Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trans women do not have periods.

684 replies

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 18:12

According to period pants maker Modibodi, transwomen can have 'periods'. Periods which are just as valid apparently.

Whilst I'm not going to suggest I know what hormone treatment tied to a trans woman, I can confidently say that no, they don't have periods. Periods involve blood. Trans women don't bleed.

Modibodi seem to acknowledge that there is no bleeding involved I transwomen's 'periods' but bizarrely under a section on how to manage their periods, trans women should wear period pants. For the life of all God's WHY???! Wtf would wear period pants if they didn't have to?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
55
Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 09:40

Lelophants · 21/12/2023 09:14

Wow this thread is still going.

Maybe there are… more important things going on? Yes it seems a bit ‘silly’ but if period pants are more comfortable then maybe just let transwomen wear them?
Pretty sure the (very few) transwomen I’ve met wouldn’t want anyone else to know what underwear they’re wearing. These threads are something else.

Let’s also not attack people who label themselves as non binary. No I don’t get it either, but there is so much nastiness laced in this.

To reply in similar language:

Wow, your response is something else! Maybe women’s ability to use language to describe their experiences is quite important to equality and protection of their rights!?

What people do in their private lives is up to them, assuming it only involves consenting adults and breaks no laws.

However, Modibodi is owned by Essity, a global corporation with a multi billion EUR turnover.

Their website is asserting that women have a duty to affirm that periods are just a hormonal fluctuation that could happen to anyone, completely divorced from female physiology. This obscures the reality of the impact of menstruation on women as a class and limits understanding.

(Having said that this thread would be a lot shorter if more people used ‘OP posts:see all’ even if they don’t want to RTFT…)

Chersfrozenface · 21/12/2023 09:39

EtiennePalmiere · 21/12/2023 09:29

Those things actually do happen more often on my period 😂
I do shed womb lining at the same time though.

But then they didn't used to coincide with my periods, when I had them.

Not all women experience PMS Indeed, studies report that only 20% to 32% of women do.

So it's not universal even amongst women who do have periods.

EtiennePalmiere · 21/12/2023 09:29

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 21/12/2023 09:17

It's worse than that, @BrightGreenMoonBuggy. They aren't even redefining it as 'bleeding of any type'. They're redefining it as 'any sensation or emotion at all that you think happens regularly'.

Got a headache? That's your period.

Farting more? That's your period.

Have the urge to upset people? That's your period.

Ate a piece of chocolate? That's your period.

[Edit: impressive telepathy skills! How did you manage to reply before I'd posted?]

Edited

Those things actually do happen more often on my period 😂
I do shed womb lining at the same time though.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 21/12/2023 09:28

And yes marketing - as a friend of mine (marketing in an international form which is well and truly rainbow washed) ‘if it was ‘on trend’ to kick puppies and kittens, that would be our next campaign’.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 21/12/2023 09:27

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 21/12/2023 09:13

@BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn yeah, exactly as I said. None of that is a ‘period.’ That’s nothing to do with menstrual bleeding. That’s redefining what a period is so it includes the side effects of men taking female hormones. No womb, no bleeding = not a period.

So if they decide that the pants are for ‘periods’, not periods - and that they will redesign them include a wee pouch for your chocolate, a warm pad to heat your tummy, tissue pocket for your emotional outbursts… but take away the bulky gusset for, y’know actual bleeding?

wear them all month!

Helleofabore · 21/12/2023 09:24

Lelophants · 21/12/2023 09:14

Wow this thread is still going.

Maybe there are… more important things going on? Yes it seems a bit ‘silly’ but if period pants are more comfortable then maybe just let transwomen wear them?
Pretty sure the (very few) transwomen I’ve met wouldn’t want anyone else to know what underwear they’re wearing. These threads are something else.

Let’s also not attack people who label themselves as non binary. No I don’t get it either, but there is so much nastiness laced in this.

So you happy to dismiss misinformation then? And dismiss a brand using that misinformation to sell a group, one that we are told is one of the most vulnerable in the UK , products that they don’t need?

And you believe that you should be able to attempt to shame women pushing back by telling us that we should be speaking about something else? That is a deflection tactic and is commonly used to silence discussion that you don’t agree with.

Do you have anything of substance to contribute? Or just here to do a drive by scolding?

TheKeatingFive · 21/12/2023 09:24

Maybe there are… more important things going on?

Personally I think that biological accuracy and respect for the dignity and experience of women and girls are pretty important. But you do you. No need to read if you have so much more important stuff to be doing.

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 09:23

Lelophants · 21/12/2023 09:14

Wow this thread is still going.

Maybe there are… more important things going on? Yes it seems a bit ‘silly’ but if period pants are more comfortable then maybe just let transwomen wear them?
Pretty sure the (very few) transwomen I’ve met wouldn’t want anyone else to know what underwear they’re wearing. These threads are something else.

Let’s also not attack people who label themselves as non binary. No I don’t get it either, but there is so much nastiness laced in this.

I agree there are more important things, such as the fact that female rape survivors in many parts of the country no longer have access to female only support because that is yet another thing that must be inclusive of trans women.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 21/12/2023 09:17

It's worse than that, @BrightGreenMoonBuggy. They aren't even redefining it as 'bleeding of any type'. They're redefining it as 'any sensation or emotion at all that you think happens regularly'.

Got a headache? That's your period.

Farting more? That's your period.

Have the urge to upset people? That's your period.

Ate a piece of chocolate? That's your period.

[Edit: impressive telepathy skills! How did you manage to reply before I'd posted?]

MrBigsCat · 21/12/2023 09:17

More important than letting our daughters read stuff like that on the modibodi website and then be confused as to what a period actually is?
how are women supposed to spot irregular bleeding, missed periods etc if a period is not just the bleeding part?
I feel ‘periody’ from ovulation to my period starting, does that mean I actually have a 3 week long period?
im disappointed in modi bodi and M&S do decent period pants for anyone interested in changing too

Lelophants · 21/12/2023 09:14

Wow this thread is still going.

Maybe there are… more important things going on? Yes it seems a bit ‘silly’ but if period pants are more comfortable then maybe just let transwomen wear them?
Pretty sure the (very few) transwomen I’ve met wouldn’t want anyone else to know what underwear they’re wearing. These threads are something else.

Let’s also not attack people who label themselves as non binary. No I don’t get it either, but there is so much nastiness laced in this.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 21/12/2023 09:13

@BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn yeah, exactly as I said. None of that is a ‘period.’ That’s nothing to do with menstrual bleeding. That’s redefining what a period is so it includes the side effects of men taking female hormones. No womb, no bleeding = not a period.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 21/12/2023 09:10

Trans women have periods if you completely redefine period so that it’s nothing to do with the lining of the uterus and instead make it something that they can feel ‘included’ about such as bleeding from the surgery used to remove their penis. I mean, there’s no point in not telling the truth about these things. Periods are biological, not gender concepts. The only way trans women bleed into a towel or tampon is from some sort of cut / healing taking place on a surgically created vagina. Anything else is a product of imagination. Fascinated to hear the arguments against this being the case so bring them on.

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 09:07

I don't think people would be getting their knickers in a twist about trans people if it weren't for the fact that the trans activist movement is trying to force women to include trans women in places and experiences that belong only to female people. That is literally what most of us are objecting to.

That and the promotion of restrictive gender stereotypes and all the instances where people use the cover of trans rights to assert power over women, and the astonishing number of men who do this and then also have a social media account demonstrating that their identity is part of a fetish.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 21/12/2023 09:05

You'd know that if you'd read beyond your initial knee jerk.

We do know that. As you'd know if you'd read beyond your initial.knee jerk, @brainworms

Read The Link.

https://www.modibodi.co.uk/blogs/womens/transwomen-period?

(If you're still struggling, concentrate on paragraphs 2 and 8.)

How some trans women get their period

Menstruation is a part of many people’s lives. Find out how some trans women get their period and how you can be a supportive friend.

https://www.modibodi.co.uk/blogs/womens/transwomen-period

Eleganz · 21/12/2023 09:04

People are not entitled to their own biological or medical truth. I am supportive of people living how they choose until it comes to having your own facts and claiming that others are behaving in a discriminatory way towards you of they point out that these "facts" are just made up. I'm sure I am not alone in being tired of this and dismayed that the insistence on making these ridiculous claims is just giving the right-wing nutcases in this country the fuel they need to get support for their oppressive laws.

Modibodi are a business trying to make money. They will say or do anything that increases sales and if that means telling everyone that transwomen have periods when they don't because it increases sales then they will do it if not prevented from doing so.

No, transwomen do not have periods, they do not menstruate, they do not need menstrual products. If you believe they do, you need to learn more about how the human body works.

HoneyButterPopcorn · 21/12/2023 08:57

Sisters and brothers - how very ‘religious-y’ wording there.

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 08:55

I have to say I don't really understand what @runningpram is getting at.

Saying that some places and experiences belong only to female people would get you labelled a TERF by many of those "trans sisters".

I don't think people would be getting their knickers in a twist about trans people if it weren't for the fact that the trans activist movement is trying to force women to include trans women in places and experiences that belong only to female people. That is literally what most of us are objecting to.

The phrase "trans sisters" makes my teeth itch a bit because it feels like forced teaming to me. I feel a form of sisterhood on a basic level with all women worldwide because of our shared experience based on our biology. I don't feel any kind of sisterhood with trans women at all, and I don't believe it is wrong to say that. You can't make people feel things they don't feel.

So when you say you welcome and value your trans sisters, what does that mean? I am happy to welcome and value trans women in the same circumstances and situations where I would be equally happy to welcome and value men. That doesn't include any women's spaces.

jeaux90 · 21/12/2023 08:34

@runningpram they are not your sisters. They are men.

Men should be more welcoming to their non conforming brothers.

Have a read about AGP before you expect the rest of us women to budge up and accept these males into our spaces.

Yes people with dysphoria deserve kindness and help, it doesn't make them the opposite sex.

runningpram · 21/12/2023 08:20

This is excellent - thank you
I absolutely welcome and value my Trans sisters but there are some places and experiences that can only belong to women who were born female. It’s wrong and dismissive of those experiences to try to claim them.
Equally, there are some experiences that can only belong to trans women - for instance the transition process, the process of coming out.

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 08:16

Gentle pisstaking aside, @brainworms.

You're a non binary person with a uterus. I'm a woman with a uterus.

What do you believe is the difference between you and me?

HoneyButterPopcorn · 21/12/2023 08:06

So does that mean if you go to a country say, where the women wear trousers and are CEOs, and the men wear makeup and look after the babies, you become ‘binary’?

I always thought ‘binary’ was a lot of 111000…

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 08:01

sendinthefrownz · 21/12/2023 07:58

This is not being goady, genuinely I’d like an explanation of non-binary.

Would I be right thinking that it’s, for example, a female sexed person who does not want to adhere to or want people to treat them as their biological sex’s stereotype. so they don’t feel like the stereotype of societies idea of a woman?

If so, I fit that category, with my dress sense, lack of make up, hair style, career and outlook. But, I would just count myself as woman and a feminist.

if this is completely inaccurate I’d love to hear an actual definition of what it means to be non-binary that differs from mine.

As far as I can work out, a non binary person is someone who mistakenly believes that everyone else conforms to regressive gender stereotypes.

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 08:00

HoneyButterPopcorn · 21/12/2023 07:44

If only there was a word for that…

Well we could invent a new word for it but I don't think it would be long before some people with penises started claiming to identify as that.

And this is the crux of the issue really, isn't it?

Calling someone a trans woman if it is clear to everyone that they are a man who prefers to present as a woman and that's OK most of the time unless issues of safety or fairness are concerned is one thing.

But "trans women are women" and "trans women are female" and "trans women have periods" just demonstrates the truth of the matter, which is that some people don't believe women should be able to have any words for themselves or even words for their body parts and bodily functions which aren't inclusive of them.

That's not a reasonable request, it was never a reasonable request, they didn't even request it but just imposed it on us, and it's really time for the whole of society to grow some balls/ovaries and say, "No. Not everything is for you. Not everything is about you. Not everything should include you. I'm sorry you find that upsetting but you are going to have to find a way to deal with your disappointment."

sendinthefrownz · 21/12/2023 07:58

This is not being goady, genuinely I’d like an explanation of non-binary.

Would I be right thinking that it’s, for example, a female sexed person who does not want to adhere to or want people to treat them as their biological sex’s stereotype. so they don’t feel like the stereotype of societies idea of a woman?

If so, I fit that category, with my dress sense, lack of make up, hair style, career and outlook. But, I would just count myself as woman and a feminist.

if this is completely inaccurate I’d love to hear an actual definition of what it means to be non-binary that differs from mine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread