Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad my DD missed Christmas dinner

811 replies

UndertheCedartree · 19/12/2023 17:25

My 11yo DD is autistic and she has recently started at a new school. The school have been great in supporting her.

Sadly, she went into a Science class for the first time yesterday and as they have set seats she asked the teacher where she should sit. The teacher snapped at her that she didn't know and she had to stand at the front of the class waiting for the others to sit down which really unsettled and upset her.

Today was their Christmas dinner day and they could go in wearing pyjamas. She was really looking forward to this. But as we got closer to school this morning she got more and more distressed. Once in school she had a full on meltdown that went on for ages. Eventually she calmed down enough for me to leave and they took her up to the Learning support centre where she promptly fell asleep exhausted after her melt down. She missed her Christmas dinner! After a while they asked me to come and pick her up. I feel so sad for her. I'd spent a lot of time preparing her for the Christmas dinner and it was going to be a nice way to introduce her to the canteen. And she was so looking forward to it. All spoilt because a teacher took her bad mood out on her.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 19:09

Boomboom22 · 20/12/2023 11:10

So the op is a nurse. And has been a teacher. I do not buy for a second that most nurses are polite, have you ever been in a hospital?
The head having a word is quite a big deal, much much more than extremely rude nurses ever get, un fact nurses are usually defended when laughing very loudly at all hours, ignoring buzzers, outright ignoring anyone they walk past. People are threatened / scared of not getting any treatment at all if they complain.
And still it's not clear what is wrong with a science teacher appropriately asking a new student to wait to allocate a seat and even going so far as to apologise for snapping and explaining they are in a bad mood! Teachers must be smiley friendly robots but nurses are perfectly allowed to be sullen, in fact it appears to be a prerequisite. Not nurses at the Dr's, they see you 1-1 so are much better at appearing at least to care.

Yes, I've been in a hospital! 😂

If a member of my staff were rude to a patient I'd have a word. It's usually HCAs that answer the buzzers. A nurse may walk past you because they are doing the meds round or needing to do some time critical treatment. I'm sorry if you've had a negative experience. I wouldn't tolerate anyone being threatened with no treatment! I've never experienced anyone doing that. If you've experienced that I'm very sorry for you.

But please read what I said. The science teacher did not ask a new student to wait to allocate a seat nor did they apologise.

And my expectation of a teacher to be polite is the same as my expectation for all of my nurses to be polite. I'm happy you find us practice nurses much better! My team certainly care.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 19:00

WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 11:05

You sound extremely sensible OP, and the posters having a go clearly have no clue how difficult and stressful it is to have a secondary aged child struggling to attend and access school, whilst trying to keep a job. I’m in a similar situation and I think you’re doing a fantastic job.

Some posters here seem to have no idea how the Equality Act and inclusion works, or to understand that autistic meltdown is a neurological event due to sensory overload and not a behavioural issue.

It can be really tough can't it? I just hope some teachers can take on board a few things as I've tried to take on board suggestions too.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:57

Nepmarthiturn · 20/12/2023 10:45

Teaching involves teaching other humans. These humans will not be robots and will need to be taught in a variety of ways to teach them successfully. So yes, it absolutely is the teacher's job to provide a suitable learning environment that takes into account that actual people they are teaching otherwise those people will not be able to learn and therefore the teacher is failing to do their job.

I'm not sure a teacher can just pick and choose who to teach so they don't have to deal with ND kids. How would that even work?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:54

Chipsahoyagain · 20/12/2023 10:37

I like the way the answer to a teacher being rude to a SEN DC is that the DC must be moved out of mainstream education rather than teachers always being polite!

But teachers signed up to teach. Not to manage all these additional scenarios that they now have to do. It's not fair on anyone - the child or the teacher. Can you imagine having 29 kids in your care, having to provide them an education, then remember and manage each and every detail of these kids on top, and be cheery and bright through all of it. They are human and sometimes will make a mistake. You say it's the first time this has happened so the school can't be all that bad.

Yes, I can because I've done it. It isn't so very hard to be polite, imo. And it's not as if secondary schools don't have Learning support departments to help. But yes, we all make mistakes.

And I've said how fantastic the school is.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:50

Nepmarthiturn · 20/12/2023 10:37

It is absolutely shocking. I've seen some hideously ableist threads on here but this one is astonishing.

An autistic child managing a secondary school environment is already far more resilient than most NT adults, who have no idea what it's like to cope in an environment that is literally hell for you in every conceivable way. And on top of this to be new to the school. And then have the adults who are meant to be helping you settle in be rude and dismissive to you like that and make the anxiety even worse. Poor, poor child.

All public bodies have a legal duty to ensure their services are designed and delivered in such a way that they do not disadvantage disabled people and make them accessible for them. Schools exist for the sole purpose of helping each child reach their full potential so if even they cannot meet this legal duty in the most basic of ways that cost them nothing except a bit of consideration then it's pretty pathetic frankly. So many posts saying how we should think of the poor teachers, and no concern for the child involved.

Do you tell asthmatic people to just "be more resilient" and stop fussing about inhalers? Should people with peanut allergies just "be more resilient" and eat a bowl of peanuts? It is flabbergasting that people think it's acceptable to dismiss and minimise the needs of an ASD child in this when they'd never dream of doing so for other health conditions.

I just don't think people really understand how important these things are to those with ASD. And they don't realise that they could see my DD at school most of the time and she'd be coping fine. People trying to make out her needs are just so complex when in all honesty they're not.

I would like teachers to recognise that manners cost nothing and they can make such a difference to an ASD child.

OP posts:
Mojolostforever · 20/12/2023 18:49

muggart · 20/12/2023 13:46

The teacher was unprofessional.

This thread demonstrates how low our expectations of teachers are, which is a shame because many of them would not behave like your DCs teacher did.

I have respect for (good) teachers and think they provide a vital service. But in no other service industry is it acceptable to snap at a customer because you're in a bad mood. At least she admitted it, I suppose.

Children are not customers and teaching is not a service industry. Customers don't cause mayhem with the kind of low level disruption caused in classrooms.

WombatChocolate · 20/12/2023 18:47

Well I think I’m out of this thread.

OP says the issue is resolved in her mind. As mentioned above, the only thing that seems to remain is that she thinks people shouldn’t be rude or speak harshly. I think we’d all agree that but most people also accept that occasionally it does happen. We might not excuse it but we understand it and know that in a myriad of human interactions at work in busy places, the tone or facial expression or body language might not always be what people would hope for. That’s it.

Hope your DD enjoys her new school Op and it works out well for her. No doubt there will be set backs along the way, but hopefully there wont be too many and when they happen, both of you are able to deal with them and move forward.

WombatChocolate · 20/12/2023 18:40

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:24

No, my DD was having a meltdown in reception and the headteacher asked if we wanted to come into her room as it was warmer (and I expect she wanted to give DD some privacy.) Not sure what teacher you're refering to but I think I've already said what everything said. People wonder why I repeat myself but it is because multiple people ask the same thing and then insist I've not answered their question and I'm trying to avoid it or something!

The reason people ask the same question multiple times, is because most of your replies don’t relate to the posts just above it, but to one’s from hours or days ago. This means the thread doesn’t run as a conversation or chronologically like most threads do. It’s very disconnected. It feels as if OP isn’t interested in a progressing conversation which is based around lots of people contributing together, but simply 1-2-1 conversations with multiple people. And despite the fact that OP often doesn’t reply to comments for more than 12 hours, she still expects people to have read the whole thread and spotted an answer to a similar question 10 pages back.

It seems OP stated her upset in the first post and wants acknowledgement of her feelings and agreement….but not the usual kind of suggestions about next steps or explanation of why this might have happened, that usual threads get. It emerges that she was upset and thinks the way the teacher spoke want professional and she would never speak like that to anyone and struggles to understand that this could and does happen. And essentially that’s it. But it can fill 20 plus pages, with OP filling almost half of those.

it’s very u usual as a thread.

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:40

WombatChocolate · 20/12/2023 10:24

So where is this thread going OP?

You say you haven’t complained, don’t require any action to be taken. Is it simply the case that you feel you have to respond to all the comments made by other posters?

I find it extraordinary that you work as a nurse and have worked in schools and haven’t encountered or seen people respond. With less than the best manners, politeness and kindness to others around them. Or, that you can’t imagine that you yourself have never shown an expression that might be viewed as exasperated or used a tone that might not be considered friendly or polite.

The essence of your complaint about the teacher is the way they spoke to your DD. No-one has condoned it, but very many have tried to explain why this could happen. You speak of working in schools and as a nurse, but don’t seem to recognise the working environment where there is so much information and short notice information and so many demands, that actually having everything to hand before a class/patient arrives (such as having the new seating plans in your mind) just isn’t always possible. Pressures and stress at work are a cause of people not always speaking in the best way and it is common.

So, by responding with many many comments about the teacher and their way of speaking to your DD, are you purely feeling the need to respond to posters, but don’t see this as an on-going issue. Is it resolved in your mind? Have you moved on? Your responses are keeping the topic alive. They seem to suggest you want action taken… it surprisingly, few people joining the thread will read 15+ pages. Have you put this to bed or are you getting something yourself from the on-going thread? What is the purpose of it now?

Yes, I do feel if people take the time to comment on my post I should make the effort to respond. I mean you've taken the time to write quite long posts and have asked me questions so yes, I suppose I do feel obligated to respond. I'm probably wrong to feel that, but I do.

I've not said anyway I've not seen people behave like this, of course I have. It's not that I can't imagine that but I would expect to be called out on it. I wouldn't feel I could just excuse it by saying I was tired or stressed. As far as I am aware I've not been impolite in a professional capacity. I fully admit I have privately.

I understand why it could happen as I have said. I understand those things and would never expect someone to have a seating plan in their mind. I know people get stressed, they get flustered. I just don't find being rude helpful in anyway. It just alienates people. I just don't think it would be right for me to be rude especially to a student or patient. So maybe it comes more naturally to me. The thing is, people really are looking to condone the rudeness. They are giving endless lists of why someone might be rude and seem to expect me to say, you know what, I hadn't thought of that, yes, in that case the rudeness was fine. I just don't believe that. And neither do many who have commented on this thread including multiple teachers.

We don't all have to believe the same things. It's ok for someone to disagree with you. Yes, I do have a strong belief of treating others as you wish to be treated. It's pretty important to me. It might not be as important to someone else for all sorts of valid reasons and that's ok.

Yes, it's resolved in my mind. But I do find it interesting learning about others viewpoints whether in support of mine or against. So if other people are interested in discussing the topic then I'm happy to respond.

OP posts:
SkinOffNose · 20/12/2023 18:31

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:24

No, my DD was having a meltdown in reception and the headteacher asked if we wanted to come into her room as it was warmer (and I expect she wanted to give DD some privacy.) Not sure what teacher you're refering to but I think I've already said what everything said. People wonder why I repeat myself but it is because multiple people ask the same thing and then insist I've not answered their question and I'm trying to avoid it or something!

OP don’t feel like you have to answer every single post or question. You have answered most questions already so people should just read the thread!

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 20/12/2023 18:25

WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 16:31

This too. Not mutually exclusive! But inclusive environments are the goal, surely?

I'm not sure it's possible to be inclusive to every single need at once, but of course yes, the aim should be to have safe, welcoming, and inclusive spaces, with clear boundaries and support where needed.

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:24

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 20/12/2023 10:21

So it just happened that the headteacher was waiting with the LSA when you dropped your dd off?
What did the teacher actually say?

No, my DD was having a meltdown in reception and the headteacher asked if we wanted to come into her room as it was warmer (and I expect she wanted to give DD some privacy.) Not sure what teacher you're refering to but I think I've already said what everything said. People wonder why I repeat myself but it is because multiple people ask the same thing and then insist I've not answered their question and I'm trying to avoid it or something!

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:20

zingally · 20/12/2023 10:16

Not the science teachers fault.

It sounds like what happened was a very normal part of a secondary school day.

It sounds more like your DD has just had a culmination of a difficult week (surely this was her first week, as this was her first science lesson - a subject they have multiple times a week) in an unfamiliar place, and just being "end of term tired". Plus a very strange time of year to change schools. Everyone knows the last week before Christmas break is usually very off timetable and full of unusual events. Personally, I'd have kept her off and started fresh in January.

The whole "missing Christmas lunch" is not something to get upset about here. Concentrate on having a restful, quiet Christmas instead.

As I've explained it was her 4th week. They have Biology once a fortnight, Chemistry once a fortnight and Physics once a fortnight. This was the first time with this teacher. She didn't change schools she just started her secondary school as I had to go through the appeal process. And no, the attendance officer wouldn't have been happy for her to just start in January!

Thank you, we will do.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:14

Nepmarthiturn · 20/12/2023 10:11

That's what "pupil passports" are for. No member of staff should be working in a classroom even temporarily without having reviewed a basic summary of the needs of any children in the classroom with SEN.

I do think this is best practice. And is all flagged up on the register at my Dd's school.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 18:11

DiaryOfaTTCer · 20/12/2023 10:00

How do you know that the teacher 'has a reputation for being rude'? You've mentioned that a few times.

I don't know the teacher has a reputation for being rude all I said was I saw a look pass between the LSA and Head when DD told the Head the teacher had been rude to her. It seemed as if it didn't necessarily come as a suprise to them. However, I've been quite clear I could be wrong about that.

OP posts:
Americano75 · 20/12/2023 18:08

And OP, I hope your daughter is OK. I'm not looking forward to my 10 year old starting secondary myself.

Americano75 · 20/12/2023 17:56

The teacher was out of order, I know teaching is a stressful job but an 11 year old child asking you a simple question does not warrant that kind of response.

BlackeyedSusan · 20/12/2023 17:51

43ontherocksporfavor · 19/12/2023 20:49

This is why so many teachers are at breaking point . Parents want bespoke education in a mainstream setting.

Edited

Parents want schools to fulfil their legal duties as laid out in the Sendcop.

And adults to be resilient enough not to snap at disabled children.

DiaryOfaTTCer · 20/12/2023 17:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 17:31

EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 09:56

Your posts are increasingly contradictory and confusing.

If you ‘forgive’ the teacher and know she will make amends next lesson, then why make such a big deal out of it? Why keep insisting that she was rude and unprofessional if you claim to appreciate that she was probably knackered and under pressure?

The way you keep referring back to posts from the thread at random is also very confusing. It doesn’t help the conversation when you keep jumping back to posts out of the order and context in which they were written.

What big deal have I made of it? I've not complained, I've not said anything about it. I've just had a vent on an onymous forum! I honestly feel you've made a bigger deal of it than I have! 😂

Being tired doesn't mean that snapping at my DD wasn't rude. I mean come on! So people can go around being as rude as they like then say, I was tired therefore I wasn't rude atall!

I'm going through posts in exact order.

OP posts:
WombatChocolate · 20/12/2023 17:26

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 17:06

I assume she has some way to access this seating plan otherwise what is the point? I didn't expect her to memorise it! As you say she could access it and then would be able to tell my DD where to sit. There was no need for the rudeness she could have just told my DD to hang on a sec while she accessed the seating plan. Some parents have been/are teachers so do have a clue what happens. And yes, as I've already said I gave her the benefit of the doubt.

‘I assume…otherwise what is the point’. Well, yes you might think this, but To be honest, in schools today, you can’t really assume anything. You cannot assume info has reached everyone it should reach, or that everyone has had a chance to read it or implement it for all kinds of reasons.

Parents sometimes forget that a teacher might see 300 children in a week and receive emails about adjustments needed by dozens of them based on pastoral issues, additional needs, friendship issues and all kinds of other things each week.

If you’re someone who has worked in schools and as a nurse, you’d know this….the deluge of info, often arriving very last minute….the fact that things and people are sprung upon you with little or no warning, or even when you’ve had warning, you might simply have forgotten due to info overload.

So, DD turns up and teacher either hasn’t been told or has forgotten or whatever…..so needs to access the seating plan and find where she is to sit….has to download it or find the right email….and at the same time, 4 other children are trying to tell her something, and she has to submit the register within 2 mins or someone will be after her, and another urgent message is flashing on the screen, and there is a loud noise outside in the corridor and…and ….

Most if the time most teachers manage to respond calmly and pleasantly. Occasionally they might sound a bit stressed or stretched or even irritated. Not ideal. Understandable to most people that this might happen.

When a child is ND in mainstream school and has additional needs but there is no real funding or resourcing, it is their needs that often get hit. They are the least able to cope with the changes in routine, stretched and stressed teachers and actions that schools have to take to deal with a shortage of staff and other complications which every day require difficult decisions to be made. Things don’t run smoothly. Children of all types see the consequences of these funding cuts and consequences. And to be honest, it will get worse.

UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 17:25

EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 09:43

@UndertheCedartree

You seem focused on the concept that the teacher was rude and you can’t seem to appreciate any nuance around why she might have spoken to your daughter in the way she did. You keep saying there is no excuse for being rude even though numerous people have explained how it is unreasonable to expect your daughter to always be spoken to politely by staff at school because those staff are human.

You say you are a nurse and are not ‘allowed’ to be rude at work. Well, I’m sure all of us who have had the misfortune to be in hospital have an anecdote of a rude or uncaring nurse we’ve encountered. I certainly have! So you have got a rather unrealistic view of the behaviours displayed by members not only of the teaching profession, but also of your own. Both are stressful and emotional jobs that sometimes push those doing them into situations where they lose their cool. That is the reality. I think we can all forgive the occasional lapse of professionalism under pressure.

It’s still unclear what you want or expect going forward. You have mentioned wanting an apology. So why not arrange to meet with this teacher so you can get one? This teacher will be with your daughter all year, so resolving this situation and moving forward positively is in everyone’s best interests. Rather than discussing the teacher with other staff at the school and with strangers on the internet, have a conversation with her directly and give her the opportunity to set things to rights. You have made a lot of assumptions about her and I don’t think that’s particularly kind or fair. Respect goes both ways.

I've not mentioned wanting an apology. What would the teacher have to apologise to me for? I just said it would be nice if she apologised to DD. I haven't discussed the teacher with other staff at the school. I honestly don't know what this opportunity to set things to rights would involve? She_s got nothing to set right with me? I'm also confused what assumptions I've made? I suggested she may have been having a bad day which I don't think is a bad thing to say.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 20/12/2023 17:19

EnidSpyton · 20/12/2023 09:43

@UndertheCedartree

You seem focused on the concept that the teacher was rude and you can’t seem to appreciate any nuance around why she might have spoken to your daughter in the way she did. You keep saying there is no excuse for being rude even though numerous people have explained how it is unreasonable to expect your daughter to always be spoken to politely by staff at school because those staff are human.

You say you are a nurse and are not ‘allowed’ to be rude at work. Well, I’m sure all of us who have had the misfortune to be in hospital have an anecdote of a rude or uncaring nurse we’ve encountered. I certainly have! So you have got a rather unrealistic view of the behaviours displayed by members not only of the teaching profession, but also of your own. Both are stressful and emotional jobs that sometimes push those doing them into situations where they lose their cool. That is the reality. I think we can all forgive the occasional lapse of professionalism under pressure.

It’s still unclear what you want or expect going forward. You have mentioned wanting an apology. So why not arrange to meet with this teacher so you can get one? This teacher will be with your daughter all year, so resolving this situation and moving forward positively is in everyone’s best interests. Rather than discussing the teacher with other staff at the school and with strangers on the internet, have a conversation with her directly and give her the opportunity to set things to rights. You have made a lot of assumptions about her and I don’t think that’s particularly kind or fair. Respect goes both ways.

It's not that I can't appreciate nuance, it's just that I don't think there is any excuse for rudeness. If I was rude at work I'd get pulled up on it. If my staff are rude I'd talk to them. That's just my honest opinion. It doesn't mean I don't know it happens or reasons why it might happen, I just don't agree with it. It's like you think if you give me enough reasons I'll agree it's ok. I have high standards, that's the way I am. And the school suits our family as they have high standards too. I'm not saying there's anything wrong if you have a different opinion or whatever. That's just mine.

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 20/12/2023 17:12

Because sometimes NT children need a severe telling off in a way that would not be appropriate for ND children.

These days teachers would probably get in trouble for delivering anything resembling 'a severe telling off' to any student, NT or otherwise.

Mirabai · 20/12/2023 17:08

WaitingForMojo · 20/12/2023 14:44

Why would it not be relevant to neurotypical children?

We’re talking about neuroinclusive environments here, which absolutely can be done. Unfortunately the reality is often different due to institutional practice and also funding.

Because sometimes NT children need a severe telling off in a way that would not be appropriate for ND children.

Neuroinclusive can be done for sure - but much easier to implement in small schools with small classes. I just don’t know how that would even work at a National level with schools of 1-2000 kids with no funding and no money for extra teacher training or indeed extra teachers.