Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Trans women do not have periods.

684 replies

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 18:12

According to period pants maker Modibodi, transwomen can have 'periods'. Periods which are just as valid apparently.

Whilst I'm not going to suggest I know what hormone treatment tied to a trans woman, I can confidently say that no, they don't have periods. Periods involve blood. Trans women don't bleed.

Modibodi seem to acknowledge that there is no bleeding involved I transwomen's 'periods' but bizarrely under a section on how to manage their periods, trans women should wear period pants. For the life of all God's WHY???! Wtf would wear period pants if they didn't have to?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
55
NanaTucker57 · 20/12/2023 08:58

Men don't menastrate, only women do....not trans, only females...PERIOD!!!!

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 08:56

Baldieheid · 20/12/2023 08:50

And who is having "be kind" demanded of them.

Is it the men who are being asked to "be kind" to those of their own sex who express themselves differently through clothing, hair, make up or other sexist gender expressions?

Is it men who are being asked to "be kind" to the members of the opposite sex who gatecrash their single sex medical facilities and services?

Ooooh look, no it's not.

So who IS having "be kind" demanded of them?

Hmmmm.

Oh, I know!

People who might have a legitimate use for period pants at some point in their lives. They are the ones who need to be kind.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 08:54

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 08:42

Also, since when did 'be kind' become 'lie to people to affirm their delusion'. We aren't 'kind' to anyone else in that way.

Everyone needs to ask themselves whose interests are they serving here? And why?

I don't actually think it is that kind to lie to people with dysphoria and pretend we see them the way they see themselves. The more people are willing to go along with the pretence, the more crushing it must be when they encounter someone who isn't prepared to do it.

I have thought for a long time that pharmaceutical companies should be trying to develop a drug to alleviate the symptoms of dysphoria, similar to an antidepressant. Surely it would be much better to help trans people overcome their dysphoria and live more comfortably in the body they are actually in.

But I doubt this will happen because pharmaceutical companies have more to gain from pumping people full of synthetic hormones for the rest of their lives, and society in general isn't brave enough to say that it would actually be beneficial to try and find a cure for dyphoria, because that would imply that there is something wrong with being trans.

Baldieheid · 20/12/2023 08:50

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 08:42

Also, since when did 'be kind' become 'lie to people to affirm their delusion'. We aren't 'kind' to anyone else in that way.

Everyone needs to ask themselves whose interests are they serving here? And why?

And who is having "be kind" demanded of them.

Is it the men who are being asked to "be kind" to those of their own sex who express themselves differently through clothing, hair, make up or other sexist gender expressions?

Is it men who are being asked to "be kind" to the members of the opposite sex who gatecrash their single sex medical facilities and services?

Ooooh look, no it's not.

So who IS having "be kind" demanded of them?

Hmmmm.

Laurendelaney1987 · 20/12/2023 08:45

TheAlchemistElixa · 19/12/2023 20:37

Oh my god. Ok. I stand corrected and take it all back! That is batshit

Well done admitting when you were wrong!!! I too first thought it was referring to trans men who were born women.

i have no problem with trans women. But they do not have periods

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 08:42

Also, since when did 'be kind' become 'lie to people to affirm their delusion'. We aren't 'kind' to anyone else in that way.

Everyone needs to ask themselves whose interests are they serving here? And why?

HoneyButterPopcorn · 20/12/2023 08:40

‘Be kind’. Hmmmm. I try to ‘be nice’ to people in general - why would I attempt to be horrible? I don’t blanket ‘kindly’ a load of people because they are ‘special’.

sendinthefrownz · 20/12/2023 08:38

WhichIsItWendy · 19/12/2023 20:51

Honestly, the language you're using makes it sound like you've been knee deep in gender critical text books and are just regurgitating it.

Your extremism isn't helping anyone. Calm down and put the podcasts down.

@WhichIsItWendy
You could do with reading a few gender critical books yourself. Your post is so patronising and exaggerated.

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 08:36

But I believe in being kind to trans women in general

Personally I don't believe in 'being kind' to delusional or fetishising men in a way that undermines the dignity and experience of women and girls.

But I guess we all have our value systems 🤷‍♀️

Baldieheid · 20/12/2023 08:17

I think that your description of the pain, inconvenience and restrictions on our lives pretty much describes the fetish these men have......

zaazaazoo · 20/12/2023 08:17

@IamfeelingSad yes I did actually have the link to post in my OP but didn't link it. Duh. I use a phone and I can't edit on it I don't think. Sorry. In any case so many people including me have linked. So people seriously not read any of a thread at all before posting?

OP posts:
runningpram · 20/12/2023 08:14

Last night my little girl asked about periods. I have to say I felt quite sad about the prospect of her going through this shit and dealing with pain, mess and inconvenience every month for 40ish years - even if it all goes ok for her.
In fact, I hope that we soon find a way of getting rid of periods all together - they are such a design flaw.

i find it so offensive that this company is peddling this bullshit - it is utterly dismissive of the pain, unpleasantness and the social and physical constraints periods place on women during the prime years of their lives.

TheKeatingFive · 20/12/2023 08:10

but if trans women have hormonal swings/cycles etc and want to call it a period, then so be it.

Why though? The word has a clear medical meaning. Who exactly benefits from muddying the waters with inaccuracies? It sure isn't women.

Channellingsophistication · 20/12/2023 08:09

@MargotBamborough I totally agree.

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 07:59

BrutusMcDogface · 19/12/2023 20:36

Sorry. I didn’t realise there were so many pages.

Having read the article, though, I still don’t see the big deal. Period pants are obviously completely superfluous but if trans women have hormonal swings/cycles etc and want to call it a period, then so be it.

Another poster upthread made a really valid point about how spreading medical misinformation can cause real harm.

Lots of women are woefully ill-informed about their own bodies. You see it on threads here all the time where it is clear that many women don't understand how ovulation works. There has also been a lot of discussion about how using phrases such as "people with cervixes" risks losing women who don't understand what a cervix is or where it is or whether they have one but would understand a very clear and simple statement that women need to have smear tests.

There may be girls and women reading the Modibodi website who see that page about trans women getting periods and consequently do not understand that a period is vaginal bleeding caused by the uterus shedding its lining two weeks after ovulation. So they feel a bit crampy or a bit moody from time to time and count that as having a period when actually they are not menstruating regularly, or all. Women need to be able to accurately answer the question, "When was your last period?" if their doctor asks them, and this sort of thing may confuse some of them. If you are not bleeding out if your vagina, it is not a period. Full stop.

Aside from the above, I find this appropriation of womanhood and hijacking of women's healthcare by biological males offensive and insulting. Now fair enough, you might think that's a me problem and I don't have the right not to be offended. But if we don't have the right to offend trans women by pointing out that they are male, surely they should be taking care not to offend us by pretending to be female. Why doesn't the kindness go both ways?

WomensRightsRenegade · 20/12/2023 07:55

Daftolive · 19/12/2023 18:38

It’s just so odd. Unless you’re worried you might be pregnant and you really don’t want to be, who actually wants to have a period? The bloating and mood changes, the mess and pain and inconvenience. It’s why contraception that stops periods is so popular.

Men who have the privilege of fetishising periods precisely because they never have and never will experience the reality

MyHomeIsMyHappyPlace · 20/12/2023 07:49

100% this.

BlackPanther75 · 20/12/2023 07:44

You know what, as infuriating as this whole thing is, if the company had just focussed on the message of being inclusive to all people who want to wear their undies it would go unnoticed… what’s happened is they have got preachy and holier than thou… telling us about the ‘truth’ about ‘some trans women have periods’ etc etc .

MargotBamborough · 20/12/2023 07:43

CatMadam · 19/12/2023 19:22

… basically every reply in the thread is blatant transphobia. There is really no denying that.

The link describes the hormone changes trans woman go through which sound similar to those cis women have during periods. I know I had a week where i felt very ‘period-y’ without bleeding when I had the contraceptive implant. But I believe in being kind to trans women in general :)

Do you believe in being kind to all women?

Or just the ones who were born with penises?

HermioneWeasley · 20/12/2023 06:46

@sendinthefrownz ive got flowette and they don’t seem to have lost their grip on reality (yet)

sendinthefrownz · 20/12/2023 06:32

Alternatives to Modibodi products please? I won't be buying again.

comfyoldcardi · 20/12/2023 05:57

Do they not teach GCSE biology at school any more?

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/12/2023 04:09

I am loving the number of times the same link has been posted. My dd has lots of modibodi pants. I won’t be buying again and will look for alternatives if required.

Mutters123 · 20/12/2023 01:51

Utter bollocks! The world has gone mad!

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 20/12/2023 01:41

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 20/12/2023 01:27

No one has two complete sets of working reproductive organs. That's not how disorders of sexual development work. Even in the case of Persistent Mullerian Duct Syndrome (diagram of typical case on left), there's no external vaginal opening and, importantly, no ovaries to release the female hormones that cause menstruation.

The closest to what you describe is caused by XX/XY (or XX/XXY, etc) mosaicism, leading to an ovary and a testis coexisting. Fertility in these cases is only recorded 11 times in medical history (content note: mentions clitoral mutilation of a baby) because of the conflicting hormones and the rest of the reproductive organs being atypical. The person does not develop full reproductive organs of both types, i.e. complete vas deferens and complete vagina, cervix, uterus, and fallopian tubes, because of the two different tissue types and two sets of gonadal hormones. (The difference between a clitoris and a penis is a mere matter of size and urethral routing.)

Also, usually babies with disorders of sexual development tend to be raised as girls because it's easier to cut a baby's big clitoris smaller (I consider this to be abusive mutilation) than to make it bigger, so it's very very unlikely that a person who menstruates would have been raised as a boy, even if that person was XX/XY mosaic.

tl;dr People with disorders of sexual development who have working uteruses and were raised as boys are so vanishingly rare that I'd be surprised if I needed two hands to count the number on the whole planet. These people aren't who Modibodi is targeting with this nonsense.

I shouldn't type this late at night:

tl;dr People with disorders of sexual development who have working uteruses and were raised as boys are so vanishingly rare that I'd be surprised if I needed two hands to count the number on the whole planet. These people aren't who Modibodi is targeting with this nonsense.

Having a working, menstruating uterus excludes having a working, sperm-making testis. The levels of testosterone required for spermatogenesis block menstruation, as transmen on T know, plus internal testes tend to be too warm to make sperm. So anyone with an internal testis who is menstruating is reproductively female and cannot by definition be a transwoman. If they were believed to be boys earlier in life, that's because their doctors made a mistake.

Swipe left for the next trending thread