Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or does anyone else get tired of the way men treat women's home-based jobs as if they aren't real?

136 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:19

Does anyone else have this? I WFH two or three days a week, have done for years, have a home office. I feel like whenever I interact with men (and sorry but it is usually men) in the course of my working day they treat my job as if it's a joke and something I can just drop at any minute. Little things, but these three things happened to me yesterday and I'm 90% sure they wouldn't have happened to a bloke.

Having work done on my house: I had a plasterer round to do a job. When I spoke to him last week to arrange it I said Monday is good but please can you try not to arrive between 10 and 11.30am as I'm on a work call which I can't step away from. All good, he says, he'll be here by 9.30am latest. He tips up at 10.30am and knocks on the doorbell. I'm leading a call with about 15 people and have to get up to let him in which is embarrassing and awkward for my junior team.

I'm irritated but I get that you can't always control the arrival time in heavy traffic so I don't get pissed off with him, but he doesn't apologise for the timing and starts yammering on to me in excruciating detail about what he's going to do when we've already had this conversation. I then make my excuses and say if you're going out to your van can you leave the door on the latch because I can't get away again. 15 minutes later he does exactly the same thing, rings the doorbell, drags me off the same call and then drags me down into the kitchen to talk about what he's going to do.

A bit later my ex husband calls to speak to my DD (he's overseas at the moment) and insists on putting me on the phone to his mother (who I still get on well with) for a chinwag. I tell him I'll call back after I've finished work. "But you work from home," he says. "You can talk to my mum for a minute." I say no, call after work hours. He calls back half an hour later (11.30ish) and puts his mum straight on to me without checking if I'm free. It's embarrassing telling an elderly woman who I hardly see that I don't have time to talk to her so I have to spend 10 minute chewing the fat when I'm frantically busy.

Later still the dad of a friend of my DD calls me to say he's going to be late back from work and can the friend come back to mine for an hour after school. I say ordinarily it would be fine but today it's not ideal because by then DD will be out and I'm working. "It's fine, she can just watch TV," he says, before I put my foot down.

Despite the fact that hybrid working is the norm for many people, I feel like a lot of people (mainly blokes although some women do it too) feel it's a nice cushty one for women which they can do to earn pin money while they look after their kids and think they have an absolute entitlement to butt into it as they see fit.

No one would dream of doing that to someone working in a City office. It's a job. It doesn't matter whether you're in the suburbs or in a gleaming building in the centre of town, you still should have the right not to be endlessly disturbed by other people just to make their lives slightly easier. It's just another example of men thinking they have the right to interrupt woman and take as much of their time as they need, isn't it?

OP posts:
minipie · 22/12/2023 07:58

Yes it’s short shrift. I have no idea what a shrift is though!

MrsClatterbuck · 22/12/2023 07:36

possiblenow · 19/12/2023 15:36

Or is it short shift?

Short shrift is what I always heard it as

whatkatydid2013 · 22/12/2023 07:36

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:49

Because I have someone coming to do a job at my home. I don't understand what you expect me to do if I'm not allowed to respond to a phonecall or the door during working hours?

I wfh 3/4 days a week. I find it’s best to just ignore the phone. If it’s really important people will call again right away and/or leave a message. With the workman I agree booking a day off shouldn’t be necessary but I would block off time in the morning for something I was doing alone - documentation, testing, email etc so that if (when) I was interrupted it only impacted me. In that case it would be no issue losing 15-20 mins as I could just do the work later that day. If someone comes to the door and I’m leading a call I just ignore it. If I’m on a call but just listening I’ll answer it but if it’s anything requiring more interaction than just taking a parcel (neighbour popping by, person trying to sell stuff etc) I say I’m sorry I’m on a work call and can’t talk then close the door. The phone calls from your ex in the OP are a particularly ridiculous example. He called and you said you couldn’t talk but then he called back later and you answered. He likely assumed if you couldn’t talk you wouldn’t answer the phone

queenmeadhbh · 22/12/2023 07:21

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:49

Because I have someone coming to do a job at my home. I don't understand what you expect me to do if I'm not allowed to respond to a phonecall or the door during working hours?

What would you do re:plasterer and parcel if you had a job where wfh was impossible?

DelphiniumBlue · 22/12/2023 06:48

Your boundaries are not strong enough. You say you can't answer the door at x time, but then you do answer it. You say you can't talk on the phone, but then you do just that. If you don't treat yourself seriously, you can't expect other people to do so.
And fyi, people who work out of the home have to arrange time off work to deal with appointments that they can't arrange for the evening or weekend.

RoseGoldEagle · 22/12/2023 03:50

But the plasterer isn’t ‘treating your job like a joke and something you can drop’- he’s not cold calling- you have booked him to come round! A bit annoying he was late, but that’s life, and again he’s not doing that because he doesn’t value your job- he’s got his own work load to juggle, and everyone knows workmen aren’t always on time.

If anything it’s you that’s treating your job that way if you arrange something where there’s a good chance you will need to be interrupted during an important meeting. And surely you just don’t answer your personal phone if you’re busy, same as you wouldn’t in the office?

I just don’t think you can have it both ways- either don’t book people in/answer personal calls if you’ve got really important meetings that can’t be interrupted- or do book them but appreciate it means you need to be able to nip out to answer the door or chat about a problem. It’s up to you if your job is the type that lends itself to that- it’s not the plasterer or your partners decision to make- but if you book the former/take calls from the latter- that’s surely on you- not them?

CryptoFascist · 22/12/2023 01:10

It's not just men who still don't grasp that WFH is actually working. I WFH part of the week and have to fend off comments that I am "off", "leaving off for the day" , people assuming I'm off sick if I'm not in the office. This, despite the fact that the majority of the leadership team work from home most of the time, AND the very people who say I am off then spend the rest of the week in meetings, calls and email exchanges with me... Cognitive dissonance!

DSN88 · 22/12/2023 00:50

I’m pretty confused. If it is so essential to not be distributed when WFH, do not have a plasterer around on a day you’re working. If you were in an office, you would either book the day as annual leave, or WFH and accept to be disturbed. Why was your daughter at home whilst you are working? If she’s not old enough for her dad to contact her herself, it sounds like you would be on call to answer her needs too? Both my husband and me work from home and we will both disturb each other, obviously not if we’re on calls or busy, but other times we do, just as colleagues would do in an office, otherwise you’d book a meeting room and even then, can assume it would be fine ducking out if a reason came about. You do sound unreasonable, more for the sake that you’re making it about men doing this to women, when I’d say it’s 50/50. Don’t wfh if you have issues with people interrupting you when you’re allowing personal time into work time, and don’t expect a plasterer to pander to you…he’s also working and may need to discuss extra things.

LolaSmiles · 21/12/2023 20:55

I think some people do treat women's jobs like they're pin money jobs and not real jobs, but most of what you've outlined OP is you not setting appropriate boundaries with your work time.

Slightlyboredandseverlyconfused · 21/12/2023 20:50

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:49

Because I have someone coming to do a job at my home. I don't understand what you expect me to do if I'm not allowed to respond to a phonecall or the door during working hours?

I don’t. When I’m WFH I basically only leave my office for a quick cuppa or for lunch. I treat like working from the office. I don’t even look at my mobile phone most of the time. Too busy. It’s different though as o work part time so I’d book work people to come on my days off. I guess if you worked in an office you’d have to either leave them a key or take the time off?

Strikeback · 21/12/2023 20:43

I still don't understand why you would schedule someone to come on a working day when you only work 2/3 days a week. Surely the whole point of part-time is that you have a day or two free for that sort of thing.

KK05 · 21/12/2023 20:23

I don’t think it’s a woman thing I think it’s a WFH thing.

My DH works from home on occasion and I used to be the person telling him xyz needs doing leave him with the dog (we use day care or he comes with me). During Covid I used to get deliveries daily etc as he was home most of the time. He used to moan about it and I never got it. I would leave for work and he would still be asleep then when I got home he was on the sofa with his feet up. I think even some days worked from the sofa. I think I saw him as having an easy life.

I then got a job wfh (unfortunately i was an and am a key worker) and I seen the reality of what I was asking him to do. Yeah there are benefits like doing washings, tradesmen, deliveries etc but in actual fact these things are a nightmare fitting in around work. A key benefit was the lie in before work as no commute and when you clock off your home already.

I think the main issue is people who have never wfh don’t understand. They just see that you’re in the house more than likely in comfy lounge clothes and not the workload you have.

I found the best way to get through to people was arrange for deliveries to a collection point, take actual time off for tradesmen and ignore my phone until breaks.

MystyLuna · 21/12/2023 20:17

I have worked from home for years.
Earlier this year when I started having a lot more meetings I would put a note on the front door saying "Please do not knock on the door" anytime I had a meeting and my husband wasn't home.
Over 2 months 19 people knocked on the door (none of them wanted me). It really annoys me.

Simonjt · 21/12/2023 20:15

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:47

@Dotjones

YABU because if you're choosing to mix personal jobs with your business work it's your own fault. In other words, you're trying to have the best of both worlds.

So how if you are a working single parent are you supposed to get personal jobs done if they are never allowed to intrude in the 9 to 5?

By that logic if I were in an office from 9 to 5 and I couldn't ever have a personal job intrude into my work life I'd never be able to get any work done on my house. Never be able to get an appliance fix. Never be able to receive a parcel at home etc.

I used to use annual leave, just as I did when I was working from home.

AnonnyMouseDave · 21/12/2023 20:04

Redlocks30 · 21/12/2023 11:52

By that logic if I were in an office from 9 to 5 and I couldn't ever have a personal job intrude into my work life I'd never be able to get any work done on my house. Never be able to get an appliance fix. Never be able to receive a parcel at home etc.

What do you think those of us who have to work out of the home do?! Get parcels delivered to collection points, book work during holidays/annual leave etc. I am a teacher and can’t answer my phone at all during the working day. If I want work done, I’d do it during the holidays. My friend who is a nurse is similar, she books work in the house during her days off or books annual leave for it.

You need to tell people you are busy and not answer the phone when you are working!

"You need to tell people you are busy and not answer the phone when you are working!" Some people do and some people don't. Teaching should pay at least 3 or 4 times what it does based on my perception of how appealing a job it is.

WashItTomorrow · 21/12/2023 19:37

YoniGetAnOohWithTyphoo · 21/12/2023 19:28

And wow. Some of the replies on here are super rude. They must all be the most ‘professional’ women in the world to be so unforgiving of someone leaving a video call for 2 minutes. Wouldn’t like to work with such judgemental people.

I couldn’t possibly do that. I work in live TV. I can’t just disappear even for five seconds.

YoniGetAnOohWithTyphoo · 21/12/2023 19:28

And wow. Some of the replies on here are super rude. They must all be the most ‘professional’ women in the world to be so unforgiving of someone leaving a video call for 2 minutes. Wouldn’t like to work with such judgemental people.

ttcat37 · 21/12/2023 19:27

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 15:47

@Dotjones

YABU because if you're choosing to mix personal jobs with your business work it's your own fault. In other words, you're trying to have the best of both worlds.

So how if you are a working single parent are you supposed to get personal jobs done if they are never allowed to intrude in the 9 to 5?

By that logic if I were in an office from 9 to 5 and I couldn't ever have a personal job intrude into my work life I'd never be able to get any work done on my house. Never be able to get an appliance fix. Never be able to receive a parcel at home etc.

Lots of people are in that exact situation. You book annual leave to be available or arrange for someone to go to your house and let them in.
Parcels go in the parcel box or to a neighbour.

You're justifying having a wfh job to enable the exact behaviour that you’re finding annoying.

YoniGetAnOohWithTyphoo · 21/12/2023 19:16

I get this CONSTANTLY and it drives me nuts too!

It doesn’t help that I work in Academia, so I also get ‘but your hours are flexible’ - possibly, to a point, but if there’s a meeting or if I’m leading a seminar, that isn’t flexible at all! I also suspect that many see it as ‘not REAL work’ because it’s not like I work in finance or something, so basically I’m a glorified uni student.

I have literally answered the door to tradesmen and delivery men who have been incessantly ringing the doorbell during my calls, with my laptop in hand and clearly on a call, and they STILL blithely chatter on like I have all the time in the world to cater to their every need!

Mind you, my mother is just as bad. She really doesn’t understand ‘why I can’t answer my phone during work hours when I work from home’. I tell her that she often calls me whilst on a video call to 100+ students, or during admissions interviews, or Management Board meetings, and it’s not something I can pause - but it never sinks in.

CruisingForAMusing · 21/12/2023 18:37

Honestly, I don't recognise any of this, but that might be because I don't have kids, so I feel on an absolute even footing to men when it comes to the working world.
Tradesman have often never done anything else, so can't understand how tied to a laptop you are in office work. But it's probably not personal.

AShiningThongOfAngels · 21/12/2023 17:09

Dotjones · 19/12/2023 15:25

YABU because if you're choosing to mix personal jobs with your business work it's your own fault. In other words, you're trying to have the best of both worlds.

If you were in an office the plasterer wouldn't have interrupted you. If you had scheduled the plasterer for a day when you weren't working, they wouldn't have interrupted your work. What happened is your responsibility.

You chose to answer the phone for personal calls. If you're working properly then maybe you should act as you would if you got a personal call in the office, ignore it or tell them you'll call back when it's convenient for you.

To be honest you sound like the reason people thing those WFH are taking the piss, letting personal errands and their social life get in the way of the work they're being paid to do.

This first response nails it.

You're taking the piss. It's nothing to do with being a woman. Your junior colleagues might well be eyeing up your job in case you get the boot for carrying on your private business when you're supposed to be in an online meeting with them.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 21/12/2023 16:56

I think you can't have it both ways. If you arrange for tradespeople to come and do work on your house when you're supposed to be working, it's pretty obvious that it's going to disrupt your working day and people will naturally assume that you will be able to work around the interruptions. Likewise if you take personal calls - if you're busy, just don't answer?

You seem to want to mix work time with personal stuff as and when it suits you to do so, but then you object when others assume that this isn't a problem for you.

stayathomer · 21/12/2023 16:51

I don’t think it’s a man/ woman thing- when I was out working and dh was wfh the exact same thing- it’s just that people don’t class wfh as work

gannett · 21/12/2023 16:49

Communication and clear boundaries (and sticking to them) are ultra-important if you WFH.

My day-to-day job is a mix of tasks of varying importance ranging from things that can be interrupted or done with minimal attention, to things that cannot be interrupted at all. Usually I have some idea of when those things will happen in advance. So if arranging a tradesman I would avoid the days which are higher-stress, higher-intensity or higher in terms of Cannot Be Interrupted. If it can't be avoided and if he didn't turn up when he said he would, I'd message him and/or stick a note on the door saying I'd be unable to let him in until X time.

I can't really fathom the ex-husband/MIL scenario. I assume his overriding your boundaries is a reason he's an ex, but... you don't have to answer the phone.

Let the phone ring until it's convenient for you. Let the late tradesman stand at the door until it's convenient for you. That's how you train other people to respect your time.

Dutch1e · 21/12/2023 16:30

I'm with you, although I found it much more difficult to drum into people's heads before COVID made remote-work better understood. I've been WFH for almost 20 years and the number of pop-ins I got was mind-blowing.

It got to the point where I would stick a notice in my window "WORKING, UNAVAILABLE UNTIL X TIME" and ignore the woefully late tradies who hadn't bothered to call in a reschedule, and also the oblivious relatives/friends who had repeatedly been politely told about my working hours.

Amazingly, most would stand directly in front of the notice (!!!) banging on the window to get my attention.

And yes, apart from one particular woman they were all men.