Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad my DD missed Christmas dinner

811 replies

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 17:25

My 11yo DD is autistic and she has recently started at a new school. The school have been great in supporting her.

Sadly, she went into a Science class for the first time yesterday and as they have set seats she asked the teacher where she should sit. The teacher snapped at her that she didn't know and she had to stand at the front of the class waiting for the others to sit down which really unsettled and upset her.

Today was their Christmas dinner day and they could go in wearing pyjamas. She was really looking forward to this. But as we got closer to school this morning she got more and more distressed. Once in school she had a full on meltdown that went on for ages. Eventually she calmed down enough for me to leave and they took her up to the Learning support centre where she promptly fell asleep exhausted after her melt down. She missed her Christmas dinner! After a while they asked me to come and pick her up. I feel so sad for her. I'd spent a lot of time preparing her for the Christmas dinner and it was going to be a nice way to introduce her to the canteen. And she was so looking forward to it. All spoilt because a teacher took her bad mood out on her.

OP posts:
EnidSpyton · 19/12/2023 20:23

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 20:13

The teacher had 3 weeks notice. As I have said she didn't ask her to wait. I know that she snapped. And how if I apparently have no idea, you a complete stranger apparently know what happened! I'll trust my DD and the school to tell me what happened!!

All other members of staff were briefed. The headteacher told me this teacher has also been briefed. I get the impression she has a reputation for being difficult maybe? Of course they were too professional to tell me anything like that it was just the looks they gave each other. I may be wrong on that, though. And if the teacher really hadn't been briefed and therefore it wasn't her fault she hadn't sorted the room plan - it was even less so my Dd's fault so why snap at her?

I still don't know what you want from this thread.

The Headteacher has investigated. The teacher has admitted she didn't handle the situation well. She can't change it now.

You need to move past it. Teachers do sometimes snap. Teachers do sometimes get flustered and overwhelmed. You weren't there either. You don't know what happened from the teacher's perspective. If I've got a class of 30 kids coming into my classroom, I might just have got there myself, and I'm trying to get them settled and sat down, I'm trying to get logged into the computer, I'm trying to get books handed out, and then I've got kids queuing up to tell me that they need the toilet, can they go to their locker, they forgot their homework, and then if someone then said to me, oh I don't know where to sit, where should I sit, I might turn and say - slightly snappily - can you just wait a minute?

Can you REALLY not see from the teacher's perspective how this might have happened?

You seem absolutely determined to believe that this teacher is a malicious, unprofessional nasty cow who deliberately targeted your autistic daughter. Maybe she did. Maybe she hates autistic kids. Maybe she doesn't want your daughter in her class. Maybe she's an evil crone who shouldn't be anywhere near kids.

Or maybe - just maybe - she's a knackered, overworked woman who in a moment of feeling overwhelmed and underprepared made an error of judgement. She has admitted it. I'm sure she feels terrible. I would in her shoes.

Rather than continuing to demonise her, how about giving the teacher a chance to make amends and to build a positive relationship with your daughter, rather than holding onto a grudge and encouraging your daughter to do the same?

StupidStunts · 19/12/2023 20:23

So - assuming the teacher is nd, the nd teacher gets a pass because she is human, but the nd 11yo doesn't and should develop 'resilience'?

I am autistic with autistic dc. I expect more from myself than I do from them, because I have been alive longer and had more chance to develop coping mechanisms.

Not giving special treatment, expecting resilience and masking, damaged me as a teen. This thread is so full of ablist crap

thefallen · 19/12/2023 20:23

People are doing those with SEN a massive disservice if they are assumed not to be able to develop resilience.

OP - things happen. Your daughter's teacher will have been dealing with 29 other children at the same time. He or she is probably exhausted. Your daughter can be helped to understand that sometimes people make mistakes.

BarelyCoping123 · 19/12/2023 20:22

@PaperDoIIs Then maybe you should do some reading on autism. Or be you know, more flexible and stretch your imagination a bit.

Actually I know quite a bit about autism. Are you suggesting that flexibility & resilience are not things that we as parents should try to adopt, nor try to model for children with autism? If so, I think you do a great disservice to parents & children alike.

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 20:21

EnidSpyton · 19/12/2023 17:55

This is nothing to do with the teacher.

If it's the end of December and your daughter is going into the Science lesson for the first time, that's a very unusual situation. It sounds like the teacher may not have been given any warning or much warning that they were getting a new student, and clearly didn't have time to allocate her a seat in advance, so asked her to wait to see where a spare space would be free before allocating her somewhere to sit. You have no idea that she 'snapped'. That's your daughter's perception but may not have been the reality.

If the school is this shit at giving teachers a heads up about new starters, I doubt this teacher was given any information about your daughter's autism, either.

I would speak to the SENCO and find out what's going on regarding internal comms. Why is your daughter only going to this Science class for the first time right at the end of term? Why had the teacher not been briefed? It's not the teacher's fault the school doesn't communicate with their staff.

Please be mindful that this is a VERY long term for teachers, and teaching is a stressful and exhausting job. Sometimes we are snappy because we're human and can't be perfect all the time. Teachers are not going to be able to always ensure your daughter gets spoken to or treated in a way that won't cause her to have a meltdown, and expecting them to is unreasonable. If you choose to place your daughter in a mainstream school, you have to help her prepare for that reality.

Edited

Sorry to explain why she was only just going into this class - they have each Science only once over a 2 week period and DD started with a transition so wasn't going into all classes initially.

I honestly don't think it is the school being shit as all other teachers have been aware, it seems and some clearly were aware based on conversations I have had with them etc. I understand teachers are human but would you snap at another member of staff? Would you snap at the head teacher? If not, why not?

I don't think it is unreasonable to expect a teacher to be polite, kind and welcoming. And neither does the head teacher. This was one of the reasons I chose this school. It has a wonderful atmosphere because the teachers are like that and therefore the students are too.

And what exactly do you mean by if I 'choose' to place her in mainstream? It's hardly a choice for most parents. And besides she does well in mainstream with some support. Support that all the other teachers haven't had a problem providing.

OP posts:
Witchdr92456 · 19/12/2023 20:21

Is your dd in secondary school? Has she got a echp? unfortunately when they leave primary they aren’t cared and nurtured anymore. They are basically just a number and if it’s a large school they are forgotten about because of the numbers in the year groups. I would be looking to change to a more specialist provision as they will keep happening

Keepingthingsinteresting · 19/12/2023 20:20

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 19:13

And what she should have done differently? Well, like all the other teachers she should have been welcoming and polite and got DD seated quickly as per the seating plan she should have done.

Ok. @UndertheCedartree this is where you lost me. The teacher is not an air hostess, the welcome may not have been perfect, but it clearly wasn’t intentional and it’s been made very clear by lots of posters the pressure and lack of support teachers are under.
It was a less than ideal situation, it’s a shame for your daughter, but this will sadly not be the last time, and honest if you alienating teachers you are in for a long rough riddle, you catch more flies with honey that vinegar.

Hope your DD is starting to feel better.

kimchio · 19/12/2023 20:19

waterdusky · 19/12/2023 20:17

How do you know the teacher is NT? Teaching, because of the rigid routines and pre-determined core routines, actually attracts a higher number of ND people than you'd realise. The vast majority of our maths, IT and science teachers at our school have autism.

Thanks for saying this. I think some parents forget this.

Pieceofpurplesky · 19/12/2023 20:18

An autistic child can be triggered by anything and it can manifest in many ways at any time. An incident one day can easily lead to a meltdown the next. I see this day in day out at school (specialist).

I left mainstream as children like the OP's DD were being let down. The OP says that all teachers are aware of her daughter and her needs but I disagree unless it's a tiny school. Many teachers do not have the time to read a full EHCP and its recommendations because they are being battered by SLT about results, communication is shit and trying to manage increasingly challenging behaviour (even in a girls' school with good behaviour).

The teacher may have snapped, she probably feels terrible - but she did need to keep your daughter to one side to see where the seat was - she probably hadn't had time to see what the seating plan said.

OP please blame the system that lets kids and teachers down!

waterdusky · 19/12/2023 20:17

Nonplusultra · 19/12/2023 20:10

The teacher needs to develop more resilience and emotional regulation so that she’s not snapping at students.

Shouldn’t be a problem for a neuro typical adult judging by the expectations a lot of posters on this thread have about what disabled children should manage.

How do you know the teacher is NT? Teaching, because of the rigid routines and pre-determined core routines, actually attracts a higher number of ND people than you'd realise. The vast majority of our maths, IT and science teachers at our school have autism.

doglover90 · 19/12/2023 20:16

@Nonplusultra how do you know the teacher is neurotypical?

Hercisback · 19/12/2023 20:15

was even less so my Dd's fault so why snap at her?
Because she's HUMAN.

onanislandfaraway · 19/12/2023 20:15

2023 and people still haven't got a fucking clue what it means to be Autistic. Sorry OP I would give a better reply but I'm so angry reading the ignorant twatish responses you've had on here.

Devonshiregal · 19/12/2023 20:15

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 20:02

And how do you know that?

The thing is you can only take things a step at a time. She is working on lots of new things right now and resilience against teachers being unprofessional isn't something anyone thought she would need right now. I honestly don't think resilience should be the answer to rude behaviour.

mainly old school teachers tend to be unprofessional in my experience. Often. They snap. They put kids down. They still say sexist shit like “young ladies don’t behave that way.” They get pissed off when you don’t know something.

unfortunately that’s what you get in schools. I am NOT saying it’s ok. I find it hard to deal with and half the time want to drag my kid out of school and they go to a good one! (By nice I mean mainly nice teachers)

you cannot expect that this kind of thing won’t happen again and regularly. It will.

people are also dickheads in life so it really is a good thing to teach her some good responses and how to deal in situations she’s not comfortable.

I know it’s not easy so please don’t take that as me being flippant but you can’t control other people, you can only “control” your reaction. (Obviously being Nt this is not so easy but you know what I mean) So maybe some kind of ‘script’ she could go to when she feels shouted at?

I'm probably teaching you how to suck eggs (or whatever that phrase is) so sorry.

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 20:13

EnidSpyton · 19/12/2023 17:55

This is nothing to do with the teacher.

If it's the end of December and your daughter is going into the Science lesson for the first time, that's a very unusual situation. It sounds like the teacher may not have been given any warning or much warning that they were getting a new student, and clearly didn't have time to allocate her a seat in advance, so asked her to wait to see where a spare space would be free before allocating her somewhere to sit. You have no idea that she 'snapped'. That's your daughter's perception but may not have been the reality.

If the school is this shit at giving teachers a heads up about new starters, I doubt this teacher was given any information about your daughter's autism, either.

I would speak to the SENCO and find out what's going on regarding internal comms. Why is your daughter only going to this Science class for the first time right at the end of term? Why had the teacher not been briefed? It's not the teacher's fault the school doesn't communicate with their staff.

Please be mindful that this is a VERY long term for teachers, and teaching is a stressful and exhausting job. Sometimes we are snappy because we're human and can't be perfect all the time. Teachers are not going to be able to always ensure your daughter gets spoken to or treated in a way that won't cause her to have a meltdown, and expecting them to is unreasonable. If you choose to place your daughter in a mainstream school, you have to help her prepare for that reality.

Edited

The teacher had 3 weeks notice. As I have said she didn't ask her to wait. I know that she snapped. And how if I apparently have no idea, you a complete stranger apparently know what happened! I'll trust my DD and the school to tell me what happened!!

All other members of staff were briefed. The headteacher told me this teacher has also been briefed. I get the impression she has a reputation for being difficult maybe? Of course they were too professional to tell me anything like that it was just the looks they gave each other. I may be wrong on that, though. And if the teacher really hadn't been briefed and therefore it wasn't her fault she hadn't sorted the room plan - it was even less so my Dd's fault so why snap at her?

OP posts:
PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 20:11

BarelyCoping123 · 19/12/2023 20:10

Bit odd to blame today's meltdown on yesterday's science teacher, OP, i cant see that theyre related.
Also i dont think the festive dinner would have been a good introduction to the canteen at all - this should be done on a different day, with staff, ideally before the full student population piles in.
Try not to get invested in specific events, like a festive dinner - youre setting yourself & DD up for constant disappointments. Just try to be flexible and resilient, and set an example for DD.

Then maybe you should do some reading on autism. Or be you know, more flexible and stretch your imagination a bit.

Nonplusultra · 19/12/2023 20:10

The teacher needs to develop more resilience and emotional regulation so that she’s not snapping at students.

Shouldn’t be a problem for a neuro typical adult judging by the expectations a lot of posters on this thread have about what disabled children should manage.

BarelyCoping123 · 19/12/2023 20:10

Bit odd to blame today's meltdown on yesterday's science teacher, OP, i cant see that theyre related.
Also i dont think the festive dinner would have been a good introduction to the canteen at all - this should be done on a different day, with staff, ideally before the full student population piles in.
Try not to get invested in specific events, like a festive dinner - youre setting yourself & DD up for constant disappointments. Just try to be flexible and resilient, and set an example for DD.

Pieceofpurplesky · 19/12/2023 20:10

Witsend101 · 19/12/2023 19:57

Not the point of this thread but I'd love to know where these 'specialist' schools are that cater for academic ND children who can manage the schoolwork but have difficulties with the environment. I can see numerous posts from teachers and others suggesting that ND children would fare better outside of mainstream so how does one go about finding this provision as it sounds like an ideal solution to this issue ? Where do we apply? There would be a queue for miles for a provision like that.

I work in one. Left mainstream a couple of years ago. We could fill the school three times over.

waterdusky · 19/12/2023 20:09

I have a DD with autism. I am a teacher and currently have around 45 out of the 302 students I teach a week that have an autism diagnosis. Sometimes I get it wrong. Sometimes I snap because I have ADHD and I get overwhelmed. I don't mean to, but I am human and make mistakes. The chronic underfunding of SEND and the governmental lack of engagement with advice has led to this level of responsibility being put on teachers to an unmanageable level. I cannot learn that many SEND profiles and in my 10 years of teaching across 3 schools, zero hours of training time has been put aside for autism. Any knowledge I have gained has come from trial and error and my own DD. Mistakes are going to continue to happen unless something drastically changes with the SEND provision in state schools. This teacher is human and made a mistake and doesn't mean they are a bad teacher, just that they are fallible. Nothing you will do can change what has happened. You are upset and looking to point the finger, I get that. But if she acknowledged that she snapped to your daughter, this means she's reflecting on her actions and learning from them, so I'd see how things go from here.

Hercisback · 19/12/2023 20:08

This so could have been me as the teacher. Part through the day at a lesson transition and not being 100% sure of where the gaps were in my seating plan. Flustered I'd ask the child to wait to the side and possibly be attempting to deal with another incident in the meantime, and could sound like I snapped.

Poor teacher probably feels awful, will have had an awkward conversation with the head and now be questioning their career.

BlueMongoose · 19/12/2023 20:08

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 20:02

And how do you know that?

The thing is you can only take things a step at a time. She is working on lots of new things right now and resilience against teachers being unprofessional isn't something anyone thought she would need right now. I honestly don't think resilience should be the answer to rude behaviour.

I don't think the teacher was being 'unprofessional'.
That word is a very serious one, and should be reserved for behaviour well outside what's acceptable of a professional teacher, like hitting or swearing at a pupil, or having pupils cheat in exams. And frankly, this is nothing of the sort, nor anything remotely like it. It's not a word to bandy round for this sort of incident. 'Unprofessional' means the sort of thing someone ought to be facing the possible sack for. You're getting this completely out of proportion- if you used that word for some other professionals in a similar context, they could sue you.

And blaming the teacher for what happened the day after.....
I am beginning to see a pattern here.

What job do you do?

NorthernGirlie · 19/12/2023 20:07

My Wednesday morning class has 29 students.
4 have autism (1 of whom is non verbal)
1 is partially sighted so I need to remember to enlarge his work and pick it up from my desk after morning registration
1 has severe seizures
1 has a parent on end of life care and needs keeping an eye on
1 has ODD
1 is on the verge of exclusion for behaviour
1 is non binary so I need to remember that
1 us struggling with endo but is shy about asking to nip to the loo so I like to keep an eye on her for signs of pain and nudge her to nip out

Countless have other struggles, especially at this time of year.

I try - I really, really do but sometimes I can't remember what everyone needs all the time. That's just 1 class.

I love my job - the students are a blast and keep me on my toes. There are a couple I'd move in to my house and give them the care they don't get elsewhere if I could...

I'd be gutted if I upset a child and I'd apologise to them (not to their parent, or the head) because i genuinely want all of the children in all of my classes to be comfortable. I do fuck up sometimes though!

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 20:06

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 19:37

YANBU . It's shit it happened. It's really shit that it will probably happen again.

I won't advise you how to deal with the school as you seem to be on it, you have your daughter's back and say the school staff in general seem supportive.

I would say, don't make this a big deal in front of your daughter (not implying you would,but just in case). It will just be an added layer of anxiety, that time when everything went wrong, she had a meltdown and missed on this big thing. Make it as little as possible, there will be other opportunities, and look at all these events in the new year she could try etc. Use it as a reassuring moment instead, not a lot happened despite the meltdown and everything going wrong. She was ok, she will be again. Everyone understood. Just work with her and preferably with extra support (if any available) to learn from these things , regulate herself as best as she can and try to muddle through. Because sadly, it will happen again and it's devastating for both of you.Flowers

Oh and I don't say this in a "she needs to learn resilience " kinda way. She's showing enormous amounts by showing up every day, being there,learning,trying.

It's in a reminder that it's ok kinda way. It's ok to have a meltdown, it's ok no not be able to cope at times and find things overwhelming and not know what to do or how to react. She was ok after. She's ok now. She will be ok next time and she can always try again.

Jacfrost · 19/12/2023 20:06

Witsend101 · 19/12/2023 19:57

Not the point of this thread but I'd love to know where these 'specialist' schools are that cater for academic ND children who can manage the schoolwork but have difficulties with the environment. I can see numerous posts from teachers and others suggesting that ND children would fare better outside of mainstream so how does one go about finding this provision as it sounds like an ideal solution to this issue ? Where do we apply? There would be a queue for miles for a provision like that.

Ha, that's what I've been thinking. My autistic DD is at a selective grammar school...the academics aren't an issue but the environment can be (thankfully not to a huge extent, she's managing so far with some adjustments)

Where are all these specialist schools that would cater for my DD? I'd like single sex please as she currently has, great exam results, short bus ride away but for all the pupils to be ND 😂