Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's such a shame that family bonds are being destroyed and going NC is becoming more and more common?

340 replies

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:21

Just that really. I might just be an old fart desperately yearning for the old days but I was raised to believe in the importance of having family around you and I find it horribly sad that so many people I know have family that haven't spoken to them for years.

Obviously in cases where some bad behavior has gone on it's understandable but surely there's nothing that can't be worked on? Going NC is so extreme and I think should be a last case resort if done at all.

OP posts:
Marblessolveeverything · 19/12/2023 18:47

So the woman was out of line and continued to be out three times. I seriously doubt these are isolated incidents.

I would go NC to avoid continuously being told what to do 😡

Honestly some women really think they have a right to control everyone and have no insight into boundaries.

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 18:47

Pinkpinkplonk · 19/12/2023 18:29

@PaperDoIIs 30 years ago I married into a family like this. My DH warned me from the beginning that we needed to stay away, I didn’t believe him! 30 years later, after much heartache we are NC. It took for my own children to ask me why I put up with PIL treatment of me. My youngest said, gma, why were you mean to mummy? To which my MIL replied “ don’t be so rude, I am the matriarch.” I still thought, it’s his mum. In the end I gave up. She still phones occasionally playing the victim, crying. Will tell everyone what an awful person I am.

It was awful as a child and a complete mindfuck. I couldn't stay away from the people I didn't like (for very good reasons) because they were family. Then when shit went down it was my fault for being too friendly. I was fucking told to!

Or not understanding why it was wrong to enjoy spending time with one set of cousins and their parents (I understood later and they were awful) and why we couldn't stay over or see them more but still went for x and y and everyone played happy families.

Lalalanding · 19/12/2023 18:46

Sparklfairy · 19/12/2023 18:23

I think people are often unable to manage conflict effectively. You see it here all the time 'I hate confrontation'. Nobody enjoys confrontation but effective conflict management skills can mean that family members can set boundaries and everyone could then get along.

As it is, boundaries are not set, or are weak, and people can't cope when family members are 'mean' so go NC because they don't have the appropriate skills to stand up for themselves.

This isn't all cases, but many. So many people are conflict avoidant to the point that they'd rather sever a relationship completely than get to the point where others knew they couldn't get away with treating them badly, so don't.

Where do people learn these skills though? People typically learn how to manage conflict, or how not to manage conflict, in families. And what happens when one member goes out into the world and learns about managing conflict but the others don’t. The biggest issue in my DH’s family is the complete intolerance for boundaries of any kind. FIL was wildly physically abusive, MIL is extremely codependent. Family members railroad any attempts at heathy interactions and are massively resistant to any boundaries.

PhulNana · 19/12/2023 18:46

I always say 'walk a mile in someone's shoes before criticising them'. That way, they're a mile away when you do, and you've got their shoes.

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 18:42

Sparklfairy · 19/12/2023 18:23

I think people are often unable to manage conflict effectively. You see it here all the time 'I hate confrontation'. Nobody enjoys confrontation but effective conflict management skills can mean that family members can set boundaries and everyone could then get along.

As it is, boundaries are not set, or are weak, and people can't cope when family members are 'mean' so go NC because they don't have the appropriate skills to stand up for themselves.

This isn't all cases, but many. So many people are conflict avoidant to the point that they'd rather sever a relationship completely than get to the point where others knew they couldn't get away with treating them badly, so don't.

Absolutely bullshit. That only works when the other family members are willing to listen and respect those boundaries. The vast majority of people going NC do so because there is a refusal to listen and respect boundaries.

You can't do conflict resolution with selfish people, with people that always play the victim, with people that always put themselves first. Because they don't govern a shit and it's all about what they want and when they want it and the minute you stand firm you're the bullying,horrible one. So you have three options 1.shut up and put up 2. deal with huge amounts of drama or 3.go NC because what's the fucking point?

JanefromLondon1 · 19/12/2023 18:41

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

HelenaHandcart · 19/12/2023 18:38

It kills me to not have anyone to call family anymore - but seeing as most of my immediate family think I should be killed for leaving their religion. I think I'll take dying of sadness over the alternative, thanks!

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 19/12/2023 18:34

forming your views did you consider that by going NC with a parent you are forgoing one of the only sources of unconditional love in your life and might also have to cut out family members you adore in case your abusive family member uses them as leverage/takes it out on them?

Tell me that you don't understand that there are people who've never had parents (or family) capable of unconditional love without saying it…

And, yes, if you've grown up in a seriously dysfunctional family, you understand the consequences at an early age. Look at the advice for women who are leaving their husbands/partners to not only take their children with them but any family pets for fear of retribution on the pets. It's such a common concern that refuges have Pet Fostering projects associated with them.

In a home where abuse is happening, pets are at real risk. Most refuges and hostels can’t take animals, but our Pet Foster Project can help.
The Pet Foster Project is a vital part of the jigsaw for women, providing a safe place for their pets to be housed temporarily so they can flee abuse and go into refuge or other emergency accommodation.

https://junowomensaid.org.uk/pet-foster-project/

Pet Foster Project - JUNO Women's Aid

help for all your family including your pets Pet Foster Project In a home where abuse is happening, pets are at real risk. Most refuges and hostels can’t take animals, but our Pet Foster Project can help. The Pet Foster Project is a vital part of the j...

https://junowomensaid.org.uk/pet-foster-project

WowIlikereallyhateyou · 19/12/2023 18:33

Comtesse · 19/12/2023 15:24

I think you should walk a mile in someone else’s shoes before sitting in judgement about how other people live their own lives.

Correct.

TheRealProfessorYaffle · 19/12/2023 18:33

OP, I am interested that you appear to be minimising and denying information that runs counter to your argument (that people really go no contact for minimal reasons). I'm also interested in how you presented your story about your dear friend. I wonder what made you hear that story so uncritically and readily. I wonder if you find it easier to notice posts that support your hypothesis and reject posts that show people to really agitate to come to a decision to reduce contact. I wonder how that bias serves you, and what it means about your own relationships. I wonder if you have some experience of this and feel too shamed about this to be open, but instead are looking for indirect validation that you are right, that other people are the problem.

As a middle aged survivor of a very difficult childhood, my siblings and I have all had significant mental health challenges. Two feel suicidal, decades later. We are all still in contact, and two of us talk frequently about how we wish our surviving parent was dead so that we can finally start putting our childhood behind us. We weren't sexually abused. We weren't hit more than typical for culture and era. How bad does it need to be for you to not minimise the impact of a damaging relationship? Why are you invested in this?

Just some thoughts.

JenniferJuniper80 · 19/12/2023 18:30

Im 60+, so possibly an 'older' old fart than you.
I'm sorry you feel your need to play happy families is more important than my familarul abuse.

My parents 'fell out' with my brother in the 1980's then got upset that he didn't fall over backwards to make up with them. (He did nothing wrong, but oh well)
I eventually fell out with the old cow that's my mum in the early 2000's

We don't all live in a Disney movie.

Pinkpinkplonk · 19/12/2023 18:29

@PaperDoIIs 30 years ago I married into a family like this. My DH warned me from the beginning that we needed to stay away, I didn’t believe him! 30 years later, after much heartache we are NC. It took for my own children to ask me why I put up with PIL treatment of me. My youngest said, gma, why were you mean to mummy? To which my MIL replied “ don’t be so rude, I am the matriarch.” I still thought, it’s his mum. In the end I gave up. She still phones occasionally playing the victim, crying. Will tell everyone what an awful person I am.

IncompleteSenten · 19/12/2023 18:29

Life is too short to waste on people who treat you badly and being related to someone shouldn't mean you accept being treated like crap because faaaaaaaamileeeeee

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 18:27

Sparklfairy · 19/12/2023 18:23

I think people are often unable to manage conflict effectively. You see it here all the time 'I hate confrontation'. Nobody enjoys confrontation but effective conflict management skills can mean that family members can set boundaries and everyone could then get along.

As it is, boundaries are not set, or are weak, and people can't cope when family members are 'mean' so go NC because they don't have the appropriate skills to stand up for themselves.

This isn't all cases, but many. So many people are conflict avoidant to the point that they'd rather sever a relationship completely than get to the point where others knew they couldn't get away with treating them badly, so don't.

I think you've hit the nail on the head there.

OP posts:
CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 19/12/2023 18:24

OP, I’ve tried to go NC after years of physical and mental abuse that have left me absolutely crippled with MH issues. The decision to go NC is sometimes used as a tactic in arguments between generations (“I’ll never speak to you again, you’re so mean”) but in forming your views did you consider that by going NC with a parent you are forgoing one of the only sources of unconditional love in your life and might also have to cut out family members you adore in case your abusive family member uses them as leverage/takes it out on them? The first time I cut out my mother (committed GBH on my father, daily verbal abuse towards all of us, literally stalked me after I cut her off) I visited my maternal grandparents and my nana was literally too afraid to talk to me because of the daily campaign of shouting which had just transferred to her.

People with what you call trivial reasons will either be the problem themselves, in which case going NC or LC is the best thing, or it’ll be the straw that broke the camel’s back or they won’t want to share the more horrible things for various reasons.

I have much more mixed feelings about the advice to LTB over playing his harmonica too much or something, but you can’t just get new parents. Going NC is a serious matter. Even a significant minority of those advised to do it probably won’t.

Sparklfairy · 19/12/2023 18:23

I think people are often unable to manage conflict effectively. You see it here all the time 'I hate confrontation'. Nobody enjoys confrontation but effective conflict management skills can mean that family members can set boundaries and everyone could then get along.

As it is, boundaries are not set, or are weak, and people can't cope when family members are 'mean' so go NC because they don't have the appropriate skills to stand up for themselves.

This isn't all cases, but many. So many people are conflict avoidant to the point that they'd rather sever a relationship completely than get to the point where others knew they couldn't get away with treating them badly, so don't.

DeeCeeCherry · 19/12/2023 18:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Lalalanding · 19/12/2023 18:21

I think @Newbutoldfather is very likely deluded about the scale of the instances of what he considers to be appropriate reasons to cut off family. Sexual abuse within families is endemic, people delude themselves it is rare for their own comfort reasons but it is actually a huge problem. I presume that is an allowable reason. Addiction is common, coercive control is common, psychological abuse and manipulation are common. The instances where people should cut off family are as common as the number of people who cut off family because significant dysfunction is not rare in families.

KnowThyself · 19/12/2023 18:21

@Vegetus Same here but it is an online forum which means that the overall percentage of people with issues will be higher than average. See the I never answer the door threads and I have zero friends threads. Whilst it is their lived experience and those experiences exist and are valid it’s very much the minority.

DPotter · 19/12/2023 18:21

I think you're looking back in hindsight with rose tinted spectacles.

avocadotofu · 19/12/2023 18:20

Changingplace · 19/12/2023 15:23

I think it’s sadder that in the past people felt that had to put up with all sorts of unacceptable behaviour from family or partners just because it was frowned upon to cut ties/get divorced.

Absolutely this! I totally disagree OP! I don't see why you should have to see people that make you miserable just because they're family.

PossumintheHouse · 19/12/2023 18:15

Newbutoldfather · 19/12/2023 17:59

I think going NC is pretty selfish and cowardly. Of course there are exceptions, but they are relatively few.

The vast majority on here who go NC is with elderly parents whom they no longer need and find annoying and an interfering. Ultimately just restricting contact to the polite minimum and having strong boundaries I’m conversation will do the same. Job without being hurtful.

If course the above does not apply to parents who were abusive (in the old fashioned sense of the word) or genuinely deliberately cruel.

Relatively few exceptions? That just isn’t true.
A large majority of people who choose to go no contact with their parents/close family members won’t ever tell you the full extent as to what they are going NC for. I’d wager that even a number of people on MN who go NC for what you perceive as ‘selfish’ reasons aren’t divulging the whole story. It’s often horrible to type out why, let alone talk about it.

AmazingDayz · 19/12/2023 18:14

Nothing? What about abuse?

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 18:11

I'm from a country where family ties are important as fuck. It's also dysfunctional and toxic as fuck. Years and years of hate , despising each other,jealousy, abusive and fucked up behaviours, backstabbing,gossip,duty and bullshit. Then all nicey nicey at the big gatherings,kiss kiss ,aren't you lovely, family is sooo important, we're family darling.

What's the fucking point?

Angrycat2768 · 19/12/2023 18:09

sprigatito · 19/12/2023 15:59

Yeah, I'd really like to hear the DIL's version of that story.

Agree. She sounds like a massive interfering PITA, and that's just from what she told you. I can imagine there is much more to that particular story. ;Innocently; demanding to turn up to hospital when she wasnt wanted and 'innocelntly' undermining a mother trying to breastfeed her baby. Poor breastfeeding support and pressurising mothers into saying getting breastfed babies to conform to feeding schedules and weight guidelines designed for formula fed babies is a major reason for mothers stopping breastfeeding, making them feel like failures.