Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trans women do not have periods.

684 replies

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 18:12

According to period pants maker Modibodi, transwomen can have 'periods'. Periods which are just as valid apparently.

Whilst I'm not going to suggest I know what hormone treatment tied to a trans woman, I can confidently say that no, they don't have periods. Periods involve blood. Trans women don't bleed.

Modibodi seem to acknowledge that there is no bleeding involved I transwomen's 'periods' but bizarrely under a section on how to manage their periods, trans women should wear period pants. For the life of all God's WHY???! Wtf would wear period pants if they didn't have to?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
55
VickyEadieofThigh · 20/12/2023 17:16

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 17:09

These threads always make me laugh- pages on pages of genuine seething hatred against trans people, than hand-wringing and great offence when the innocuous word ‘terf’ appears. I can’t see anything online about a court judgment over the word?

"Seething hatred". Another claim for which citations (a LOT, as you refer to "pages on pages") are needed, please.

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 17:09

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:47

yes. It is. Just because you don't want to believe it is, doesn't make it not a slur. There is even a court judgement describing it as such.

Edited

These threads always make me laugh- pages on pages of genuine seething hatred against trans people, than hand-wringing and great offence when the innocuous word ‘terf’ appears. I can’t see anything online about a court judgment over the word?

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 16:49

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:45

Oh for goodness sake, no I didn’t. ‘Terf’ is not a derogatory slur.

You sure about that?

www.terfisaslur.com

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 16:48

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:24

I have no clue why my reply was deleted, I was saying my notifications aren’t brilliant and I’m not seeing a lot of quotes/mentions that apparently have happened! I’m a female rape survivor and I’m not sure why I wouldn’t be kind to others, I think I’ve missed something here ?

I'm sorry that happened to you.

Do you think that you and other female rape survivors should have the right to access female only support, i.e. a group which is not inclusive of trans women?

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:47

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:45

Oh for goodness sake, no I didn’t. ‘Terf’ is not a derogatory slur.

yes. It is. Just because you don't want to believe it is, doesn't make it not a slur. There is even a court judgement describing it as such.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:46

I remember reading that one group considered it transphobic that trans people were not allowed to surgically operate on each other.

There are many personal definitions of what is considered transphobic. Just saying the word in relation to what others write is not necessarily the reflection of the truth.

It is really just like when male people describe themselves as women or as girls. They have no concept of what that is because they are male people. All they have is their own perception of what a woman or girl is or is not. Hence, they are not women or girls. Because they are only emulating and living how they perceive a woman or a girl lives their life. The reality is that they are rejecting living how they perceive a man or a boy lives. That is only thing that they are able to do. Even with surgery and hormones, it is only ever about rejecting what they perceive how a man or boy lives.

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:45

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:29

Maybe you were deleted because you called people who disagree with you a derogatory slur.

Oh for goodness sake, no I didn’t. ‘Terf’ is not a derogatory slur.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 16:42

It's not exactly clear if you can't give even one example. This is what I absolutely hate about TRA's. There's not even an attempt to justify or explain or get into any reasoned debate or give any examples of transphobia. It's just 'wah wah waaaah, you're transphobic, it's clear to see, all the comments are transphobic!!'.

I've asked about a million times on here and on another group, please attempt to explain WHAT IS TRANSPHOBIC and I've yet to receive a well reasoned, well argued answer.

Just like the word woman, the meaning of transphobia has been changed to suit an ideology, that no one needs to believe in if they don't want to. It's not transphobic to state trans women are not women because it's factually true. Why are fully grown functioning adults buying into this nonsense.

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 16:41

I’ve said that basically every comment on this whole thread is very clearly transphobic

I'm only seeing statements of reality. Is reality transphobic?

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:41

Don't forget everyone that some people operate under their own definitions for words and that them simply saying that something is hateful and transphobic is just them using their own personal definition for that state of being.

The moderation of this forum is very strict when it comes to transphobia. It will be deleted. MN use society's definition of transphobia, shaped also by court cases and legal advice, on what is considered transphobia and what is not. If posts are still standing on this thread, then they are not considered transphobic in the legal sense or by the wider UK society's understanding of the word 'transphobic'.

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 16:34

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:29

I’ve not failed to say what’s transphobic, I’ve said that basically every comment on this whole thread is very clearly transphobic, and if you can’t see that I don’t know what to say to you 🤷‍♀️ it’s not unkind to point out bigotry !

Citation needed.

VickyEadieofThigh · 20/12/2023 16:33

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:29

I’ve not failed to say what’s transphobic, I’ve said that basically every comment on this whole thread is very clearly transphobic, and if you can’t see that I don’t know what to say to you 🤷‍♀️ it’s not unkind to point out bigotry !

I say that the comments on this thread are NOT transphobic.

Explain how I'm wrong.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 16:32

@CatMadam in what world is that an explanation? You can't say what's transphobic as there's been no transphobia. It's about as clear as mud. Stating reality isn't transphobia. Give an example. Just one.

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:29

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 16:27

@CatMadam how is calling others transphobic, but failing to say exactly what is transphobic, kind?

I’ve not failed to say what’s transphobic, I’ve said that basically every comment on this whole thread is very clearly transphobic, and if you can’t see that I don’t know what to say to you 🤷‍♀️ it’s not unkind to point out bigotry !

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:29

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:24

I have no clue why my reply was deleted, I was saying my notifications aren’t brilliant and I’m not seeing a lot of quotes/mentions that apparently have happened! I’m a female rape survivor and I’m not sure why I wouldn’t be kind to others, I think I’ve missed something here ?

Maybe you were deleted because you called people who disagree with you a derogatory slur.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 20/12/2023 16:27

@CatMadam how is calling others transphobic, but failing to say exactly what is transphobic, kind?

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:24

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 13:43

@CatMadam I didn't see your reply to me because it has been deleted.

Can I assume it didn't address the issue of being kind to female rape survivors who need single sex support?

I have no clue why my reply was deleted, I was saying my notifications aren’t brilliant and I’m not seeing a lot of quotes/mentions that apparently have happened! I’m a female rape survivor and I’m not sure why I wouldn’t be kind to others, I think I’ve missed something here ?

Staniam · 20/12/2023 16:11

runningpram · 20/12/2023 08:14

Last night my little girl asked about periods. I have to say I felt quite sad about the prospect of her going through this shit and dealing with pain, mess and inconvenience every month for 40ish years - even if it all goes ok for her.
In fact, I hope that we soon find a way of getting rid of periods all together - they are such a design flaw.

i find it so offensive that this company is peddling this bullshit - it is utterly dismissive of the pain, unpleasantness and the social and physical constraints periods place on women during the prime years of their lives.

Interestingly they're a consequence of modern life. Our bodies were designed to get pregnant pretty soon after menarche, with periods suspended by pregnancy and prolonged breastfeeding pretty much up to menopause. We were designed to have them occasionally, not every single month for most of our fertile lives.

This is one of the reasons why the risk of many reproductive cancers such as breast cancer goes up significantly if you have never been pregnant or breastfed. The fewer hormonal cycles your body goes through, the lower the cancer risk.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 20/12/2023 15:54

Ugh. ‘Empowered’ my fat ar*e.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 15:54

Ramalangadingdong · 20/12/2023 15:23

I am going to "unwatch" this thread because it is rewriting what has actually been said on the blog in order to generate a hysterical and indignant response from women, which would probably be justified if that was actually what they were saying. Hell, I would be annoyed if they were saying that men can bleed and should wear period pants, but they categorically do not say that, so I am out.

Perhaps you have missed the very explicit sentences that Modibody have made in that blog then. Because they ARE saying that these male people should wear period pants because they are experiencing 'periods'.

Your attempt to parse this as 'they didn't explicitly say those male people bleed' is rather a dishonest interpretation of what is happening.

No one is 'rewriting' what has been said on the blog. It is all right there for everyone to read. But sure, please do come and scold women for what you choose to not read properly.

IamfeelingSad · 20/12/2023 15:32

Ramalangadingdong · 20/12/2023 15:23

I am going to "unwatch" this thread because it is rewriting what has actually been said on the blog in order to generate a hysterical and indignant response from women, which would probably be justified if that was actually what they were saying. Hell, I would be annoyed if they were saying that men can bleed and should wear period pants, but they categorically do not say that, so I am out.

This thread continues because of posts like your’s which are incorrect - modi body does say transwomen should buy period pants and links to their products - this is a direct quote from their transwomen advice on periods article
“Tips for navigating your period as a trans womanHere are some top tips for managing your period as a trans woman:

  • Track your hormonal cycle: Use a tracker app like Clue to keep tabs on your cycle and any related symptoms. This is a quick and easy way to feel more prepared and in control.
  • Wear period underwear: By offering a sense of comfort, freedom and security, period underwear can help you feel comfortable, affirmed and empowered throughout your cycle. Check out our Women’s briefs and All Gender collection.”

Tips for tracking your period when you're trans

If you’re transgender or non-binary, tracking your menstrual cycle can help you identify patterns and be prepared for what's coming next.

https://helloclue.com/articles/cycle-a-z/tips-for-using-clue-when-you're-trans

Chersfrozenface · 20/12/2023 15:29

This suggests that the company is not selling underwear to trans women.

It literally says:
"Tips for navigating your period as a trans woman

Here are some top tips for managing your period as a trans woman
...

So yes, Midibodi is selling period underwear to transwomen.

maddogpeople · 20/12/2023 15:28

Ramalangadingdong · 20/12/2023 15:23

I am going to "unwatch" this thread because it is rewriting what has actually been said on the blog in order to generate a hysterical and indignant response from women, which would probably be justified if that was actually what they were saying. Hell, I would be annoyed if they were saying that men can bleed and should wear period pants, but they categorically do not say that, so I am out.

Please read their blog. They acknowledge TW don’t bleed but still encourage TW to wear period pants.

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 15:27

OceanicBoundlessness · 20/12/2023 15:23

Yes it does suggest they buy some as they might find it validating. Fancy a large company preying on some emotionally vulnerable people like that too make a few more sales.

It's not being misrepresented. Their own website talks about trans women's periods, then provides the link to transwomen reading the page so that they can purchase the underwear. They ARE selling the underwear to trans women.

Read the quotes above, I'm not going to quote it again, it's there in black and white, it's up to you if you want to believe it or not.

maddogpeople · 20/12/2023 15:26

Ramalangadingdong · 20/12/2023 15:19

Op, they actually say the hormonal response is that person's version of a period because it is monthly and akin to a woman's hormonal response to menses, although the trans woman doesn't bleed. This suggests that the company is not selling underwear to trans women.

However, if a trans man is bleeding they have a right to wear period pants.

Don't get me wrong, I do not believe that trans women are women, but it really gets my goat that someone has wilfully misinterpreted a blog in order to serve their own agenda.

This is from their blog page under the section ‘Tips on navigating your period as a trans woman’

They are explicitly marketing period underwear to TW.

All Gender Period Underwear | Leak-free |

Our All Gender period underwear is inclusive by design. Made to be worn and loved by all people who menstruate. Shop the full collection at Modibodi today!

https://www.modibodi.co.uk/collections/all-gender

Swipe left for the next trending thread