Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think this school policy is ridiculous

771 replies

sadbutdontknowwhy · 20/12/2023 11:50

Secondary school
DS15 has had his phone confiscated for the 3rd time this term.
Absolutely fine, he shouldn't have had it out so deserves the punishment
However, they won't give it back to him at 3.15. A parent has to go and collect it.
Tried to explain that 1, it means one of us leaving work, and 2, he needs it to access the gym straight after school, and 3, it his property but they won't budge. It stays with school until a parent can collect
In no way am I kicking off about the confiscation, but I'm fuming I'm also being punished as well!
Arghhhhh. Rant over.

OP posts:
betterangels · 20/12/2023 14:21

Three times is ridiculous. Is there a consequence at home for inconveniencing his parents this way?

Tracker1234 · 20/12/2023 14:19

The boy clearly cannot understand simple rules yet he is allowed to go to a gym and needs his phone to what - make arrangements for a pick up? What is wrong with organising it the night before bearing in mind he wont have his phone.. He will know what time he is finishing.

Anele22 · 20/12/2023 14:19

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 12:01

Every time I hear about schools confiscating phones I wonder what legal right they actually have to take it? Taking it away from your son to stop him using it in class - ok, I suppose, though surely it being left in his bag/locker would be more appropriate than them stealing it? To not return it to him at the end of the day is even more ridiculous though - they should return it to him.

Don’t be ridiculous - they’re not stealing it

RheaRend · 20/12/2023 14:19

Tell him you'll pick it up after Christmas when you have time.

EarthlyNightshade · 20/12/2023 14:19

EarthlyNightshade · 20/12/2023 14:16

What would be your sanctions?
Especially after three occasions of unauthorised phone use.

I can't see where you explained.
You said about moving the bag, what else did you say?
(Sorry, there are a lot of posts)

cardibach · 20/12/2023 14:18

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 13:54

The phone should have been in a bag (under the desk)/locker to start with, hence there being no opportunity to use it.

Yes. It should. It wasn’t.
Next.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:17

EarthlyNightshade · 20/12/2023 14:16

What would be your sanctions?
Especially after three occasions of unauthorised phone use.

If you scroll back you'll see I have already explained.

UrsulaBelle · 20/12/2023 14:17

The trouble with just confiscating it and giving it back to the child is that it’s not an adequate punishment or deterrent. Where’s the deterrent? Your child shouldn’t be using his phone during the school day, so whether it’s in his bag switched off or in a teacher’s drawer it’s all the same to your DS. He can’t use it. So he may as well try to use it and risk getting caught.

Unless there’s a stronger deterrent like parents having to collect it, confiscation doesn’t work. You can’t confiscate it for a week as parents may argue it’s needed in the evenings etc. So parents being inconvenienced and angry with their children works much better as a deterrent.

EarthlyNightshade · 20/12/2023 14:16

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:14

Of course sanctions are needed, but they don't have to involve physically taking someone else's property.

What would be your sanctions?
Especially after three occasions of unauthorised phone use.

cardibach · 20/12/2023 14:16

AnonnyMouseDave · 20/12/2023 13:51

They may well call for a lift when they finish at the gym? They may need to call as they leave the gym to let their parents know when they are due home?

When my kids are old enough to have phones and are wandering around by themselves I do not consent to a teacher deciding my kids don;t need their phone to be safe getting home.

But that’s getting home from the gym, not school. He could get home safe.y without the gym. Or ask the gym to phone. What would he do if his phone froze/died/was stolen because he keeps showing it around at school?

greenacrylicpaint · 20/12/2023 14:14

yabu
our dc school has a similar policy.
4th time it's parents pick up the phone after a week...
they learn quickly.
dc put their phones into their lockers as soon as they arrive at school.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:14

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 14:13

But if you did have a local school that allowed kids to use their phones as and when with no fear of sanctions you'd pick it right? Strangely, in my city, hardly anyone does.

Of course sanctions are needed, but they don't have to involve physically taking someone else's property.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:13

BombaySamphire · 20/12/2023 14:11

Now we have the “possible disabilities” thing 🙄
Being too dumb to learn your lesson until the third time you’re told doesn’t qualify.

That comment doesn't sound as clever as you think it does.

Tracker1234 · 20/12/2023 14:13

Bombay has said what others are thinking! There are some really entitled pain in the bottoms on this thread who think the world revolves around what THEY want for themselves and their kids. Phones are a massive issue in schools now.

I am not always the greatest fan of teachers but honestly they cannot be messing around moving people's bags, making sure they have what they want, moving bags to the back of the class etc.

Jesus - no wonder some schools struggle with discipline.

The boy cannot follow simple rules. You need to take a half day leave or better still move him to a school where they dont have rules like this and they can just do what they like and you dont get bothered like this.

FGS - speak to your son and tell him that him messing around has caused you to have to take his consequences. Unless of course you are teaching him that doing what he likes is just fine with you.

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 14:13

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:09

Two high schools where we live, the others would involve a long boat journey either side.
(I realise we're not typical.....)

But if you did have a local school that allowed kids to use their phones as and when with no fear of sanctions you'd pick it right? Strangely, in my city, hardly anyone does.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:13

NuffSaidSam · 20/12/2023 14:05

Yeah I know!

And we've all been telling you that's what the rule at his school is 😂😂

You agree with the school.

You think the rule should be phones in bags/lockers.

The rule is phones should be in bags/lockers.

You and the school are on exactly the same page 😂

Slight concern for your reading comprehension that it's taken this long, but fair play you got there in the end.

So, what would your policy for punishment be? I know you disagree with the school on that one, but this boy has broken YOUR rule. The rule YOU wanted. He didn't keep his phone in his bag or locker like YOU think he should. Oh dear. What now?

I don't agree with the school.
They confiscated something that isn't theirs to confiscate.
Read my posts properly before appearing so smug in your wrong assertions.

BombaySamphire · 20/12/2023 14:11

Now we have the “possible disabilities” thing 🙄
Being too dumb to learn your lesson until the third time you’re told doesn’t qualify.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:11

Cerealkiller4U · 20/12/2023 14:08

@Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter the issue is you agree to the schools policies and terms and conditions as it is. So to then say you don’t…..

there are policies that you can access online and it shows you what your school can/can’t do.

for example hair styles is usually a big one. But you’ve always signed into it.

I'm really not sure how you are getting that from my comments.
I have always said the phones should be out of reach (unless it's in one of the classes they are allowed to use them some of the time), it's the school taking and it and not returning it/making it difficult to get back that I have issue with.

willWillSmithsmith · 20/12/2023 14:10

Catza · 20/12/2023 11:55

Invoice the school for your time off work.

No, not picking it up in a hurry would be a far better consequence. Your method is condoning her son as well as no consequences for him.

Anisette · 20/12/2023 14:09

Ffsmakeitstop · 20/12/2023 13:29

Struggling to follow rules. What a shame. Time they learnt to follow rules.

That rather depends, doesn't it? If the school is arbitrarily bringing out lots of new rules and changing the goalposts, it needs to allow some slack, particularly to children with possible disabilities.

Boobsallgone21 · 20/12/2023 14:09

It’s a very common school policy and the idea is that the child and parents are inconvenienced and hopefully won’t do it again

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 14:09

@Nanny0gg I expect their kids are really fucking careful not to get their phones confiscated in the first place. But our school will return unclaimed phones to kids at the end of the school year.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 14:09

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 14:05

Oh I don't know, most places have at least one school with terribly low standards of behaviour and plenty of spaces. They're just not really that popular for some reason.

Two high schools where we live, the others would involve a long boat journey either side.
(I realise we're not typical.....)

LondonJax · 20/12/2023 14:08

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 13:30

OK, it's not theirs to confiscate then.
The policy should be that phones are left in lockers, if they have them, or in bags under the desk, during class time.
Taking/confiscating/stealing something that isn't yours is not acceptable.

Also, this has been raised already but worth saying again - some schools expect children to have a phone use in some subjects (eg they play kahoot games as a class or they look up info etc) but also penalise them for glancing at said phone. It is a mixed message.

Our policy is that phones are switched off in pockets on in bags under the desk during the school day.

So in line with what you've said.

I've had kids taking their phone out in the corridor to text their friends to say where they are. All phones should be switched off and in pockets or in bags.

Or call their mum (in front of me or a colleague - the lack of respect is ridiculous) to ask if they can go to a particular club or out with a friend (we have a rule that they can call parents from the school office and they can use their phones after school finishes). All phones should be switched off and in pockets or in bags.

Or check their timetable (which is on their laptop or which a member of staff can print out for them at any time and, at this time of year, I'll guarantee most kids know where they are going. I ask kids regularly, just out of politeness, what's your next lesson. Not one has ever had to check their phone by this time as they've had the same timetable for 12 weeks plus). All phone should be switched off and in pockets or bags.

Sorry for the repeat of the policy. That's the reality. The kids (and their parents) know the policy. They just don't seem to think it applies to them (or their kids). It does. It applies to everyone including me. It only doesn't apply if there is a medical need - like an app that monitors something for the child. In which case they have a note on the PC for the teachers and the nurse issues a card to show if they are told to put the phone away. But still the kids get their phones out. A policy is useless unless it has sanctions or consequences.

I can't have my phone out during school time. As a mother I manage to obey it and my need could be said to be greater than a kid's as I have a child so could get a call from their school. If I can cope, the kids can cope.

Cerealkiller4U · 20/12/2023 14:08

@Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter the issue is you agree to the schools policies and terms and conditions as it is. So to then say you don’t…..

there are policies that you can access online and it shows you what your school can/can’t do.

for example hair styles is usually a big one. But you’ve always signed into it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread