Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's such a shame that family bonds are being destroyed and going NC is becoming more and more common?

340 replies

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:21

Just that really. I might just be an old fart desperately yearning for the old days but I was raised to believe in the importance of having family around you and I find it horribly sad that so many people I know have family that haven't spoken to them for years.

Obviously in cases where some bad behavior has gone on it's understandable but surely there's nothing that can't be worked on? Going NC is so extreme and I think should be a last case resort if done at all.

OP posts:
MrsHughesPinny · 19/12/2023 16:52

Going NC with a parent is the best decision I’ve ever made.

ssd · 19/12/2023 16:52

Some things aren't fixable and it does your mental health no good at all continually looking for something that doesn't exist.

KrisAkabusi · 19/12/2023 16:52

It just feels that these days the reasons for isolating a family member have become increasingly petty or small. Someones MIL isn't their cup of tea so now their children will never know their granny

I don't believe that people are going no contact on a whim. I don't believe you have any evidence to show that either. What you may have is anecdotal data of you/ your friend 🙄being cut off by their daughter in law, clearly without looking at the other side of the story.

Grapewrath · 19/12/2023 16:52

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

This grandparent sounds incredibly interfering and did cross boundaries. She shouldn’t be advising on how dil should feed the baby or insisting on visiting the hospital (she doesn’t sound like a person to ask nicely)
Your friend sounds very overbearing and I guarantee the DIL has a very different perspective on this

TWmover · 19/12/2023 16:51

It's this kind of societal judgement that makes people keep 'family' in their life that they shouldn't and which gives dysfunctional and abusive people leverage to make family members play along even in horrible circumstances.

I saw a post online recently saying:
Question: Name one gift many people take for granted.
Answer: Supportive parents.

Good for you OP that you haven't had to grow up in an environment that has forced you to make this decision. No one doesn't want family or the judgement that comes with it.

RatherBeRiding · 19/12/2023 16:51

There really are some things that cannot and should not be 'worked on' - abuse in its many forms being one of them. If there has been bad behaviour where the perpetrator can own their behaviour, seek to change and beg forgiveness that's one thing, but abusers often cannot change, do not want to change, and refuse to see that they are wrong. In which case I fully applaud the decision to cut these people off and refuse to have them in their lives any more.

VolvoFan · 19/12/2023 16:51

I voted YANBU. But.... I went NC with my mum many years ago. She is mentally ill.

From the account of my uncle on my mum's side (who is a bit loopy himself) and of my aunty on my dad's side, my mum was a decent person before an accident with a powerdrill that led to a brain haemorrhage.

My older brother (I wasn't born until around 8 years later) was around 18 months old when my mum, post-powerdrill accident, fell to the floor when an aneurysm in her head exploded. The doctors drained the blood from her head and eased the pressure on her brain before it could kill her, unfortunately substantial brain damage had already occurred from the pressure and the doctors told my uncle that she would not be the sister he grew up with and will not be able to differentiate between right and wrong.

From then on, she had two more children, one of whom died at just 2 weeks old, and then me. Obviously I never knew her pre-brain bleed, but suffice to say my upbringing was awful. She nearly destroyed me. There's a chance that had she not have had a brain haemorrhage years prior, she would have not been the nasty witch she became, but there is no way for me to know for sure. I didn't want to go NC with her, as I hate how fractured families become after cutting people off.

I had to go NC with her because she was on a path to completely ruining my life.

TL;DR Generally YANBU, but sometimes needs must.

Sugarsun · 19/12/2023 16:51

Someones MIL isn't their cup of tea so now their children will never know their granny?

In situations like this, I would say the woman is abusive/controlling.

The MIL would have a son who is an equal parent to the grandchildren and is also not letting them see his mum.

So he either agrees and chooses to go NC for bigger reasons or his wife is abusive and controlling and stopping him and the kids from seeing his mum.

pickledandpuzzled · 19/12/2023 16:51

You remind me of all the people who tell me ‘You’ll miss her when she’s gone, I’d give anything to have mine back, oh it’s not very nice to talk about her like that…’ when I mention my mum.

If my mum was like theirs, I probably would. She isn’t.

SutWytTi · 19/12/2023 16:50

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 16:47

So a lot of people have rightfully pointed out that going NC is hardly a new thing which is of course correct so to rephrase it's the reasoning behind going NC that I think has been taken too far. It just feels that these days the reasons for isolating a family member have become increasingly petty or small. Someones MIL isn't their cup of tea so now their children will never know their granny? I feel often the children in these situations never get considered as its always about mum or dad having a row with someone and then boom all of a sudden they go NC and extend it to their children who now are losing our on family and a support network

I don't think you've taken on board what has been said on this thread.

Do you think a life of petty arguments and toxic interactions is healthier?

PermanentTemporary · 19/12/2023 16:49

I do think low contact is hidden better in bigger families. My great grandmother was one of nine children, and inevitably in a family that big there were relationships that barely functioned, but you'd hardly notice in a group that size. It just becomes accepted that because X has gone to live in the Orkneys you don't see her any more.

It took me until I was about 40 to notice that one of my aunts and one of my uncles just didn't get on and you barely saw them at the same family events - perhaps once a decade. But because they were from a family of 5, so 10 with partners plus myriad children, nobody had to notice it.

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 16:49

youcandanceifyouwanna · 19/12/2023 16:47

Yes and no. Some people are escaping abuse etc and go no contact for understandable reasons. Sometimes seeing someone again can reopen old traumas especially if you know they will never change and it's best to walk away. However it is fairly common on MN to see replies diagnosing OPs relatives as narcissists or toxic, based solely on a one sided account of an emotionally charged disagreement. They will then advise the OP to go NC which is quite worrying.

Some situations I see on this site send shivers down my spine. The amount of encouragement to go NC over the most silly and petty things is devastating to witness 😔

OP posts:
adultchildofalcoholicparents · 19/12/2023 16:48

TheGreatGherkin · 19/12/2023 15:40

@Dotjones

Have you got a link or point me in the direction re 1600s murder rates? It's not something I know anything about.

Not a direct link to that but there are studies of murder maps.

The historian Laurence Stone calculated that homicide levels in medieval England were at least 10 times what they are today. Certainly, we cannot doubt that it was a dangerous time in which to live. An exceptional case, even by medieval standards, is provided by 14th‑century Oxford. Levels of violence there were considered unacceptably high by contemporaries: in the 1340s, the homicide rate was around 110 per 100,000. (In the UK in 2011, it was 1 per 100,000.)

https://www.historyextra.com/period/medieval/life-violence-middle-ages-murder-crime/

NB: I haven't checked the data analysis of any of these links or claims.

https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/medieval-murder-maps

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-05/murder-in-medieval-london-mapped

Medieval Murder Maps

How students made Oxford the murder capital of late medieval England

https://www.cam.ac.uk/stories/medieval-murder-maps

fitzwilliamdarcy · 19/12/2023 16:48

Family members who behave so badly that a person finds it easier to take the self-injurious route of cutting themselves off from their family don't tend to be receptive to "just working on it".

Otherwise we'd do that instead of, you know, cutting them off.

It isn't done on a whim. It isn't done because they're being a little bit overbearing, or perhaps a touch eccentric, or maybe a smidge thoughtless at times. It's because the person is inflicting or has inflicted physical or emotional harm, and shows no awareness of it or remorse for it.

I loathe threads like this because of course you don't understand why people go NC if you think that people go NC because of a bit of bad behaviour that can be sorted out over a nice cuppa.

Grapewrath · 19/12/2023 16:47

Yabvu
My mothers family hid sexual abuse and alcoholism under the guise ‘well we don’t need to talk about that’
They maintained superficial and damaging relationships with one another and lied to themselves about how much they loved each other. My own parents then felt they could do/say whatever they wanted and ‘we didn’t need to fall out’. They pretend my neglectful childhood didn’t happen and when I raised it accused me of being a trouble maker.
i am breaking that cycle and i am unapologetic about it. It should have happened generations ago.

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 16:47

So a lot of people have rightfully pointed out that going NC is hardly a new thing which is of course correct so to rephrase it's the reasoning behind going NC that I think has been taken too far. It just feels that these days the reasons for isolating a family member have become increasingly petty or small. Someones MIL isn't their cup of tea so now their children will never know their granny? I feel often the children in these situations never get considered as its always about mum or dad having a row with someone and then boom all of a sudden they go NC and extend it to their children who now are losing our on family and a support network

OP posts:
youcandanceifyouwanna · 19/12/2023 16:47

Yes and no. Some people are escaping abuse etc and go no contact for understandable reasons. Sometimes seeing someone again can reopen old traumas especially if you know they will never change and it's best to walk away. However it is fairly common on MN to see replies diagnosing OPs relatives as narcissists or toxic, based solely on a one sided account of an emotionally charged disagreement. They will then advise the OP to go NC which is quite worrying.

tokesqueen · 19/12/2023 16:44

You're wrong.
Poor behaviour needs consequences. My brother was a bully to myself and my parents growing up. They're now dead and I'm his only sibling. Too bad. You don't get rewarded with a sibling relationship for that. Weirdly, it's my way of coming out on top.

RocketDog101 · 19/12/2023 16:41

:)

RocketDog101 · 19/12/2023 16:40

Oh how life goes when only know the side of the 'apparent victim' eye roll families don't just walk away from other BLOOD relatives because they're bored or having a tiff, they walk away because they've had enough BS to last a life time and decide to break the cycle of toxicity! Very few fallings out are through petty happenings - I'd go as far to say that sometimes the most petty of reasons are just the thing to tilt a person over the edge to no contact.

Consider, your friend's son was willing to sever a relationship from his mother ONLY because of those few reasons you gave?! Nah, a family member who is otherwise secure and supported by their parent wouldn't do that (bar reasons of DA, and being issolated) unless there are underlying reasons.

I agree with a previous poster - you're either naive to how family's REALLY run; really believe family are everything even where their presence is toxic or, you are speaking from a place of privilege and have no idea what it's like to turn your back on those who are meant to have just that, your back/interests at heart/love you unconditionally.

I'm past wishing for what I never had, and wish well those who have 'normal' relationships (with typical disagreements ha) but my focus is using that energy I would be wasting trying to repair shit on my own family...and trying to help those who don't 'get it' that maybe the person they're friends with, isn't being completely honest as regards why they're not, umm, required 😉

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 19/12/2023 16:38

I agree with most PPs that there can be very good reasons.

However, this

People don't go NC for silly reasons

gives me pause for thought. In families, there is the phenomenon of the scapegoat child/family member. If you asked the family why they're not in touch with that family member, they'd come up with what would sound like "silly reasons" but they'd all have their roots in the scapegoat script. It's not unknown for the all parties to have no idea that that is why is happening, so what they're left with is what sounds like "silly reasons". (It's not just narcissist families but can be ones with addiction etc.)

https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-narcissist-in-your-life/202202/the-8-types-children-scapegoated-in-narcissistic-families

The 8 Types of Children Scapegoated in Narcissistic Families

4. Truth-tellers.

https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-narcissist-in-your-life/202202/the-8-types-children-scapegoated-in-narcissistic-families

MrTiddlesTheCat · 19/12/2023 16:34

(worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

This little gem tells us everything we need to know about why your DIL your friend's DIL went NC. Good on DIL, I hope she finds peace having broken away from her toxic MIL.

IdaPolly · 19/12/2023 16:34

If I had my time again I'd move far away from my mother and have minimal contact. I've been an absolute doormat to play happy families given how she treated me and my father. I hope young women now will have higher standards and self worth than I did.

cocog · 19/12/2023 16:33

If people want you in their lives they should treat you with respect and kindness. In most cases this is not done lightly but to protect yourself and your children from harm and abuse or toxic situations. I think people are more aware now that they don’t actually have to put up with awful people who bring nothing but negativity and or make them or their children feel awful every time they see them!

Charliebighamfan · 19/12/2023 16:32

You’re talking absolute bobbins OP!

Swipe left for the next trending thread