Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's such a shame that family bonds are being destroyed and going NC is becoming more and more common?

340 replies

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:21

Just that really. I might just be an old fart desperately yearning for the old days but I was raised to believe in the importance of having family around you and I find it horribly sad that so many people I know have family that haven't spoken to them for years.

Obviously in cases where some bad behavior has gone on it's understandable but surely there's nothing that can't be worked on? Going NC is so extreme and I think should be a last case resort if done at all.

OP posts:
SutWytTi · 19/12/2023 16:11

they won’t say how they’ve emotionally abused said son for years as they don’t see it as anything wrong This is a major part of the issue.

Parent does/says xyz upsetting thing.
Child says 'please don't do/say that, it really upsets me'
Parent says 'oh, we didn't mean any harm'
Cycle repeats over and over.

Infusedwithfigandhoney · 19/12/2023 16:10

If PIL had been one of the toxic variety I read so much about on mumsnet then I might understand it. In fact, they are really not. I had a great relationship with them from the start and considered myself very lucky I had the ideal MIL - supportive without being interfering, always kind, always welcoming. Clearly former SIL saw it differently. But abusive? Never, ever.

Not abusive to you doesn't mean they weren't abusive to her.
My relative was smiley, happy salt of the earth to everyone out of our house.
Classic Street Angel/ House Devil
No one would believe the utter demon of rage, violence and abuse heaped on us .
That's how they operate and get away with it.

Gallowayan · 19/12/2023 16:10

Not sure it is more common - do you have evidence for this? Plenty of people went 'no contact' before the expression began trending on forums like this.

Mumsnet has quite rightly validated the practice of separating your own life from that deeply unpleasant family. members who are never going to change.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 19/12/2023 16:09

YABU. People don't cut ties for no reason.

ComputerStick · 19/12/2023 16:09

Yeh your friend isn’t going to tell her friends what she actually did to get cut off.
my mil will tell everyone her dil is a shit and stoping poor son from contacting, they won’t say how they’ve emotionally abused said son for years as they don’t see it as anything wrong

SutWytTi · 19/12/2023 16:08

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

You only have one side of this story.

I think YABVVVVU to be so judgmental about people who have family difficulties. Xmas Biscuit for you.

uclpp · 19/12/2023 16:07

OP you say there’s nothing that can’t be worked on - well, that’s true, but have you considered that abusers don’t actually want to work on not being abusive?

TooTender · 19/12/2023 16:04

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

I think with things like this you have to accept you’re only getting your friend’s version of events.

Of course she will say she only offered a few well intentioned suggestions, but it’s also possible she consistently crossed boundaries and wasn’t willing to accept that her own behaviour was problematic when told by her son and DIL.

Going NC is a hard decision and I think it is almost always a last resort. But the person whose behaviour is the problem is unlikely to see it that way if they aren’t willing to face up to their own flaws.

Stompythedinosaur · 19/12/2023 16:04

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

Come on, op, does it seem likely that a perfectly helpful and nice relative would be cut out in this way?

I suspect your friend is not telling the truth.

I don't think going nc is at all common, so when it happens, it happens for a reason.

FuckingHellAdele · 19/12/2023 16:04

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

That explains why the DIL is no contact. What about her son/daughter, you know her actual child- are they NC also?

Bookworm1111 · 19/12/2023 16:04

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

You are naive if you think that's the only reason they went NC. People usually do it after years of having their boundaries trampled over. Guaranteed this would've been the tipping point for them to go NC, not the start.

RedToothBrush · 19/12/2023 16:04

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

'a dear friend'.

5foot5 · 19/12/2023 16:03

People don't go NC for silly reasons. They go NC after years of abuse, either physical, emotional, sexual.

Well in general you would suppose so. Certainly reading some of the shocking and heartbreaking experiences described by other posters on this thread it is easy to see why NC is the best solution for many people.

However, the only case of NC that I have had direct experience of was for none of these reasons. Nearly 30 years ago SIL (DH's brother's wife) fell out with the rest of ILs for various difficult to understand reasons and insisted her DH choose between her and his birth family. He chose his wife and son. Sure enough there has been no contact since, MIL is now dead and FIL in his 90s.

If PIL had been one of the toxic variety I read so much about on mumsnet then I might understand it. In fact, they are really not. I had a great relationship with them from the start and considered myself very lucky I had the ideal MIL - supportive without being interfering, always kind, always welcoming. Clearly former SIL saw it differently. But abusive? Never, ever.

Mumof2teens79 · 19/12/2023 16:03

I am not overly set on the importance of family but people in general just seem to be very unforgiving, refusing to accept anyone's imperfections and cutting ties very quickly.

uclpp · 19/12/2023 16:02

Being related by blood isn’t a licence to abuse someone, OP. It’s good that people can make reasonable choices these days, rather than being forced by society to spend time with cruel relatives.

Most people who have gone NC have endured years of abuse and nastiness - you don’t go NC because a family member didn’t like your new wallpaper.

You are lucky not to have experienced a close family member abusing you - you clearly do not understand what some of us have tolerated for decades and finally cut ties. Count yourself lucky and don’t sit in judgement about something you very clearly don’t understand.

LemonLight · 19/12/2023 16:02

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

There's definitely another side to the story. Do you not think you might be a bit biased? Or your friend perhaps isn't being entirely forthcoming about what lead to the relationship breakdown.

RedToothBrush · 19/12/2023 16:02

My great great grandfather used to knock his wife about. There's a couple of newspaper articles about it. Eventually on of the sons seems to have stepped in and thrown his Dad out. This is about 1895 ish.

The couple were originally from Dublin and moved to Scotland.

After the father was thrown out he returned to Dublin and died in the workhouse. Alone. It looks like the whole family went no contact.

It looks like the violence in the home was normalised and accepted for the most part. No one did anything. But several of the daughters married and moved to Canada and don't appear to have stayed in touch.

My feeling from researching mine and DHs family is that going no contact wasn't uncommon - immigration certainly was common. But domestic abuse certainly was more tolerated. And it was also harder to leave. One relative of mine was a city missionary so worked to try and help people in absolutely desperate situations. The stories are utterly appalling to read.

And then there's the murder in DHs family of an aunt. It's a proper gruesome job - from about 1870ish. Woman had her throat slashed from ear to ear. And sadly it seems it wasn't hugely uncommon. She was blamed for it in the press though the husband was eventually hung.

So id question if we really did have more No contact. Larger families made it easier to just go and do you own thing to an extent. Emigration meant you would never see your family again. Prostitution was more prevalent. Violence was more tolerated and when that violence went too far, murders were more typical.

No contact is really the softest edge of all that in a world where we are almost unable to escape 24/7 contact.

Chimmo · 19/12/2023 16:02

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

And did you get the dil side from all this? My mother probably says all sorts about why we don’t speak.

mrssunshinexxx · 19/12/2023 16:01

You are so naive op to think that 'most things can be worked on'

SwearyBetty · 19/12/2023 16:01

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

Have you heard the DIL’s side of the story?

queenatom · 19/12/2023 16:00

@PinotViogner has your friend tried apologising to her DIL for the things she said?

sprigatito · 19/12/2023 15:59

PinotViogner · 19/12/2023 15:58

So I (wrongfully) assumed that it went without saying that obviously when it comes to things like SA it is of course fine to go NC over that. When we're talking about literal crimes and serious abuse situations then I support anyone who chooses to leave.

I was referring more to some of the really petty reasons people have been using these days. It just seems that in my experience it takes so little for someone to immediately be forbidden contact.

As an example, a dear friend of mine in her 60s has only met her grandson twice as she apparently 'crossed boundaries' set by her dil by 1) asking to visit baby in hospital after birth 2)offering to stay over and help out as dil had a very difficult labour and was physically unable to get around much afterwards and 3) suggesting that maybe switching to formula would be beneficial for baby and would take the stress away from dil (worth noting that dils insistence on breastfeeding caused the baby to end up underweight before she finally relented).

She was just trying to be helpful during a stressful time and now has a grandchild she never sees and it absolutely kills her. This is the kind of stuff I think is getting out of hand.

Yeah, I'd really like to hear the DIL's version of that story.

Infusedwithfigandhoney · 19/12/2023 15:59

Comtesse · 19/12/2023 15:24

I think you should walk a mile in someone else’s shoes before sitting in judgement about how other people live their own lives.

Absolutely this.
Nice up there on your smug tower of " nice family" OP?
People usually go through heart breaking trauma and abuse before going NC so stop minimising their pain.
I stopped generations of abuse by putting my DC first .
This was after threats to kill, knife in hand in front of them so FO .
Yabvvvu

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:59

Honestly I'd prefer people felt able to cut toxic family out of their life if they felt they needed to than that they slogged on with people in their lives who made them feel like shit.

Bonds are important, but I have never understood the logic that blood family takes automatic precedence over family you create yourself and friends.

Family can a lifeblood but it can also be something which massively holds people back from achieving their potential if its not a supportive family. Good family are absolutely worth keeping in touch with but I don't think you should have to maintain contact with people purely because they are related to you, no.

Torganer · 19/12/2023 15:58

@PinotViogner I think you need to think about what you’ve done to make your family go no contact with you. People don’t just do it for silly reasons. Was it an argument or an ongoing issue?

Swipe left for the next trending thread