothing to convince me op thinks her son plays much of a role in this.
I bet it was back in his hands straight away.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/12/2023 18:29

I would hope that the school is able to come up with appropriate punishments in order to reduce disruption.

If such punishments existed, there would not be such a massive problem with behaviour in schools, would there? Do you not think that if there were punishments that schools were allowed to use, and which were effective, schools would be using them?! Why on earth wouldn't they?

I ask again... what punishments do you think schools would be allowed to use, which would actually deter kids from bad behaviour?

Available punishments are basically these: detentions, internal exclusion from lessons, suspension from school and permanent exclusion. That's it. Detention doesn't deter them much, and some kids just don't turn up to it (sometimes with their parents' backing). Internal exclusion and suspension don't stop them re-offending, and schools are limited in the amount of exclusion time they can issue. Permanent exclusion (i.e. expulsion) is hard to achieve. They often get back in on appeal, and even if they don't, they're just passed on to another school, where they cause the same problems.

So go on, @AnonnyMouseDave - please list the punishments you'd recommend. I'm sure we can all benefit from your wisdom.

Whatafustercluck · 21/12/2023 18:22

17yo Dnephew has asd. He is also fixated / obsessed with his phone. Dsis insists that he leaves it outside his bedroom at night because otherwise he's on it all night. Anyway, just recently she noticed that he was really tired during the day, to the point where she began to get concerned he was ill. Turns out he spent almost £1,000 on a new secret phone (money that had been given to him for driving lessons) and was using that at night instead.

You're doing your son no favours ignoring what could well be a very unhealthy addiction. I don't think a digital detox would be a bad thing, op, and it should probably be on a regular basis.

LaurieStrode · 21/12/2023 17:18

I'd not pick it up and tell the boy that for the school break he's on a "digital detox" which should actually help with any attention-span and concentration issues. Pull the plug on any home video games, etc., too. Reading real books, working out, walking, etc., is a good way to spend the break.

WearyAuldWumman · 21/12/2023 16:28

Ah. Good old 'restorative practice'.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 21/12/2023 16:18

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/12/2023 13:25

Go on - what kind of punishments do you have in mind?

Basically speak softly to the pupil. Make him promise he won’t ever get his phone out again. That seems a reasonable (non punishment) punishment doesn’t it? Note the sarcasm!

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 21/12/2023 16:16

sadbutdontknowwhy · 21/12/2023 10:59

@Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain

Excuse me? I never said I was a better parent than anyone else, so I don't know why you've said that

I didn’t actually say you said you were a better parent than anyone else… I mean if you’re gonna quote me then do it properly…

I actually do feel sorry for you a bit cos you’ve got your arse handed to you here… regardless I do think some posters (probably including me) either don’t read your OP, or just think you’re being soft on your son. Still…maybe after it this means your son won’t play with his phone in future and do as he’s told rather than ignore his teacher. But I’m not holding my breath.

Daya1 · 21/12/2023 13:54

Maybe chop an ear off to
Make

one to comply

VickyEadieofThigh · 21/12/2023 13:25

AnonnyMouseDave · 20/12/2023 18:47

I would hope that the school is able to come up with appropriate punishments in order to reduce disruption. I would not support deliberately inconveniencing parents and I would not support anything that punishes the child out of school hours (other than detention or extra homework).

Go on - what kind of punishments do you have in mind?

ISSTIUTNG · 21/12/2023 13:08

OP if it's inconvenient then don't do it. Your son is almost an adult. I presume you actually want him to live and work independently eventually so stop wiping his arse for him. If he can't keep off his phone when asked to how's he meant to survive in the working world? In many jobs he'd be disciplined or sacked for not following this clear rule.

What the school have implemented actually gives you the perfect opportunity to implement a natural consequence. You just don't want to do it.

Of course he can live without his phone. Don't be so ridiculous. How do you think thousands of generations survived before they were invented?! It's a communication device not water. I'd actually be secretly glad he didn't have it for so long in your shoes as the fact he can't keep off it when asked to suggests he's becoming addicted.

What exactly do you expect school to do? They can't teach if they're not being backed up. No wonder nobody wants to teach any more when this is our society's shitty attitude towards education. Why bother?

ilovesooty · 21/12/2023 12:12

AnonnyMouseDave · 21/12/2023 10:26

I thought we were all agreed that the kid shouldn't have his phone out and should be punished, I thought we were debating whether this punishment is a good one?

You just can't admit that you made a mistake, can you?

That might cast some light on the attitude you convey.

ilovesooty · 21/12/2023 12:09

AnonnyMouseDave · 21/12/2023 10:02

If it was a crap job maybe. If it was a job worth having then they wouldn't care whether you used your phone occasionally so long as the work got done.

There are necessary and useful (not "crap") jobs where you simply can't have access to a phone.

Do some research.

stomachameleon · 21/12/2023 11:46

Oh your Back. I thought you were done.

Maxus · 21/12/2023 11:14

Bromptotoo · 21/12/2023 10:29

@enchantedsquirrelwood said:

I am not sure how keeping someone's phone puts your child's safety at risk.

Most of us under the age of about 40 managed to get through school and journeys to and from school without having a mobile phone

The point is that the world has moved on. 24/7 contact is a mixed blessing - see parents worrying the their Gen X offspring have been off radar for a day - but they also facilitate stuff we could not do.

Forty years ago there were payphones at the end of every street. If I got in a pickle on the way home I could make a reversed charge call to my Mum.

The rise of the mobile means such boxes, there were even a few doted around the school in 1978, are now like hen's teeth.

This was my generation. I can assure you there wasn't a phone box at the end of every street. On my walk to school which took 30 minutes I didn't pass any. I never had to make an emergency call either. We got to school and back just fine without a phone or a phone box. I think you are romanticising about that era.

LaurieStrode · 21/12/2023 11:04

I'm 60 and have made it through life (including living overseas for my dad's work as a child without speaking that country's language) without ever having to place an emergency phone call.

These teenagers who can't make it to and from school without a phone in hand are excessively coddled. I really worry about their lack of resilience and resourcefulness, and ability to think independently and troubleshoot.

Bromptotoo · 21/12/2023 11:02

How often in practice did you or your friends get into a pickle necessitating a call home?

Not that often measured over seven years but enough. Usually the bus not arriving so arranged to walk up to where I could meet Mum on her way home from work.

Being roughed up by kids from a rival school was another.

sadbutdontknowwhy · 21/12/2023 10:59

@Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain

Excuse me? I never said I was a better parent than anyone else, so I don't know why you've said that

OP posts:
Grimpo · 21/12/2023 10:51

Welcome2thecircus · 21/12/2023 09:52

Personally i'd take the phone away. Three strikes and all that. Presume gym can issue a membership card or fob. If you don't follow the rules there has to be a consequence or it will just keep happening.

You don't get three warnings as an adult, you'd just get fired hehe so I get what they are doing although it's disruptive for you.

You don't know anything about employment law, do you?

Grimpo · 21/12/2023 10:50

Bromptotoo · 21/12/2023 10:29

@enchantedsquirrelwood said:

I am not sure how keeping someone's phone puts your child's safety at risk.

Most of us under the age of about 40 managed to get through school and journeys to and from school without having a mobile phone

The point is that the world has moved on. 24/7 contact is a mixed blessing - see parents worrying the their Gen X offspring have been off radar for a day - but they also facilitate stuff we could not do.

Forty years ago there were payphones at the end of every street. If I got in a pickle on the way home I could make a reversed charge call to my Mum.

The rise of the mobile means such boxes, there were even a few doted around the school in 1978, are now like hen's teeth.

How often in practice did you or your friends get into a pickle necessitating a call home? I can't remember it ever happening to me, my siblings or my friends. Of course it doesn't mean that it can't happen, but the chances of something unsafe happening which parents (and no-one else) can actually help with by phone are minuscule.

PuttingDownRoots · 21/12/2023 10:32

AnonnyMouseDave · 21/12/2023 10:26

I thought we were all agreed that the kid shouldn't have his phone out and should be punished, I thought we were debating whether this punishment is a good one?

You said only crap jobs had "no phone" policies...

Bromptotoo · 21/12/2023 10:29

@enchantedsquirrelwood said:

I am not sure how keeping someone's phone puts your child's safety at risk.

Most of us under the age of about 40 managed to get through school and journeys to and from school without having a mobile phone

The point is that the world has moved on. 24/7 contact is a mixed blessing - see parents worrying the their Gen X offspring have been off radar for a day - but they also facilitate stuff we could not do.

Forty years ago there were payphones at the end of every street. If I got in a pickle on the way home I could make a reversed charge call to my Mum.

The rise of the mobile means such boxes, there were even a few doted around the school in 1978, are now like hen's teeth.

AnonnyMouseDave · 21/12/2023 10:26

PuttingDownRoots · 21/12/2023 10:09

@AnonnyMouseDave I presume you have heard of security which is why phones are banned in some workplaces eg Government departments, prisons, defence firms, science labs etc?

Then safeguarding so nurseries, teaching etc?

I thought we were all agreed that the kid shouldn't have his phone out and should be punished, I thought we were debating whether this punishment is a good one?

enchantedsquirrelwood · 21/12/2023 10:21

I am very angry (not quite unhinged) at the thought of my kid's safety after school being put at risk and / or myself of my partner being massively inconvenienced as a result of the school using inappropriate punishments, yes

I am not sure how keeping someone's phone puts your child's safety at risk.

Most of us under the age of about 40 managed to get through school and journeys to and from school without having a mobile phone.

Anyway, if a child is that worried about getting the school bus home without a phone, or walking home without a phone, they'll make sure it stays at the bottom of their bag during lessons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread