Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad my DD missed Christmas dinner

811 replies

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 17:25

My 11yo DD is autistic and she has recently started at a new school. The school have been great in supporting her.

Sadly, she went into a Science class for the first time yesterday and as they have set seats she asked the teacher where she should sit. The teacher snapped at her that she didn't know and she had to stand at the front of the class waiting for the others to sit down which really unsettled and upset her.

Today was their Christmas dinner day and they could go in wearing pyjamas. She was really looking forward to this. But as we got closer to school this morning she got more and more distressed. Once in school she had a full on meltdown that went on for ages. Eventually she calmed down enough for me to leave and they took her up to the Learning support centre where she promptly fell asleep exhausted after her melt down. She missed her Christmas dinner! After a while they asked me to come and pick her up. I feel so sad for her. I'd spent a lot of time preparing her for the Christmas dinner and it was going to be a nice way to introduce her to the canteen. And she was so looking forward to it. All spoilt because a teacher took her bad mood out on her.

OP posts:
adviceneeded1990 · 20/12/2023 14:40

@UndertheCedartree I understand. It just all still seems really unprofessional to me, staff members would never discuss one another’s behaviour in front of a parent at my school let alone with a child in the meeting too! Surely your DD will now be of the opinion that the LSA and HT are on her “side” against her class teachers? I agree with modelling the behaviour you wish to see but if I was that teacher I’d have the Union in speaking to the head teacher regarding the follow up!

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 14:33

BewaretheIckabog · 19/12/2023 22:57

The school may seem great but I’d have reservations about a Head Teacher who described a teacher as unprofessional in front of LSA or parents.

No wonder so many teachers want out.

That didn't happen. Not sure if I did write that but it was incorrect if I did. The head teacher saw the situation as incorrectly handled and stepped in to hopefully prevent a repeat.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 14:30

Whereismycat · 19/12/2023 22:52

OP can I just say GO YOU! Well done for standing up for your DD. My autistic DD is currently home Ed after everything fell apart in year 1. I don’t have the energy to go in to it but suffice to say her needs weren’t being accommodated. Like many other SEN children that are failed by the education system because they don’t fit in. My DD is bright, she is fabulous & she is bloody resilient! I’m sick of these sorts of comments so thank you for taking them on!

Oh, I'm sorry to hear that. I had to home educate my DS and DD for a bit before she got the place at this school. DS is now doing T levels at college. I've had to fight tooth and nail for both their education's. Good luck to your DD, I'm sure she will go far!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 14:20

EnidSpyton · 19/12/2023 22:47

I don't think you can comment if you've never taught a class of teenagers. You don't get it and you never will get it. Our jobs are completely, utterly different, and contain totally different stressors and pressures.

It is not unprofessional to snap at a child occasionally. It is human. No one is saying that it is OK that the teacher 'took her mood out' on a child (which apparently was what the teacher admitted to her Head and the Head repeated this to the parent - all of which I find very hard to believe, I must say) and that it's recommended that teachers go around snapping at children. All people like me - who actually do have experience of teaching teenagers, unlike you (respectfully - I wouldn't presume to tell you how to deal with toddlers in a professional setting, as I have no experience of doing it) - are saying is that teachers do sometimes drop the ball, teachers aren't always given the information they need to support SEN kids properly, and that teachers are human, are juggling multiple demands on their time and energy, and sometimes they react badly to a situation and regret it later. We don't need to hang, draw and quarter them when they do. What we can do is take a step back, appreciate they do a very stressful job, and cut them a bit of slack. And hopefully teach our kids to do the same.

I might add that we don't actually know what this teacher supposedly said to the OP's child, as the OP has never stated this clearly. It seems like she was simply told to wait in a snappy tone while the teacher worked out where to put her in the seating plan. I don't think that's the crime of the century. In the moment it was upsetting for the OP's daughter, and that's regrettable of course, but it was hardly done with malicious intent - more in a moment of being flustered at the beginning of a lesson when she had a million other things to deal with.

I'm very impressed that you are the model of perfection all the time at work. I certainly am not. I admit that. I've been working for 20+ years and worked with hundreds of colleagues in that time. I've never met someone who didn't once lose their cool on the job. You are certainly one in a million and I applaud you.

No, I didn't say that I said that the teacher said to the class she was in a bad mood.

And I have absolutely said nothing about hanging, drawing or quartering. I can say I believe the teacher didn't act appropriately and at the same time appreciate she may be stressed, tired, having an off day. None of that is unique to teaching although I know teaching is a tough job. And I absolutely do teach my Dc to give the benefit of the doubt when appropriate.

Look, I'm a nurse, I'm tired, stressed, overwhelmed, am autistic and have 2 autistic Dc and I'm a single mum. I'm allowed to have a vent on MN! There's nothing so terrible about saying a teacher did something wrong which affected my DD. You're taking this too personally inho.

If you have read my posts I have already clearly said the teacher said 'I don't know'. I've said that more than once and explained it left my DD not knowing what to do. She at no point asked her to wait while others sat down!

OP posts:
Mirabai · 20/12/2023 14:10

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 08:28

Exactly, this provision doesn't exist.

It does but it’s expensive. The last Labour government pursued a policy of closing special schools and educating SEN students in mainstream schools. Around 100 schools closed across the country. It was Ruth Kelly who oversaw this and then sent her own SEN son to a private school. (I’m a Labour voter so I have no political axe to grind I just thought it was a disastrous misguided policy and still do).

The only alternative if there are not funds for a private school is homeschooling.

ntmdino · 20/12/2023 14:07

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 13:36

@ntmdino I would be surprised if the child was 'specifically and uniquely disadvantaged' deliberately though. We really do expect teachers to be super human sometimes.

I didn't say it was deliberate. It was, however, what happened because of the teacher's conduct.

As I said...imagine the same circumstances, but involving a child with a physical disability. In that case, whether it was deliberate or not, there would be outrage - and rightly so. And yet here, in this thread, many people are saying that the autistic child needs to suck it up and learn to deal with it - which is like saying "walk it off" to a child with one leg.

Happilyobtuse · 20/12/2023 13:58

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 10:33

I do teach my DD to cope with situations. She already coped with countless things. She has coped with mainstream school for 6 years so far so sure she can continue to cope. There is no specialist provision for DC like her anyway.

I like the way the answer to a teacher being rude to a SEN DC is that the DC must be moved out of mainstream education rather than teachers always being polite!

Considering she's managed all this time I'm sure she can continue to manage!

See no one should be rude to anyone in a perfect world. Unfortunately people are rude all the time, either they are stressed, tired, moody etc. So the teacher should definitely be advised but blaming her for something that took place the next day is a bit of a stretch. Instead maybe we need to teach our children that no one is perfect and we all make mistakes. The teacher didn’t mean to hurt your feelings and she is sorry. It is more likely that this lack of routine and change to pyjamas upset her more that the teacher’s behaviour from the previous day. Did she say the teacher upsetting her the day before was the reason or are you assuming that?! Also if it is the reason you really need to teach her better coping mechanisms. Whether SEN or not we all need to be able to forgive each other for mistakes. None of us is perfect, we can only try. Also vilifying the teacher will not help in the large scheme of things, we live in a very imperfect world and we can’t expect everyone to follow a script on how to interact with our child.

Mirabai · 20/12/2023 13:55

WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 13:27

This is a huge deal for many autistic children. Mine tend to think they are being told off, and it causes issues such as meltdown, not sleeping, school avoidance, panic.

Ideally, whole class teaching should be neuro-inclusive. There are no disadvantages to neurotypical children and it ensures that undiagnosed neurodivergent children aren’t traumatised.

Not sure if that’s realistic. It would mean ultimately that naughty disruptive NT children would not be reprimanded or reprimanded in a way that’s only relevant to ND children.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 13:53

@muggart well then everyone who occasionally has a bad/stressful day and accidentally isn't as perfect as they should be is unprofessional. I doubt she set out to upset the child, I imagine she feels bad, she apologised, there isn't much more she can do. No teacher can completely prevent this happening.

muggart · 20/12/2023 13:46

The teacher was unprofessional.

This thread demonstrates how low our expectations of teachers are, which is a shame because many of them would not behave like your DCs teacher did.

I have respect for (good) teachers and think they provide a vital service. But in no other service industry is it acceptable to snap at a customer because you're in a bad mood. At least she admitted it, I suppose.

CHRIS003 · 20/12/2023 13:45

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 23:11

This is her 4th week at the school.

As a parent of an adult son with asd - I have been through all of this in the past.
Just wondering what the teachers on here think of the following.

  1. Campaigning for the inclusion of special needs modules in teacher training.
Maybe work placements for student teachers in asd units etc. Also not just for asd - training sessions for adhd / dyslexia / children with medical or social needs and how education is affected.
  1. CCTV in the classroom? Would it not solve a lot of parent teacher he said/ she said debates if a teacher could record each lesson or in lessons where there are particular issues ? Would it not save a lot of time / stress parents complaints etc. If you could just check back on a recording and see who did what ?
WombatChocolate · 20/12/2023 13:40

randomstress · 20/12/2023 13:20

I been reading through the thread and feeling sorry for both dd and the teacher.

I was wondering if OP was ND herself as her thinking is very rigid and also very black and white.
Most of life is grey, messy and full of mistakes.

Try to support your dd to accept that people make mistakes, to show grace and keep on advocating for yourself and others. This may be the first mistake but it won't be the last.

Absolutely.
Yes, 20 pages in, OP has said she is autistic herself.

Being ND in institutions which are chronically underfunded is always going to result in staff who are over-stretched and under-trained, as one of the consequences is what happened yesterday to OPs DD …..and far worse happens too.

As an earlier poster said, blame the government and its funding of schools as the root of provision not being better than it is.

Seeing the nuance in the situation and the events themselves and their causes as complex rather than simply down to someone being in a bad mood or choosing to be rude is necessary…..but OP probably finds that tricky.

We all want provision to be better. The parents with ND children on here want it to be better and have experienced vast amounts of disappointment and worse over the years. Ultimately, this will continue and probably get worse whilst this funding crisis continues.

OP wanted to vent and has had lots of opportunity here to do so. I hope it has helped her move on and forwards from this rather than becoming bogged down in the incident.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 20/12/2023 13:39

Teachers do try to deal with the umpteen different, and often regularly-changing, needs of multiple students in each of our many classes. But we are human, and we are not always going to manage it. Each parent views their own child's needs in isolation. We can't do that really.

If parents could be a fly on the wall in their child's school, or trail a full time teacher for the day, they might have a better understanding of how hard it is to even remember all those individual requirements, never mind balance them against the needs of the rest of the class.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 13:37

WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 13:27

This is a huge deal for many autistic children. Mine tend to think they are being told off, and it causes issues such as meltdown, not sleeping, school avoidance, panic.

Ideally, whole class teaching should be neuro-inclusive. There are no disadvantages to neurotypical children and it ensures that undiagnosed neurodivergent children aren’t traumatised.

I am sorry it's hard for your children, however a teacher must also be able to discipline a class within reason - it actually would be a disadvantage were he/she not able to do that, and learning may suffer.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 13:36

@ntmdino I would be surprised if the child was 'specifically and uniquely disadvantaged' deliberately though. We really do expect teachers to be super human sometimes.

WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 13:27

ShittingPeugeot · 20/12/2023 12:43

Out of curiosity what happens then when the class is getting spoken to as a whole, say the whole class is getting told of for collectively being disruptive, does that now not happen due to one or two autistic people in the class?

I'm genuinely curious before anyone slates me!

This is a huge deal for many autistic children. Mine tend to think they are being told off, and it causes issues such as meltdown, not sleeping, school avoidance, panic.

Ideally, whole class teaching should be neuro-inclusive. There are no disadvantages to neurotypical children and it ensures that undiagnosed neurodivergent children aren’t traumatised.

randomstress · 20/12/2023 13:20

I been reading through the thread and feeling sorry for both dd and the teacher.

I was wondering if OP was ND herself as her thinking is very rigid and also very black and white.
Most of life is grey, messy and full of mistakes.

Try to support your dd to accept that people make mistakes, to show grace and keep on advocating for yourself and others. This may be the first mistake but it won't be the last.

Teder · 20/12/2023 12:51

Some people really lack the ability to be empathetic. Yes, this is AIBU but it’s clear
the OP is upset and frustrated that her daughter had a bad day. Perhaps she does not have anyone in real life and wanted to share her human emotions. Lots of people on here are saying the teacher is only human and was probably tired and stressed, so snapped. That’s fair. It’s equally fair that the OP is feeling emotional.

ShittingPeugeot · 20/12/2023 12:43

lavenderlou · 19/12/2023 18:53

OP, best to stick to the SEN board to discuss issues like this. Most posters in AIBU do not understand why what seems like no big deal to a NT child is a huge deal to a child with autism. I am a teacher and a parent of autistic children. Tone of voice can be a huge deal to children with autism. I would make sure the school put into her plan that teachers need to be aware of how they use their tone of voice around her. It's not a criticism of the teacher, it's just making them aware that this SEN student needs an adjustment in how they are spoken to compared to a NT student.

Edited

Out of curiosity what happens then when the class is getting spoken to as a whole, say the whole class is getting told of for collectively being disruptive, does that now not happen due to one or two autistic people in the class?

I'm genuinely curious before anyone slates me!

ntmdino · 20/12/2023 12:30

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 12:21

You are still stuck on this despite the numerous posts explaining how hard teachers lives are and that we all have off days?
Have you never snapped or behaved slightly less than ideally?

That's all well and good, but holding to that perspective makes it easy to lose sight of the fact that a disabled child was specifically and uniquely disadvantaged by the teacher's outburst and her lack of understanding of the consequences of her conduct.

Now, I've not read all 20 pages in detail, but it's totally possible that the teacher didn't actually know that OP's daughter is autistic. That'd be the only genuine mitigating factor here, because otherwise it's outright discrimination, and excusing it as "having an off-day" wouldn't be a mitigation for any other disability or protected characteristic (and nor should it be). Try to imagine how a teacher snapping at an amputee because they couldn't get to their seat and asked for help might go over - would having a bad day excuse it, or would they (as the actual adult in the room) be expected to put that to one side to avoid being the cause of more problems for the child?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 12:21

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 12:06

Just been polite.

You are still stuck on this despite the numerous posts explaining how hard teachers lives are and that we all have off days?
Have you never snapped or behaved slightly less than ideally?

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 12:17

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 19/12/2023 22:47

Bollocks you've not looked to apportion blame! You've castiged this science teacher to her colleagues, the LSA, and senior management. If any of my dc or dc in my family suggested they wanted to teach I'd absolutely warn them off.

Where have I said I castigated this teacher to her colleagues, the LSA and senior management? I've not said a word about her!

And if you want to warn the off do so, it's no skin off my nose.

OP posts:
Sartre · 20/12/2023 12:17

Was the teacher supposed to wake her up so she could have the dinner? I’d imagine the teacher thought leaving her to rest was the kindest solution.

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 12:14

Teder · 19/12/2023 22:43

I think many many people realise that teaching is underfunded, poorly resourced, lacking in respect from others and genuinely a tough profession. However, this is an 11 year old ND child and they are not the one in the position of power here. We’ve had lots of informative posts about the pressures of teaching so teachers on here have given their perspective but we need to look at it from this child’s perspective. Of course the OP is going to protect her child and prioritise her.

While some people (not all) are badgering the OP and also commenting “maybe the teacher is ND” well, perhaps the OP is also ND……so give her a break! She’s not asking for the teacher to be hung, drawn and quartered. She’s disappointed and upset. It doesn’t sound like @UndertheCedartree has gone in “fuming” and demanding the teacher is fired - I assume?!

YANBU to be upset your DD missed out, especially as you had planned. However, if you can support her to focus on how amazingly well she has done to transition to a new school, that sounds like a positive. It won’t take away the disappointment but sounds like she has been extremely resilient in starting her new school.

Yes, I'm autistic too. No I haven't gone in fuming, I haven't made a complaint atall. My DD just told the headteacher why she was feeling so upset today.

Thank you, yes, we will focus on the positives!

OP posts:
WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 12:12

The responses on this thread are horrid. And they say it’s autistic people who lack empathy.