Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter knows that everything is fake

307 replies

Krismuss · 20/12/2023 09:48

I don’t know what has gone wrong here. My 3 year old daughter knows everything is fake. A few examples - I took her to see Santa - afterwards I asked if she enjoyed it and she said “yes, but it’s only pretend isn’t it?”
We went to Disneyland earlier this year and I said “wow look DD, a real princess castle!” And she said “silly mummy, it’s not real”. Same with the characters - she knew they were just people playing dress up.

Last week I took her to a party and “Elsa” was there. “Elsa” danced with her and when we got home I told DH that DD had been dancing with Elsa - DD said “not the real Elsa though, because it’s not real, only pretend”.

I said to her this morning “you best be good because Father Christmas is watching!” And she again said “it’s not real mummy”

she has no older siblings or relatives that would tell her this and she isn’t at school or nursery. Why doesn’t she believe in anything? :-( I feel like there is no point in doing the usual small child activities because she knows it’s all fake. Even at the Christmas market there were reindeers there and I said “I wonder which one is rudolf?” And she said “they’re just reindeers, none are rudolf”.

DH hasn’t told her anything is fake either, he’s as perplexed as I am. So not to drip feed she is on the waiting list for autism assessment, could this have something to do with it?

OP posts:
ZebraDanios · 20/12/2023 13:25

WinkyTinky · 20/12/2023 13:22

I think she sounds great! My two are similar, very down to earth and scientific, and I much prefer that to all the silly pretend stuff that some kids bang on about. Good for her!

I believed in Santa until I was 11. I also have a chemistry degree. You can be scientific and still enjoy “all that silly pretend stuff”.

MrsTwatInAHat · 20/12/2023 13:24

I was this child too. It's not a bad thing to have a bullshit detector!

As as PPs say, you can still enjoy all the traditions and fun "make believe" without actually believing it - much like theatre or fairy tales. Ignore anyone who thinks children have to be "innocent" and swallow the "magic" of Christmas wholesale or else it's all ruined.

SisterAgatha · 20/12/2023 13:23

I believed in Santa. My grandad worked at a place that reports the news on TV and so when we saw “Santa” at his workplace party, why wouldn’t I believe an international news organisation. That’s logic.

Santa in a suit that smells like a storage unit, in a local shopping centre, with toy reindeer, of course looks shifty. That’s also logic and instinct.

Neither of those are exclusive to autism though.

If you told her the sky is red and expected her to believe you and didn’t, would you call that autism too? Let’s be sensible.

WinkyTinky · 20/12/2023 13:22

I think she sounds great! My two are similar, very down to earth and scientific, and I much prefer that to all the silly pretend stuff that some kids bang on about. Good for her!

Covidwoes · 20/12/2023 13:19

@Katiesaidthat my 5 year old DD is exactly the same!

Katiesaidthat · 20/12/2023 13:18

My daughter does believe in father Christmas but knows that all the ones she sees around are helpers (so fake). She´s 5.

ohdamnitjanet · 20/12/2023 13:15

Wow, I love your daughter, she’s fab!

laclochette · 20/12/2023 13:13

I didn't believe Disney, Santa at grottos etc were real at her age either. I don't think it's a problem per se. As ever it's how we handle these things. I would focus on enjoying the power of imagination. After all, we all enjoy what isn't real all our lives - films, novels etc. it's about going there with her, but in a way that emphasises what we can all imagine and enjoy for the pleasure it brings to suspend our disbelief. As little kids, we don't do this because we actually believe. The magic is that once we know the truth, we still take pleasure!

VolvoFan · 20/12/2023 13:11

Unlikely to be because she's autistic, she's just very intelligent and not easily fooled. You have a very smart kid, OP. Be proud.

ZebraDanios · 20/12/2023 13:08

And that not seeing they're pretend doesn't make people silly, it's OK for people, especially children her age, to believe in those things.

I can’t remember which book I read this in, but children’s brains are actually programmed to be a bit gullible, because there just isn’t time for them to learn everything they need to learn by experience. There’s nothing defective or “less”
about children who don’t think these things are fake, and it doesn’t mean they’ll grow up to believe everything they hear either.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 20/12/2023 13:08

It is fake though. I don’t think anything has gone wrong at all — rather the opposite. I’m all for a bit of knowing make-believe but actually can’t understand the parents who actively set out to deceive their children by wanting them to believe Santa etc are ‘real’.

DrNo007 · 20/12/2023 13:07

And I agree with those who point out that not believing in the fantasy doesn’t mean you don’t enjoy Xmas.

ZebraDanios · 20/12/2023 13:04

Sceptic1234 · 20/12/2023 12:58

I've said this before......but I cannot believe any child truely believes in father christmas. I never did, and I cannot remember a single child in my class / friendship group who ever did. This doesn't mean we didn't enjoy the idea of Santa claus etc, it's just that we all knew it was a whimsical fantasy and just a nice idea to make christmas fun.

We also knew that elves, fairies, dragons etc did not really exist. Doesn't mean we didn't enjoy stories about them.

I am in my mid 60s, and, until recently, I don't think I have ever met a parent who thought their children really believed in Santa. I have deliberately spoken about this to several women my age.... by and large they all agree with me. They all knew that their children understood that it was just a story. Everyone joined in just for the fun of it. I think the idea of children really believing is very recent. I have sometimes wondered if it's related to video games / on line life. Children don't seem to "play make believe" anymore.

Your daughter sounds perfectly normal to me.

I can assure you that I very definitely believed Santa was 100% real. I was not just playing along. I vividly remember being unable to sleep one Christmas Eve, falling asleep for what felt like five minutes, and being astonished that he’d been in that time.

But as previously mentioned, I have always had a very lively imagination!

DrNo007 · 20/12/2023 13:04

Your daughter is very bright and I was the same as a kid.🙂 As someone who can tell the difference between lies and reality she is well equipped to cope with modern life. Don’t try to keep up lies, however attached you might be to the idea that it’s somehow good for kids to be sucked into them, as you don’t want her associating her parent with deception (which is what happened to me, however people might condemn the young me as a neurotic over-thinker).

Youregoingthewrongway · 20/12/2023 13:03

I knew it was all fake, op. Didn’t stop me enjoying it, just took it for what it was. I remember telling my older db not to be scared by the rando in our house on Christmas Eve, it was just our dad in a costume. I must have been 3 1/2.

Echobelly · 20/12/2023 12:59

I agree that maybe it's just her personality, I'd try not to problematise it. Although also I might have a word with her about other children and that if she says things to peers it might spoil things for them if they like to see the things DD knows aren't real as actually real. And that not seeing they're pretend doesn't make people silly, it's OK for people, especially children her age, to believe in those things.

Canisaysomething · 20/12/2023 12:59

Believing in things like Santa and the tooth fairy isn’t about thinking things are real. It’s about believing in the magic of make believe, myths and fantasy. Just have a conversation about this with your child.

Sceptic1234 · 20/12/2023 12:58

I've said this before......but I cannot believe any child truely believes in father christmas. I never did, and I cannot remember a single child in my class / friendship group who ever did. This doesn't mean we didn't enjoy the idea of Santa claus etc, it's just that we all knew it was a whimsical fantasy and just a nice idea to make christmas fun.

We also knew that elves, fairies, dragons etc did not really exist. Doesn't mean we didn't enjoy stories about them.

I am in my mid 60s, and, until recently, I don't think I have ever met a parent who thought their children really believed in Santa. I have deliberately spoken about this to several women my age.... by and large they all agree with me. They all knew that their children understood that it was just a story. Everyone joined in just for the fun of it. I think the idea of children really believing is very recent. I have sometimes wondered if it's related to video games / on line life. Children don't seem to "play make believe" anymore.

Your daughter sounds perfectly normal to me.

Ethylred · 20/12/2023 12:57

She sounds fantastic. Send her here if she's too much for you.

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 12:55

My son was exactly the same and he's autistic. Autism isn't a superpower by any means but my son's special ability, which I've seen in quite a few autistic kids, is to be very clearsighted when it comes to reality. From a young age he hated things like Father Christmas because its so bloody illogical (put his hand up in class and asked why children were starving if FC could bring them food and if he didn't, why didn't he and why wasn't that more important than giving toys - poor teacher!).

It hasn't stopped him enjoying Christmas mind you, and he enjoyed the tooth fairy as a game - he didn't need it to be real.

It helps with other things too. He has no truck with sexual stereotyping because he can see how ridiculous it is.

He's very good at spotting the difference between what people say and how they behave, which has meant he's chosen good friends and is surprisingly politically (small p) astute.

He is not tolerant of hypocrisy (although he's learnt to hold his tongue about it on occasion). And whatever the antithesis of gullible is, he's that.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/12/2023 12:54

ShoesoftheWorld · 20/12/2023 10:06

We've never, ever pretended any of this sort of stuff is real. We've always taken it for what it is - a fun game. Any direct questions got a direct answer. 'No, it's not real, but it's a lovely game to enjoy playing'.

My dd is 8 and has always known this but appears this year to have made the decision to 'believe' (to suspend her disbelief, anyway) in Santa. She is a very imaginative girl and knows the stories she makes up are stories but are no less joyful for that.

I've never subscribed to this strange idea that 'magic' comes from actually believing something is real. I think it comes from the ability to enter (and leave) worlds of imagination at will. Your dd is enjoying things in her way. Leave her to it. It's fine.

This x 10

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 20/12/2023 12:53

Why would you want your DD to believe in lies in the first place?

NotFastButFurious · 20/12/2023 12:47

My mum tells me I was the same about Santa from being a toddler and I don’t recall ever having a moment where I found out he wasn’t real!

ZebraDanios · 20/12/2023 12:45

Pigeonqueen · 20/12/2023 12:41

I agree. As per my comment above I believed in Santa and “magic” until I was 13, I have autism and I’m definitely not stupid - was accepted into Oxbridge and given a full scholarship to one of the top private schools.

Thank you!

I’m not autistic, but also believed in Santa until I was about 11 I think, and also went to Oxbridge.

I remember during one of the summer holidays when I was about 19 I got so absorbed in a book that when my Dad asked me what had happened that day I started telling him I’d heard about this thing on the news…and then I remembered that actually, it had just happened in my book!

BallaiLuimni · 20/12/2023 12:43

The whole 'santa is real' thing pissed me off as a child, it was all so stupid and it annoyed me that anyone would try to trick me into believing it. I never spoiled anyone else's belief but I objected to having to pretend I believed something so obviously untrue.

As result we never made out the whole thing was real with our kids - we just said it's a nice story. My DS never bothered with it (he's like me) but my DD has always talked about Santa - the fact that she knows it's not real makes no difference to her, in fact, I think it's better as there'll be no realisation of the truth.

It boggles me when people think you have to insist Santa is real to preserve the magic - to me that's very small, literal thinking. You can imagine something and still find it magical and exciting, no lies required.