Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you say yes if at front of line and was asked to let a disabled child first ?

230 replies

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 16:06

Today my DD with her aunt went to some Xmas pop up thing, which had a character meet n Greet with one of her fav characters.
her rang me on the way home whilst I was talking with a friend and said how when they got there the line was massive and she took DD to the front to speak to the lady ( DD has visible tubes ) to ask how long the wait was in which they replied 2 hours. Aunt told DD there was no way she would stand in that cold for 2 hours and that maybe they could do something else. The worker then asked the front people if they didn’t mind if they Let her quickly run in to do the meet and greet, they were fine with this and DD got to go in.
my friend was mortified 😂 she was like I would be fuming and what about the people behind the first family what if they cared ?
she thinks it was very unfair as it was such a long line that everyone had to wait.
would you have minded ?

OP posts:
TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 18:23

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:22

I am aware it’s a real thing- I am stating that she probably has but not diagnosed.
but that is isn’t the reason she couldn’t line up

But nobody is saying that it is.
We're just comparing different disabilities.
Because 99% of people on this page assume disability = skip to the front.
And don't consider that there could be loads of them.

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:22

I am aware it’s a real thing- I am stating that she probably has but not diagnosed.
but that is isn’t the reason she couldn’t line up

OP posts:
TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 18:19

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:09

I shall add my daughter isn’t “ neurodiverse”
well she probably is but that’s not what the issue was.
I get the whole thing we see it a lot on theme parks which is why the system changed to the virtual line situation.
I get a lot of yeh I agree my son has adhd / autism but that is not what the situation was or is.
the same goes when the convo changes to the whole offensive about blessings and people with neurodiverse children who clearly have their own set of issues get offended like well we wouldn’t change it why is it not a blessing.
our situation isn’t like that I would change it in a heart beat and I’m not ashamed of that.
I am glad that all children / adults etc have their adaptions made in certain places but not every disabled person is “ neurodiverse “
it always becomes about that.

the difficulty is I suppose that every disability comes with it own set of challenges and that each person has their own abilities and struggles that it does make it hard to be fair.

for what’s it’s worth I would never ask, and if we were in a situation where something wasn’t accessible to her or she couldn’t do then we would go else where.

You don't to put 'neurodiverse' in quotes,. it's an accepted term and I have no idea what your issue is with it.
The discussion only arose because, in saying that people would let someone ahead. They have to have made a value judgement as to that person's capability.

Your daughter has tubes coming out of her, clearly this means to a lot of people she's in need. And I guess you agree? I don't know whether tubes = unable to queue.
However, ADHD, autism, other ND conditions are examples of 'invisible' disabilities where the same 'kindness' might not be extended. Equally, other physical disabilities like a wheelchair might not preclude queueing.

So this isn't about neurodiversity it's about how people cannot proclaim 'I'd DEFINITELY do it !' As though it was bleedingly obvious who was worthy of sympathy and who wasn't.

Seriously though. That is not the most relevant. The only thing to take away. If 1-2 people. 5+ people - not fine.

You asked 'would I have minded' well if your daughter was the 10th person, in the time I was queuing I certainly would. 1st person, probably not. You yourself said, you'd have left the queue.

autienotnaughty · 19/12/2023 18:18

No issue at all and heartwarming to see the majority agree

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:18

see this is what’s confusing me - if they had not let my DD which is fine we would of gone home not got in line - because it would have been impossible. Sometimes that’s life and she has to miss out on things as I know her capabilities.
the argument of well people in the line may have difficulties or if someone was turned away from the front so then got in to the line baffles me - you either can’t line up or you can …

OP posts:
marshmallowfinder · 19/12/2023 18:17

No idea why your friend was embarrassed. Seems a very odd reaction.

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:14

I think in that situation I wouldn’t have allowed it and would have removed my own daughter and taken her home.

OP posts:
ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 19/12/2023 18:13

@Nearlyfinished2023 Yes.

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:12

@ANightmareBeforeChristmas do you mean the really nice couple who let a child who needed it in front should then re line up for 2 hours that they already done so then making it 4 hours for them because they were kind ?

OP posts:
ANightmareBeforeChristmas · 19/12/2023 18:10

My view is that people letting others go in front of them in a queue should cede their own place - i.e. go to the back if the person they're letting in is not already in the queue. You don't know the circumstances of everybody who is queuing - there might be others struggling.

Nearlyfinished2023 · 19/12/2023 18:09

I shall add my daughter isn’t “ neurodiverse”
well she probably is but that’s not what the issue was.
I get the whole thing we see it a lot on theme parks which is why the system changed to the virtual line situation.
I get a lot of yeh I agree my son has adhd / autism but that is not what the situation was or is.
the same goes when the convo changes to the whole offensive about blessings and people with neurodiverse children who clearly have their own set of issues get offended like well we wouldn’t change it why is it not a blessing.
our situation isn’t like that I would change it in a heart beat and I’m not ashamed of that.
I am glad that all children / adults etc have their adaptions made in certain places but not every disabled person is “ neurodiverse “
it always becomes about that.

the difficulty is I suppose that every disability comes with it own set of challenges and that each person has their own abilities and struggles that it does make it hard to be fair.

for what’s it’s worth I would never ask, and if we were in a situation where something wasn’t accessible to her or she couldn’t do then we would go else where.

OP posts:
colourfulchinadolls · 19/12/2023 18:03

Of course I wouldn't mind. Having a disabled child is difficult enough. Cut them some slack. Life is hard enough already.

TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 18:02

willingtolearn · 19/12/2023 17:52

I disagree that someone with a visible disability is 'pitiable' and that their life is so much harder than others with non visible disabilities and other difficulties in life.

People with disabilities are part of society, not a special group that we must all pity. Sometime this means that they too must deal with the same difficult situations like queueing. Sometimes because they have particular difficulties, it means that they cannot - and that accommodations need to be made for them.

We have no idea of the make of up the queue and whether there were individuals in there that had equal difficulties because of their age, abilities and other factors with waiting for two hours.

What if there was a whole group outing for people with additional needs, - would we make those with visible differences go first, even if they actually had a greater capacity to wait than others with non visible difficulties?

It's not as simple as people are making out.

Exactly.
@BungleandGeorge , I completely agree. But you are wrong about jealousy from the 'non-disabled'. Assuming that everyone else is perfectly able to queue with zero problems.
In same cases the issue could even be from other disabled people whose needs aren't 'as great'. While I'm not at the point of totally being 'unable to queue' the sensory impact of cold is very hard for me. Am I selfish for not wanting my wait time to be extended drastically?

It's all very nuanced and situational. Nobody can say, for sure, in all situations that their attitude is right. If you are at the front of the queue. it's fine for you, because you're definitely going to go next but... at the back of the queue... the impact of the drip drip drip of people is greater.

But maybe, you guys believe, there wouldn't be that many disabled people with queuing issues out in these conditions anyway.... because... erm... there's not many and they should all be at home? Therefore, it will be only '1 or 2'? And so, too many people going ahead would never happen?

Btw in this case OP is entirely blameless the staff member offered for them to go first. But if someone showed up and asked to go first they have no way of knowing whether they were the first or 10th person to make the same request that day....

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 19/12/2023 18:00

I'd be happy to let her go in first

TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 17:57

@penjil Google the 'Equality Act' and neurodiversity I think you don't need my guidance on how to do that?
@BungleandGeorge How do you know who can queue and who can't? Same as the wheelchair example above. It seems to be accepted that the majority of wheelchair users need to skip the queue... but.... why? It's obvious for someone in crutches, but a wheelchair? Solely based on being in a wheelchair obviously but not any other conditions. Happy to be educated. Genuinely.

The point I'm trying to make is. The answer to this question hinges on the premise of, at most, a 'few' people skipping the queue. And it being '5 mins', a small inconvenience. But as I and @greedygreattit have experienced, that's often not the case. Because you can't guarantee that the number of disabled people who can't queue is tiny enough for it to not be an issue!

Btw I think the friend was wrong to scold OP, the staff member offered. But the OP's question is 'would I have minded'? Yes, if too many people were doing it. No, if it was only a few.

How can you be genuinely sure it's the latter and not the former?

BungleandGeorge · 19/12/2023 17:57

People think about disability in the wrong way, we should be making everything more accessible not having ridiculous systems and accommodating the disabled. Why on earth couldn’t people just be booked in and return after 2 hours- everyone will be better off. No need for jealousy from the non-disabled who don’t have a clue how their lives are so much easier either!

BungleandGeorge · 19/12/2023 17:53

Treesinmygarden · 19/12/2023 17:48

Actually I wouldn't be in the position because I wouldn't queue for anything for 2 hours in the cold!

I’m astounded that any young child would queue for 2 hours in the cold tbh!

willingtolearn · 19/12/2023 17:52

I disagree that someone with a visible disability is 'pitiable' and that their life is so much harder than others with non visible disabilities and other difficulties in life.

People with disabilities are part of society, not a special group that we must all pity. Sometime this means that they too must deal with the same difficult situations like queueing. Sometimes because they have particular difficulties, it means that they cannot - and that accommodations need to be made for them.

We have no idea of the make of up the queue and whether there were individuals in there that had equal difficulties because of their age, abilities and other factors with waiting for two hours.

What if there was a whole group outing for people with additional needs, - would we make those with visible differences go first, even if they actually had a greater capacity to wait than others with non visible difficulties?

It's not as simple as people are making out.

TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 17:50

Sirzy · 19/12/2023 17:43

A wheelchair itself doesn’t stop someone from queuing but for a lot of people with disabilities queuing in the cold for two hours could be dangerous for their health

But I wasn't talking about general 'people with disabilities'. Surely that's obvious? I was talking about wheelchairs, as an example because for many PP that's an 'obviously genuine' case for queue jumping.
These people have clearly never watched the Paralympic Games.
A wheelchair just means you can't stand. If you're an amputee for example you could otherwise be in perfect health and, in fact, MORE than able to wait in the cold compared to the average person.

While someone, with say autism that might result in a meltdown not 'obviously disabled' could be just dismissed.

Treesinmygarden · 19/12/2023 17:48

Actually I wouldn't be in the position because I wouldn't queue for anything for 2 hours in the cold!

penjil · 19/12/2023 17:48

TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 17:39

You're assuming it's just one person though. 6 people = half an hour! Which is 25% more queuing time.
OP, I'd be fine if it was just your daughter but I've been in quite a few queues where it's been a constant stream of people cutting in. That's unfair.

Also as @SiliconHeaven pointed out - who's worthy?

Disabled people aren't a 'small' minority neurodiverse people alone account for 1 in 5 people if properly diagnosed before you include everyone else (FTR, I'm ND).

Letting people go ahead isn't to make up for the 'unfairness' of being disabled it's about genuinely being unable to queue. I'm not sure how a wheelchair for example automatically precludes a child from waiting in the cold (obviously they're not standing).

Furthermore, 'non-disabled' kids might also have an issue, they might cranky due to being cold, hungry, needing the toilet if accompanied by a solo adult what are they supposed to do? They can't leave their place in the queue.

Edited

"Disabled people aren't a 'small' minority neurodiverse people alone account for 1 in 5 people.."

But since when has 'neurodiverse' been a recognised disability?! It isn't!

There are 67 million people in this country, so by your 1 in 5 reckoning, that makes 13.4 million disabled people then! (Which there clearly are not!)

BungleandGeorge · 19/12/2023 17:47

TurnthePotatoes · 19/12/2023 17:39

You're assuming it's just one person though. 6 people = half an hour! Which is 25% more queuing time.
OP, I'd be fine if it was just your daughter but I've been in quite a few queues where it's been a constant stream of people cutting in. That's unfair.

Also as @SiliconHeaven pointed out - who's worthy?

Disabled people aren't a 'small' minority neurodiverse people alone account for 1 in 5 people if properly diagnosed before you include everyone else (FTR, I'm ND).

Letting people go ahead isn't to make up for the 'unfairness' of being disabled it's about genuinely being unable to queue. I'm not sure how a wheelchair for example automatically precludes a child from waiting in the cold (obviously they're not standing).

Furthermore, 'non-disabled' kids might also have an issue, they might cranky due to being cold, hungry, needing the toilet if accompanied by a solo adult what are they supposed to do? They can't leave their place in the queue.

Edited

1in 5 may be ND but the majority of that number can queue! The bigger group is dyslexics who are not going to get a skip the queue pass!

greedygreattit · 19/12/2023 17:46

I think one child is fine, a few children is still ok but it can be a problem when too many disabled children cut in.

I've been in a similar line with my younger cousin who is autistic but was still waiting for diagnosis at the time, she struggled with queueing like a lot of young children do. Our wait was more than boubled by various different children cutting to the front. Some were visibly disable. I didn't mind the first few but it got way too many all different families one after the other. The queue wasn't even that long and should have only taken about 20 minutes. I could see the front the whole time. I wouldn't have joined otherwise as knew she would struggle to wait for too long.

It was incredible frustrating and I put a complaint in after with the company. I have no issue with the cutting to the front in theory but it does need to be spaced out.

paisley256 · 19/12/2023 17:46

MarkWithaC · 19/12/2023 16:17

Of course YANBU. I hope if I were near the front of that queue with a non-disabled child I would suggest your DD and aunt went before me.

Exactly.

TinselTitts · 19/12/2023 17:46

Under those circumstances I genuinely can't think of anyone I know who wouldn't have let her go first.