Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not yet be happy with my weight?

87 replies

Parvanati · 20/12/2023 09:11

I am probably vain so that’s fine you can come for me on that and I don’t want to make anyone feel bad about themselves so sorry. I have worked hard to lose a lot of weight this year and get fitter. I have done this in a sensible calorie deficit, not extreme and I’m not starving myself it’s a whole lifestyle change not just a diet as I will just eat this way at maintenance calories when I stop.

I didn’t feel very comfortable or healthy and I prefer being a size 12 rather than a size 18. Some people can look and dress really nicely at different sizes but it didn’t suit me I felt so bothered and hot when it’s warm and out of breath. I’m not doing it to impress other people or get their validation.

I still have weight to lose to get nearer to a healthy BMI (currently it’s 28) but everyone who sees me keeps telling me to stop, it will affect my face, I will be too slim, I don’t need to lose more etc etc. This includes my partner! People comment on what I eat or when I decline treats and it makes me uncomfortable. Family and DP keep asking if I will eat normally at Christmas and to take time off my diet, keep offering me things, it will be fine I won’t gain weight but actually, I probably would and I don’t want to do it.

Now I do not see what they see and am worried I now have body dysmorphia? I am still 12st 6 and not tall, so I am still overweight? I can see exactly where the remaining weight is held, it’s my tummy, hips and bum, looks ok in clothes but not great naked and I am not happy with how it looks yet. I’m not blind or stupid I don’t think I am misjudging that I am still overweight? (I’m 5’5).

I have diet cycled in the past and fallen off the wagon, and gained even more back I worry a lot about this happening again so this time I have done everything slowly and differently but it’s making me feel anxious.

AIBU to feel like this has anyone else?

OP posts:
Parvanati · 20/12/2023 10:31

Also well done to everyone who has reached their goals or on their way to doing so xx

OP posts:
ActDottie · 20/12/2023 10:27

28 is still overweight so definitely not unhealthy to keep up the healthy eating.

Also comments about your face are silly! I lost a lot of weight and my face slimmed down and I looked better for it! So I really don’t understand their point there! I’m 36 weeks pregnant now and swollen and puffy and put weight on and I don’t like my face!!

lechatnoir · 20/12/2023 10:26

Also had this when I lost quite a bit of weigh - I'm 5ft 6 and went from 13.5 stone to 10.5 and the number of people commenting was staggering. I was a size 12, BMI firmly in the healthy range but would never be described as skinny. Even my Dsis who is teenie tiny at same height & 2.5 stone lighter than me told me I looked skinny so clearly it's nonsense. As others have said, people get used to seeing you a certain way and relatively speaking you will look much slimmer but, at 5ft5 and 12stone6 you are doing amazingly well but should keep going until you are comfortably in the BMI healthy range.

EdgarsTale · 20/12/2023 10:20

Other people can feel very uncomfortable when someone does something about their weight & gets healthy.

You are still overweight, so I’d focus on getting down to a healthy BMI. You’re doing great, so keep at it & ignore those trying to jeopardise your efforts.

Parvanati · 20/12/2023 10:19

thank you all so much, it’s nice to know I am not going mad! I cannot possibly look gaunt I am still quite overweight and it feels gaslighting and bizarre to tell me otherwise?

To who asked about anxiety, it’s that I am afraid to fall off the wagon and when people get into your head that’s easy to do. Also that I am still seeing myself as overweight when people tell me I am not is confusing.

I am going to end up fairly muscular in my lower limbs, as this is my build, I am bottom heavy with muscular legs, so will be more difficult to get and stay under BMI 25, I am also using tape measurements as muscle takes up less space than fat. I will be fine and happy with a BMI of 25/26 and a comfy size 10/12.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 20/12/2023 10:16

I’d just say that you want a healthy bmi. If they trot out the bmi is a load of tosh/x rugby player has a high bmi just say you feel better this way.
That was my aim when losing to be healthy bmi. Then no drs appointment can be fobbed off as oh lose some weight and it personally made my engagement with health checks etc better as I knew they wouldn’t go on about my weight.

Ansjovis · 20/12/2023 10:11

I think sometimes people can be a bit blind when they see you every day. I had a BMI of 27 and got many similar comments. I'm now down to a BMI of 20 and those same people are saying that I look great and I'm clearly so much healthier and fitter.

Seadreamers · 20/12/2023 10:10

I had this when I went from a size 18-20 to a size 8-10. The negative comments far exceeded the positive, and as pp have said a lot of people hate change or are jealous of your willpower and success.

My ‘D’M used to look me up and down and comment when I was overweight, and when I was a size 8-10 she still gave me dirty looks while looking me up and down and would say you are anorexic now, just look at the state of you, you look hideous etc. Some people can’t handle the new you and often the increased self-confidence that goes with it.

Keep on doing what you want and ignore them. If anyone keeps on at you ask them if they would like you to comment negatively on their body to see how they like it.

Allthatglittersisntart · 20/12/2023 10:10

Other people arent always helpful when it comes to weight loss. Is your family on the plump side?
Unless you have lots of muscle mass, you have a way to go and should expect your DP to support you not tempt you! I would focus on how you feel and look rather than BMI though.
Taking a break for Christmas day wont hurt though. You are allowed cheat days.
Yes a fatter face can hide aging but a toned body will actually keep you young and healthy!

FeathersFerns · 20/12/2023 10:09

I had this OP (also 5'5'') - slimmed down from a size 18 to a 12, felt amazing in comparison but still overweight BMI (26). The key to my success was not telling anyone I was trying to lose weight (other than DH and even then I barely talked about it).

People seemed to noticed all of a sudden and then came the comments to stop etc. and the interest in what I was eating. It didn't help at all - and whilst I can't blame them (or Covid - that is when I started to pile it back on again) I am back up to a size 18. I wish I could go back in time and tell myself to cherish and enjoy the size 12 whilst slowly aiming to lose a bit more/stay the same for a bit. Oh and not engage with sharing what I was doing when people noticed.

Janinejones · 20/12/2023 09:59

Congratulations on losing some weight and also for losing it in a sensible way. As others say, people are funny if one is successful at weight loss. It is envy because so many of us fail.
As you have done this in a measured way it is unlikely you will look drawn and gaunt. Keep going to suit yourself, keep up fluid intake and enjoy Christmas & New Year.
🤔When you get to 7st you might want to pause the regime!😉

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 20/12/2023 09:57

My bmi is 28 and I’m a 14. I have lost weight but could easily do with losing a good bit more. People don’t like change and will often undermine efforts to lose weight/ stop drinking. Best thing is to be non-commit all. Oh gosh I don’t know, I’ll just see how it goes/ see what I fancy at the time type replies.

DropDeadFreida · 20/12/2023 09:52

People can have very strange reactions to others' weight loss. I would have a serious conversation with those who are making comments and say that they do not have the right to make comments about your body as you do not do that to them. When you lose weight it's like your body becomes public property-it's very unsettling.

And I know exactly what you mean about how easy it can be to fall off the wagon, the thought is very anxiety-inducing and stays with you forever. And once you have been overweight it can be really easy to regain weight unfortunately, so their comments are not helpful.

LuisCarol · 20/12/2023 09:51

I haven't got any wise advice, but just wanted to say I'm in almost exactly the same position and can very much relate. It's not just you. (And it's not just me, which is helpful to know, thank you).

Sloth66 · 20/12/2023 09:50

Well done on what you’ve achieved so far.
people are threatened by change , that’s their issue not yours.

NotFastButFurious · 20/12/2023 09:41

In my experience no one ever tells you you’re too fat apart from my mother but everyone will comment about how thin you’re getting!
as a nation we are loosing sight of what’s a healthy weight and size because the average is going up and up. A size 12 for many people (myself included) puts them in the overweight BMI category and I agree with you that it’s not where I want to be.

Holly60 · 20/12/2023 09:41

With a BMI of 28 you can still afford to loose a significant amount more weight if that is what you want.

I would say with your height and current weight people are not being truthful about looking gaunt. Some people don't like to see others succeed. Keep going if that is what you want!

piscesangel · 20/12/2023 09:41

I think this is awful of your family and partner! I'm the same height and also struggle with my weight - but people our height really are still medically quite overweight at your current point. My doctor suggested no more than 10 stone is about right for our height so it's not a marginal thing at over 12 stone. I wish you all the very best for continuing your journey to a healthy weight

IglesiasPiggl · 20/12/2023 09:41

Isthatarealname · 20/12/2023 09:37

I had this, I had a BMI of 27 and people were saying if it lost more I'd be gaunt. I think its a mix of them comparing it to your old shape and public in general being overweight. Just ignore then, if you still feel you need to lose more when you're in a healthy BMI review it then. You are absolutely right if you give up the diet you probably will regain (speaking from experience).

I agree with this. Also, I have decided that if it comes down to a choice, I would rather be a little gaunt in the face but have less fat stored around my vital organs, than have a face that pleases others at the expense of my own health.

Montasaurus · 20/12/2023 09:40

It’s your body. You do what makes you happy. Ignore everyone else.

Well done on your progress so far.

SandboxSalsa · 20/12/2023 09:40

They are being ridiculous. Don’t let it put you off. I let people get in my head like this for years, which stopped me getting to the weight I wanted to be, and I regret it a bit. You are the person with a say in this, no one else.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 09:40

Congratulations on your weight loss, OP.

You are clearly well aware that your BMI is still higher than is recommended by healthcare professionals. Your GP would no doubt encourage you to continue losing weight until your BMI is less than 25.

I think it's a little concerning that the people around you are trying to undermine your efforts rather than supporting you. It's none of their business whether your weight loss affects your face, or makes you slimmer than they think you should be, for whatever reason. Your body, your choice. And you are trying to make healthy choices which will benefit you in the long term.

I'm sorry people are being like this. I think you need to firmly tell - not ask - them to stop commenting on your weight loss.

Are the people telling you to stop losing weight overweight themselves, out of interest? If so, there may be an element of jealousy to it, in that they don't want to see you working your way out of a hole they they are also in. Your partner may also be worried that if you lose more weight you will be considered more conventionally attractive and other men might be interested in you.

beanontoast · 20/12/2023 09:39

People get very funny about stuff like this and likely they’re jealous. When I had a BMI of 28 I was not happy, my face was so round, nobody told me I looked fat etc but when I look back at photos I’m horrified. Now my BMI is around 22.5-23 and I’m not skinny, I look slim and feel healthier but nobody would say I’m too slim. Ignore them and carry on what you’re doing, it’s your body

Isthatarealname · 20/12/2023 09:37

I had this, I had a BMI of 27 and people were saying if it lost more I'd be gaunt. I think its a mix of them comparing it to your old shape and public in general being overweight. Just ignore then, if you still feel you need to lose more when you're in a healthy BMI review it then. You are absolutely right if you give up the diet you probably will regain (speaking from experience).

IglesiasPiggl · 20/12/2023 09:35

Well done on your health journey so far. Other people can pipe down, you want to reach a sustainable healthy weight that's a good investment in your long term health and mobility. I agree - I have a small frame and whenever I have hit size 14 in the past I have felt fat, doughy and uncomfortable. It's too big for my frame size so I have lost weight. Crack on, OP!