Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think being asked for money at work like this is not ok?

612 replies

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 08:48

I don’t know if I’m feeling sensitive about money and actually this is totally reasonable…

We have one dc in full time nursery costing 1500 a month. I work for a professional services company and we have a lot of support staff. We are seen to be paid huge money. However I am only on 63k and we are struggling so much at the moment, some people more senior are on well over this with grown up dc. A month ago a Teams message was started by someone senior saying does anyone want to pitch in for a gift for the secretaries. I found this very inappropriate on teams as it was difficult to say no in a group chat.

I know the answer in practice is just don’t give anything if you can’t afford it but I’ve since been chased on a separate teams message asking if I am contributing and when I ignored that I got an email.

I feel this puts so much pressure on people and think it is massively inappropriate thing to do at work? Am I being a dick?

OP posts:
MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 15:04

LightToTheWorld · 19/12/2023 15:00

No one has assumed OP is able or willing to contribute though- they have asked a question. She hasn't answered it so they've asked again.

It's a reasonable assumption that senior staff have the ability to say yes or no. No one cares whether OP contributes or not- someone has just been given the job of doing the collection and wants to cross her off the list one way or the other. They certainly don't want a lecture on the cost of living.

If you don't want a lecture on the cost of living, don't bloody chase people if you've asked them once and they haven't responded!

LightToTheWorld · 19/12/2023 15:00

No one has assumed OP is able or willing to contribute though- they have asked a question. She hasn't answered it so they've asked again.

It's a reasonable assumption that senior staff have the ability to say yes or no. No one cares whether OP contributes or not- someone has just been given the job of doing the collection and wants to cross her off the list one way or the other. They certainly don't want a lecture on the cost of living.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 14:51

myphoneisbroken · 19/12/2023 14:47

Oh my god DO NOT send this message - it is the worst sort of preachy virtue signalling (and I speak as a preachy virtue signaller myself). If I received this from a member of staff, my eyes would roll themselves out of their sockets.

You have two good choices: give a fiver, or reply to say "I'm sitting this one out".

That's just your opinion though.

I think it is a reasonable point that the business itself should be thanking its staff at Christmas, particularly the lower paid ones, or ideally paying them properly in the first place.

Making assumptions about which staff are deserving or in need of a little extra at Christmas and which staff can afford to put their hands in their pockets to pay for it is inherently problematic, especially in the current climate.

myphoneisbroken · 19/12/2023 14:47

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 13:15

@xmasmoney If you are still reading, you may want to consider raising this with the organiser in a polite way.

Something like this:

"I know it is traditional for senior members of staff to contribute to Christmas gifts for admin staff on the grounds that they aren't as well paid as us. However, taking the view that senior staff are well paid enough to afford this is somewhat simplistic, especially in the current economic climate. My salary is lower than that of other senior people due to my level of experience, and I am the main breadwinner supporting my family with very high outgoings. This year I really have no spare cash at all, but feel awkward saying so or declining to contribute because on paper I earn a decent salary. I don't know whether anyone else is in the same boat but I think it is increasingly difficult to make assumptions about what people can afford, especially given people's vastly different circumstances in terms of housing costs, childcare and student loans, which are largely age dependent. I also think that if admin staff are seen to be more deserving or more in need of a gift at Christmas due to their lower salaries, it will make a bigger difference to them if the business can ensure that they are getting inflation beating pay rises each year and ideally some sort of Christmas bonus. It is far more transparent to thank admin staff officially, taking into account what the business can afford based on known and transparent factors, than it is to ask individual members of staff to contribute when their own financial circumstances are not known."

Oh my god DO NOT send this message - it is the worst sort of preachy virtue signalling (and I speak as a preachy virtue signaller myself). If I received this from a member of staff, my eyes would roll themselves out of their sockets.

You have two good choices: give a fiver, or reply to say "I'm sitting this one out".

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 14:23

FreebieHound · 19/12/2023 14:16

Incorrect assumptions? You've made a fair few yourself. No doubt this will astound you, but many people working in admin/other low-income jobs are also graduates with student loans to repay - and the lowest threshold for this just over £22k per annum. Some have children, and those who don't are subsidising those who do, just like any other childless people working full-time and paying tax.

I can certainly imagine/understand why a homeowner whose household income is well over the national average and has only one child might have no money left at the end of the month, but I don't think that person is justified in being mean about a small contribution to a Christmas gift for support staff.

Edited

Paying 22 quid a month towards your student loan is not the same as paying 300+ quid a month towards your student loan, is it?

Honestly. If you can understand why someone in the OP's position might have no money left at the end of the month, surely you can understand why someone with no money left at the end of the month does not want to contribute money they don't have towards a Christmas present fund on the basis of someone else's assumption that they can afford it.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 14:20

Boomboom22 · 19/12/2023 14:01

But not quite enough to realise those with normal 25 to 50k salaries also pay the same for nursery, food, mortgage etc with no more help except child benefit.

Edited

The point is that they don't all have exactly the same expenses.

Your point would be a valid one if the OP had specified that the admin staff whose Christmas gift she is being asked to contribute to all have exactly the same circumstances she does only their salaries are lower.

People's actual and varied circumstances are so different and the factor that makes the biggest difference in reality is your age, not your gross salary.

If the OP's net take home pay is 3500 per month and she pays 1500 in nursery costs, that leaves 2000 per month. According to the Money Supermarket mortgage calculator if you have an outstanding mortgage of 220k, which isn't even that high considering the OP's salary and what sort of property that amount will buy in an expensive part of the country, she would be paying around 1250 per month in mortgage costs at today's rates, leaving just 750 for everything else including bills, food, transport etc. We don't know how much her partner is earning, but if it's only a small salary it's not actually that hard to see where their money might be going each month and why there is nothing left over.

Whereas one of her colleagues on 25-30k might be in their 50s and have no young children and their mortgage paid off, or have a higher earning partner meaning their household income isn't that different to the OP's, or be entitled to child benefit and possibly even universal credit to help with their childcare costs.

So no, you cannot assume that the OP's lower earning colleagues have the same outgoings as her, or that they are not getting help either via the benefits system or their family support network that the OP does not have.

FreebieHound · 19/12/2023 14:16

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 12:26

But it is economically illiterate to splutter about someone being on "nearly half" the OP's salary without taking into account any relevant factors about the tax system, the benefits system, the student loan repayment system or the housing market.

And that's even assuming that these people on 30k actually have full time childcare costs which they don't get any help with. Nothing in the OP's posts indicates that this is the case.

So the reality is that the gap in disposable income between the OP and an admin assistant on 30k may be minimal or indeed non existent.

It is definitely economically illiterate not to be able to understand why the OP isn't rolling in it on a salary of 63k with high taxes, student loan repayments, full time childcare costs, credit card debt, a mortgage and a partner who doesn't earn very much, and why she might have £58 in her bank account in the week before Christmas and not feel able to contribute to a gift for someone on £30k who may well have far more in their bank account than she does.

None of this judgement and none of these most likely incorrect assumptions about the OP's lifestyle are going to change the fact that she is currently skint.

Incorrect assumptions? You've made a fair few yourself. No doubt this will astound you, but many people working in admin/other low-income jobs are also graduates with student loans to repay - and the lowest threshold for this just over £22k per annum. Some have children, and those who don't are subsidising those who do, just like any other childless people working full-time and paying tax.

I can certainly imagine/understand why a homeowner whose household income is well over the national average and has only one child might have no money left at the end of the month, but I don't think that person is justified in being mean about a small contribution to a Christmas gift for support staff.

Missingmyusername · 19/12/2023 14:16

SecondUsername4me · 19/12/2023 13:55

Errrr...don't secretaries working ft also need full time childcare too OP? At over 1k pcm? And they probs earn a third of your wage.

Never mind. They’ll have the chocolate to eat🤣- that’s a joke btw!

Gettingbysomehow · 19/12/2023 14:07

Grey rock....unless its a friend. I can't afford to give money for people I don't know. I'm not on 63K though but I can imagine London could eat that in one sitting with a big mortgage.

Gettingbysomehow · 19/12/2023 14:05

I totally ignore any requests for money at work.

pretzelbreath · 19/12/2023 14:05

I think the OP's choice to use 'only £63k' was very deliberate actually. It's certainly caused quite a stir up on MN on a Tuesday morning.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 19/12/2023 14:02

SecondUsername4me · 19/12/2023 13:55

Errrr...don't secretaries working ft also need full time childcare too OP? At over 1k pcm? And they probs earn a third of your wage.

I'm just wondering about the folk who are serving your coffee, your meal deal and your grocery shop when you are living in London - like where do these people live and what are they paying to travel into London?
If only the OP omitted the word 'only' , then this thread would have been a lot more sympathetic.

Boomboom22 · 19/12/2023 14:01

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 13:59

Someone with basic economic literacy who is sick and tired of seeing the same idiot responses time and time again on these threads.

"You're rich! I only earn half that! You shouldn't have such an expensive mortgage!"

But not quite enough to realise those with normal 25 to 50k salaries also pay the same for nursery, food, mortgage etc with no more help except child benefit.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 13:59

ilovesooty · 19/12/2023 13:55

Who are you to tell other people to be quiet?

Someone with basic economic literacy who is sick and tired of seeing the same idiot responses time and time again on these threads.

"You're rich! I only earn half that! You shouldn't have such an expensive mortgage!"

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 13:58

SecondUsername4me · 19/12/2023 13:55

Errrr...don't secretaries working ft also need full time childcare too OP? At over 1k pcm? And they probs earn a third of your wage.

Do they? Says who?

They might all be in their 50s for all we know.

SecondUsername4me · 19/12/2023 13:55

Errrr...don't secretaries working ft also need full time childcare too OP? At over 1k pcm? And they probs earn a third of your wage.

ilovesooty · 19/12/2023 13:55

BouncingJAS · 19/12/2023 09:57

@MarkWithaC

Agreed.

MN is full of bitter women who seem unable to comprehend that in London salaries are not low like in the rest of the country because of a much higher cost of living.

So just be quiet. All of you. Its tiring to see this type of nonsense always rear its head like clockwork.

Who are you to tell other people to be quiet?

lndnbrdge91 · 19/12/2023 13:53

The management of the business who are on the high salaries should be the ones to reward staff with gifts etc, not co-workers. Let's also remember that the secretaries and admin staff should be valued through a reasonable wage which reflects their responsibilities. If it is about showing appreciation then surely a card or a kind word is enough? Why should the OP supplement their pay/remuneration?

It's not just income but outgoings that mean people struggle, especially at this time of year.

MargotBamborough · 19/12/2023 13:51

Basilthymerosemary · 19/12/2023 13:48

If you are struggling that much you are living above your means and need to adjust spending.

£1500 a month of nursery fees is very normal, on top of mortgage and other bills.

It's entirely plausible that her mortgage payment takes up almost her entire remaining net income after nursery costs, especially if her previous fixed rate has recently come to an end.

Basilthymerosemary · 19/12/2023 13:48

xmasmoney · 19/12/2023 09:34

@Autumnalday @MargotBamborough i genuinely cant understand how 1,550 on nursery fees (after the tax free part), doesn’t explain why I have no money left at the end of the month? 63k after tax and student loans is not much more than that and I have a mortgage, food, petrol costs. Do people think 63k is easily covering this stuff because sadly it is very tight

If you are struggling that much you are living above your means and need to adjust spending.

£1500 a month of nursery fees is very normal, on top of mortgage and other bills.

LinneM · 19/12/2023 13:44

Slitheringheights · 19/12/2023 13:34

Only 63k? I’m getting excited for the min wage rise in April. Get a grip

Same😂🫣

Floopani · 19/12/2023 13:34

BouncingJAS · 19/12/2023 12:51

@Circularargument

The "MN middle classes" are having their lifestyles subsidised by hard working people just like the OP who pay a lot of tax but get zero state support.

I have zero sympathy for you folks.

OP is the one that should be pissed off at you folks.

You should be thanking her for working so hard.

Earning a lot of money does not equal working hard. It never has.

Slitheringheights · 19/12/2023 13:34

Only 63k? I’m getting excited for the min wage rise in April. Get a grip

Teder · 19/12/2023 13:22

BouncingJAS · 19/12/2023 12:51

@Circularargument

The "MN middle classes" are having their lifestyles subsidised by hard working people just like the OP who pay a lot of tax but get zero state support.

I have zero sympathy for you folks.

OP is the one that should be pissed off at you folks.

You should be thanking her for working so hard.

My life isn’t subsidised by the OP! I certainly wouldn’t be insulting her, I agree she is not “rich”. Childcare is a huge drain on your finances. I do wonder how well she is budgeting not to even have a fiver. That’s her call though. Nobody has to gift anyone anything.

Just1MoreMinute · 19/12/2023 13:20

Yes, chasing people individually is not on.

ignore the comments of ‘you should be able to afford it’. Nobody is privy to personal circumstances, and it is not the role of better paid employees to subsidise the wages of lower paid employees. It’s management responsibility to ensure people are paid fairly.

regarding showing appreciation to colleagues, if money is tight but you want to show gratitude i expensively, make them something (muffins, cake, knitted scarf etc).

I’ve had plenty of low paid jobs but I’ve never expected ‘presents’ from colleagues. It’s not written into peoples contract that you must give/receive presents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread