Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my teen to have a friendlier attitude?

56 replies

ShabbyChic999 · 20/12/2023 09:42

I'd love some advice please. My DS1 is 15 and used to be a gorgeous friendly outgoing boy. Now he is sullen and unfriendly to us and to our friends or extended family.

He's an unusual boy but has a great group of friends. When I say "unusual" I mean his hobbies are Dungeons and Dragons, Magic the Gathering and other niche board games and card games (aswell as regular video gaming). He's well behaved in terms of the fact he works hard at school work and doesn't look for big ways to rebel.......no way he'd go out drinking or anything like that, in fact his weekend socialising consists of getting together with his group for one of their boardgame or card game sessions around the table. He just seems to have no time for talking to anyone who doesn't interest him though. He walks around the house with his earbuds in most of the time listening to podcasts 😢 So he basically shuts us all out. At times we do ban the earbuds (obviously meals) and it can sometimes be possible to draw him out to a lively debate if we can hit upon a topic of his interest but otherwise he'll sit in silence. We have one other child and they get on ok but don't have much in common.

My main concern is how awkward he is socially, we had family over last weekend and he just grunted a bit not looking them in the eye and then disappeared upstairs. I'm wondering how I can encourage him to try, persuade him or bribe him or what?!?!? My brother is good with him as he ignores the unfriendly front and just starts chatting and they have lengthy debates about history or politics! But most of the family will just politely ask how he's getting on and I think he just isn't interested to engage and not polite enough to go along with it. He just totally ignores his little cousins. I get so sad when I think of how chatty and friendly he used to be, I thought the initial teen angst would pass but think I need to take action as it's going on 2 years now...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 03/01/2024 19:46

He sounds normal to me.

My ds avoided family events for about 2 years. He came back and is delightful now. This is what teens do. I mean his ambition at 16 was to win a World of Warcraft tournament.

He had a normal job now!

Wooloohooloo · 03/01/2024 19:42

He needs to be polite to visitors but I'd stop badgering him to engage when it's just his immediate family at home. It's normal behaviour for a 15 year old and he's more likely to chat when you're not pestering him.

CatherinedeBourgh · 03/01/2024 19:02

If you like novels/the theatre, it's really easy to engage with him on D&D without any need to get into the specifics. If he DMs, that's like writing a play where any of the main characters can at any point wander off and do whatever they want.

I know next to nothing about the technical side of D&D, but often have long conversations with ds about the campaigns he's creating - we talk about what makes a good villain, the importance of the relationship between characters and how to create situations to help them develop these, how to make side characters likeable enough for the players to want to get to know them better, and so on.

It's fun.

nfkl · 03/01/2024 12:21

He is 15, if he doesn t learn to make the effort to pay attention to others, feel comfortable in public, have sociable manners, etc. it will probably only go downhill and make it more and more difficult to acquire these skills later on.
A very serious conversation is in order and a change of daily habits, maybe have take him up on a social activity/hobby outside of his comfort zone.
Social skills are not instinctive.
If they don t learn young, they will be disadvantaged as an adult: dating, job, social life, self-esteem, mental health, social isolation, etc.
And beyond the social part, it s also an open gate to make kids self-involved, with low empathy and curiosity for the world.

They can decide at 12 only gaming matters, because they are never challenged by too accommodating parents, be left to it until ... then, what is going to make their world bigger?

Haggisfish3 · 03/01/2024 12:03

As an aside op, my partner is now 50 and still does d and d with a group of mates he has had since 15. They did it over lockdown and they are a remarkably resilient and happy group
of men, in no small part due to the regular interactions with each other consistently over such a long period of time. They do it on zoom now so they can do it from wherever they are and it’s very very cheap!

it’s also becoming much less niche-there is a fab festival called fantasy forest that has loads of role playing people and stalls.

ShabbyChic999 · 03/01/2024 11:58

Thanks everyone, I really appreciate each of you and the empathy you showed, it really helps and I think I need to refer back to this thread when I'm losing patience with him ❤
I definitely need to try and take an interest in his interests, I hold my hand up that I just have not tried at all.

OP posts:
Nomagicflute · 30/12/2023 07:32

He sounds great. Especially when you hear concerns of other teenagers parents and what they're up to. We're all different and it's possible he's very introverted or autistic or just doesn't like small talk or is a teenager.

I would try not to wish to change him. He's not something to be fixed. I'd just go for a few basic polite things like you need to say hello to relatives explain why.

When I was a teenager I'd get the opposite... you talk too much etc... it can seem like nothing is 'right'.

I'd try to talk to him about things that interest him but also accept he's not a big talker.

Flyhigher · 29/12/2023 11:25

I have not coped with my teen doing this at all.
I wasn't like this. I was desperate to talk to anyone. Also. I could chat a bit and move on and also cuddle little cousins. Boys are different.
He will snap out of it. Keep yourself sane in the meantime.

Flyhigher · 29/12/2023 11:23

It stops a bit at 16. Still think he needs family members his age to talk to. Or encourage one friend to come home when family descend.
Also maybe play games with family. Line charades etc. or guessing games.

Defaultsettings · 29/12/2023 09:06

RLA1 · 28/12/2023 19:09

We have on of those. He went up to University (London) as a normal outgoing type and returned 3 years later as opinionated, gay, and veggie and behaved exactly as your son. We tried to bring him back to our version of 'society' and failed. And as he explained 'why does he have to conform to our way of thinking'? He does his own thing, doesn't harm anyone and seems happy enough. So we stopped trying. Were all happier that way

i would think that he was gay before university but didn’t have the courage to tell you in case you ‘tried to bring him back to your version of society’

Maray1967 · 28/12/2023 23:58

MissyB1 · 20/12/2023 10:52

Yep mine is the same! Gets me down sometimes though I must admit. I pre warn him now before we have visitors to remember his manners.

Same here with my 15 year old.

Fortunately his older brother is out the other side now (23).

Stephenra · 28/12/2023 23:56

Sounds perfectly normal to me. I would warmly recommend Blame My Brain by Nicola Morgan. It explains the mechanisms and behaviour of the teen brain without any technical jargon and it's very funny. It will put your mind at rest. I found it hilarious that my friend's teenage daughter often quoted this book when arguing with her mum.

Bexter76 · 28/12/2023 22:46

Teen brains are going through huge neurological changes at this stage and, as annoying as it is, it's entirely normal behaviour. Reminders about manners and engaging all help but unfortunately this is a stage he biologically needs to go through.

mambojambodothetango · 28/12/2023 22:25

My 3 nephews are all delightfully sociable and enjoy chatting with us and playing with our younger DC when we see them. Their parents have always expected and modelled the behaviour they expect and they have succeeded. Sure they're normal teens and will eventually slope off or look at their phones but only after a decent amount of time engaging with people. I think OP's son sounds pretty good really and the family member who persists in engaging with him obviously gets results. I agree, keep expecting it and it will come. Maybe not just yet but it will.

MrsAKB · 28/12/2023 21:55

I haven't read other replies so have no idea what others have said (will try to read a few in a mo) but my daughter is same age and there are lots of similarities (especially the ear buds), I'm really struggling at the mo. Have actually spent afternoon sobbing because I've told her to remain at her dad's until she can change her behaviour to be less mean-spiritted! Starting to feel like she takes the pee big time. I'm told it's their age. Xxx

Tittiesthattouchmytors · 28/12/2023 20:35

Teens innit.

Echobelly · 28/12/2023 19:30

I think it's a very common teenage phase for both boys and girls - just sort of grunting and avoiding people and being awkward for at least a year some time between 13-16 but they tend to come out of the other side by 16ish. I think kids that age often feel awkward and out of sorts and not sure how to interact with people now they're not a cute little kid but also not quite an adult.

Nothingelsetobedoing · 28/12/2023 19:21

I could have written this about my son a year ago. He’s 16 now. During lockdown and for a time after he was exactly as you describe except his life was spent gaming.

I have real empathy for you, and him. It’s a really difficult time.

To be honest I didn’t haul him over the coals about it. Didn't chastise him. Didn’t make him feel guilty about it. Perhaps I should have but he was clearly quite unhappy.

Fast forward a couple of years and we have a light at the end of the tunnel. He got a part time job, a girlfriend and his hormones have settled down a bit. People have commented on how much more relaxed he seems.

He still struggles with certain people and if he doesn’t like someone he won’t engage with them.

So no real advice but my experience is that it’s a tricky phase but it will pass. Slowly but surely.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 28/12/2023 19:20

Awww - it's pretty normal and he'll get over it! Definitely pull him up on any outright rudeness, but be understanding about the monosyllabic teen grunts. I have a geeky 15yo ds too, who can be socially awkward, though he's fine with us.

HulaChick · 28/12/2023 19:15

If a teenager is sullen or rude, they absolutely need to be pulled up on it! Just because they're teenagers is not an excuse. None of us as teenagers were rude & sullen like that to wider family & guests, nor are my children or nephews. If we were rude at all, we would soon be told. My children have been brought up to be polite and chat to adults / family. If I were you, I would limit massively his time on screens and get him to be involved in family stuff & a not let him be able to have his ear buds in all the time. He's only 15 and should know how to behave. I get it that he can be rude & grumpy but it should be immediately pulled up on and he should be told it's not acceptable to behave like that. It sounds as though he's become unhealthily immersed in online gaming which is a curse in itself. 'Real' life seems to be getting much rarer these days.

Edit - this is purely a response to "all teenagers are rude & sulken", as all are not, although all certainly are at some stage but it shouldn't be brushed aside or ignored just because they're teenagers. Sorry, I realise this probably sounds pompous but I'm trying to do a million things at once and hate typing on my phone..

Jomasell · 28/12/2023 19:10

My 17 yr old went thro the ignore everyone and live in his room from 14 to 16 but now hes come out of it and engages more although still has periods of "youre all doing my head in" and storms off. He does have older sibs that are adults (36,35, 32, 29 amd 21) so their input may have encouraged him to be more approachable now. He also was sociable enough to play footy for a team, but for a while there I was head in hands. He may come through over time. Teens are rotten.

RLA1 · 28/12/2023 19:09

We have on of those. He went up to University (London) as a normal outgoing type and returned 3 years later as opinionated, gay, and veggie and behaved exactly as your son. We tried to bring him back to our version of 'society' and failed. And as he explained 'why does he have to conform to our way of thinking'? He does his own thing, doesn't harm anyone and seems happy enough. So we stopped trying. Were all happier that way

Philandbill · 23/12/2023 15:29

My friend claims she doesn't know when her son's voice broke as he only grunted for three years... He's in his twenties now and a sociable and productive member of the community 😀

Kaleidoscopeofbutterflies · 23/12/2023 15:14

I have three teenage Grandsons who are like this.. all ASD.. Will talk all day about their interests or with their peers..
I wouldn't have them any other way.

Mapletreelane · 23/12/2023 14:17

Completely normal. DS is 16 now and coming out the other side, and I see glimpses of a pleasant young man.

I realise now that Kevin the teenager wasn't a Harry Enfield comedy sketch. It was a real life documentary about teenage boys.