Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad my DD missed Christmas dinner

811 replies

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 17:25

My 11yo DD is autistic and she has recently started at a new school. The school have been great in supporting her.

Sadly, she went into a Science class for the first time yesterday and as they have set seats she asked the teacher where she should sit. The teacher snapped at her that she didn't know and she had to stand at the front of the class waiting for the others to sit down which really unsettled and upset her.

Today was their Christmas dinner day and they could go in wearing pyjamas. She was really looking forward to this. But as we got closer to school this morning she got more and more distressed. Once in school she had a full on meltdown that went on for ages. Eventually she calmed down enough for me to leave and they took her up to the Learning support centre where she promptly fell asleep exhausted after her melt down. She missed her Christmas dinner! After a while they asked me to come and pick her up. I feel so sad for her. I'd spent a lot of time preparing her for the Christmas dinner and it was going to be a nice way to introduce her to the canteen. And she was so looking forward to it. All spoilt because a teacher took her bad mood out on her.

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · 22/12/2023 23:45

To reiterate, as a primary school teacher I have 6 children in my class with Autism.

Their documents to support them are approximately 20 pages long each with tons of tiny writing and information.

I read them at the beginning of the year and regularly to remind myself, building a better picture the more I get to know each child.

I have 25 other children to get to know.

I can only imagine how many documents and differing needs a secondary school teacher needs to read and the amount of time needed to do so.

It's understandable that on first meeting they won't have a clear picture.

I don't feel that speaking sharply to any student is right but more education is not what most teachers need. It's support and time to get to know students and their needs.

Teder · 22/12/2023 23:30

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 22:44

It genuinely makes me feel so sad. And then I just feel so lonely. I don't really have anyone to talk about it to 😔

It’s patently obvious to anyone with a shred of empathy that you’re sad. I’m sorry you’re struggling with not having anyone to vent to. Did you manage to find any good Facebook groups?

There are some posters on here who are goading you which is unfair given you’ve said you also have ASD and you’re feeling sad your daughter had a bad experience.

Just to be clear, I do think you’ve projected your emotions onto the teacher but you’ve not done anything to the teacher that suggests you’re being unreasonable. I hope you are able to let it go and not be distracted by people on here.

Your DD had a bad day but you know what, she’s had good days too and adapted into her new school. I hope she’s proud of herself for managing these big changes.

Make her an epic Christmas lunch at home and remind her she is resilient. 🙂

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 23:30

EnidSpyton · 22/12/2023 22:55

I can't believe this thread is still going...

OP, the issue with your belief that we all just need to read our emails more carefully and have more training is that every autistic child is just as unique as any other. All autistic children will have different triggers and different needs and different coping mechanisms. There is no 'one size fits all' approach to teaching children with autism. Getting more training would be great, but theory only takes you so far when you're dealing with real people.

Moreover, the 'plans' we get sent are often as useful as a chocolate teapot - 'Sarah likes to talk about teddy bears and doesn't like to share. Sarah gets anxious when she doesn't understand instructions. Sarah takes everything literally so make sure you don't use euphemisms' would be a typical 'plan' in my experience. All that tells me on a practical level is to be as literal as possible when giving instructions. If this fictional 'Sarah' walked into my classroom for the first time and I had told her I didn't know where she was sitting, there would be nothing in my plan to tell me that this would cause a meltdown.

Learning to get it right with an autistic student takes time, patience, and often trial and error. I am only just now - one whole term in - getting to grips with how to make the classroom a safe space for the severely autistic child in my form group. It's taken me a good three months to work out what works best for him. His 'plan' just tells me he doesn't like electric noises and to allow him to wear ear defenders if he gets overwhelmed. That's it. The rest I've had to figure out for myself. Thankfully his mum is very understanding and supportive and gets that we're all on a journey together to learn how best to help her child manage school, and when something's gone wrong, we chat about it, chalk it up to experience and learn from it rather than her accusing me of being rude or uncaring.

You seem to be unwilling to appreciate that your expectations of your daughter's teachers are a little unreasonable. Expecting a teacher to get it 100% right with your daughter, who by the sounds of it has considerable needs (you don't seem to think so, but in my experience, a child who has such a severe meltdown at school that they need to sleep it off is a child with high needs) in their very first lesson with her is utterly unreasonable. You need to allow the teachers time to get to know her.

You do also need to get over this strange idea you have that in professional settings, everyone is automatically able to switch off their personalities and be polite and kind all the time. For most people, the occasional snappy comment under pressure is going to come out from time to time. It doesn't make them bad people or rude people. It makes them human. Saying there is 'no excuse' for rudeness in a professional setting is idealistic in the extreme. We are not robots. All of us have the experience of being snapped at by someone in a professional setting, and I'm sure all of us have been able to appreciate that it was nothing to do with us and everything to do with the person having a bad day for whatever reason. We've all been there, and so none of us have the right to judge.

Of course you are not unreasonable to be sad about the fact that your child has missed out on something she was looking forward to. It must be incredibly difficult to watch her suffer as a result of her autism. But blaming her missing out on her Christmas lunch on a teacher who spoke to her a little harshly the previous day is unreasonable. It is not the teacher's fault that your daughter had a meltdown. The teacher had no intention of causing your daughter to have a meltdown. Your insistence on wanting to apportion specific blame rather than accepting that school is an unpredictable environment that is going to be challenging for your daughter no matter what interventions teachers put in place is the unreasonable approach teachers and other posters on this thread are trying to explain to you, and you just don't seem to see it.

The plan clearly tells you that saying that would not be helpful. I get you obviously don't understand that and I'm not judging you for that but it just shows how much further we need to go in educating teachers about autism.

Please, please understand I have said nothing to this teacher. I have made no complaint. I hold nothing against this teacher. I have worked in full cooperation with the school. I do not have an expectation they will get it 100% right. My only thought is she was having a bad day.

Now, it is true I don't think there is an excuse for bad manners. Probably because that is the standard I hold myself to. That is my belief. But that doesn't mean I think everyone holds themselves to that standard. Therefore, I know people will be rude sometimes etc. I think it's a real shame it impacted my DD. It actually breaks my heart 😥

But please understand, I, her teachers, her dad, her therapist, other professionals we all know her far better than you (who do not know her atall.) She is not seen as a DC with high needs hence she does not have a 1:1.Due to my autism I find it very aggravating when people try and make out they know more about my own DC than I do when logically that makes no sense.

And I know you think it is a strange idea but many other people have commented that they also remain polite in a professional setting. It's nothing to do with switching off your personality. I think you should understand that some of us are like that and it doesn't make us strange. Different things are more or less important to different people. Maybe it is because of how rudeness affects me that it's so important to me. Maybe for many NT people it's not so important because it doesn't affect them so bad. I don't know.

I know I see it differently to you and I understand that, but I just can't see it differently. My brain just can't do that. I'm not meaning to offend anyone with it. I've honestly not taken against this teacher atall. I just don't know how to explain it because everyone thinks I hate her or something which couldn't be further from the truth.

OP posts:
DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 23:13

@UndertheCedartree

'I wonder if you have anything to say about the actual topic? Any advice around the sadness we feel when our autistic DC are devastated to miss out on something yet again?'

Now that I've left teaching I now work in a senior role at a university, leading the team which makes reasonable adjustments for disabled students, including those with neurodiversity.

My advice would be that all children with neurodiversity need to be supported to deal as best as they can with the variety of people they will come into contact with. Unfortunately we live in a society which is formed on the medical model of disability. If your child enters HE or employment, the reasonable adjustments that can be made will be much more limited than at school. So in many ways it is beneficial for neurodiverse children to experience these sorts of scenarios, so they can begin to develop as many skills as they can to manage adulthood and the big wide world.

I'm also a qualified teacher and have taught every age range from nursery up to sixth form. Previously I have been an SEN advisor for the local authority, supporting parents through the EHCP process.

So actually, I work with autistic young adults every day at work and I know quite a lot about how this type of disability can affect people. I have neurodiverse friends. I see it day in, day out.

What I disagree with wholeheartedly is the blame being solely placed on the teacher for the resulting meltdown. However you're not willing to listen to views on this or see things from that perspective.

I feel for you as a SEN mum, I really do. But this thread is pointless, because you just want everyone to agree with your point of view.

EnidSpyton · 22/12/2023 22:55

I can't believe this thread is still going...

OP, the issue with your belief that we all just need to read our emails more carefully and have more training is that every autistic child is just as unique as any other. All autistic children will have different triggers and different needs and different coping mechanisms. There is no 'one size fits all' approach to teaching children with autism. Getting more training would be great, but theory only takes you so far when you're dealing with real people.

Moreover, the 'plans' we get sent are often as useful as a chocolate teapot - 'Sarah likes to talk about teddy bears and doesn't like to share. Sarah gets anxious when she doesn't understand instructions. Sarah takes everything literally so make sure you don't use euphemisms' would be a typical 'plan' in my experience. All that tells me on a practical level is to be as literal as possible when giving instructions. If this fictional 'Sarah' walked into my classroom for the first time and I had told her I didn't know where she was sitting, there would be nothing in my plan to tell me that this would cause a meltdown.

Learning to get it right with an autistic student takes time, patience, and often trial and error. I am only just now - one whole term in - getting to grips with how to make the classroom a safe space for the severely autistic child in my form group. It's taken me a good three months to work out what works best for him. His 'plan' just tells me he doesn't like electric noises and to allow him to wear ear defenders if he gets overwhelmed. That's it. The rest I've had to figure out for myself. Thankfully his mum is very understanding and supportive and gets that we're all on a journey together to learn how best to help her child manage school, and when something's gone wrong, we chat about it, chalk it up to experience and learn from it rather than her accusing me of being rude or uncaring.

You seem to be unwilling to appreciate that your expectations of your daughter's teachers are a little unreasonable. Expecting a teacher to get it 100% right with your daughter, who by the sounds of it has considerable needs (you don't seem to think so, but in my experience, a child who has such a severe meltdown at school that they need to sleep it off is a child with high needs) in their very first lesson with her is utterly unreasonable. You need to allow the teachers time to get to know her.

You do also need to get over this strange idea you have that in professional settings, everyone is automatically able to switch off their personalities and be polite and kind all the time. For most people, the occasional snappy comment under pressure is going to come out from time to time. It doesn't make them bad people or rude people. It makes them human. Saying there is 'no excuse' for rudeness in a professional setting is idealistic in the extreme. We are not robots. All of us have the experience of being snapped at by someone in a professional setting, and I'm sure all of us have been able to appreciate that it was nothing to do with us and everything to do with the person having a bad day for whatever reason. We've all been there, and so none of us have the right to judge.

Of course you are not unreasonable to be sad about the fact that your child has missed out on something she was looking forward to. It must be incredibly difficult to watch her suffer as a result of her autism. But blaming her missing out on her Christmas lunch on a teacher who spoke to her a little harshly the previous day is unreasonable. It is not the teacher's fault that your daughter had a meltdown. The teacher had no intention of causing your daughter to have a meltdown. Your insistence on wanting to apportion specific blame rather than accepting that school is an unpredictable environment that is going to be challenging for your daughter no matter what interventions teachers put in place is the unreasonable approach teachers and other posters on this thread are trying to explain to you, and you just don't seem to see it.

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 22:44

It genuinely makes me feel so sad. And then I just feel so lonely. I don't really have anyone to talk about it to 😔

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 22:42

DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 22:11

@UndertheCedartree

This isn't a thread about autism in schools though. It's a thread where you want everyone to agree with your point of view. Honestly I think you would just chat to yourself at this point.

To your surprise, my head (who was wonderful) was sad to see me go and tried every which way to stop me from leaving. Sadly, we're in a teaching retention and recruitment crisis. Teachers are leaving because of the unreasonable pressures, which also come from parents. I resigned without a job to go to and now I work in a university with zero regrets!

Look, I know plenty of people have derailed it the way people always do on MN to try to push their idea of what happened on to the OP. I just don't really take kindly to that. But in between yes, we have been talking about it and a bit about dealing with your emotions when you have an autistic DC which was why I started the thread. I'm quite happy to agree to disagree, as I've had to spell out many times on this thread, most of the derailers on the other hand don't seem to be able to handle anyone disagreeing with them! But again I'm only talking about this because you brought it up.

And no, it's not to my suprise, atall. Why would it be, I don't know you remember? Unlike most on this thread I realise I know less about a strangers life than they know themselves!! 😂

I wonder if you have anything to say about the actual topic? Any advice around the sadness we feel when our autistic DC are devastated to miss out on something yet again?

OP posts:
DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 22:11

@UndertheCedartree

This isn't a thread about autism in schools though. It's a thread where you want everyone to agree with your point of view. Honestly I think you would just chat to yourself at this point.

To your surprise, my head (who was wonderful) was sad to see me go and tried every which way to stop me from leaving. Sadly, we're in a teaching retention and recruitment crisis. Teachers are leaving because of the unreasonable pressures, which also come from parents. I resigned without a job to go to and now I work in a university with zero regrets!

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 22:02

DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 21:59

@UndertheCedartree

In all honesty I just find it comical because you are like a broken record.

And threads like this just confirm that I am still thrilled to have left teaching, 6 years later!!

Good for you! And honestly, I'm sure teaching feels the same about you! 😂

I'm sorry you don't think Autism in schools is worth talking about. Why not find a thread you are interested in to comment on? Or start your own if you have anything interesting to talk about?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 22:00

WombatChocolate · 22/12/2023 21:43

The only thing I think we can tell from this thread is that OP wants to communicate. She wants to have disagreements with people and to keep the thread and disagreements going, long after the topic in the initial post is long over.

For whatever reason, she gets something out of this and no doubt many of us have fed that need she has. That’s it.

Wow! Amazing post. You look so clever.

Some of us are interested in the topic. Some of us want to talk about it. Is Autism such a useless subject to talk about noone could possibly genuinely want to discuss it?

I think the real question is why you feel the need to keep trying to derail it? Have you nothing to discuss so want to stop other people? What is it you're hoping to gain from your posts? Is it you just want to keep policing threads? Is that it? 🤔

OP posts:
DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 21:59

@UndertheCedartree

In all honesty I just find it comical because you are like a broken record.

And threads like this just confirm that I am still thrilled to have left teaching, 6 years later!!

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 21:55

Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:42

Knowing loads about autism really doesn't help in the moment when you're teaching with 50 different demands in 2 minutes.

I am understanding and knowledgeable about autism, I've had plenty of training, I keep up to date with autistic students information. Doesn't mean I don't snap occasionally.

It's not about snapping. Let's leave that aside for one moment!

It's that many teachers have posted on here and it's blatantly obvious they don't really understand autism.

The second point is, you say you've had a lot of training - great. Many on this thread said they'd had no training.

Many also said they had no time to keep up to date with autistic students information.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:53

I think this is the point of what we are saying about how not all teachers really understand autism. As you say you would have thought nothing of it.

But this doesn't mean I should be expected to over think every interaction with the 30+ autistic students I see every day surely? Be realistic.

I wouldn't think anything of most of the interactions I have all day with all students because I don't have time to. Sometimes I drop a ball. Not because of lack of knowledge, just the fact I'm human.

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 21:51

DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 21:41

Genuinely cannot believe this thread is still going 😂

OP I would recommend a new hobby

Genuinely, can't believe people waste their time posting on threads they're not interested in/have nothing useful to say...

It's the thread police again! 😂

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 21:49

Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:40

Agree again @Sherrystrull

From your own accounts the LSA wasn't there immediately. So I'm not sure how she dealt with it as soon as it happened....

But yes people will throw each other under the bus to save their own skin.

The behaviour of the head when you went in doesn't sound brilliant either from the teachers POV.

The teacher could be shite, of course, but the idea that all teachers need to be perfect at all times is getting further and further from the reality. The argument is becoming circular, but this sounds like an interaction I could have had with a student and never thought anymore of it. OTOH the conversation with the head it would lead to, would probably have meant I left teaching.

I think this is the point of what we are saying about how not all teachers really understand autism. As you say you would have thought nothing of it.

For what it's worth as you think I'm just making up things (fair enough if that's what your surrounded by) my friend who is going through something awful has really been supported by the Head so I honestly don't think she would go in all guns blazing unless necessary. It's not like anyone he's made a complaint or anything.

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · 22/12/2023 21:47

Of course teachers could have more training on autism. I could have more training on phonics, more training on PE skill development, more training on dyslexia, more training on GD maths, more training on pedagogy.

Teachers are learning and developing every day. We are never the finished product. The day we stop learning is the day to stop teaching.

However, I cannot juggle 100 balls every lesson without occasionally dropping one or two. Telling me to learn more about juggling won't help this.

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 21:44

Sherrystrull · 22/12/2023 21:36

Schools are like that now. They are stretched beyond capacity. No one can do everything they should and cannot meet everyone's needs every day. This leads to people throwing others under the bus to pass the buck. This would not happen ten years ago as we actually could do our jobs and meet need. I don't do it as I have gone the other way and take all the blame on my shoulders (also unhealthy) but see it a lot and increasingly among colleagues.

Thanks for explaining that. It's very sad.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:43

Yes, they will literally have no colleagues because if no one applies for the teaching jobs, they won't have any colleagues. There's a recruitment and retention crisis in teaching. So people will be overly positive to lure people in. This includes students, because without students, schools don't have funding...

WombatChocolate · 22/12/2023 21:43

The only thing I think we can tell from this thread is that OP wants to communicate. She wants to have disagreements with people and to keep the thread and disagreements going, long after the topic in the initial post is long over.

For whatever reason, she gets something out of this and no doubt many of us have fed that need she has. That’s it.

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 21:42

Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:21

What reason would a friend for example deciding at which school to accept a job at feel the need to lie to a friend about the head? Why would so many teachers, parents,students, Ofsted lie?

And there speaks someone who has no idea of the inner workings of education in the last few years.

People lie all the time. Having colleagues is better than having no colleagues is just one reason.

I don't know what you mean? Education in the last few years makes people lie to their friends because otherwise they will have no colleagues??

OP posts:
Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:42

Knowing loads about autism really doesn't help in the moment when you're teaching with 50 different demands in 2 minutes.

I am understanding and knowledgeable about autism, I've had plenty of training, I keep up to date with autistic students information. Doesn't mean I don't snap occasionally.

DiaryOfaTTCer · 22/12/2023 21:41

Genuinely cannot believe this thread is still going 😂

OP I would recommend a new hobby

Hercisback · 22/12/2023 21:40

Agree again @Sherrystrull

From your own accounts the LSA wasn't there immediately. So I'm not sure how she dealt with it as soon as it happened....

But yes people will throw each other under the bus to save their own skin.

The behaviour of the head when you went in doesn't sound brilliant either from the teachers POV.

The teacher could be shite, of course, but the idea that all teachers need to be perfect at all times is getting further and further from the reality. The argument is becoming circular, but this sounds like an interaction I could have had with a student and never thought anymore of it. OTOH the conversation with the head it would lead to, would probably have meant I left teaching.

UndertheCedartree · 22/12/2023 21:39

Sherrystrull · 22/12/2023 21:21

Seriously, teachers get it. But with multiple classes, large classes and huge amounts of differing needs it's near on impossible to ensure everyone is ok. It nearly breaks me every day. Telling me to learn more about autistic won't change the fact I have no way to meet everyone's needs and is actually hugely insulting.

I'm not aiming this specifically at you. But actually this thread shows what many of us already know that quite a lot of teachers really don't understand. Some think they understand but they don't. Also many teachers on this thread said they couldn't be expected to know about autism as they get no training on it. So it's not really insulting to suggest teachers have training on autism. There are so many stereotypes that have been thrown around on this thread, so much ableism. Please don't see learning about autism as insulting just because as we all know teachers are stretched.

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · 22/12/2023 21:36

Schools are like that now. They are stretched beyond capacity. No one can do everything they should and cannot meet everyone's needs every day. This leads to people throwing others under the bus to pass the buck. This would not happen ten years ago as we actually could do our jobs and meet need. I don't do it as I have gone the other way and take all the blame on my shoulders (also unhealthy) but see it a lot and increasingly among colleagues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread