Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think being asked for money at work like this is not ok?

612 replies

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 08:48

I don’t know if I’m feeling sensitive about money and actually this is totally reasonable…

We have one dc in full time nursery costing 1500 a month. I work for a professional services company and we have a lot of support staff. We are seen to be paid huge money. However I am only on 63k and we are struggling so much at the moment, some people more senior are on well over this with grown up dc. A month ago a Teams message was started by someone senior saying does anyone want to pitch in for a gift for the secretaries. I found this very inappropriate on teams as it was difficult to say no in a group chat.

I know the answer in practice is just don’t give anything if you can’t afford it but I’ve since been chased on a separate teams message asking if I am contributing and when I ignored that I got an email.

I feel this puts so much pressure on people and think it is massively inappropriate thing to do at work? Am I being a dick?

OP posts:
Vintageport · 19/12/2023 10:42

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 10:39

On what planet do you think someone with a child can just choose to have a smaller mortgage and lower outgoings?

The OP couldn't realistically choose to do this even if she did as you suggested and got a lower paid job or went part-time so she paid less tax. The only consequence of that would be that the OP would both have less money for herself and be paying less tax into the pot to pay for child benefit and childcare costs for lower earners.

Honestly, some of these comments are absolutely bonkers.

On what planet do you think having a child means you have to have a high mortgage and high outgoings?

I have a child and I don’t have a mortgage at all!

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 19/12/2023 10:41

Message the person collecting and telling them that you can't contribute this year.
If you have contributed in the past it's reasonable to be asked. It's not like new ground is being broken here.
Hang on in there. Nursery years are painful.

emmylousings · 19/12/2023 10:41

I loathe the obsession with gifting in office workplaces. People don't deserve gifts for doing the job, they are paid for it. I find the idea that anyone who leaves needs a leaving gift...why?
The motivation for people who instigate this is performative....they love shopping / buying stuff ( the ones who take on task of choosing the gift) and a bit if boredom relief. I really resent being expected to chip in for gifts for people I barely know and don't care about. And don't get me started on maternity gifts...usually some totally overpriced basket with a baby towel and some soap or whatever...only £60 from some RIP off 'niche' retailer. Could buy items for under a tenner in supermarket.
I used to go along with it resentfully now I'm a grown up who just ignores or says 'no thanks'.
Also the OPs main concern is that she doesn't want to appear tight to colleagues, but she should be prepared to own it. And yes you should be able to handle that if you a professional earning 64k.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 10:39

Sugarsun · 19/12/2023 10:33

🤣🤣🤣

You do realise that earning £63k a year is a choice don’t you?

You could get a job earning less or even go PT and then you wouldn’t have to pay as much tax.

You could even not choose to have such a high mortgage or such high outgoings.

Earning a high salary is a positive thing, if it wasn’t then people wouldn’t strive for it.

If you’re unhappy earning £63k and think that people on £20k have it easier or similar, then stop earning so much.

I can guarantee that you won’t though, because you know that at £60k you have much more disposable income than someone on half of that.

On what planet do you think someone with a child can just choose to have a smaller mortgage and lower outgoings?

The OP couldn't realistically choose to do this even if she did as you suggested and got a lower paid job or went part-time so she paid less tax. The only consequence of that would be that the OP would both have less money for herself and be paying less tax into the pot to pay for child benefit and childcare costs for lower earners.

Honestly, some of these comments are absolutely bonkers.

PosyPrettyToes · 19/12/2023 10:39

£63k is a take home of about £3700 a month though? So even with £1500 in nursery fees you should still have over £2k every month? You say ‘we’, so I assume you also have a partner therefore there is a second household income? What on earth are you doing with your money that you only have £58 quid?? Also, you mention that one of the secretaries is on £33k - their entire take home pay is less than what you have left over after nursery fees.

Vintageport · 19/12/2023 10:38

Sugarsun · 19/12/2023 10:33

🤣🤣🤣

You do realise that earning £63k a year is a choice don’t you?

You could get a job earning less or even go PT and then you wouldn’t have to pay as much tax.

You could even not choose to have such a high mortgage or such high outgoings.

Earning a high salary is a positive thing, if it wasn’t then people wouldn’t strive for it.

If you’re unhappy earning £63k and think that people on £20k have it easier or similar, then stop earning so much.

I can guarantee that you won’t though, because you know that at £60k you have much more disposable income than someone on half of that.

Exactly. If it was the case that people who earn £23000 have very similar spending power to those on £63000, why would anyone bother themselves to do it?

Surely they would all quit and get a nice part time job, and still be able to live a very similar lifestyle.

In fact- why would employers spend so much on salaries if their staff could all be perfectly happy on £23,000? They wouldn’t need to worry about offering more money to attract talent and stop people jumping ship to higher paid roles, because no one would need a higher paying role!

BouncingJAS · 19/12/2023 10:36

@kimchio

What planet are you on?

As a high earner she pays the full whack for nursery fees.

She effectively subsidises the lower earners who get anywhere from 30% to 85% reduction in nursery fees.

Its one of the main reasons why higher earners are having less children: nursery fees are crippling many families.

Worried234 · 19/12/2023 10:36

PhulNana · 19/12/2023 10:15

There must be a lot of us bitter types about. Maybe the supply of Murphy's Stout needs increasing?

Obviously there are a lot of you about. How proud you must be.

Savoury · 19/12/2023 10:34

@xmasmoney i agree actually and why single out the secretaries? Why not the cleaners/security/graduates who also also poorly paid?

As for those saying that you should be able to afford it, that’s 3K before tax you’re spending on nursery before transport, clothes and lunches. These are the hard years.

I buy my assistant a present directly because i choose to. I wouldn’t expect others to join in.

Tistheseason23 · 19/12/2023 10:33

I don’t think it’s shitty to point out that £63k is a well above average wage. Plus she chose to share her wage and call it ‘only 63k.’ Presumably she is not stupid if she earns that much so why say ‘only’ as if she thinks it’s not much. I don’t get that.

Sugarsun · 19/12/2023 10:33

BouncingJAS · 19/12/2023 10:15

The "woe is me" attitude in these threads when someone posts a non-poverty income is simply insufferable.

Enough. That £63k person is paying a lot of tax in order to subsidise the people that are complaining. On top of very high nursery fees.

Its astonishing this even needs to be explained to you folks.

🤣🤣🤣

You do realise that earning £63k a year is a choice don’t you?

You could get a job earning less or even go PT and then you wouldn’t have to pay as much tax.

You could even not choose to have such a high mortgage or such high outgoings.

Earning a high salary is a positive thing, if it wasn’t then people wouldn’t strive for it.

If you’re unhappy earning £63k and think that people on £20k have it easier or similar, then stop earning so much.

I can guarantee that you won’t though, because you know that at £60k you have much more disposable income than someone on half of that.

Blah12345678999 · 19/12/2023 10:30

Hmmm tbh if the secretaries were paid fairly there wouldn’t be this issue in the first place…

kimchio · 19/12/2023 10:30

Don't pleed poverty with your 63K. Your nursery fees are the same as anyone else's with a child. And they are a choice.

Fine to say sory moneys tight this year but please don't pleed poverty you'll look a fool

Shakeylegs · 19/12/2023 10:28

LeroyJenkinssss · 19/12/2023 10:04

@Shakeylegs id disagree with you on the gross amount not being relevant. Of course it is. Having ‘only’ £100 spare at the end of the month if you’re on £80k means that you have made (and are able to make) choices on what you want to prioritise your spending on. Having £100 spare when you’re on £20k means that you have to have a very tight control on your budget.

now I don’t think that the OP should have to bung in more than a fiver but £63k plus a partner who earns even taking into account nursery and mortgage means that there probably is a bit of budgeting that needs to be done.

There’s truth in what you say but it’s not necessarily the case all the time. Some people on high incomes really do have little choice. Many people on low incomes have help in other ways. And there are very many people on low incomes who have significant wealth or very few outgoings (eg a lot of pensioners).

IndecentFeminist · 19/12/2023 10:28

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 09:44

@OnlyFoolsnMothers thanks. It’s upsetting to read people saying how can I not afford it on this salary. I don’t do anything lavish or buy clothes often but sadly when 2k a month is spent on your child with nursery, petrol, food, etc, it leaves very little for your own mortgage and life. I don’t even get child benefit. I have no idea why people think 63k ca stretch further than it does.

Presumably though the lower paid staff members are also affected by the cost of living crisis, nursery fees etc. But on half your income.

moomoomoo27 · 19/12/2023 10:28

People don't go to work to be asked for money, they go to work to make money. Being asked to buy/pay for things like that at work is just annoying. I used to work at a place where the receptionist regularly sent around an all-staff email to buy from their makeup MLM and it was highly irritating.

Having said that if I were struggling on 63k I'd be looking at my finances because something is definitely wrong there.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 10:25

ShyMaryEllen · 19/12/2023 10:24

I don't know why the OP had to tell us her salary, as that was guaranteed to divert the thread into comparisons with others' earnings, but in principle it doesn't matter what she earns - she earns it and it is up to her how she spends it. I don't like assumptions about how much people 'can afford', whether it's for means-testing or expectations of generosity. Most people live up to their means.

I also think that buying gifts for the lower paid is condescending. They earn their money too. Lobby for them to be paid more if you want to help, but emphasising the hierarchy may very well make them feel patronised.

Not replying is not the way to deal with this sort of thing though. If you've ever organised anything in a work situation you'll know how annoying it is when people don't get back to you until the last minute then expect to join in, and how tricky it can be to know when to build in a deadline. A quick 'no thanks' to the organiser if you don't want to do it publicly (and why should you?) is fine.

Yes, if the general consensus is that the admin staff are hard up because they are poorly paid, surely the answer is for their actual employer to give them a Christmas bonus or even a pay rise.

beanontoast · 19/12/2023 10:25

YANBU. Being asked once is fine IMO - you are on 63k and secretaries are on nowhere near that - but being hounded loads is too much. I would reply to the email saying as much. No response is a response - no.

Beautiful3 · 19/12/2023 10:25

They're chasing you because you're not giving an answer. You need to decide what you want to do. Do you want to say, sorry nothing from me this year as I'm struggling financially. Or would you rather pick a figure you can afford and suggest that? E.g. Hi money's a bit tight at the moment, but I'm happy to donate £20.

MarkWithaC · 19/12/2023 10:24

Pigeonrific · 19/12/2023 10:05

People on above 40k who whinge have generally made poor choices in spending and bought for example the most expensive house, car and other things they possibly can then are shocked when the repayments are high. Buying cheaper things is always better no matter what salary you are on.

That's hilarious. What a sweeping statement.
And have you never heard of 'Buy cheap, buy twice'?

ShyMaryEllen · 19/12/2023 10:24

I don't know why the OP had to tell us her salary, as that was guaranteed to divert the thread into comparisons with others' earnings, but in principle it doesn't matter what she earns - she earns it and it is up to her how she spends it. I don't like assumptions about how much people 'can afford', whether it's for means-testing or expectations of generosity. Most people live up to their means.

I also think that buying gifts for the lower paid is condescending. They earn their money too. Lobby for them to be paid more if you want to help, but emphasising the hierarchy may very well make them feel patronised.

Not replying is not the way to deal with this sort of thing though. If you've ever organised anything in a work situation you'll know how annoying it is when people don't get back to you until the last minute then expect to join in, and how tricky it can be to know when to build in a deadline. A quick 'no thanks' to the organiser if you don't want to do it publicly (and why should you?) is fine.

snoozylulu · 19/12/2023 10:22

You're getting a kicking, OP, but £63k is not that much, especially not in London. I'm on £67k since July and have not had children yet because I wouldn't be as comfortable as I want to be; it's only recently that I've felt like it might be possible.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 10:21

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 19/12/2023 10:11

OP, you keep saying that your financial issues are because of nursery fees, but you said in your OP that these are £1500 per month. Given that you're on £63k and I presume that your partner is earning at least minimum wage, that still leaves quite a lot each month - more than some households earn in total even before childcare costs are factored in. Have you massively overstretched yourself on mortgage payments or something?

A lot of people are massively overstretched on mortgage payments at the moment due to interest rates suddenly skyrocketing. My friends are having to consider selling the house they bought in 2016 because they can't afford an extra 900 quid a month to service the mortgage.

The OP says she has been asked to contribute because she is "senior" but that the other people contributing are on higher salaries than her.

If the OP is on 63k with student loan repayments, nursery fees and suddenly having to find a lot more money each month because her fixed rate has come to an end, she's going to be a lot more strapped for cash than a "senior" colleague in their 50s on 80k with no student loan repayments, no nursery fees and their mortgage all paid off. But according to the company they are both "senior" enough to contribute to Christmas presents.

It's just generally a bad idea to make assumptions about what other people whose circumstances you know very little about ought to be able to afford on their salaries.

pretzelbreath · 19/12/2023 10:20

OdeToBarney · 19/12/2023 10:10

@pretzelbreath and all the other comments are equally shitty. OP has not made herself look bad at all. It's all the "how dare she earn £63k AND complain about not having spare cash" people that look bad. Imagine being so self-centred that you can't imagine someone being tight for cash after paying back a plan 2 student loan, £1,500 a month nursery fees, mortgage, feeding and clothing their children, buying petrol, paying their energy bills, council tax. Yes of course other people will also be struggling, but it is the picking on OP purely because they earn more and therefore they can't possibly be struggling at all!

Happy to be a shitty person in your eyes then to be honest. Will await you slagging off every other poster in here rather than just aiming it at me because I dared to post my own salary. And actually it wasn't the fact that OP earns such an amount AND complained about not having spare cash that got people's backs up. That's a very simplistic view. The OP's mention of their salary was tone deaf. Their repeated comments about the secretary's earnings and their partners earrings are tone deaf. There was no need at all for the OP to claim they 'only' earn £63k. It bares no relevance to the situation in reality.

SuspiciousSue · 19/12/2023 10:18

Did the sarky posters read the part where the OP said she has monthly nursery bills of £1500 and credit card debt? Just because she’s on £63k, it doesn’t mean she has loads of spare cash every month 🙄

Dont put money in if you can’t afford it, your family is more important. We had to stop foodbank donations for the last 6 months as I got made redundant and will only restart from this payday as it’s my first full pay packet. Got to think of yourself first sadly 🤷‍♀️