Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Telling DS I don't want his gift

211 replies

QueenofClutter · 19/12/2023 12:59

I know he's trying to be thoughtful, and all things considered we're not talking much money, but he's just bought me something I really don't want. How can I let him down gently without seeming ungrateful?

Bit of a longwinded back story.

I'm decluttering prior to a house move. Sold most of my vinyl records, and I'm having a clear out of CDs. (Keeping plenty, I might add, just being ruthless with stuff I haven't played for years.) Some of the vinyl is 50 years old, and anything of sentimental value or that i particularly like has already been replaced by the CD version.

Not exactly sure how, but some particular titles got mentioned while we were talking music. He's now sent me a CD of something I've already got - and is also in the recycling pile.

I've no idea how he came to think this particular CD is something I wanted! ( ps it's not a Christmas gift)

While I appreciate the gesture, I can't get enthusiastic about it - and I'm very bad at disguising my feelings too. I don't want to encourage him to buy more cds for me either!

Help!

OP posts:
LaurieStrode · 20/12/2023 04:33

TerribleWoman · 19/12/2023 13:06

I wouldn't dream of doing anything other than telling him it was very thoughtful of him and the CD is music that you love. It's one CD, you are keeping other CDs. It will take up half a centimetre on a shelf.

I might add that I am trying to move to streaming to keep "stuff" to a minimum, so if he has any other similar lovely ideas in future, might he send a streaming link?

Spontaneous gifts just because are a lovely gesture. The least you can do is make a lovely gesture in return and keep the CD.

This. Ffs.

Ladyj84 · 20/12/2023 02:18

Ah wouldn't bother me because clearly thought went into this one as you like your music. Me I would just keep it for a few weeks then filter it thru to a charity shop at some point unless I did change mind to keep it

paisley256 · 20/12/2023 02:17

OutwiththeOutCrowd · 19/12/2023 14:07

Assuming he doesn't have a gifts-I've-given-my-mother inventory list that he checks through regularly, it would be okay to 'recycle' the CD. But, honestly, my main thought would be, 'I've got a lovely son in my life who wanted to do something nice for me'. Intentions are important.

This. It's a lovely gesture from your son, a child. Why potentially hurt his feelings when he's showing you kindness?

ThePlatypusAlwaysTriumphs · 20/12/2023 02:06

Are you my MIL? She threw all of our gifts back at us last year. She's getting cold hard cash this year. So I don't need to think about what she might want or like. I don't have to think about her at all. That's her doing.
I love buying gifts (especially little ones) that I think people will like, and that they HAVEN'T asked for. I find little pleasure in handing over a gift that we all know in advance what it is. I'm excited to see people's reactions to the ones they don't know they are getting (but still get things they have asked for). My dc will act enthusiastic about all their gifts, as I will about theirs to me, whatever they are, because we know they were bought with thought and feeling, and it seems harsh to say that that effort was in vain.

MollyPuddingBowl · 20/12/2023 01:48

I wouldn't say much tbh. The thought was more than some of us receive

SwingTheMonkey · 20/12/2023 01:44

Circularargument · 20/12/2023 00:59

I'm sure it's very comforting for you to think so, @SwingTheMonkey . Feel free.

Comforting to think what?

You don’t make much sense and don’t seem to be able to follow what you and others have posted. Reading comprehension is your friend.

CherryShirt · 20/12/2023 01:19

Needmorelego · 19/12/2023 16:53

@TerribleWoman but was it actually a nice gesture or was it a half arsed bought cd from a charity shop because he vaguely remembered his mum talking about Fleetwood Mac 3 weeks ago.
If this is an adult son (the OP never came back so we don't know) surely he is aware she is downsizing and getting rid of a lot of her music collection.

This is bizarre. What adult keeps a record of when their mother throws out when she has a tidy-up? I can barely remember what I’ve thrown out myself, never mind what goes into my mother’s Oxfam box!

I’m not sure what you even mean by a “half-arsed buy from a charity shop”. So bloody what? He bought his mother a CD, he didn’t punch her in the face!

Circularargument · 20/12/2023 00:59

I'm sure it's very comforting for you to think so, @SwingTheMonkey . Feel free.

SwingTheMonkey · 19/12/2023 23:47

“Who on earth only accepts gifts if they’ve been specifically asked for?!”

“Me, because that's what everyone who knows me knows I want. Because I tell them”

Oh dear @Circularargument 🤦🏻‍♀️. Those are literally the quotes I responded ‘so nobody is allowed to buy you something unless it’s from a sanctioned list?’

When someone responds to the question ‘who only accepts gifts they’ve specifically asked for?’ with ‘me’, I’m not sure what else one could take away from that.

Your attempt to prove me a bit dim this evening has given me a bit of a giggle though, so thanks pet.

SpringIntoChaos · 19/12/2023 23:16

What is wrong with you OP?? Seriously...just thank him! Ffs! 🤦‍♀️

Fionaville · 19/12/2023 23:10

I'd keep it and thank him profusely for being such a thoughtful son! It's a CD, it's not taking up any space. If a friend bought you a toiletry set or candle you didn't like the smell of, I'm guessing you wouldn't say "I dont want that. I don't like it" You'd thank them and re gift or donate it. So don't reject your sons gift and hurt his feelings.

Circularargument · 19/12/2023 23:01

SwingTheMonkey · 19/12/2023 19:21

So, nobody is allowed to buy you something unless it’s from a sanctioned list?

Bizarre.

What's truly bizarre is that that is your take away from what I actually wrote. People ask me, they talk to me and I to them. Shocking and radical. I know. Impossible to comprehend, for you clearly 😒

SwingTheMonkey · 19/12/2023 19:21

Circularargument · 19/12/2023 19:01

Me, because that's what everyone who knows me knows I want. Because I tell them

So, nobody is allowed to buy you something unless it’s from a sanctioned list?

Bizarre.

stayathomer · 19/12/2023 19:09

Op you have possibly lost sight of something along the way of your decluttering journey: from someone whose dm decluttered away most of our toys, comic books, projects, certificates and cards and once asked did we want to take any of the cards We’d made her over the years as she’d kept two and she didn’t want to be stuck with a pile in her drawers that we’d have to clean out when she died (she’s still very much alive btw, and I love her to the ends of the earth, but I really want to have more stuff then the box of concert tickets, projects and few cds I kept in my own box!!)

Circularargument · 19/12/2023 19:04

MushMonster · 19/12/2023 17:13

Refusing a gift, particularly a small one which had some thought put into it, is the fastest way to push someone aside.
So, if you want to make your son feel unwanted, you can reject a CD, that you actually like.........

Nonsense. Some people are so bloody thin skinned. DS2 ( an adult) told me he already had a book I had bought him, so I said Oops and arranged to get an alternative. I didn't think for one second to get all silly about it.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 19/12/2023 19:02

Tell him thank you and tell him as your getting older time together is more important so for your next present youd love him to come over for an evening for a film and if he wants he can buy you a box of chocs to share.

Circularargument · 19/12/2023 19:01

SwingTheMonkey · 19/12/2023 17:31

These aren’t birthday gifts though. They’re things op’s son is seeing and buying because he thinks his mum will like them.

Who on earth only accepts gifts if they’ve been specifically asked for?!

Me, because that's what everyone who knows me knows I want. Because I tell them

Dotcheck · 19/12/2023 19:01

captaincalamari12 · 19/12/2023 13:11

Just say thank you, what is wrong with people.

This. Bloody hell op

Brefugee · 19/12/2023 18:58

QueenofClutter · 19/12/2023 17:03

He's 50 and "a bit dopey" as you put it, and not v good managing his money either. Another reason I don't like him buying me things.

I really do think it's sweet of him to get it for me and I'd never dream of upsetting his feelings. However he's got form for buying me small gifts, usually something fairly useful, nothing extravagant. I think he thinks I'm just being polite when I say "You shouldn't have"... so how can I put it more bluntly that I don't want, or expect, surprise gifts?

Use. Your. Words.

Kittylala · 19/12/2023 18:57

I think this post is alchol induced!

Spirallingdownwards · 19/12/2023 18:49

You had a chat about music and obviously mentioned you liked this artist so he bought a CD by that artist not realising you already had it. Give the other one to charity with your pile and keep this for a short while longer before doing likewise.

He saw something he thought you would like and did something kind. Just be kind back. It's not that you don't even like that music just you were getting rid of CDs. Actually if my son gave me a CD by an artist I liked that CD would have more meaning that it ever had before by virtue of the fact it now had a sentimental attachment to my son too.

SawX · 19/12/2023 18:37

QueenofClutter · 19/12/2023 17:03

He's 50 and "a bit dopey" as you put it, and not v good managing his money either. Another reason I don't like him buying me things.

I really do think it's sweet of him to get it for me and I'd never dream of upsetting his feelings. However he's got form for buying me small gifts, usually something fairly useful, nothing extravagant. I think he thinks I'm just being polite when I say "You shouldn't have"... so how can I put it more bluntly that I don't want, or expect, surprise gifts?

You don't. You learn to be gracious and have some perspective.

Needmorelego · 19/12/2023 18:37

@HulaChick the OP says he is 50. Hardly "a child" !

HulaChick · 19/12/2023 18:33

Why can no-one just be grateful for the thought someone has shown these days? Especially a child. Be grateful & don't hurt his feelings. Bloody horrible of you to even think of doing otherwise.

Beryls · 19/12/2023 17:51

Many years ago my dad had been out somewhere for the day and brought me back a dvd because he saw it and knew I liked the film. For some reason instead of just saying thank you, I told him that I already had it. He said it didn't matter and didn't seem too bothered but I was absolutely devastated afterwards and still think about it all these years later. He looked crestfallen for a split second.

i can still see that moment in my mind even now. My dad wasn't one for giving gifts and he'd obviously seen it and thought of me.

He died a long time ago now but it's still a massive regret I would go back and change if I could. Ridiculous as I know it is, I'm still cross at myself!!

Just say thanks, you can chuck it if you want to he will never know.

Off to go and cry now at my own ungrateful self! 😅