Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's such a shame that family bonds are being destroyed and going NC is becoming more and more common?

340 replies

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:21

Just that really. I might just be an old fart desperately yearning for the old days but I was raised to believe in the importance of having family around you and I find it horribly sad that so many people I know have family that haven't spoken to them for years.

Obviously in cases where some bad behavior has gone on it's understandable but surely there's nothing that can't be worked on? Going NC is so extreme and I think should be a last case resort if done at all.

OP posts:
Neitheronethingnortheother · 19/12/2023 19:29

wannabetraveler · 19/12/2023 19:05

I completely agree.

I remember one particularly batshit post where a mother was advised to "go NC" with grandparents because the grandchild had had a fall (I think) so they took them to be checked out by a doctor. Posters were frothing at the mouth that the grandparents had taken child in without the "consent" of the mother.

Jeez, if one of my clumsy kids took a tumble and my inlaws sought medical advice I'd be grateful beyond words!

If I remember rightly the grandparents took the child to the hospital, didn't tell the parents and then just casually told them when they picked the child up later

Now I wouldn't necessarily say that's an immediate NC type event. But nevertheless there is a massive disregard for the parents in that situation who have a right to know their child is in hospital. Yes by all means take the child first, but then as soon as you are waiting in the waiting room then calm the parents because besides anything else the parents should be making the medical decisions.

And if the grandparents are that casual about cutting the parents out of important issues and disregarding them as parents then there are probably plenty of other boundaries being crossed. Which is where you get to a NC situation with the constant erosion of boundaries and undermining of your position as the adult and the parent in that situation.

My nephew lives with me. But even so if he went to hospital literally the first thing I would do is pick up the phone to his parents because they have the right to know and because its the right thing to do.

Would you actually be happy if you had a young child who was upset about falling over and going to hospital and you didn't get to look after them and reassure them because no one told you thry were there?

DyslexicPoster · 19/12/2023 19:27

I think if you've never been abused it's beyound most people's comprehension.

I was kicked and punched at full force repeatedly in a rage. Lots of people have minimised that down to nothing.

But I wonder if I kicked and punched my 6 year old until I stopped because my arms hurt, would it be OK?

You see, it's not OK to kick my dd in the head. Everyone knows that. But go back 40 years and it would have been OK, normal, routine part of childhood. Or would it?

Sometimes, to stop the cycle of abuse, you need to step out of that cycle. Wouldn't you agree?

Kicking and punching a child was at one point completely normal to me. Something that every parent did. I let my mum around my kids, let her hit them, let them her verbally abuse them as it was normal. We was the scum. Is that OK?

Not brave enough to go NC. Reinforced by mil I must have deserved it. Reinforced that couldn't have been that bad. Even dh didn't seem that shocked. He was also happy to have his kids around my mum.

Because, people pleasers

Xmastime2023 · 19/12/2023 19:24

I think people are better at putting boundaries in place and not putting up with them being trampled over - more NC I say!

MondayBags678 · 19/12/2023 19:16

I think the opposite! Why’s it sad?
why should someone have to put up with bad behaviour abuse and bullying by any one! Regardless of if they are blood related or not! Family or not if someone abuses you or has no respect for you and treats people badly then why should family be any different they deserve to be cut off!

NumberTheory · 19/12/2023 19:14

I don’t think there’s any evidence it’s more common now. Lots of my friends have grandparents or uncles etc. who their parents aren’t in contact with. Where do you think the “long lost cousins” of stories past come from? The stories of people dying on their own in squalor and then the children turn up? It’s always gone on. Some people do not get on and there is little to be gained from staying in touch.

Zevitevitchofcrimas · 19/12/2023 19:12

"where finally relented"

What language to use!! Relented... Gave in... Listened to her betters older and wiser..

I'm absolutely sick of seeing posts by pregnant woman about to give birth in absolute turmoil about a mil "helpfully" coming to visit knowing that mil whose never ever been helpful will sit around being waited on, holding a baby, demanding it should be bottle fed whilst a new mum hobbles around trying to please her...

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 19:11

Socksforxmas · 19/12/2023 19:07

I think it's unreasonable to put such importance on the idea of 'blood family' in almost 2024.

However I agree that mumsnet is a hotbed of encouraging NC over the most ridiculous things. And the posts on this thread that seem to be suggesting that going NC is always justified? Probably in the majority of cases but you're being wilfully obtuse to believe that in every single one of these cases it's deserved.

I've worked in care homes most of my adult life and the amount of adult DC who simply just can't be arsed with their elderly parents anymore and ghost them completely is horrible. Going NC isn't always a 'hard and devastating decision not taken lightly' but sometimes is just what's most convenient for people.

Do you know the full background of all these relationships or is it simply how it looks ?

Ladyj84 · 19/12/2023 19:10

Don't think poster is being judgemental at all for all those jumping onto abuse. I'm not old and come from a huge family and friends and love it, supporting,helping and being there each other thru good and bad like it used to be. Now regarding abuse yes been there and totally different subject you can stand up and walk out easier now and not stand for it. Also cutting off some who have either done something dreadful or are completely detrimental to keeping peace and harmony then that's fine also. Gotta couple of those aswell but it doesn't stop the good bunch enjoying togetherness

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 19:08

wannabetraveler · 19/12/2023 18:59

I've no idea whether NC is more common nowadays, but when I read some posts on here advising people to cut off their family, or asking advice about the same, I'm often struck by how uncompromising many people are. Lamenting other people's poor behavior sometimes, but being incredibly unforgiving of what often seem to be relatively benign transgressions.

Those transgressions are rarely on a clean slate though. That's the problem. In the vast majority of cases they're the cherry on a shit cake full of abuse and neglect.

I'm not NC with my mother. I wish I was,but I can't. Each of the arguments we have now are petty and ridiculous on their own. They could very well be the last one if I had it in me. But that stupid comment/argument is on top of emotional abuse, beatings (I still have an unhealed fracture on my toes -yes plural- from her slamming the door on my foot in an attempt to kick me out at 11) , knowingly sending me to a child abuser because she thought I was too fat for him to be interested and many other things.

Socksforxmas · 19/12/2023 19:07

I think it's unreasonable to put such importance on the idea of 'blood family' in almost 2024.

However I agree that mumsnet is a hotbed of encouraging NC over the most ridiculous things. And the posts on this thread that seem to be suggesting that going NC is always justified? Probably in the majority of cases but you're being wilfully obtuse to believe that in every single one of these cases it's deserved.

I've worked in care homes most of my adult life and the amount of adult DC who simply just can't be arsed with their elderly parents anymore and ghost them completely is horrible. Going NC isn't always a 'hard and devastating decision not taken lightly' but sometimes is just what's most convenient for people.

LisaD1 · 19/12/2023 19:06

My mother was a narcissist with a forked tongue and my father tried to rape me. But yeah me going NC is the saddest part of that.

wannabetraveler · 19/12/2023 19:05

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 16:47

So a lot of people have rightfully pointed out that going NC is hardly a new thing which is of course correct so to rephrase it's the reasoning behind going NC that I think has been taken too far. It just feels that these days the reasons for isolating a family member have become increasingly petty or small. Someones MIL isn't their cup of tea so now their children will never know their granny? I feel often the children in these situations never get considered as its always about mum or dad having a row with someone and then boom all of a sudden they go NC and extend it to their children who now are losing our on family and a support network

I completely agree.

I remember one particularly batshit post where a mother was advised to "go NC" with grandparents because the grandchild had had a fall (I think) so they took them to be checked out by a doctor. Posters were frothing at the mouth that the grandparents had taken child in without the "consent" of the mother.

Jeez, if one of my clumsy kids took a tumble and my inlaws sought medical advice I'd be grateful beyond words!

MintJulia · 19/12/2023 19:04

OP, putting aside all the individual rights and wrongs of different cases, the basic ability to walk away does much to stop people killing each other.

If we all lived by your weird nostalgic ideas, the domestic murder rate would be far higher - and it is already far too high.

Nanny0gg · 19/12/2023 19:04

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:21

Just that really. I might just be an old fart desperately yearning for the old days but I was raised to believe in the importance of having family around you and I find it horribly sad that so many people I know have family that haven't spoken to them for years.

Obviously in cases where some bad behavior has gone on it's understandable but surely there's nothing that can't be worked on? Going NC is so extreme and I think should be a last case resort if done at all.

Dunno. If you knew the ridiculous reason we were cut off then maybe you could explain it to me. Clearly they didn't want any of us to do the 'work'

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 19/12/2023 19:04

I think we’ve managed to get slightly the wrong end of the stick on both side @adultchildofalcoholicparents! thanks for your response. I do agree with you and think that NC is often the best option, my point was more that it’s a difficult option that really hurts and is often quite logistically difficult.

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 19/12/2023 19:02

wannabetraveler · 19/12/2023 18:59

I've no idea whether NC is more common nowadays, but when I read some posts on here advising people to cut off their family, or asking advice about the same, I'm often struck by how uncompromising many people are. Lamenting other people's poor behavior sometimes, but being incredibly unforgiving of what often seem to be relatively benign transgressions.

It was never about the dishes by the sink.

https://matthewfray.com/2016/01/14/she-divorced-me-because-i-left-dishes-by-the-sink/

She Divorced Me Because I Left Dishes by the Sink – Matthew Fray

https://matthewfray.com/2016/01/14/she-divorced-me-because-i-left-dishes-by-the-sink

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 19/12/2023 19:00

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 19/12/2023 18:49

@adultchildofalcoholicparents I know you were quoting me, and I misspoke - I meant they are the people who are supposed to provide unconditional love. I know all too well the feeling when you need someone who is there no matter what and sticks with you. It breaks your heart. The point I was trying to make was that humans - even animals actually - are supposed to have parents they can fall back on and if they turn out to hurt you instead of helping you that doesn’t make it easier to cut them out.

I agree with you that it doesn't make it straightforward although it can be life saving to do so.

It's not all about parents and children but I was struck by this recent write-up of ostracism and families | friends | online.

Williams believes that being on the receiving end of silence is so distressing because it threatens all our human needs after the basics of food, shelter and safety have been met. This concept of a pyramid of needs was introduced in the 1950s by the psychologist Abraham Maslow, who said the higher needs included the need to belong and have social connections, the need to feel good about yourself, and the need to feel that your existence is meaningful.
In his own research, published in the journal Science in 2003, Williams and colleagues identified that when someone is ostracised, the same areas of the brain are triggered as when experiencing physical pain. They also conducted an experiment giving participants painkillers to see if feelings of rejection could be treated in the same way as physical agony and found that it could. This was backed up by MRI brain scans.
“If you get into a fight with someone, that’s not great but at least you are still connected, you are acknowledging each other,” he says. “You can demonstrate competence by winning the fight. Ostracism can be more distressing because it’s taking away all of your needs.”

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/dec/12/the-silent-treatment-one-woman-was-ostracised-by-her-husband-for-40-years

I know this sounds like NC but IME it's not unusual for an entire family to ostracise 1 or 2 members and to support each other in that ostracism and police it. Under those circumstances, painful as it can be, NC can be the lesser of several evils. And it can be easier for other members to ostracise a scapegoat than run the risk of being ostracised from that dysfunctional family | friendship group themselves.

The silent treatment: ‘One woman was ostracised by her husband for 40 years’

To be frozen out by family, friends or online can feel as bad as physical pain. We speak to those on the receiving end – and those who mete it out

https://www.theguardian.com/science/2023/dec/12/the-silent-treatment-one-woman-was-ostracised-by-her-husband-for-40-years

wannabetraveler · 19/12/2023 18:59

I've no idea whether NC is more common nowadays, but when I read some posts on here advising people to cut off their family, or asking advice about the same, I'm often struck by how uncompromising many people are. Lamenting other people's poor behavior sometimes, but being incredibly unforgiving of what often seem to be relatively benign transgressions.

Pinkpinkplonk · 19/12/2023 18:56

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 18:47

It was awful as a child and a complete mindfuck. I couldn't stay away from the people I didn't like (for very good reasons) because they were family. Then when shit went down it was my fault for being too friendly. I was fucking told to!

Or not understanding why it was wrong to enjoy spending time with one set of cousins and their parents (I understood later and they were awful) and why we couldn't stay over or see them more but still went for x and y and everyone played happy families.

I totally sympathise.
My guilt comes from not understanding those families.I forced my own children into those relationships for 15 years, til the penny dropped, and actually they were old enough to recognise the toxicity.
When we went NC the fallout was huge! But my husband said, he finally has his long awaited peace. And we’ve broken the cycle!

PaperDoIIs · 19/12/2023 18:55

@PinotViogner please enlighten me.

How would you solve these issues?

Your MIL steals all your wedding gift money and takes your SIL shopping and blows the lot.

Your cousin's husband makes up lies and accusations about you that could not only lose you your job,but get you court martialed.

A family member hires a PI to find your child's biological parents against your wishes,purely for gossip.

A family member says you let your husband die/killed him.

None of these are actually abusive or what you consider "that bad". Never mind years of abuse (emotional,physical, sexual,financial) or neglect.

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 19/12/2023 18:53

Iamtheelephantintheroom · 19/12/2023 18:49

To all those who went NC with a family member.
If that family member genuinely doesn't know what they've done.
They have apologised for anything they can think of.
They have asked if the other person can offer their side of what happened.
If the family member has not pushed it because of respecting boundaries and doesn't want to involve flying monkeys.
At what point can there ever be hope of reconciliation or is the relationship stone dead after four years of NC?

This doesn't discuss all circumstances but it gives some starting points as to why this might be true: Missing Missing reasons

https://www.issendai.com/psychology/estrangement/missing-missing-reasons.html

The Missing Missing Reasons | Issendai.com

Members of estranged parents' forums often say their children never gave them any reason for the estrangement, then turn around and reveal that their children did tell them why. But the reasons their children give—the infamous missing reasons—are missi...

https://www.issendai.com/psychology/estrangement/missing-missing-reasons.html

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 19/12/2023 18:49

@adultchildofalcoholicparents I know you were quoting me, and I misspoke - I meant they are the people who are supposed to provide unconditional love. I know all too well the feeling when you need someone who is there no matter what and sticks with you. It breaks your heart. The point I was trying to make was that humans - even animals actually - are supposed to have parents they can fall back on and if they turn out to hurt you instead of helping you that doesn’t make it easier to cut them out.

Iamtheelephantintheroom · 19/12/2023 18:49

To all those who went NC with a family member.
If that family member genuinely doesn't know what they've done.
They have apologised for anything they can think of.
They have asked if the other person can offer their side of what happened.
If the family member has not pushed it because of respecting boundaries and doesn't want to involve flying monkeys.
At what point can there ever be hope of reconciliation or is the relationship stone dead after four years of NC?

MintJulia · 19/12/2023 18:48

OP, you have to be kidding.

I was raised in a house where my father rejected the education of women. Who believed we are simple domestic functionaries. Who did everything he could, our whole childhoods, to undermine and deprive and restrict and belittle us. To make us believe we were and would always be useless and valueless.

Going NC was a joy, an escape, an indescribable relief. Being rid of him and being under no obligation to put up with such bigoted nonsense ever again is the best thing that was ever invented. It is one of the most important freedoms we have - it's called free will.

FrannieSaid · 19/12/2023 18:48

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 16:49

Some situations I see on this site send shivers down my spine. The amount of encouragement to go NC over the most silly and petty things is devastating to witness 😔

Yeah, not going to get absolved for the shit you've done, and are trying to convince yourself is "silly and petty" here. There's ALWAYS a more damming pattern to the example given.

Take a HARD look, and maybe you'll come around to being devastated at what was accepted, and stop trying to foist that abuse onto others, because you had fewer choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread