Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think being asked for money at work like this is not ok?

612 replies

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 08:48

I don’t know if I’m feeling sensitive about money and actually this is totally reasonable…

We have one dc in full time nursery costing 1500 a month. I work for a professional services company and we have a lot of support staff. We are seen to be paid huge money. However I am only on 63k and we are struggling so much at the moment, some people more senior are on well over this with grown up dc. A month ago a Teams message was started by someone senior saying does anyone want to pitch in for a gift for the secretaries. I found this very inappropriate on teams as it was difficult to say no in a group chat.

I know the answer in practice is just don’t give anything if you can’t afford it but I’ve since been chased on a separate teams message asking if I am contributing and when I ignored that I got an email.

I feel this puts so much pressure on people and think it is massively inappropriate thing to do at work? Am I being a dick?

OP posts:
beanii · 19/12/2023 17:29

Happyhappyday · 19/12/2023 17:26

I don’t think it is employees responsibility to make up for an employer not paying a secretary very much? And really not appropriate to chase you. I would reply with a simple “unfortunately I’m not able to contribute this year.” And I’d honestly complain anonymously to HR about being chased for money.

Please tell me you're joking? 🤦‍♀️🤣

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 19/12/2023 17:27

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 12:53

These responses are getting more bonkers by the minute.

I'm sure if you told someone on 30k that they just couldn't afford to have kids then your comment would be met by howls of outrage. But it's somehow OK to suggest that someone on the OP's salary shouldn't have kids if she couldn't comfortably afford it?

Where is the next generation going to come from then?

Surely if someone on 63k is struggling to make ends meet with just one child in childcare, rather than all piling on and telling her how rich she is, or alternatively suggesting that she shouldn't have had a child if she couldn't afford it, we should be talking about the fact that the system is completely broken.

Not sure about the relevance of your relative to this discussion BTW, since by your own admission her circumstances are completely different. But any economically literate person will tell you that it doesn't make any sense to pay your student loan off early unless your circumstances are pretty unusual.

I don’t quite see how my responses are getting more bonkers by the minute but judging by your many comments on this thread you seem more defensive by the minute.

Of course I’m not saying that people who earn 30K can’t afford to have kids but as a pp said people on lower incomes than OP are generally very good at managing on a shoe string because they have to! They learn to budget.

OP is probably not the only person in her household on 63K and I’m not saying how rich she is, no one is debating that mortgage, childcare under school age and other costs like student loan are expensive for her. I’m saying her budgeting skills look to be in question.

The relevance of my relative to this discussion (she actually manages better financially now she’s moved away from London as she gets more childcare help, less expensive living in London etc), is that lots of people either are or aren’t good at finance management (including her) and I do see lots of mothers of OP’s age who seem to fritter money on things they can’t afford, over-extend themselves on mortgage costs etc and then say they’re short of money on this salary similar to what OP earns.

And actually, I was always advised (maybe I’m wrong) that it was better to pay off loans (including student ones) early if you could afford to do so.

Don’t even go there re “where’s the next generation going to come from then”. That’s not my issue and I didn’t tell people to stop having kids if they couldn’t afford it. I could give you at least 3-4 examples of single mothers who bought flats by themselves, had and brought children up mostly alone until they met someone and earned less than OP, plus arranged and sorted childcare (whether nursery or not).

dishyrishi · 19/12/2023 17:27

I'm sorry to add this, but I'm a "secretary" (bloody awful word, job doesn't exist any more, we are highly skilled individuals), and I'm paid almost twice what you are... just saying

Happyhappyday · 19/12/2023 17:26

I don’t think it is employees responsibility to make up for an employer not paying a secretary very much? And really not appropriate to chase you. I would reply with a simple “unfortunately I’m not able to contribute this year.” And I’d honestly complain anonymously to HR about being chased for money.

1975wasthebest · 19/12/2023 17:26

SezFrankly · 19/12/2023 16:49

Answer the question then! Jesus H, Tthere’s some poor bastard trying to organise this, and they need to know what they’re spending. If you can’t, just say so. If you feel you need to justify it, just say you’ve had some recent unexpected expenses.

if you’re a senior manager, gifts like this are the norm and should be budgeted for in your salary, just as a nice suit/shoes etc are. Remember this for next year and don’t be so bloody tight. £63k is a perfectly good salary to live within.

You're being ridiculous that people like OP should factor in gifts of appreciation to their colleagues along with ESSENTIALS including their clothes. Only on MN do people think like this.

And no, it isn't the norm. Also, is there any benefit to always conforming to the norm, anyway? Better to be authentic, in my view.

Friendfoe1 · 19/12/2023 17:24

Even with nursery fees you’re still bringing in around 45k and have a partner bringing in money too. I do agree with PPs that you need to look into your spending habits if you only have £60 left til payday.
Just pop in a tenner.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 17:24

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 16:27

@MargotBamborough I can give you an example from my own life, where I do know the variables:

I have a child with adhd- I chose to have him assessed privately, and have been paying privately for his medication and psychiatrist reviews.

This cost around £4000 upfront, and between £120-£170 a month.

After paying this I am very short of money at the end of each month.

However-

I had the opportunity of doing this, it was a choice that I made, and I have something to show for the money I spent- a well supported child.

My best friend has a child who equally needs to be assessed but because she has a lower income, she doesn’t have the option to pay privately.

She hasn’t spent the money I have on assessments and medication, and she is still short of money at the end of the month.

So- yes, at the end of the month we are both short of money BUT in my case it is because I had money and chose to spend it on something, in her case it’s because she doesn’t have the money in the first place.

If you have £58 left at the end of the month after you have paid for your house, car, phone and holiday you have greater spending power than someone who has £58 left at the end of the month but can’t afford a mortgage, a car or a holiday.

That's fascinating, and also completely irrelevant to the thread.

vickylou78 · 19/12/2023 17:23

Op you earn a very good wage! Surely it's okay for senior staff to club together for facilities and admin staff for a Christmas gift. Even if you only gave £3-£5 would be okay wouldn't it.

I know you've mentioned nursery fees but you do realise that the admin staff have to pay nursery too and they are on half of what you earn!
I think you are being tight.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 17:22

Boomboom22 · 19/12/2023 15:47

I think Margot might think all 30 Yr olds earn about 63k then when your children leave home you take a secretary job.

One more time, all people of the same age who have the same amount of kids have to figure out either 1500 for nursery or shift work or family help. They all have to live somewhere. The op is better off than all of them who earn less. If she chooses to live in a bigger house or use an expensive montessori instead of the cheapest childminder locally that's her choice.

No student loan never makes your income lower. You pay a bit more but only ever 9 or 15% for post grad. So the more you earn up to 100k you always clear more apart from the child benefit which staggers from 50 to 60k.

One more time, the OP has said NOTHING to indicate that any of the specific people she is being asked to buy presents for ARE in the same stage of life/have the same outgoings as her.

These 30 year old secretaries with kids in full time nursery who work at the OP's company may not exist.

The OP does exist and she only has 58 quid in her bank account. Jeez.

rookiemere · 19/12/2023 17:21

dottypotter · 19/12/2023 17:15

People are stretched at this time of year, it's an impertinence to ask people for money for people at work.

An impertinence- oh my !

Some of us actually like to reward those in their admin team or providing support during the year and much better to organise a collection than everyone give them a box of cheap chocolates from Poundland as has been suggested.

People shouldn't be hounded to give though, as nobody knows anyone else's personal circumstances really.

headcheffer · 19/12/2023 17:20

Just give £5 or something??

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 17:20

professionalmum01 · 19/12/2023 17:07

So many jealous people on this thread missing the point. If you can't afford it then don't do it. At one point i was paying £3.5k a month on nursery fee and a £63k salary would just about cover it. And thats just nursery not including other bills. Thankfully our combined income more than covered that but people have no idea how much nursery costs. Its different when they start school. Ours has gone from £1.9k to only £300 a month which makes a MASSIVE difference to our disposable income. You don't need to justify to anyone why you can't afford it. Just be assertive and say you won't be contributing and don't even give a reason. The person collecting won't care as they just want to make sure that noone who is planning to contribute has not forgotten to do it.

Edited

We do know how much the op’s nursery costs are because she put it in her post. It’s £1500- it’s irrelevant that you have paid £3500.

YouHaveAnArse · 19/12/2023 17:17

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 11:07

You know many people's mortgages alone are more than 1.5k a month, right? Especially at the moment.

Edited

Some people's RENTS are more than 1.5k a month. Probably every single one of those admin staff.

dottypotter · 19/12/2023 17:15

People are stretched at this time of year, it's an impertinence to ask people for money for people at work.

rookiemere · 19/12/2023 17:13

It feels like actual gaslighting going on in this thread, with people trying to convince us that actually the OP on 63k is somehow more hard up/hard done by than the admin staff on half of that.

I am on a similar salary as OP and there is no way I would ever express that as only being on £60k, regardless of ones expenses it is well over the national average of £38k and it's therefore crass to act as if it is not a considerable amount.

girlfriend44 · 19/12/2023 17:13

It's dreadful.
If your one of these people that instigates this stop doing it, it divides people.

Ifi you want to buy them a present do, but don't rope other people.

Just give a card saying thanks if that's what you want to do.

JRM17 · 19/12/2023 17:13

Oh you poor skint little pauper, only 63k a year how ever do you manage to fuel your jet. FML. You are earning almost DOUBLE my entire household income just on your own. Give the secretary a fiver and then give yourself a shake.

Niallig32839 · 19/12/2023 17:11

If you don’t want to contribute for whatever reason you need to have balls big enough to say sorry I’m not going to contribute. For a small sum to someone to show you appreciate them goes a long way though. Secretaries can also have kids at nursery and huge fees to pay too without the 63k salary.

HollaHolla · 19/12/2023 17:09

Sorry, yes, you are being a bit of a dick. 'Only' £63k is a really good salary (unless you suddenly tell us your mortgage is £4k a month, or something), and you should still have cash left at the end of the month.
It's not about what 'the secretaries; earn, but more, do you want to show your thanks for all their hard work, to support you, over the year?
I earn considerably less than you, and am the sole wage earner. I've still spent about £75 on gifts for those who support me at work; including my own team of 16 direct reports. I want to thank them, even if it's just with a token thing.

Pineapples198 · 19/12/2023 17:09

I think it’s ok to be asked. It’s also to say no. When someone asks if you are contributing just say no thanks. You don’t need to explain why. or you could say finances a bit tight this year sorry. Or just give a fiver. I earn £25k a year and manage to give a fiver whenever someone has a big birthday , is leaving or going on maternity leave. your comment about “only” earning £63k is a little unreasonable… that’s a whopping salary I could never hope to earn, last year husband and I earned half that as a combined salary.
But yeah, if you don’t want to contribute don’t. But tell them that. I suspect they keep asking as you haven’t given an answer.

professionalmum01 · 19/12/2023 17:07

So many jealous people on this thread missing the point. If you can't afford it then don't do it. At one point i was paying £3.5k a month on nursery fee and a £63k salary would just about cover it. And thats just nursery not including other bills. Thankfully our combined income more than covered that but people have no idea how much nursery costs. Its different when they start school. Ours has gone from £1.9k to only £300 a month which makes a MASSIVE difference to our disposable income. You don't need to justify to anyone why you can't afford it. Just be assertive and say you won't be contributing and don't even give a reason. The person collecting won't care as they just want to make sure that noone who is planning to contribute has not forgotten to do it.

LlynTegid · 19/12/2023 17:07

Someone giving their bank details via work email (in reality not a 100% secure method) is a person I would only ever had cash to.

The OP may be on a good income and have not managed it well, but the point about others being pestered is a valid one.

Thatswhy11 · 19/12/2023 17:06

63k isn't as much as it sounds BUT it's more than most will ever earn. Is your mortgage high OP? How much do you spend on food a week? If you have a partner why are things so tight?

Howdidtheydothat · 19/12/2023 17:05

Chuck them a fiver and forgo a coffee or
say “thanks doing my own thing and don’t ( or bring them in something from home ( crafts from kids?)”

Notamum12345577 · 19/12/2023 17:03

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 09:34

@Autumnalday @MargotBamborough i genuinely cant understand how 1,550 on nursery fees (after the tax free part), doesn’t explain why I have no money left at the end of the month? 63k after tax and student loans is not much more than that and I have a mortgage, food, petrol costs. Do people think 63k is easily covering this stuff because sadly it is very tight

If you are paying full time nursery costs your DH/DP is I assume working full time? So if they are only on minimum wage you would have a household income of at least 80k a year? So you can’t claim you are paying the nursery fees out of 63 when there is another wage to add to that.