Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad my DD missed Christmas dinner

811 replies

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 17:25

My 11yo DD is autistic and she has recently started at a new school. The school have been great in supporting her.

Sadly, she went into a Science class for the first time yesterday and as they have set seats she asked the teacher where she should sit. The teacher snapped at her that she didn't know and she had to stand at the front of the class waiting for the others to sit down which really unsettled and upset her.

Today was their Christmas dinner day and they could go in wearing pyjamas. She was really looking forward to this. But as we got closer to school this morning she got more and more distressed. Once in school she had a full on meltdown that went on for ages. Eventually she calmed down enough for me to leave and they took her up to the Learning support centre where she promptly fell asleep exhausted after her melt down. She missed her Christmas dinner! After a while they asked me to come and pick her up. I feel so sad for her. I'd spent a lot of time preparing her for the Christmas dinner and it was going to be a nice way to introduce her to the canteen. And she was so looking forward to it. All spoilt because a teacher took her bad mood out on her.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:45

Twixandtinsel · 19/12/2023 20:06

And the teacher is not unprofessional. She is HUMAN.

Yes, humans can be unprofessional. We're all human but doesn't mean we have to act unprofessionally.

OP posts:
NotSayingImBatman · 20/12/2023 08:44

I’m sorry your poor DD had to go through that. You’ll get very little sympathy on MN, there’s a lot of anti SEN sentiment here, usually hidden under a thin veneer of support for teachers, but there’s some wonderful Facebook groups out there where you’ll get a lot of support. I’m autistic myself and I would’ve simply expired on the spot if a teacher had a) snapped at me and b) left me standing like a lemon in front of the whole class!

Chickenfeed67 · 20/12/2023 08:44

This really sounds like the LSA should have been more active - if they were present and doing their job, they should have introduced your daughter to the teacher, not left her to speak to the teacher herself. You presume the LSA was dealing with another child? But you don’t know that.

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:43

BewaretheIckabog · 19/12/2023 20:03

Putting an autistic 11 year old in to a new school 3 weeks before Christmas seems a really bad decision.

Obviously do not know whether this was OP’s choice or not.

There’s so much going on, all young kids get giddy towards the end of term especially at Christmas. Routines change, there are additional events and the child will not have built up friendships.

These factors are likely to have more impact on the child than one teacher’s words.

It’s ok to be sad your daughter missed the lunch but pinning the blame on one teacher is ridiculous.

Yes, it wasn't my choice. It has all been routine until yesterday and DD was coping really well. You are significantly underestimating the effect a teacher's words can have on a DC. I wish teachers would realise this.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:39

BlueMongoose · 19/12/2023 20:02

Wait- the LSA 'backed it up'? Was this person present? If not, they don't know what happened any better than you do. If they were, WTF were they doing?

Yes, they were present, dealing with another child I expect. They then stepped in and got DD seated when it appeared the teacher was struggling.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:37

Macaroni46 · 19/12/2023 19:59

@UndertheCedartree

Prinnny
Hardly the teachers fault, YABU to put your child’s meltdown onto them.

Even though the meltdown was because of the unprofessional behaviour of the teacher?

But how do you it's because of the teacher? The seating plan incident happened the day before. The day of the meltdown involved wearing pjs and a Christmas dinner, both situations which would increase anxiety in any child.

Because I know my DC (i.e wearing pyjamas was no issue) and because she told us what caused the meltdown. It's really quite straightforward.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:35

BlueMongoose · 19/12/2023 19:59

You need to bear in mind if your child has difficulties that teachers are not always informed by the school about kids' problems, plans or not. You say all the teachers know. How are you so sure of that?

And you also need to bear in mind that teachers are human, too.

I used to be one, though I taught 16+ . The way things are now, I wouldn't consider the job in a school no matter what you paid me. You're expected to be a teacher and get good academic results, which is a tough job in itself and to my mind should be all a teacher should do- plus spend most of your time outside school doing paperwork even in holiday time, be a police officer, a social worker, a psychologist, a counsellor, (all of which should be qualified specialists, not teachers), a leader in out of school activities for no extra pay, take all the crap parents throw at you when an idle kid or just one that is a good kid but not good at the subject isn't achieving, bring their kids up properly to tell the truth, socialise, and behave decently when parents often can't be bothered to, put up with actual violence from kids and parents, and cope with 30 at a time when most parents, with far more sanctions available, can often not cope with just one. And you must, according to modern ideas, never once speak unkindly to any of them. Sod that for a lark. There aren't enough saints with boundless energy and totally unassailable good physical and mental health to go round to staff schools with people who can do all that.

Of course it's reasonable to try to help kids who are struggling, and many teachers are positively heroic in doing so however knackered they are, but this needs to come with a warning- if accommodating kids problems goes too far, it prepares kids very badly for the world outside, and the world of work.

I'm basing it on what the headteacher told me. But maybe she was mistaken about this individual teacher, but seemed like she'd looked into it.

I've taught myself so do understand. I just think there's no excuse for bad manners. I'm a nurse now so know all about being knackered, but I remain polite.

OP posts:
imnotthatkindofmum · 20/12/2023 08:34

Good grief. A new student asking where to sit? Why is everyone defending the teacher, how rude and uncaring! All they needed was to speak kindly, it's not hard!

I'm a teacher btw. Secondary. So no coming at me about teachers stress etc.

MistletoeandJd · 20/12/2023 08:32

Many of our kids SHOULDN'T be in mainstream, they also shouldn't be in full on sen schools catering to very complex needs. The middle ground being SEMH are all packed to capacity. We need more

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:30

mfbx5sf3 · 19/12/2023 19:58

Why have you bothered posting in AIBU? Everyone someone tries to explain the teachers point of view you are instantly stomping your foot all “No they are wrong/ my poor child”. Find another source for your self validation

Because my AIBU wasn't about the rights and wrongs of the teacher. And I'll get my self validation where I like, thanks.

OP posts:
MistletoeandJd · 20/12/2023 08:29

PatienceOfEngels · 20/12/2023 07:03

I'm a secondary school teacher (and parent of a child with ASD).

If I had a student with ASD attending my class for the first time I would have been informed. I would have read the student's IEP.

Any new student attending a class for at the first time would have a buddy student to help them.

If I have assigned seats/seating plan then I would know which seats are free and therefore where to place them, I wouldn't have to wait for all the students to sit down.

The two incidents (science and meltdown) are not necessarily directly related as I think many of my ASD students would be unsettled simply by the pyjama day and/or the Christmas dinner, but it would not have helped in the big picture.

It's always a really difficult time of year for students with additional needs. You know your daughter best OP and what she needs to be able to cope. There will always be things which you'd like her to be able to cope with/experience which she struggles with. It's one of the things I've had to come to terms with as a parent of a ND child.

In your shoes I would be letting her tutor know that this experience was difficult for her. As a teacher I'd also want to know if a student had been affected like this so I could adjust my approach.

We need more of you !!

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:28

Witsend101 · 19/12/2023 19:57

Not the point of this thread but I'd love to know where these 'specialist' schools are that cater for academic ND children who can manage the schoolwork but have difficulties with the environment. I can see numerous posts from teachers and others suggesting that ND children would fare better outside of mainstream so how does one go about finding this provision as it sounds like an ideal solution to this issue ? Where do we apply? There would be a queue for miles for a provision like that.

Exactly, this provision doesn't exist.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:27

TinselTitts · 19/12/2023 19:53

I know she snapped at her as my DD told me and the LSA backed it up.

What words did the LSA actually use?

'yes, she did'. Further discussion happened between the LSA and headteacher that I wasn't privy to. However, the headteacher told me that she doesn't condone impolite polite behaviour from anyone at school, refering to the the teachers behaviour as impolite.

OP posts:
WhereIsBebèsChambre · 20/12/2023 08:26

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:15

She didn't suddenly join a class midweek. She hasn't been moved at short notice. And yes,I do have sympathy with the idea the teacher may not have enough training in ASD. But all the other teachers have managed and the reaction by the head teacher and LSA to this incident made it seem this was a teacher issue (at least on part.)

Tis a shame this amazing LSA wasn't actually helping and supporting your dd when all this actually occurred. (Which i would presume was her role?) She stood aside, didn't greet your dd into the class, help her find her seat and settle into it, but rather stood and observed your daughters distress, the class teachers unprofessional failings ready to feed back to the head, other teachers?

FUPAgirl · 20/12/2023 08:24

OP I hope your dd has a better day today 🙏

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:23

wronginalltherightways · 19/12/2023 19:53

100%

Everything about today was new and unsettling for OP's daughter: new class, new people, new routine, different clothing, special meal. She was always going to strugg.e.

And 'Snapped' is a second hand interpretation of a teacher asking her to wait until everyone is so she could see where to put her, as would be done for any new student on the second to last day of a very long term where everyone is soooo done.

The teacher didn't ask her to wait the teacher snapped at her.

OP posts:
EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 08:22

FUPAgirl · 20/12/2023 08:16

I read all of the posts, don't worry! I honestly understand where you're coming from with regards to your own stressful experiences- I just don't think you're grasping this scenario in the OP. There's not much point in bringing in reasons why YOU snap at teens, it's got nothing to do with this teacher or this DD. What the person you're arguing with previously and myself are saying that it was unacceptable for this teacher to snap at this new pupil. Had dd swore and threw a chair, obvs we would be supporting the teacher. One of my kids can be an absolute shit and believe me, I support the school staff 100% in however they choose to deal with him furing those times!

Anyway, I hope you have a good day today and are breaking up for Christmas soon. 🎄

I have grasped the scenario. I don’t need you to explain it to me.

I haven’t described any incidents when I’ve snapped at anyone. I’m not sure where you’ve got that from.

I and other teachers have explained reasons why the teacher may have snapped that are highly relevant to the situation outlined in the OP. The topic has digressed somewhat as other people have contributed or asked questions, and it seems you’ve got the wrong end of the stick somewhere along the line as you’re managing to misunderstand a great deal
of what has been said.

Thanks for your well wishes - I am already on holiday and having a marvellous time!

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:21

snackatack · 19/12/2023 19:51

YABU - if you thought 'Christmas dinner' would be a nice calm way to introduce anyone to eating a new environment.

Your DD will get there but settling so soon to the end of term -with tired staff and pupils is never going to be easy

It would have been just Y7 in there and she would have been with her form and form teacher, rather than the whole school. That was why learning support suggested it as a good introduction.

That was actually what her HOY said yesterday 'we'll get there' and I'm sure that is true.

OP posts:
EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 08:17

FUPAgirl · 20/12/2023 08:06

EnidSpyton, you can justify snapping at children all you like, and attempt to justify your own behaviours. However this DC did not do any of the awful things you keep describing, did she? And no, I have not ever snapped at a patient in my care, disbelieve me a you like but absolutely haven't and wouldn't.

Obviously I would if someone threw a chair at me though!

Good for you. You’re a paragon of virtue we can all only aspire to emulate.

Back in the real world, some of us lose our cool sometimes and aren’t afraid to admit it. I don’t need to justify myself. Anyone who is around children for longer than 5 minutes knows they can be incredibly trying sometimes.

The teacher in this scenario snapped at the OP’s child when she asked where to sit because she obviously felt unprepared and stressed at the beginning of the lesson. She’s human. She’s admitted fault. She can’t change it now. No it wasn’t a great thing to do and yes she could have handled it better and I’m sure she will
learn from it going forward. I don’t see what more there is to say. We can’t hold teachers up to a standard of perfection that it’s impossible for them to achieve and then wonder why we don’t have any teachers!

FUPAgirl · 20/12/2023 08:16

EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 08:08

This post is part of a conversation with another poster who said she couldn’t imagine a situation where a teacher could ever snap at a child and I was simply giving some scenarios to help her imagine. This has nothing to do with the OP’s description of her daughter’s school and I haven’t said it is.

If you want to wade into a discussion this far in, please read all the posts before you start quoting people, as you’re accusing me of all sorts of nonsense due to not having understood the wider context of some of my posts.

I read all of the posts, don't worry! I honestly understand where you're coming from with regards to your own stressful experiences- I just don't think you're grasping this scenario in the OP. There's not much point in bringing in reasons why YOU snap at teens, it's got nothing to do with this teacher or this DD. What the person you're arguing with previously and myself are saying that it was unacceptable for this teacher to snap at this new pupil. Had dd swore and threw a chair, obvs we would be supporting the teacher. One of my kids can be an absolute shit and believe me, I support the school staff 100% in however they choose to deal with him furing those times!

Anyway, I hope you have a good day today and are breaking up for Christmas soon. 🎄

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:15

EnidSpyton · 19/12/2023 19:44

It's highly unusual to have a child who has been at the school for several weeks already to suddenly join a new class midweek. So something has happened internally where the OP's daughter has either been added to a new class or moved from another class, at what sounds like very short notice, as the teacher didn't have a seating plan ready.

We can only speculate, but given the unusual circumstances, I would imagine the teacher wasn't given the information in time, or didn't have time to read through everything before the class.

Giving a student with very complex needs to a teacher for the first time right at the end of term, with no training or support or preparation, is a very unhelpful thing to do. This is a bigger problem than the teacher.

She didn't suddenly join a class midweek. She hasn't been moved at short notice. And yes,I do have sympathy with the idea the teacher may not have enough training in ASD. But all the other teachers have managed and the reaction by the head teacher and LSA to this incident made it seem this was a teacher issue (at least on part.)

OP posts:
marcopront · 20/12/2023 08:12

How come the LSA heard the teacher snap but still left your daughter standing at the front waiting for ages?
Maybe the biggest issue was the person she trusted to help her didn't do so quickly enough.

Also why didn't they wake her up and ask her if she wanted to go for lunch?
If she had the meltdown when she arrived at school she must have been asleep for a couple of hours.

OfTheNight · 20/12/2023 08:09

Horrible@FUPAgirl ? No. It’s realistic. There is no where near the provision needed to accommodate SEN in schools. There is zero money, zero resources, zero support services. And more children than ever that need support.

People need to wake up a bit in regards to our education system and the state it’s in.

The teacher might not have even been told they had a new starter. Even if they had, are they expected to recall, perfectly every seating plan for every session? They are only people. People make mistakes.

EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 08:08

FUPAgirl · 20/12/2023 07:58

Where in the op did you read that the class was full of teens or that chairs were being thrown? Wow, you really did read a whole other op to me!

This child, who is new to the school and ND simply asked where to sit - she did not deserve to be snapped at.

You are projecting your experiences of teaching onto this OP despite them being completely irrelevant to the situation.

This post is part of a conversation with another poster who said she couldn’t imagine a situation where a teacher could ever snap at a child and I was simply giving some scenarios to help her imagine. This has nothing to do with the OP’s description of her daughter’s school and I haven’t said it is.

If you want to wade into a discussion this far in, please read all the posts before you start quoting people, as you’re accusing me of all sorts of nonsense due to not having understood the wider context of some of my posts.

FUPAgirl · 20/12/2023 08:06

EnidSpyton, you can justify snapping at children all you like, and attempt to justify your own behaviours. However this DC did not do any of the awful things you keep describing, did she? And no, I have not ever snapped at a patient in my care, disbelieve me a you like but absolutely haven't and wouldn't.

Obviously I would if someone threw a chair at me though!