Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think being asked for money at work like this is not ok?

612 replies

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 08:48

I don’t know if I’m feeling sensitive about money and actually this is totally reasonable…

We have one dc in full time nursery costing 1500 a month. I work for a professional services company and we have a lot of support staff. We are seen to be paid huge money. However I am only on 63k and we are struggling so much at the moment, some people more senior are on well over this with grown up dc. A month ago a Teams message was started by someone senior saying does anyone want to pitch in for a gift for the secretaries. I found this very inappropriate on teams as it was difficult to say no in a group chat.

I know the answer in practice is just don’t give anything if you can’t afford it but I’ve since been chased on a separate teams message asking if I am contributing and when I ignored that I got an email.

I feel this puts so much pressure on people and think it is massively inappropriate thing to do at work? Am I being a dick?

OP posts:
beanii · 19/12/2023 17:02

Turtletoe · 19/12/2023 16:52

Wow, people see 63k and think this is massive. That is the case for most, however 63k after tax and ni is around 3,700 per month. Take away 1500 of that for childcare 2200 remains for housing, heating, eating and all the other soul draining bills.
I haven't read 17 pages of comments so forgive me, but Id imagine this person has not only a big mortgage, rising rapidly like every one else, but a big council tax to match.
No you're not being unreasonable.

Edited

Most people don't have £2200 take home before nursery fees come out 🤦‍♀️

You're as out of touch as the OP.

MushMonster · 19/12/2023 17:02

Just tell the person chasing the contribution you are sorry, but cannot give at this time.
Next time they ask in future, just say, sorry I cannot.
You need to be assertive and confident enough to do this.

10yDrama · 19/12/2023 17:02

Turtletoe · 19/12/2023 16:52

Wow, people see 63k and think this is massive. That is the case for most, however 63k after tax and ni is around 3,700 per month. Take away 1500 of that for childcare 2200 remains for housing, heating, eating and all the other soul draining bills.
I haven't read 17 pages of comments so forgive me, but Id imagine this person has not only a big mortgage, rising rapidly like every one else, but a big council tax to match.
No you're not being unreasonable.

Edited

It's not £63k total household income.

We live in the SE near London.

Our combined isnt far off £63k.

While I don't doubt that with nursery etc there's not a lot of spare cash, I wouldn't be snubbing a work Christmas whip round.

Sounds like OP spends a lot more than just nursery etc.

Fishwiife · 19/12/2023 16:59

63k gets heavily taxed, you lose your right to child benefit and you pay a huge amount for childcare. It is a good salary but those costs are heavy.

OP much respect to you for pursuing your career. Well done for not accepting a low wage or reducing your hours. You have my understanding of your situation, it’s not easy!

professionalmum01 · 19/12/2023 16:57

All these people saying £63k seems a lot. It's not when you have a £1.5k nursery bill and a mortgage and other bills. Those on lower wages might have far lower outgoings .

OP i'd just say unfortunately i cannot contribute as money is tight or just give a couple of quid but they shouldn't be chasing you.

Catlady1978 · 19/12/2023 16:53

@xmasmoney is this for real? ‘Only’ £63k a year and you can’t chip in for the secretaries who are no doubt on around £25-£29k per year? Everyone has debt etc - this is a cost of living crisis. Just be glad you have £63k a year to do it. If you don’t want to turn grow a backbone and say no!

Turtletoe · 19/12/2023 16:52

Wow, people see 63k and think this is massive. That is the case for most, however 63k after tax and ni is around 3,700 per month. Take away 1500 of that for childcare 2200 remains for housing, heating, eating and all the other soul draining bills.
I haven't read 17 pages of comments so forgive me, but Id imagine this person has not only a big mortgage, rising rapidly like every one else, but a big council tax to match.
No you're not being unreasonable.

SezFrankly · 19/12/2023 16:49

Answer the question then! Jesus H, Tthere’s some poor bastard trying to organise this, and they need to know what they’re spending. If you can’t, just say so. If you feel you need to justify it, just say you’ve had some recent unexpected expenses.

if you’re a senior manager, gifts like this are the norm and should be budgeted for in your salary, just as a nice suit/shoes etc are. Remember this for next year and don’t be so bloody tight. £63k is a perfectly good salary to live within.

TiredMummma · 19/12/2023 16:49

A £63k salary is about £3k a month, with £1500 going on childcare and still bills and rent/mortgage to pay its shows why you are going to debt.

Anyone else on lower salary with no local family and a young child cannot afford to work right now. That's the situation the county is in.

The debate here should be about the complete unaffordablity of childcare that even those on higher incomes are going in to debt instead of attacking the OP for feeling pressured on top of all the other pressure.

Having said all that, I would have just said I can't afford it or here is a fiver

Abbyant · 19/12/2023 16:45

Whip rounds for staff are common and your being unreasonable not replying on a separate note you need to have a very good look at your finances if you are struggling on 63k a year, I earn 25k and with childcare costs of £880 a month but can still manage a fiver for staff.

beanii · 19/12/2023 16:41

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 08:52

@Doggymummar i do want to. I have done in the past. We have no money at the moment and credit card debt. Being asked in this way I have found really uncomfortable

If you're on £67k and in debt you need to quickly look at your outgoings!

That's ridiculous.

beanii · 19/12/2023 16:39

You lost me at 'ONLY earn 67k' - you need a reality check.

Chip in for gifts - that's what 'us' on minimum wage (around £20k) do 😒

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 16:27

@MargotBamborough I can give you an example from my own life, where I do know the variables:

I have a child with adhd- I chose to have him assessed privately, and have been paying privately for his medication and psychiatrist reviews.

This cost around £4000 upfront, and between £120-£170 a month.

After paying this I am very short of money at the end of each month.

However-

I had the opportunity of doing this, it was a choice that I made, and I have something to show for the money I spent- a well supported child.

My best friend has a child who equally needs to be assessed but because she has a lower income, she doesn’t have the option to pay privately.

She hasn’t spent the money I have on assessments and medication, and she is still short of money at the end of the month.

So- yes, at the end of the month we are both short of money BUT in my case it is because I had money and chose to spend it on something, in her case it’s because she doesn’t have the money in the first place.

If you have £58 left at the end of the month after you have paid for your house, car, phone and holiday you have greater spending power than someone who has £58 left at the end of the month but can’t afford a mortgage, a car or a holiday.

SkySecret · 19/12/2023 15:50

*You forget that you only pay 20% marginal tax on your £45k of income.

OP pays 40% marginal tax from £50k to £63K

And then you add NI (2%) and studen loan (9%).*

@BouncingJAS but you’ve not added the 12% NI for the person on basic rate tax. The jump from basic to higher rate is actually a jump from 32% to 42%. Not a jump from 20% to 40%. It’s not as significant as people assume.

Sodndashitall · 19/12/2023 15:48

I agree it's not a nice way to do it. I'd make the point that in future it may be better to just do a truly voluntary collection pot rather than nagging people. There may be others feeling the same way

Boomboom22 · 19/12/2023 15:47

I think Margot might think all 30 Yr olds earn about 63k then when your children leave home you take a secretary job.

One more time, all people of the same age who have the same amount of kids have to figure out either 1500 for nursery or shift work or family help. They all have to live somewhere. The op is better off than all of them who earn less. If she chooses to live in a bigger house or use an expensive montessori instead of the cheapest childminder locally that's her choice.

No student loan never makes your income lower. You pay a bit more but only ever 9 or 15% for post grad. So the more you earn up to 100k you always clear more apart from the child benefit which staggers from 50 to 60k.

telestrations · 19/12/2023 15:40

Just say you can't this time round

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 15:39

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 15:13

Why are you assuming that all the people on lower incomes have the same costs the OP does?

Does a 50 year old secretary with no minor children and no student loan have the same outgoings as the OP?

No, she does not.

And it's not the size of the student loan that matters, but the size of the monthly repayment.

Someone on 25k with a student loan will be making monthly repayments equivalent to the cost of a couple of drinks in the pub, not upwards of 300 quid.

This is what I mean about economic illiteracy.

Wow. Resorting to insults.

I am not in the least economically illiterate.

Look at what I wrote- where do I say the admin staff have exactly the same circumstances as the op? Precisely nowhere.

What I said was that people on high incomes do not hold the monopoly on high outgoings, and that it is an utter nonsense to continually argue that if you have a high income you only have the same spending power as someone who earns a lot less.

We could all invent 20 different scenarios where people have this, pay that, married him, have 12 kids etc but it wouldn’t affect the basic logic.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 15:33

Teder · 19/12/2023 15:20

You cannot lecture about economic literacy and say “someone on 25k will be paying the equivalent of a couple of drinks”. It’s proportionate to your salary.

You need to look at like for like. Let’s assume a single women aged 30 (no dependents) earns £25k and another single woman aged 30 (no dependency) earns £50k. They work for the same company. Both need a bedroom and roof over their head. Of course it’ll be tighter on the lower salary!

I am very senior in my team and significantly out earn some other people. I wouldn’t start harping on about my student loan (which rises as my salary does!) nor the cost of housing because we all have the same. It would be incredibly insensitive.

We are talking about student loan repayments. It's proportionate to your salary above the repayment threshold.

Someone on 25k repays 22 quid a month on Plan 1 or zero quid a month on Plan 2.

Someone on 63k repays 307 quid a month on Plan 1 or 267 quid a month on Plan 2.

"You need to look at like for like" is literally what I have been saying all along in this thread.

Comparing someone on 63k who is making student loan repayments, paying 1500 per month in nursery fees and has a large mortgage with not much equity in their home yet with someone on 30k who is not in the same situation is not comparing like for like, is it?

LightToTheWorld · 19/12/2023 15:24

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 15:04

If you don't want a lecture on the cost of living, don't bloody chase people if you've asked them once and they haven't responded!

Plenty of people appreciate being chased because they're busy and haven't got round to donating. It really isn't that hard to say "no thanks" if you don't want to, I have no idea why OP has no done this.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 19/12/2023 15:22

You have two good choices: give a fiver, or reply to say "I'm sitting this one out"

Or a 3rd, simply ignore and delete the emails.

Teder · 19/12/2023 15:20

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 15:13

Why are you assuming that all the people on lower incomes have the same costs the OP does?

Does a 50 year old secretary with no minor children and no student loan have the same outgoings as the OP?

No, she does not.

And it's not the size of the student loan that matters, but the size of the monthly repayment.

Someone on 25k with a student loan will be making monthly repayments equivalent to the cost of a couple of drinks in the pub, not upwards of 300 quid.

This is what I mean about economic illiteracy.

You cannot lecture about economic literacy and say “someone on 25k will be paying the equivalent of a couple of drinks”. It’s proportionate to your salary.

You need to look at like for like. Let’s assume a single women aged 30 (no dependents) earns £25k and another single woman aged 30 (no dependency) earns £50k. They work for the same company. Both need a bedroom and roof over their head. Of course it’ll be tighter on the lower salary!

I am very senior in my team and significantly out earn some other people. I wouldn’t start harping on about my student loan (which rises as my salary does!) nor the cost of housing because we all have the same. It would be incredibly insensitive.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 15:13

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 15:08

But you do understand that all of that applies to people earning a lot less than £63000?

Other than the income tax they will still have absolutely massive student loans, accommodation costs higher than if you were born 10 years earlier etc.

I don’t understand why people keep making the argument that you don’t have much more disposable income on £63,000 than on much less- if this were true why would anyone go to the bother of securing a high income?! They could earn less, pay less tax and still have a similar lifestyle.

Why are you assuming that all the people on lower incomes have the same costs the OP does?

Does a 50 year old secretary with no minor children and no student loan have the same outgoings as the OP?

No, she does not.

And it's not the size of the student loan that matters, but the size of the monthly repayment.

Someone on 25k with a student loan will be making monthly repayments equivalent to the cost of a couple of drinks in the pub, not upwards of 300 quid.

This is what I mean about economic illiteracy.

Lou670 · 19/12/2023 15:11

It depends if you like to receive a gift when there is a whip round for an occasion such as a birthday. If you don't want to participate then just say no to them but be prepared for other staff members to have taken a mental note of it. I feel sorry for the secretary if others are like you and if they are begrudgingly contributing. I would rather not receive a gift that was not given in kindness.

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 15:08

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 11:59

All of this.

To add the above...

Based on the limited information we have it sounds like the OP is most likely in her early 30s. I'm basing that on the fact that she has a young child and is still making student loan repayments on a salary of 63K, which suggests that she hasn't been earning 63k for all that long and started university between 2006 and 2011. If she had started university before that she would have paid lower tuition fees and on her salary would most likely have repaid the full loan by now. It is possible that she started university in or after 2012 and has an absolutely massive student loan, but that would make her most likely under 30 which is pretty young to be a home owner with a child if you are in a graduate job. So she is most likely between 30 and 36.

If my guess about her age is correct, she probably did not get on the property ladder all that long ago, and she probably paid a high price for a starter home within commuting distance of her job.

If she didn't get on the property ladder all that long ago then she probably doesn't have a lot of equity in her home, making her very vulnerable to rising interest rates. If you owe hundreds of thousands on your mortgage when your fix comes to an end and your interest rate suddenly goes up by 4%, that's going to hit you much harder than if you are, say, 20 years older and only earning 33k in your admin role but bought a house when property was much more affordable and your mortgage is all but paid off.

There is a reason why nursery fees are such a killer for people like the OP. They earn the kind of salary that makes the economically illiterate on Mumsnet say, "But you're RICH, stop complaining!" and make stupid jokes about tiny violins, but you get nothing in the way of state benefits to help you pay these costs, you're paying a huge marginal tax rate including student loan contributions and your housing costs are much higher than they would have been if you'd been born even ten years earlier.

People not in this age and income bracket have a completely unrealistic idea of what sort of lifestyle people like the OP are living, and comments about "prep school" (ffs!) make that abundantly clear.

Edited

But you do understand that all of that applies to people earning a lot less than £63000?

Other than the income tax they will still have absolutely massive student loans, accommodation costs higher than if you were born 10 years earlier etc.

I don’t understand why people keep making the argument that you don’t have much more disposable income on £63,000 than on much less- if this were true why would anyone go to the bother of securing a high income?! They could earn less, pay less tax and still have a similar lifestyle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread