Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not yet be happy with my weight?

87 replies

Parvanati · 20/12/2023 09:11

I am probably vain so that’s fine you can come for me on that and I don’t want to make anyone feel bad about themselves so sorry. I have worked hard to lose a lot of weight this year and get fitter. I have done this in a sensible calorie deficit, not extreme and I’m not starving myself it’s a whole lifestyle change not just a diet as I will just eat this way at maintenance calories when I stop.

I didn’t feel very comfortable or healthy and I prefer being a size 12 rather than a size 18. Some people can look and dress really nicely at different sizes but it didn’t suit me I felt so bothered and hot when it’s warm and out of breath. I’m not doing it to impress other people or get their validation.

I still have weight to lose to get nearer to a healthy BMI (currently it’s 28) but everyone who sees me keeps telling me to stop, it will affect my face, I will be too slim, I don’t need to lose more etc etc. This includes my partner! People comment on what I eat or when I decline treats and it makes me uncomfortable. Family and DP keep asking if I will eat normally at Christmas and to take time off my diet, keep offering me things, it will be fine I won’t gain weight but actually, I probably would and I don’t want to do it.

Now I do not see what they see and am worried I now have body dysmorphia? I am still 12st 6 and not tall, so I am still overweight? I can see exactly where the remaining weight is held, it’s my tummy, hips and bum, looks ok in clothes but not great naked and I am not happy with how it looks yet. I’m not blind or stupid I don’t think I am misjudging that I am still overweight? (I’m 5’5).

I have diet cycled in the past and fallen off the wagon, and gained even more back I worry a lot about this happening again so this time I have done everything slowly and differently but it’s making me feel anxious.

AIBU to feel like this has anyone else?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CharlotteRumpling · 22/12/2023 05:20

I dont post any photos of myself online at all, so I am not so keen on progress photos!

Parvanati · 21/12/2023 12:09

@CharlotteRumpling I don’t think I would ever be comfortable posting progress photos for these reasons. I thought about it - I have worked hard, but it would make others feel bad about themselves and I am not sure it’s the inspirational thing it’s made out to be?

OP posts:
StampOutDunningKruger · 21/12/2023 09:32

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/12/2023 16:40

I doubt it's jealousy ,I just think people get used to seeing you a certain way and when you change shape dramatically it's a bit of a shock and takes time for people to get used to how you look now.

I think it's this, it takes a while for people to adjust and feel familiar with the new "you". Keep prioritising your health and in six months or a year they'll be used to your new look and feel comfortable with it.

CharlotteRumpling · 21/12/2023 08:03

Parvanati · 20/12/2023 17:43

@5128gap put like this it makes a lot of sense. I did buy into this for a while myself but being fatter did not make me feel good as I aged. I do not feel superior or inferior to people due to their size or want to make people feel that way, I was even nervous to post this in case it made someone feel upset!

Body positivity has a lot to answer for. I see nothing empowering about having aching knees, a bad back and Type 2 diabetes in my 50s. I am not superior. I just don't want to be in pain, having seen that many of my friends are in constant pain.

Parvanati · 20/12/2023 17:43

@5128gap put like this it makes a lot of sense. I did buy into this for a while myself but being fatter did not make me feel good as I aged. I do not feel superior or inferior to people due to their size or want to make people feel that way, I was even nervous to post this in case it made someone feel upset!

OP posts:
Lucytheloose · 20/12/2023 17:32

I would ignore advice from anyone not medically qualified.

rookiemere · 20/12/2023 17:31

I know when I lose weight it tends to come off from the face downwards and the stubborn bits - tum and hips are the last to lose any weight.

Therefore it's likely that when they see your face and top half you do look thin, but further weight loss is probably not going to make you look gaunt as it will be from those hard to lose areas.

Well done on your weight loss journey so far.

Mumaway · 20/12/2023 17:22

How you feel is probably independent of the actual weight. If you are happy and healthy then that's great and everyone else can do one.

At that weight and height you are still officially overweight, and so it would be very reasonable to keep losing until you are within the 20-25 BMI range, as long as it works for you. Long-term your body will thank you

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 20/12/2023 17:21

Well done on your weight loss so far! You’ve done really well. But yes, a bmi of 28 is still overweight and if you want to continue to loose then that’s up to you and probably no bad thing.

I’ve also been on a slow and steady weight loss journey this year and don’t want to put it all back on over Christmas. My bmi was only 26 but the way I’m built I actually look quite chunky at that weight. I’ve lost 2 stone and feel so much better for it. My bmi is now 22 and I’ve had some comments from friends saying I look skinny. I don’t. I’m a size 10 and probably about right, I’m exercising more and feel so much better. I don’t intend to loose more, but just want to maintain where I am. Don’t let others get to you. Do what makes you happy.

Swishyfishy · 20/12/2023 17:15

Ignore them, people often have a distorted idea of what’s a healthy or unhealthy weight. Go by the BMI which points to you being overweight. Aim for 9:4 which will be about the middle of the healthy range.

5128gap · 20/12/2023 17:05

I think the pressure women have felt to be thin for decades is getting a backlash.
So first we all agreed (correctly) that being thin does not make you superior, that larger bodies can be equally beautiful, that eating disorders are a serious concern that we need to stay alert to and mitigate against.
Then, things seemed to go a little further, with it being seen as superior and more high minded to not care about something as trivial as your weight. And that women who diet are joyless and boring. That actually 'curvy' bodies are better than thin ones (because men prefer them apparantly). And that being thin is 'aging' and that many women at a healthy BMI look ill. And that BMI is a nonsense anyway. And women who don't eat much are performative and trying to make other women look bad.
Within this context, a woman who has lost weight and is no longer visibly 'large', is going to face a fair bit of negativity if she continues to diet.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/12/2023 16:40

Animallover87 · 20/12/2023 09:22

I suspect they are jealous and seeing you get slim is making them feel bad about themselves.

Well done on the weight loss and keep going until your BMI is in the healthy range and you'll feel even better!

I doubt it's jealousy ,I just think people get used to seeing you a certain way and when you change shape dramatically it's a bit of a shock and takes time for people to get used to how you look now.

THisbackwithavengeance · 20/12/2023 16:36

I think people are very quick to tell previously overweight/obese women that they are "too thin" even when their current weight is nowhere near underweight or even if they are still a little overweight.

I think a woman losing a lot of weight disconcerts a lot of people for various reasons I won't go into.

Particularly if you've been "the fat friend" amongst a bunch of slim ladies.

Parvanati · 20/12/2023 15:33

I’m sorry lots of us have experienced this! I assumed it was just me as I would never say it to someone. I might tell them they looked great but I can’t imagine encouraging them to eat things they were actively avoiding. My DD bought me a chocolate advent calendar which was sweet but she gets upset if I don’t open the doors (it’s a lindor one) so I started stashing them in a pot where she can’t see.

I do weights now to try to tone up it’s made a huge difference. When I do body balance I notice my legs are too big to do some of the positions (leaning forward over them)

well done to everyone and thanks for replying, don’t give up hope of getting back on that wagon either and we should all not let anyone derail us.

My partner is not jealous or insecure but he doesn’t really buy into my methods tbh. He is able to crash diet himself slimmer very fast.

OP posts:
luckylavender · 20/12/2023 14:20

I've just reached a healthy BMI, top end. I've lost just over 4 stone. And honestly it's the same, people can't shut up. I still would like to lose a bit more. But I get all that nonsense too. Ignore them.

CharlotteRumpling · 20/12/2023 14:02

I agree weight is a very loaded issue and people see it as a comment on their own weights! I just quietly push away the sugar and go for the healthier choices without saying anything.

5128gap · 20/12/2023 13:36

Yes, I feel like this. This time last year I had a BMI of 21 and was very happy. I've gained ten pounds over the year through not being able to excercise as much. I'm by no means fat, not even in the OW category, but still greatly preferred how I looked and felt ten lbs lighter. Everyone I know tells me I was too thin before. Yet strangely last year they told me how fantastic I looked, so I think there's an element of saying 'the right thing' going on. Weight is a very loaded issue because its very difficult to comment on or take action about your own without someone seeing it as a comment on theirs. The best advice I have is to quietly get on with doing as you please diet wise. Don't engage with people about it. If they ask are you going to eat 'normally' just say 'of course' and eat what you choose when the time comes.

SylvieLaufeydottir · 20/12/2023 13:27

Yeah, you actually really don't get this if you've always been thin, even if you're objectively much thinner than the OP. I'm small and people very rarely comment on my body. It's the change that provokes the comments.

This is one of many reasons I never comment on a person's body unless I can see they've lost weight and they've told me they're actively trying to lose. It's that person's own feelings about their weight and body that is driving their comments, OP, not your body.

CharlotteRumpling · 20/12/2023 13:14

I agree that people get strangely worked up about other people being healthy. I am in my 50s, and I can tell you that any excess weight immediately has my knees and back aching. No need to be a diet bore, but there are really no health benefits to being overweight.

DGPP · 20/12/2023 13:04

I am your height and 10st 10 so my BMI is 25, bordering on 26. I need to lose 10lb to be well within the health range. And that’s my plan for new year. You’re still overweight OP so it’s fine to keep going. Just know when to stop

CruisingForAMusing · 20/12/2023 12:58

People don't like to see others succeed OP.
I've only ever been a size 10 and have never had anyone comment on my weight. But someone slimming down from a size 22 gets told to stop once they're a size 14. Odd isn't it?!
My uncle lost 8 stone. My mum, who has always been overweight, kept pushing the rhetoric that he was too thin. I always replied with "nope, he looks great and there's not a single health benefit to being overweight".
Keep going OP! To hell with others' jealousy.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 20/12/2023 12:50

You’re doing great op, don’t let them de-rail you.

I’ve seen this a lot. I don’t think it’s intentional but as a pp said, people don’t like change so they do their best to make you stay the same. I’ve noticed this with dh. If I ever say I’m going to cut down on sweet things for example, he turns up with loads. He doesn’t realise until I tell him then he is mortified!

At the minute he is the one losing weight and if I’m honest it is a little disconcerting seeing the changes in him but I’m forcing myself to be positive about it and praise his efforts as he is doing really well. I’m certainly not going out and buying junk food for him!! If anything it’s giving me a nudge to focus more on my own health.

Just keep doing what you’re doing and ignore. They will soon get used to the new you and the sabotage attempts will pass.

Yoyoban · 20/12/2023 12:38

Unless you're very muscly/big boned (i.e. broad shouldered etc) such that your body fat is already low, then you are still overweight so yanbu.

People get very funny about others losing weight it brings out all their insecurities and forces them to face the uncomfortable truth about their own eating habits (and some people do just have very distorted ideas of what's healthy). And I suppose when you're very used to seeing someone look a certain way, relatively speaking you might look skinny and gaunt, even if to everyone else you wouldn't.

Even so they should still recognise the weight loss is good for your health and be supportive.

Well done on your weight loss so far

Sartre · 20/12/2023 12:21

You’re still overweight so losing more weight will be beneficial health wise. I know where you’re coming from with comments though, my Mum is the same. I lost 4 stone 2 years ago now and she still tells me I’m too skinny every time I see her even though I’ve looked this way for 2 years…

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/12/2023 12:13

They're feeling threatened. That's all it is - you're making choices that benefit you, not them, which is leading them to fear you making choices in other areas of your life that they might not like.

Those pigs in blankets on your plate? They're to stop you being attractive to other men. Blackmail over roast potatoes? So you don't realise that perhaps he's behaving in ways that you don't have to tolerate and other people don't have to put up with outside him attempting to dictate what you eat.

I've been on the receiving end of diet sabotage from an ex. Right up to and including him interfering with food that I was cooking for myself because I was declining the things he kept on trying to push onto me. And when even that failed, it was all about 'you're doing this to pick up men, you're having an affair, you're trying to have an affair, if you aren't cheating, prove it by eating yourself back to the way you were'.

In comparison, DP doesn't have all those hangups. So he might get a mini Christmas pudding or cake for himself, but he'll make sure that there's fruit I like because I prefer it (and won't be dousing them in sugar, dunking them in melted chocolate and swimming in cream to up the calorie content to the equivalent of a entire box of Ferrero Rocher).

It's not losing sight of anything that's the problem. It's a fear of losing control.

Swipe left for the next trending thread