Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My daughter knows that everything is fake

307 replies

Krismuss · 20/12/2023 09:48

I don’t know what has gone wrong here. My 3 year old daughter knows everything is fake. A few examples - I took her to see Santa - afterwards I asked if she enjoyed it and she said “yes, but it’s only pretend isn’t it?”
We went to Disneyland earlier this year and I said “wow look DD, a real princess castle!” And she said “silly mummy, it’s not real”. Same with the characters - she knew they were just people playing dress up.

Last week I took her to a party and “Elsa” was there. “Elsa” danced with her and when we got home I told DH that DD had been dancing with Elsa - DD said “not the real Elsa though, because it’s not real, only pretend”.

I said to her this morning “you best be good because Father Christmas is watching!” And she again said “it’s not real mummy”

she has no older siblings or relatives that would tell her this and she isn’t at school or nursery. Why doesn’t she believe in anything? :-( I feel like there is no point in doing the usual small child activities because she knows it’s all fake. Even at the Christmas market there were reindeers there and I said “I wonder which one is rudolf?” And she said “they’re just reindeers, none are rudolf”.

DH hasn’t told her anything is fake either, he’s as perplexed as I am. So not to drip feed she is on the waiting list for autism assessment, could this have something to do with it?

OP posts:
DewHopper · 21/12/2023 17:55

She's a smart kid OP. Stop trying to pretend that all that shit is real!

Anotherpinkginplease · 21/12/2023 17:52

Does she watch YouTube? We've had some near misses thanks to YouTube videos!

ThreeLocusts · 20/12/2023 21:53

Sounds to me like your daughter has good intuitions. A good bullshit detector. I don't think anything has gone wrong. You can teach her to be polite about others' beliefs without sharing them.

gannett · 20/12/2023 21:05

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/12/2023 09:57

She's smart and insightful.

However, it might be a plan to start teaching her about protecting other's feelings, as although she's only disappointing you at the moment, you don't really want her to be the reality check kid telling all of Reception Santa's not real - or declaring that religion is nonsense either in school or to somebody whose parent has died that their Daddy isn't in Heaven, silly, there's no such thing.

I was that kid in reception class. I didn't understand why it was such a bad thing to have just told everyone the truth, and yet I was the one who got in trouble. A part of me still doesn't understand.

I never believed in Santa. I knew what stories were and I knew what myths were and I just naturally put Santa into that category. (I still loved reading stories, knowing that it's fiction doesn't take away any magic at all.)

Not believing in God proved rather more problematic in a heavily religious family and was probably the origin story of having to go NC with them.

Aroundthewaygirl · 20/12/2023 20:59

She sounds like she would be fun to be around.

I knew at around 5 yrs old that Santa wasn't real but didn't take away my enjoyment of Xmas.

Balloonhearts · 20/12/2023 19:09

And also be thankful that you will never have to know the torture of doing bloody elf on the bastard shelf.

Puffling235 · 20/12/2023 18:25

This thread made me smile. I've always intuitively known not to take dd to 'meet Santa', knew she'd see straight through it and have far too many questions. Confirmed when we spotted one from afar at a lights show and she asked 'why is that man dressed up as Santa, mummy?' 😅 Better to keep a bit of distance/mystery for these kinds of kids. We managed through til age 7 / y2....

EtiennePalmiere · 20/12/2023 18:14

Does any child think the Disney characters are real instead of people in costumes ? I never believed in Santa either, this is a non-issue

begaydocrime42 · 20/12/2023 15:46

My daughter believes in God (her choice) but never believed in Santa. I remember her saying why do we have modern things but Santa doesn't have technology? It did make me think it is ridiculous that people push the idea of a bearded man that exists solely in a quasi-Victorian bubble!

whatsappdoc · 20/12/2023 14:41

... just in case.

whatsappdoc · 20/12/2023 14:40

Thinking back to my own childhood I felt the same about santa as god. I didn't think they were real but I 'believed'

hydriotaphia · 20/12/2023 14:30

Totally normal in my experience.

NoTouch · 20/12/2023 14:10

“not the real Elsa though, because it’s not real, only pretend”.

She thinks there is a "real Elsa" though. Does she think there is a "real" Santa too?

I think it is fine, and healthy, preferable, they know the Santa's and Elsa's at parties etc are not the "real" ones. Mickey at Disney is not the "real" mouse etc. I don't recall ds thinking any of them were "real" - the best real ones are in your imagination. Which is why I always kept it light and avoided any excessive attempts to provide evidence they were "real" - like half eaten mince pies and snow prints on the carpet Christmas morning or moving Elves on Shelves in the run up. It was still magical to ds in his own imagination.

Then as they get older, develop and they mature they realise how the "real" ones work. Such as Santa is a "real" historical tradition loosely based on St Nick, and the "real" Elsa is a character in a movie.

Each parent needs to adjust their approach to their individual child.

Wobblyheart · 20/12/2023 14:02

Oh yes, forgot to mention that someone I know has an autistic son who is 11 and still believes in Santa so I think this is more of a personality thing!

SapphireSeptember · 20/12/2023 13:49

I'm on the other end, I still believed in Father Christmas when I was 12! I'm also autistic, but a great believer in magical things and woo, and I have a deeply held belief system that brings me great comfort.

JesusAndMaryPain · 20/12/2023 13:48

My kids loved "fake santa". Introduce her to the concept or pretending as being fun! "Believing" is about believing in the spirit or idea of it, not the actual thing. Your DD sounds fabulous!

dottiedodah · 20/12/2023 13:39

I think she sounds clued up! Maybe just see if she wants to keep it a secret though ,dont want her to tell other DC. She sounds smart and grounded to me .I always wondered as a child how on earth Santa made all his deliveries .

Anisette · 20/12/2023 13:36

I would guess that she can just see for herself that the Santas and Elsas concerned don't look like the ones she's seen in books or on screen. It may well have something to do with possible ASD, as some people on the spectrum can tend to be quite rigid about facts and will not see nuances, It might tend to mean that, for instance, your DD would struggle to tell polite lies (e.g. "I had a lovely time" when she hasn't) but you can keep an eye open for that and maybe start teaching her early.

scalt · 20/12/2023 13:36

I was like this as a child. As my parents put it, I "saw through the system" with many things. I knew that stories were made up, and I enjoyed discussions at primary school on "is this story true?". From a young age, I noticed that teachers asked questions when they already knew the answers, so it was a bit of an act. I never believed in Santa; he was just another story. At the theatre, I was often far more interested in the mechanics and stage lights that what was happening on the stage; in the cinema, I would look behind me to see where the picture was coming from (and in those days, you could see the projector beams through the smoke). My parents didn't bother making things out to be true, because I wouldn't have believed it.

However, I did have some wrong ideas: I believed that if things appeared a lot in stories, they must be fake, and sometimes I was surprised to learn that certain things were real. For example, rainbows: I remember the amazement of seeing one for the first time. Also that the Queen was real, although I was a bit confused by us not having a King as well, like in fairy tales. I usually liked it when something I had believed imaginary turned out to be real: I was delighted to learn that Hamelin (as in the Pied Piper of Hamelin) is a real place.

I remember one time adults briefly convinced me something "magical" was happening, aged five or six. I was blindfolded and sat in a chair outdoors, which was lifted up, and told I was flying really high up, with "look at those tiny fields and houses below". For a few minutes, I actually felt I was flying, especially as I found I was in a very different place from where I thought I had started. Some years later, I learned how they created this illusion, but I did believe it for a while.

MrsTwatInAHat · 20/12/2023 13:34

Yes I'm not dissing kids who do believe in it - until they're about 10 (if NT) and then I can't really believe they do, but they way some parents push it it's not surprising they feel they have to say they do.

Obviously children, like everyone, have a range of different levels of credulity or inclination to believe things that don't make logical sense, and that's a normal human spectrum IMO.

BudgieBardot · 20/12/2023 13:34

My daughter is pretty much the same. Last year when she 3, and getting the gifts out of her stocking she said "thank you Mummy"

cordeliaflynne · 20/12/2023 13:32

My DS was like this - "of course there are no trolls under the bridge, there's no such thing", "we can visit the wizard's cave but its not real, wizards aren't real", "how can Father Christmas fit down the chimney and anyway the fire is in the way so it must be you" etc. etc. Just a quick heads up, another mum at primary school was very cross with me (not sure why me as he has formed these opinons on his own much like your child) as her child completely believed and mine was voicing his (quite reasonable) doubts. Difficult to explain to a 4/5 year old that there are some things they should keep to themselves in front of their classmates. Easier when they are a few years older.

Wobblyheart · 20/12/2023 13:30

I am NT and used to believe in Santa somewhat but also could clearly remember that when I was around 4-5 I knew that Santa that we met was fake. Your daughter sounds like he communicates great with you btw, and sounds fabulous!

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 13:30

I was totally credulous as a child btw (and am a scientist now), so that wasn't meant as an insult.

Tacotortoise · 20/12/2023 13:28

You can enjoy "all that silly pretend stuff" without being credulous tbf.