Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trans women do not have periods.

684 replies

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 18:12

According to period pants maker Modibodi, transwomen can have 'periods'. Periods which are just as valid apparently.

Whilst I'm not going to suggest I know what hormone treatment tied to a trans woman, I can confidently say that no, they don't have periods. Periods involve blood. Trans women don't bleed.

Modibodi seem to acknowledge that there is no bleeding involved I transwomen's 'periods' but bizarrely under a section on how to manage their periods, trans women should wear period pants. For the life of all God's WHY???! Wtf would wear period pants if they didn't have to?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
55
Helleofabore · 21/12/2023 10:48

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 10:16

If you aren’t menstruating you are having symptoms that women who menstruate also get, but that isn’t a period.

It’s important because clear language is important - when you are going through menopause it’s important to distinguish between symptoms you experience because of your menstrual cycle and symptoms you experience because of HRT. It is dangerous when doctors speak in euphemisms because they assume everyone knows something.

People wouldn’t question this if they were talking about religion or age. There is no similar web page for post menopausal women who don’t identify with their age. The expectation is that they just get on with things. The similarity with other situations where women are expected to affirm men at their own expense are just too obvious.

I’m concerned because it’s a societal default that is dangerous for women.

It sounds like slightly is getting ovulation symptoms too. Would that be it? I used to get mid cycle symptoms that involved cramps and discomfit and others in my family get the same. It is still all part of the menstrual cycle though.

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 10:47

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 10:34

I think that is just standard in Australia. It’s not about being inclusive - you could argue that it glosses over too much.

Unless they are actually donating money to these causes then it's just performative virtue signalling, isn't it?

If I saw a statement such as, "we are proudly Australian and $X of every sale we make will be donated to Y charity which supports aboriginal communities" or "we are committed to ending period poverty and have set up a programme to donate period underwear to girls living in poverty" or "we believe in ending period shame and donate money to X charity which aims to end the harmful practice of menstrual confinement and ensure safe toilet access for all women and girls in Y country", that would be great and I would be more likely to buy from them.

But it feels like most of these companies are just going for the low hanging fruit when it comes to inclusiveness and don't actually put their money where their mouth is.

My friend works for a woketastic employer in the UK. Pronoun central, you know the type I mean. She recently told me that one of her colleagues who has a disability had asked for more support and training for her team members because she was being left out of meetings and they said no. My friend said that it was a bit iffy for an employer which bangs on about inclusiveness and being all kind and fluffy, and I was just like, yes, "Well it's not real, is it? They're not actually nice or kind or inclusive." She knows my gender critical views and disagrees with me so I didn't say much other than that there is a big difference between talking about being inclusive and actually being inclusive and it is clear which category her employer is in.

OceanicBoundlessness · 21/12/2023 10:44

How is it healthy or kind to tell a man who is having symptoms due to the hormones they're taking that it's their period? Normalising symptoms that if I was taking a substance that my body is not meant to have in those quantities I'd be quite concerned about.
It may be that the kinder thing is to be able to recognise these are side effects and know that their body is being clobbered into doing something it's not meant to do.. and maybe it's detrimental to their body and mind to be giving it opposite sex hormones.

Mornusting · 21/12/2023 10:39

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 10:34

I think that is just standard in Australia. It’s not about being inclusive - you could argue that it glosses over too much.

Ah ok it is standard in Australia?

Mornusting · 21/12/2023 10:38

OneTC · 21/12/2023 10:23

What's wrong with this?

I didn't say it was wrong but I did point it out as an example of the extent of how inclusive they are or want to be seen. I don't know - is this required in law in Australia? Or is it showing how woke or aware they are in acknowledging their history? We don't have British companies making statements about the ancient Brits and their customs. I know in the USA there may be similar statements so maybe it is a feature of "new countries"

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 10:34

OneTC · 21/12/2023 10:23

What's wrong with this?

I think that is just standard in Australia. It’s not about being inclusive - you could argue that it glosses over too much.

TheKeatingFive · 21/12/2023 10:32

If you watch some of the videos on popular video sharing sites of these people, a lot of them even have a huge grin on their faces while writhing around on a bed with about water bottle clamped to their imaginary uterus. And no I'm not joking, go and have a look and then come back and tell me this isn't a colossal appropriation of womanhood.

Exactly. It's really distasteful.

It is a great source of 'trans joy' apparently. Though I've reached my own conclusions around what that actually means.

OneTC · 21/12/2023 10:30

The delusion of buying and wearing period pants when you don't have a period is kind of understandable at an individual level given the context of the wider delusion it occurs in but a company intentionally marketing quite expensive stuff to people that don't need it is capitalism at it's worst.

Surely you market stuff for women, at women and then those that are women and those that believe they're women are included by default. Selling women's underwear that's for blokes seems to kind of pull the rug out from under it a bit

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 10:30

HootyMcBooby · 21/12/2023 09:58

" So may be that is the experience of trans women? May be you can have some menstrual symptoms from taking female hormones when you have a male body with no uterus"

But transwomen who claim to "get their period" also complain of all the typical female symptoms associated with that, INCLUDING CRAMPING.

WHAT THE FUCK IS CRAMPING?
This is itself proves that this is at best, psychosomatic, and at worst, delusion or pisstaking or "thou that shall not be named" on this site.

If you watch some of the videos on popular video sharing sites of these people, a lot of them even have a huge grin on their faces while writhing around on a bed with about water bottle clamped to their imaginary uterus. And no I'm not joking, go and have a look and then come back and tell me this isn't a colossal appropriation of womanhood.

I wonder about this.

I've been lucky enough not to experience much in the way of menstrual symptoms in my life. I was on hormonal contraception which completely suppressed my menstrual cycle from my teens to the age of 30. Then I got a copper coil and started to experience a natural menstrual cycle again, including strong cramping from time to time which I suspect was exacerbated by the copper coil.

I think I'm pretty clued up about this sort of thing but I have to admit that until I was in my 30s and starting to think about trying to get pregnant, I didn't give my uterus much consideration at all. Perhaps for a lot of women, having a uterus and a menstrual cycle seems rather abstract until you have actually tried to use your uterus for its intended purpose. And if you are on the kind of pill where you stop every three weeks to have a withdrawal bleed, perhaps in your mind you don't really appreciate the link between ovulation and menstruation, in which case I can see why you might not automatically reject the idea of someone without ovaries or a uterus having periods.

It's really only after the last few years of having a menstrual cycle, multiple miscarriages and two babies that I have really gained an appreciation of what is going on in there, and the fact that cramping is your uterus contracting to make your cervix dilate and let something out, which could be endometrial tissue, an 8 week embryo or a full term baby.

So yes, I read this shit and I think WHAT THE FUCK IS CRAMPING too, but I can understand why a lot of younger women might not have the same reaction.

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 10:23

HootyMcBooby · 21/12/2023 09:58

" So may be that is the experience of trans women? May be you can have some menstrual symptoms from taking female hormones when you have a male body with no uterus"

But transwomen who claim to "get their period" also complain of all the typical female symptoms associated with that, INCLUDING CRAMPING.

WHAT THE FUCK IS CRAMPING?
This is itself proves that this is at best, psychosomatic, and at worst, delusion or pisstaking or "thou that shall not be named" on this site.

If you watch some of the videos on popular video sharing sites of these people, a lot of them even have a huge grin on their faces while writhing around on a bed with about water bottle clamped to their imaginary uterus. And no I'm not joking, go and have a look and then come back and tell me this isn't a colossal appropriation of womanhood.

Given the severity of the pain some women experience because their womb is contracting to expel blood, it seems dangerous to suggest that this is normal in TW with a different internal physiology.

OneTC · 21/12/2023 10:23

Mornusting · 21/12/2023 10:06

They also carry this on every page so are obviously wanting to be seen as super all inclusive.

We acknowledge the traditional custodians of country throughout Australia and their continuing connection to land, sea and community. We pay our respects to them and their cultures and to their elders both past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.

Edited

What's wrong with this?

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 10:18

runningpram · 21/12/2023 09:57

I think it’s clear what Im getting at. But for those
struggling: There are spaces and experiences
that should be the preserve of women that were born women.

You know that most of them would consider you a "TERF" for that view though?

Merrymouse · 21/12/2023 10:16

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 21/12/2023 09:44

I am a woman. Born that way. I am taking HRT to deal with peri symptoms. I get period like symptoms with no bleeding during my two weeks on progesterone. I get cramping, I’m full of rage, feel emotional, get bloated and windy. But don’t bleed. I then get my natural period at the end of the progesterone two weeks. All the same symptoms but with a bleed too. Hurrah! I am trying to sort it out so the progesterone times better with my natural cycle because it’s miserable! But that aside…

I came on to post this to say that I don’t know what the addition of female hormones would do to a male body, but hormones are pretty powerful. So may be that is the experience of trans women? May be you can have some menstrual symptoms from taking female hormones when you have a male body with no uterus? My female friends following an hysterectomy still have cycles and feel the ebb and flow of their hormones. Im not an expert but I think it sounds possible, but haven’t researched it.

It looks to me like the blurb about period type symptoms is unnecessary and a bit virtue signalling, (but nowhere near as awful as the greenwashing I see everywhere I look) but the marketing
of the pants is aimed at ‘anyone that menstruates’ and seems focused on trans men to me - which makes sense.

Whether or not you agree with people being trans is a separate question. I’m in the ‘live and let live’ camp and want everyone to be able to express their ‘true selves’ as long as it doesn’t interfere with the safety and well-being of others. But in terms of this company and it’s marketing - I can’t get too het up about it TBH. I get more angry about greenwashing and marketing at children.

If you aren’t menstruating you are having symptoms that women who menstruate also get, but that isn’t a period.

It’s important because clear language is important - when you are going through menopause it’s important to distinguish between symptoms you experience because of your menstrual cycle and symptoms you experience because of HRT. It is dangerous when doctors speak in euphemisms because they assume everyone knows something.

People wouldn’t question this if they were talking about religion or age. There is no similar web page for post menopausal women who don’t identify with their age. The expectation is that they just get on with things. The similarity with other situations where women are expected to affirm men at their own expense are just too obvious.

I’m concerned because it’s a societal default that is dangerous for women.

Tatumm · 21/12/2023 10:13

MrsTwatInAHat · 21/12/2023 10:05

I was thinking about his thread and it occurred to me that Modibodi probably aren’t doing this just for sales to period-appropriating TW. They are appealing to the masses of young “ally”/“be kind” women and girls who they hope will choose Modibodi In admiration of their wonderful modernity and inclusiveness. As well as the many trans-identifying/non-binary females who do need period products.

Even if they are aware that this will lose them some sales, GC feminists tend to be older and so less of a target for brand loyalty.

Absolutely. It’s young women that this bollocks appeals to mainly.

Baldieheid · 21/12/2023 10:12

Yeah, it's cynical marketing aimed at the younger audience who are now used to Dylan Mulvaney gurning his way through a tampax advert.

I'm old and jaded and remember Gerald Ratner spectacularly blowing up his own business. I doubt this crap will have as much impact on their bottom line. I quite like that they're being open - it gives people a choice.

Mornusting · 21/12/2023 10:06

They also carry this on every page so are obviously wanting to be seen as super all inclusive.

We acknowledge the traditional custodians of country throughout Australia and their continuing connection to land, sea and community. We pay our respects to them and their cultures and to their elders both past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.

MrsTwatInAHat · 21/12/2023 10:05

I was thinking about his thread and it occurred to me that Modibodi probably aren’t doing this just for sales to period-appropriating TW. They are appealing to the masses of young “ally”/“be kind” women and girls who they hope will choose Modibodi In admiration of their wonderful modernity and inclusiveness. As well as the many trans-identifying/non-binary females who do need period products.

Even if they are aware that this will lose them some sales, GC feminists tend to be older and so less of a target for brand loyalty.

Chersfrozenface · 21/12/2023 10:03

EtiennePalmiere · 21/12/2023 09:59

I never said they were universal, just an amusing coincidence that your examples happened to be my main personal symptoms.
A lighthearted aside to a serious topic, apologies for any offense.

I doubt if anyone was offended, I certainly wasn't.

I was just pointing out a fact about PMS, on the back of your remark and my own about our individual experiences

Baldieheid · 21/12/2023 10:02

runningpram · 21/12/2023 09:57

I think it’s clear what Im getting at. But for those
struggling: There are spaces and experiences
that should be the preserve of women that were born women.

If that were respected, I suspect none of the argy-bargy would be happening. Trouble is, saying what you just said makes you, in the eyes of TRAs and their "allies", a "raging transphobe". How DARE you "other" TW by excluding them for each and every aspect of the female experience?

I agree with you, BTW, except I do not include TW in "women". They are TW, with their own health care needs, social challenges and requirements. These overlap with mine only so far as any other male's needs would. I'd prefer TW and TM to be catered for specifically, so that they receive the appropriate care suited to them.

EtiennePalmiere · 21/12/2023 09:59

Chersfrozenface · 21/12/2023 09:39

But then they didn't used to coincide with my periods, when I had them.

Not all women experience PMS Indeed, studies report that only 20% to 32% of women do.

So it's not universal even amongst women who do have periods.

I never said they were universal, just an amusing coincidence that your examples happened to be my main personal symptoms.
A lighthearted aside to a serious topic, apologies for any offense.

HootyMcBooby · 21/12/2023 09:58

" So may be that is the experience of trans women? May be you can have some menstrual symptoms from taking female hormones when you have a male body with no uterus"

But transwomen who claim to "get their period" also complain of all the typical female symptoms associated with that, INCLUDING CRAMPING.

WHAT THE FUCK IS CRAMPING?
This is itself proves that this is at best, psychosomatic, and at worst, delusion or pisstaking or "thou that shall not be named" on this site.

If you watch some of the videos on popular video sharing sites of these people, a lot of them even have a huge grin on their faces while writhing around on a bed with about water bottle clamped to their imaginary uterus. And no I'm not joking, go and have a look and then come back and tell me this isn't a colossal appropriation of womanhood.

runningpram · 21/12/2023 09:57

I think it’s clear what Im getting at. But for those
struggling: There are spaces and experiences
that should be the preserve of women that were born women.

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 21/12/2023 09:44

I am a woman. Born that way. I am taking HRT to deal with peri symptoms. I get period like symptoms with no bleeding during my two weeks on progesterone. I get cramping, I’m full of rage, feel emotional, get bloated and windy. But don’t bleed. I then get my natural period at the end of the progesterone two weeks. All the same symptoms but with a bleed too. Hurrah! I am trying to sort it out so the progesterone times better with my natural cycle because it’s miserable! But that aside…

I came on to post this to say that I don’t know what the addition of female hormones would do to a male body, but hormones are pretty powerful. So may be that is the experience of trans women? May be you can have some menstrual symptoms from taking female hormones when you have a male body with no uterus? My female friends following an hysterectomy still have cycles and feel the ebb and flow of their hormones. Im not an expert but I think it sounds possible, but haven’t researched it.

It looks to me like the blurb about period type symptoms is unnecessary and a bit virtue signalling, (but nowhere near as awful as the greenwashing I see everywhere I look) but the marketing
of the pants is aimed at ‘anyone that menstruates’ and seems focused on trans men to me - which makes sense.

Whether or not you agree with people being trans is a separate question. I’m in the ‘live and let live’ camp and want everyone to be able to express their ‘true selves’ as long as it doesn’t interfere with the safety and well-being of others. But in terms of this company and it’s marketing - I can’t get too het up about it TBH. I get more angry about greenwashing and marketing at children.

tennesseewhiskey1 · 21/12/2023 09:43

The world is slowly going mad. I fear for my poor children with this sort of rubbish they put out.

Baldieheid · 21/12/2023 09:43

MargotBamborough · 21/12/2023 09:23

I agree there are more important things, such as the fact that female rape survivors in many parts of the country no longer have access to female only support because that is yet another thing that must be inclusive of trans women.

Or the female patient who was raped in a women's ward of a UK hospital and gaslit for a full year that it could not have happened, seeing as there were only women on the ward.

It took the hospital an entire year to admit there was a male individual as a patient, but that this person wasn't a man as he had girlie feelz. His feelings were more important than the woman he raped.

A year where they lied to the police and the victim of the attack. Told her it couldn't have happened.

But we're to "be kind"???

Who to?

it's certainly not women.

Is compassion for her a step too far for you?

This won't be the last time either, if single sex services are allowed to disappear because the "be kind" ninnies are complacent.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/03/17/hospital-told-police-patient-not-raped-alleged-attacker-transgender/