Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trans women do not have periods.

684 replies

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 18:12

According to period pants maker Modibodi, transwomen can have 'periods'. Periods which are just as valid apparently.

Whilst I'm not going to suggest I know what hormone treatment tied to a trans woman, I can confidently say that no, they don't have periods. Periods involve blood. Trans women don't bleed.

Modibodi seem to acknowledge that there is no bleeding involved I transwomen's 'periods' but bizarrely under a section on how to manage their periods, trans women should wear period pants. For the life of all God's WHY???! Wtf would wear period pants if they didn't have to?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
55
MrsTwatInAHat · 20/12/2023 13:11

And another thing. Re the "but some women don't have periods, and they're still women, so TW are women" argument.

It's a complete logical fail to start with - you might as well say "well some cats don't miaow, and dogs don't miaow, so dogs are cats if they feel like cats". To be able to say this requires a complete lack of understanding of how logic and facts work. Have a think about it.

But also, if this were the case, why aren't period companies making a big deal about these women who aren't having periods? I bet some of them wish they were, and I bet some of them have hormonal fluctuations, so... why not a marketing campaign with a smug non-menstruating woman wearing period pants and instructions on how to handle your "period" that consists of a couple of hormonal ups and downs and some wishful thinking, by popping on some comfy period pants for validation?

Or would that be completely bonkers, rude and inappropriate? Hmmmm.

Pandering to TW is not about a real situation. It's about a big pretence. We aren't expected to indulge people's pretences in other contexts, perhaps aside from young children or people who are very unwell. Especially not pretences that are sexually motivated - which a lot of TW's are. Increasingly so, precisely because the trans trend and the public messaging has been all about (if you like to dress up as a woman ands get a thrill from pretending to have a woman's body, you're included under the trans "umbrella" and everyone must bow down and validate you." That's encouraged all kinds of dodgy men to come out of the woodwork and try their luck and loads of naive women to cheer them on because "LGBTQ+ rights".

jeaux90 · 20/12/2023 13:10

@comfyoldcardi well said

VolvoFan · 20/12/2023 13:03

It used to be widely accepted that men are men and women are women. Men cannot be women and women cannot be men. There are also effeminate men and there are also masculine women. Additionally, there are gay men and there are lesbian women.

All was fine in the world.

And then full-strength crazy came along. I don't like it.

I want to go back.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 13:02

@comfyoldcardi 👏 👏 👏

comfyoldcardi · 20/12/2023 12:51

This whole ideology is about removing women's rights to privacy, dignity and safety. It is dedicated to forcing women and girls to shower, use the toilet and change in the presence of males. (see school toilets; Lia Thomas for example. Listen to Riley Gaines talking about Lia's antics in the changing room and the silencing and coercion of the poor girls who were bullied into going along with it). It is forcing the acceptance of men taking women's medals and prizes in sport and putting them at serious risk of injury in contact sports. Tanikka Brents had her skull fractured by Fallon Fox. Fallon Fox enjoys beating up women and easily got a free pass to do it.
This ideology wants to normalise the sterilisation and mutilation of children who are statistically likely to be autistic, have suffered sexual abuse, are in care, are gay, are experiencing homophobia. Thereby making lots of money for the pharmaceutical industry and rogue surgeons.
This ideology removes the rights of lesbians to have spaces to meet and socialise without men.
It wants to remove the rights of raped and abused women to access single sex spaces in refuges, rape crisis centres and prisons and is doing so successfully.
Imagine being compelled to refer to the man who raped you as She and Her in court.
I can't see what is kind about any of this. I am disgusted by any commercial company going along with any of it. Over 90% of males who say they identify as women have no surgery or hormone treatment and no intention of doing so. They are straight, adult males with a well documented paraphilia. It needs to stop and IMO the women who pander to this are worse than the men.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 20/12/2023 12:37

Then hysteria.

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 12:31

Chersfrozenface · 20/12/2023 12:30

"screeching", eh?

And there's the misogyny, right there.

Wait for the "frothing", that's usually next.

popebishop · 20/12/2023 12:30

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 12:09

Surely you NEED to be male to qualify as a transwoman?

Or am I missing something here? I thought it was one of the pre-requisites?
Otherwise they would just be women, wouldn't they?

Can I be a transwoman? Can my daughters be transwomen?

I'm female and I thought I could be both a woman and trans as it's such a wide and inclusive term, but it's unclear due to definitions being seen as bigoted and exclusionary. Happy for a definitive clarification.

Chersfrozenface · 20/12/2023 12:30

xILikeJamx · 20/12/2023 12:21

Did anyone actually click onto the website and look at the products before all the screeching started?

"screeching", eh?

And there's the misogyny, right there.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 12:25

Beowulfa · 20/12/2023 12:20

In some parts of the world menstruating women are treated as social outcasts, and girls are unable to attend school on those days.

By pretending that a period can be just a vague feeling you are minimising their discrimination, and also the pain and impact heavy periods can have on women and girls across the globe.

I am not going to shove these women under a bus by "being kind" to male fantasists.

Absolutely this.

I wonder how many trans women there are in countries where women are confined to menstrual huts every month and subjected to other degrading treatment due to their sex?

I once asked a trans activist on Twitter whether they thought there were a lot of trans women in Afghanistan and they said, "Of course not, it's far too dangerous to be out as a trans person in Afghanistan!"

Oh, mate. That's the sound of the point whooshing over your head. It's far too dangerous to be a woman in Afghanistan but unfortunately women can't just pop a pair of trousers on and present as men.

All this "trans women are women and extremely oppressed and vulnerable and we should be kind to them" stuff is the epitome of a luxury belief system invented by people with little or no exposure to real persecution.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 12:22

xILikeJamx · 20/12/2023 12:21

Did anyone actually click onto the website and look at the products before all the screeching started?

Did you? Maybe you should before you post any further 🙄

xILikeJamx · 20/12/2023 12:21

Did anyone actually click onto the website and look at the products before all the screeching started?

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 12:21

If one were to picture a hypothetical "flowchart", the two boxes at the top would read "men" and "women" (or male and female).
Under the "female" box, it would sub-divide into all kinds of female people, including trans men, gay women, women with DSDs of the female pathway, straight women, and non-binary women who remain biologically female.
Under the "male" box, it would sub divide into all kinds of male people, including trans women, gay and straight men, non-binary men who remain biologically male, and those with DSDs of the male sexual pathway.

Trans women belong under the "male" heading because they are , and remain, biologically male despite any and all medical or surgical interventions.
They can never jump across to the "female" box because their biology (which is the distinguishing factor of maleness or femaleness) will not allow for this.

Trans women are a subset of men.

It's not an opinion, it's not MY opinion, it's nobody's opinion.

It is a FACT.
Whether you or they like it or not.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 12:21

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 12:14

That is belief it is not material reality.

To those reading along, this is the impact of using preferred pronouns and preferred language. You see arguments such as this.

Spurred on because a brand uses the preferred words of transwomen. Which the majority of the Uk population does not understand the meaning of.

no. Male people are never female they remain male and have male health conditions . Denying this through harmful misinformation is dangerous. They are still a subset of men. No matter their language preferences

This is it, exactly.

If trans women are women, meaning that "women" now refers to a group of people who may be either male or female", what words can members of the female sex use when they want to make it clear that they are talking specifically about members of their own sex regardless of any kind of identity and not under any circumstances any members of the opposite sex?

If you say you want your smear test to be performed by a female nurse and the nurse turns out to be a trans woman, what do you do if you say, "no, I said female" and they say, "this nurse IS female, she is a woman"?

It's gaslighting, it's abusive, and I judge people who go along with it very harshly.

Beowulfa · 20/12/2023 12:20

In some parts of the world menstruating women are treated as social outcasts, and girls are unable to attend school on those days.

By pretending that a period can be just a vague feeling you are minimising their discrimination, and also the pain and impact heavy periods can have on women and girls across the globe.

I am not going to shove these women under a bus by "being kind" to male fantasists.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 12:14

sweetpickle23 · 20/12/2023 11:58

Women- clue's in the name.

That is belief it is not material reality.

To those reading along, this is the impact of using preferred pronouns and preferred language. You see arguments such as this.

Spurred on because a brand uses the preferred words of transwomen. Which the majority of the Uk population does not understand the meaning of.

no. Male people are never female they remain male and have male health conditions . Denying this through harmful misinformation is dangerous. They are still a subset of men. No matter their language preferences

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 12:09

Surely you NEED to be male to qualify as a transwoman?

Or am I missing something here? I thought it was one of the pre-requisites?
Otherwise they would just be women, wouldn't they?

Can I be a transwoman? Can my daughters be transwomen?

Theeyeballsinthesky · 20/12/2023 12:09

sweetpickle23 · 20/12/2023 11:57

Only if you believe that transwomen are men, which I don't.

lol of course they’re men otherwise what would they be transitioning from? 🤷🏻‍♀️

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 12:07

sweetpickle23 · 20/12/2023 11:57

Only if you believe that transwomen are men, which I don't.

Would you be OK with one joining a support group for female survivors of rape and sexual violence then?

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 12:06

If brands wish to expand their market, of course they can. That is capitalism in a capitalist economy.

They cannot then be upset when their primary market rejects them. And the primary market rejecting them for lack of understanding about the needs of the primary market is not cruel for fucks sake. Cruel could be said to be leveraging female bodily functions as opening up a new male market. A male market that requires female people to have been actively using the product before so it was considered a female product brand.

That is exploiting your established market cruelly for expansion .

Friedfriedplantain · 20/12/2023 12:05

Yep calling a transwoman's bleed a "period" is appropriative af.

They won't care though.

And "be kind" can go and fuck itself.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 12:05

sweetpickle23 · 20/12/2023 11:55

Honestly? I really can't @MargotBamborough

There are scores of women who were born women and do not have periods, it doesn't make them any less of a woman.

I'm a woman, and frankly the fact that I have a period is one of the least interesting things about me.

I don't want to step on the feelings of anyone else, so if you feel that transwomen wearing period pants damages you and other women then that is valid. I personally don't feel that way.

OK, I'm no longer specifically talking about the word "period", I'm talking about all the words pertaining to members of the female sex and their sex based needs and bodily functions which have been redefined to include members of the male sex.

Take the words "woman" and "female", as the most basic example.

Imagine you were raped by a man. You join a women only rape crisis group for female survivors of rape and sexual assault. One day a male person joins the group. This sets all your trauma responses off and you are no longer able to participate in the discussion. You ask the service provider if it is possible to move to a women's group which is exclusively for female survivors only. They say no, because trans women are women, and also female.

How do you stand any chance of getting what you need, or even saying what you need, if the people you are talking to are using the words "women" and "female" to include the literal opposite of what you understand these words to mean, and when even when you understand the other person's different perspective, there are no other words you can actually use to communicate your meaning because they have all been taken and redefined?

This isn't about period pants in isolation.

It is the appropriation of womanhood and women's issues by biological males who believe that female people's language, spaces and even healthcare communications should be dramatically altered to include and centre them.

So yeah, it is actually important for there to be clear words which society uses to label particular things and people, particularly things and people as important as, say, the entire childbearing sex, and that we do not tolerate the use of these words being changed to include their literal opposite.

And for what it's worth, fetishising periods is fucking grim and people who do this should not be pandered to.

PathOfLeastResitance · 20/12/2023 12:04

bryceQ · 19/12/2023 18:40

Do trans women have periods?
Many trans women have periods. Some trans women don’t have uteruses, so they won’t bleed as part of a monthly menstrual cycle. But the hormonal experience of menstruation can still be very real.
Some trans women undergo gender-affirming treatment in the form of feminising hormones. These hormones can result in a range of physical and emotional symptoms, including:
• Anxiety
• Appetite changes
• Bloating due to water retention
• Cramping
• Tiredness and fatigue
• Listlessness
• Mood swings
These symptoms may occur at the same time each month, just like premenstrual syndrome (PMS). For many trans women, this is their period.
Having a period feels totally normal and fine for many trans women. Some even find it deeply cathartic and validating. But if your period symptoms are upsetting you, chat with your doctor about adjusting your hormonal regime so that it doesn’t trigger a noticeable cycle.

This is absolutely bizarre. So basically it's saying they want to have PMT style symptoms because it makes them feel more like a woman? Wtf

I agree, it’s shit. I read this bit on their website and as far as I’m aware, none of those symptoms require modibodi products. Unless I’ve missed something and they stop bloating or relieve pain? It’s just another route for companies to make money and they won’t be having mine.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 12:01

It does impact women and girls collectively. It is very dismissive that anyone tries to do this by limiting it to their own lack of impact. That is the ‘ I am alright Jack approach ‘.

"Trans women’s periods are just as real and valid as anyone else’s, so whether it’s tracking your hormonal cycle, slipping on some comfy period underwear"...

This cannot be reposted often enough. It is misinformation. It does not help anyone in the end to perpetuate this lie. A ‘period’ is not just a ‘hormone cycle’. It is a specific cycle and never is it a male one. Not even synthetised that emulate roughly a female body.

Chersfrozenface · 20/12/2023 12:00

sweetpickle23 · 20/12/2023 11:57

Only if you believe that transwomen are men, which I don't.

Do you believe they are male?

Swipe left for the next trending thread