Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trans women do not have periods.

684 replies

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 18:12

According to period pants maker Modibodi, transwomen can have 'periods'. Periods which are just as valid apparently.

Whilst I'm not going to suggest I know what hormone treatment tied to a trans woman, I can confidently say that no, they don't have periods. Periods involve blood. Trans women don't bleed.

Modibodi seem to acknowledge that there is no bleeding involved I transwomen's 'periods' but bizarrely under a section on how to manage their periods, trans women should wear period pants. For the life of all God's WHY???! Wtf would wear period pants if they didn't have to?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
55
VolvoFan · 20/12/2023 20:56

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 20:33

and more shite...WTF?

"Meghan’s period confidant is her wife, who will notice her mood swings and make fun of her. “She’ll say ‘I know you're on your period because you’re being moody, you're emotional,’' Meghan says. She says comments like this feel “strangely validating” and “wonderful.”"

This bit:

“If I had a choice of my body having a period or not I’d choose not, but if you take a second to think about why I don’t have one it’s because my body can’t bear children. There’s nothing ‘lucky’ about that,” she says. "

That is so unbelievably hurtful.

I've been ttc for a good while and all four conceptions I've achieved have miscarried. I'm a biological woman who has a body that is DESIGNED to bear children, but so far have not been able to.

These people are going to rue the day this pain turns to anger.

VanityDiesHard · 20/12/2023 20:55

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 17:28

Just bumping this question.

I could be wrong, but I think that CatMadam meant that she is a survivor of rape by a female.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 20:39

yes. And posters keep posting ‘where is the harm’? Perpetuating the ‘bitchy’ narrative is fucked up. And so to is this ‘ mood swings’ narrative. These male people are choosing to take hormones that will cause these supposed moments. There is no need for them to take these cycling hormones. They choose to.

That is misogynistic. They are mocking women and girls reality with the paragraphs posted above.

That is another layer of harm right there.

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 20:36

@OceanicBoundlessness it's like me saying I want to be a transman so that I can be aggressive , socially dominant and be emotionless! 🙄

OceanicBoundlessness · 20/12/2023 20:34

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 20:31

This is the kind of shit said too - yes it is the BITCHINESS which tells them they are experiencing menstruation feelings. Tess is a trans woman.

"On period-tracking apps:
As they started noticing PMS symptoms coming every month, many of the women we spoke to started using period-tracking apps to know when to expect mood swings or cramping. “I'm in the process of trying to map something, because I'm noticing that there are some weeks when I’m just feeling bitchy. I don't want to be, but I can't help it. And it seems to be cyclical,” Tess says. She’s started using a period tracker to track her symptoms, and while she’s had to disable some of the features — she doesn’t care about ovulation or whether or not she might be pregnant — she’s able to see the emotional cycle. "

https://periodaisle.com/blogs/all/6-transgender-women-talk-menstruation

Yes I saw that when I did a quick search to see what else was being said of trans women and periods.

Bitchiness and something about being cat called and talked over

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 20:33

and more shite...WTF?

"Meghan’s period confidant is her wife, who will notice her mood swings and make fun of her. “She’ll say ‘I know you're on your period because you’re being moody, you're emotional,’' Meghan says. She says comments like this feel “strangely validating” and “wonderful.”"

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 20:32

Oh and yes we have to be careful what we say to them....

"On clueless things cisgender women say (but shouldn’t):
“The only negative emotions I’ve had relating to periods is when cis women tell me I’m ‘lucky’ for not having them,” Mia says. She understands that it’s meant to be a joke about how terrible periods are, but it’s a hurtful comment nonetheless. “If I had a choice of my body having a period or not I’d choose not, but if you take a second to think about why I don’t have one it’s because my body can’t bear children. There’s nothing ‘lucky’ about that,” she says. "

Same reference as above.

Mornusting · 20/12/2023 20:31

This is the kind of shit said too - yes it is the BITCHINESS which tells them they are experiencing menstruation feelings. Tess is a trans woman.

"On period-tracking apps:
As they started noticing PMS symptoms coming every month, many of the women we spoke to started using period-tracking apps to know when to expect mood swings or cramping. “I'm in the process of trying to map something, because I'm noticing that there are some weeks when I’m just feeling bitchy. I don't want to be, but I can't help it. And it seems to be cyclical,” Tess says. She’s started using a period tracker to track her symptoms, and while she’s had to disable some of the features — she doesn’t care about ovulation or whether or not she might be pregnant — she’s able to see the emotional cycle. "

https://periodaisle.com/blogs/all/6-transgender-women-talk-menstruation

6 Transgender Women Talk Menstruation

Do trans women have periods or experience PMS? We spoke with six transgender women about their experiences with menstruation, from dysphoria to PMS. 

https://periodaisle.com/blogs/all/6-transgender-women-talk-menstruation

turbonerd · 20/12/2023 20:29

Friedfriedplantain · 20/12/2023 12:05

Yep calling a transwoman's bleed a "period" is appropriative af.

They won't care though.

And "be kind" can go and fuck itself.

But do transwomen (or trans women, can never remember which is the way to write it)
BLEED?

You need a uterus that sheds its lining after not being impregnated to bleed.

Men do not have that, it is part of the female reproductive organs. Only women bleed from menstruation, unless you know something the rest of us don’t?
(I’m not goady. I am pretty sure transwomen don’t bleed at all, but am curious what you meant here.)

TempName247 · 20/12/2023 19:43

All they needed to say is our underwear is not just for periods, it is comfortable and suitable for people of any gender. The bit about trans women having periods is disgusting and offensive. Surely it is not representative of trans women, I can’t imagine any more than a minute few claim they actually have periods (menstrual bleeding).

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 20/12/2023 19:42

somehow TW don't seem to want 'those' sort of periods

Somehow doubt they'd want mine, either, which is used to be so painful that when I had appendicitis I didn't realise it.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 19:12

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:29

I’ve not failed to say what’s transphobic, I’ve said that basically every comment on this whole thread is very clearly transphobic, and if you can’t see that I don’t know what to say to you 🤷‍♀️ it’s not unkind to point out bigotry !

Mind you the hyperbole of this comment is always a great demonstration of the emotional manipulation extreme trans activists use. Not saying this poster is an extreme trans activist, but they are using the tactics of that group.

And before any poster tries to frame my post as hyperbolic, I am talking about the people who demand that male people are indeed women and therefore should be treated as women and prioritised above female people where sex matters. Ie. That the demand that male people are treated equally to female people
where female people have special protections.

I am not talking about trans people who are campaigning for their needs while respecting that where there are conflicts with other groups that unique solutions may need to be found. Because trans people deserve respect.

Bookist · 20/12/2023 19:01

I can't recall anyone needing to 'be kind' to me when I had a period? And sometimes the cramps were so severe that I would vomit, and often ended up with a blistering migraine. But somehow TW don't seem to want 'those' sort of periods, or experience them? Pushing the 'be kind' agenda for TW supposedly having periods is just patronising them because we know they're not actually menstruating.

They're just playing at being women in the same way Marie Antoinette liked to play at being a simple country girl at Hameau de la Reine. You know, where her cows wore perfume, were led by flowered halters and milked into silver pails. Her 'peasant dresses' were made from pure silk and the finest lace.

OceanicBoundlessness · 20/12/2023 18:52

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 16:29

I’ve not failed to say what’s transphobic, I’ve said that basically every comment on this whole thread is very clearly transphobic, and if you can’t see that I don’t know what to say to you 🤷‍♀️ it’s not unkind to point out bigotry !

Every single comment?

"Yes it does suggest they buy some as they might find it validating. Fancy a large company preying on some emotionally vulnerable people like that too make a few more sales."

Of course I paraphrased they actually used the words empowering and affirming.. However, I'm not sure how being concerned about people being taken advantage of and sold things they have no need for by a large company is transphobic?

Baldieheid · 20/12/2023 18:40

It all looks to me like widespread systematic and business-led abuse of children and yes, trans identified people. Women are collateral damage. Who gives a toss about women?

Surgeons and doctors are getting rich "yeeting the teets". Pharmaceutical companies are rubbing their hands in joy at the lifelong patients created for their products. Businesses such as Modibodi and Tampax and Body Shop want a slice of that. It's body modification and sexual fetishism as a commercial product.

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 18:23

The bottom line is that reality IS 'transphobic'. Ie won't bow to TRA delusions.

Rather than wrap their heads around this, they're shooting us messengers for pointing it out.

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 18:19

If it’s not fetishisation if periods, what is it?

This is an excellent question

HootyMcBooby · 20/12/2023 18:13

Seriously, seething hatred? Get a grip.
Take out any biology, physiology or anatomy book in your local library and open the pages referencing sex and reproduction.

It's all documented 100% irrefutable FACT.

Are the biology books also transphobic?
Should they all be burned and outlawed as they are not "kind" to trans people?

NOTHING stated in this thread is anything other than stating fact, which is that trans women are men, remain biologically male, do not have periods and are not women or female.

FACTS ARE NOT TRANSPHOBIC.
FACTS DON'T CARE ABOUT YOUR FEELINGS.

Hiding your head in the sand of this ideology and shouting "la la la" does not change the facts.

Merrymouse · 20/12/2023 18:12

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 17:09

These threads always make me laugh- pages on pages of genuine seething hatred against trans people, than hand-wringing and great offence when the innocuous word ‘terf’ appears. I can’t see anything online about a court judgment over the word?

Can you not understand why this looks like fetishisation of periods? If it’s not fetishisation if periods, what is it? Do you not think women should be able to talk about this?

Apologies if somebody has already offered an alternative explanation, but if one exists I would be grateful if you could provide it.

MrsTwatInAHat · 20/12/2023 17:48

genuine seething hatred against trans people

Do you honestly, really think that understanding that humans can't change sex and transwomen can't have periods, and feeling annoyed that a thing that only happens to women is being appropriated and faked, equals "hate"? Why?

Can you maybe see that the transactivist lobby makes this claim - that trans people are the victims of some kind of hate campaign - so as to shut down reasonable and logical objections to certain things, such as males in female spaces making females less safe, or pushed out of their own sporting categories for example?

By regurgitating it you're just making clear that you think what you're told to without interrogating or checking it at all. And that you think accusing people of "hate" for stating facts and asking reasonable questions is actually a reasonable way to debate. It's not. It just shows you have no arguments or explanations and don't want your illogical, unevidenced position to be looked at too closely.

I don't hate trans people, and just like people who believe in astrology, crystal healing or a religion, I think they should be able to believe what they like and not be persecuted for it. However, I do take exception to women being disadvantaged and harmed by an ideology that cannot be proved and is not based on any evidence, and I don't see why I shouldn't point that out. If you looked into this you would find that many trans people themselves agree with this view too.

If Modibodi claims TW can have periods it pisses me off. A) because I have had periods and I know that no male can experience what I have, a real period - it's incredibly insulting appropriation, which you would find it easy to disapprove of if the victims of it were a different group. And B) because as PPs have explained, they are pushing a harmful ideology that harms women, gay people and children, and I disagree with that.

You might think it's "kind" to pretend TW can have periods and "validate" them in that pretence. But the fact you think it's kind shows you know they are male and can't really have a period. Women who actually have periods don't need anyone to be "kind" to them by agreeing with them, it seems?

And while you're being "kind" but do actually know that TW are male, a generation of children are now growing up being told that you CAN change sex, and that if you are trans you can be as much the opposite sex as any real member of it, and all they have to do is choose. They will believe TW can really have perionds. There are children and young people transitioning (and some detransitioning) who are saying they thought they could just grow their breasts or their penis back again if they wanted. They thought they would really be the opposite sex and are devastated to realise they aren't. They didn't realise their sexual function would be removed, or that they wouldn't be able to have a baby. That's because of this insane drive to pretend that TWAW and TMAM and it's "transphobic" to say otherwise.

Not being able to talk about the truth is really harmful.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 17:28

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 16:48

I'm sorry that happened to you.

Do you think that you and other female rape survivors should have the right to access female only support, i.e. a group which is not inclusive of trans women?

Just bumping this question.

Tatumm · 20/12/2023 17:25

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 17:09

These threads always make me laugh- pages on pages of genuine seething hatred against trans people, than hand-wringing and great offence when the innocuous word ‘terf’ appears. I can’t see anything online about a court judgment over the word?

Seething hatred? Give me strength 😂

Bookist · 20/12/2023 17:24

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 16:46

I remember reading that one group considered it transphobic that trans people were not allowed to surgically operate on each other.

There are many personal definitions of what is considered transphobic. Just saying the word in relation to what others write is not necessarily the reflection of the truth.

It is really just like when male people describe themselves as women or as girls. They have no concept of what that is because they are male people. All they have is their own perception of what a woman or girl is or is not. Hence, they are not women or girls. Because they are only emulating and living how they perceive a woman or a girl lives their life. The reality is that they are rejecting living how they perceive a man or a boy lives. That is only thing that they are able to do. Even with surgery and hormones, it is only ever about rejecting what they perceive how a man or boy lives.

This is what always puzzles me. Feeling 'like a woman' is infinitely subjective, so how can men possibly know they 'feel like a woman'? Or want to feel 'like a woman'? My experience of being an actual woman will vary hugely from other actual women's experiences.

I have a close female friend who is happily married with three children. But she's also a civil engineer who never wears make up, or colours her hair or wears particularly feminine clothes. Yet very few TW seem to want to adopt her female experience though?

elliejjtiny · 20/12/2023 17:21

This is ridiculous. Also as a woman who has nightmare periods which leave me anaemic every month then I find men pretending to have periods to be extremely distasteful.

Helleofabore · 20/12/2023 17:18

CatMadam · 20/12/2023 17:09

These threads always make me laugh- pages on pages of genuine seething hatred against trans people, than hand-wringing and great offence when the innocuous word ‘terf’ appears. I can’t see anything online about a court judgment over the word?

The case in question is the Harry Miller case, I believe. The judge ruled that terf is a derogatory slur.

But again, your own interpretation is based on a deep prejudice that you hold about people who disagree with you. Great that you find people’s response to your personal attacks funny. Again, it shows the disproportionality of your response.

People are stating clearly the harms of not pushing back on brands acting in this way. All you have done is denigrate, derogate and demonise those who don’t share what seems to be an ideological belief of yours. By all means, continue. But I don’t think your approach convinces many people. I am sure it makes you feel good though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread