Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When one half of a couple is pregnant, should the other partner not be 'allowed' to drink?

114 replies

fishonabicycle · 19/12/2023 08:27

A woman I know is pregnant and has announced that her partner won't be drinking as she can't.

I'm interested to know what the consensus is on this!

AIBU - she is reasonable.
AINBU - she is not reasonable

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 09:49

No one can "allow" or "not allow" their partner to do anything. If she is sufficiently bothered by her partner's drinking that she wants to control it she is in the wrong relationship and should leave when she is able to.

I think alcohol is quite a frequent flashpoint during pregnancy though: a pregnant woman suddenly prioritises her health in a way she may not have done before and the prospect of being drunk and around drunk people is less and less appetising when you are responsible for the health of an unborn child.

If the couple previously moved in quite boozy circles that's likely to drive a wedge between them. Pregnancy was when my ex husband's drink problem became a problem for me: before then it was something which vaguely crossed my mind but because I drank a fair bit too it didn't overly worried me. When I was teetotal for nine months and then afterwards nursing a small baby and he couldn't go a day without drinking four cans of lager in the evening I found it harder and harder to paper over the cracks. It was the main reason I decided not to continue in the relationship. I didn't want my daughter growing up in a home which was dominated by drinking.

But the bottom line is no one can force behaviour on their partner. If it bothers you that much you take responsibility for it and leave.

Sapphire387 · 19/12/2023 09:44

Anecdotally, I have observed in my own life and in my close family and social circle that...

The men who give up alcohol in solidarity while their wife/partner is pregnant, are more likely to be the decent dads who genuinely see parenting as a joint endeavour instead of 'helping' / 'babysitting'.

It's like they can immediately get their heads around the fact that life has to change, and they see it as fair that as far as possible, that change is balanced.

I think it's really grim and distasteful when men go out and get hammered while their partner is pregnant.

I have never dictated it - because both men I have had children with have automatically stopped drinking while I was pregnant.

FluffMagnet · 19/12/2023 09:43

My feeling is pregnancy can be a fucking awful 9 months for some women, and society decides to heavily judge and dictate to women, and impose rules that are often not fully medically accurate (e.g. total abstinence of alcohol, because the NHS decided women cannot be trusted to stick to just a small amount). Therefore, why can't partners also share in some of the rules? It avoids temptation for the woman (mine was salamis and rare steak) and frankly (having read a lot of threads over the years where men don't see any change in their lifestyle and carry on past birth, making them a shit partner and father) prepares the partner for the massive change that is about to occur in their life. Also, partners who go out on any drinking sessions when their partners are 30+ weeks should be judged hard by everyone around them, as they are leaving the pregnant woman up a creek without a paddle should she go into labour or have any complications and need to travel to hospital.

SallyWD · 19/12/2023 09:41

My DH doesn't drink much at all and it never occurred to me that he should stop completely when I was pregnant.
I mean I stopped drinking because I had a baby growing inside me. That wasn't the case for DH!
If either me or DH felt he should stop drinking during my pregnancy then that would be implying that alcohol was a really big deal to us. That alcohol was so important that I couldn't even bear to see my DH having a glass of wine. Not the case. I just wasn't bothered

VisiblyNot25 · 19/12/2023 09:39

It’s completely the couples decision but expecting your partner not to drink for 9 months just because you can’t wouldn’t feel right to me. I did ask my DH not to drink - or at least not to drink above the driving limit - in the 2-3 weeks leading up to my due date in case we needed to get to the hospital.

anythinginapinch · 19/12/2023 09:36

I guess logically that if "we" are pregnant then "we" should both avoid booze.

CremeBrunette · 19/12/2023 09:35

BIL’s partner was heavily pregnant and craving wine and rare steak. It’s not that she had an alcohol problem but we’d gone out and that was what she would have chosen to eat and drink if she’d not been pregnant. BIL decided to order a massive steak and a bottle of red to himself. I don’t think it would have been unreasonable for her to ask him not to drink, he knew how much she was craving that and didn’t give a shit just continued with what he was doing regardless.

If DH was wanting a drink, he’d ask if I minded and I was missing a glass of red, he’d have something else or just not drink that night. We were also due to attend a wedding when I was heavily pregnant, didn’t attend as baby turned up and we were still in hospital, but we’d agreed he wouldn’t drink there so we could go to the hospital if needed.

Pregnancy can create a lot of feeing of missing out for the woman, which the partner doesn’t feel. Some of it is stuff you can’t eat or drink, some of its stuff you can’t do and some of it is having a heightened risk assessment at work and feeling infantilised. So I don’t think she has a problem with drinking if she’s insisting, she’s just very aware of how much her life has changed while his hasn’t at all. Especially at this time of the year, all the drinks and food she can’t have.

When I was pregnant I craved some pineapple. When I tried the pineapple it tasted weird and I didn’t like it, so I started crying. DH didn’t really understand why I was crying but he ate the pineapple, which also made me cry. I wanted the pineapple but obviously couldn’t eat it but I also didn’t want DH to eat it because I wanted it. We just agreed that pineapple was just a trigger food for a little while.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 19/12/2023 09:21

AIBU ?
AINBU ?

Flappingseal · 19/12/2023 09:19

I've enjoyed reading this thread for the various perspectives on this.

maltichi · 19/12/2023 09:19

Someone I know did this with her partner, alcohol isn't an issue for her at all AFAIK. Was purely a thing of I'm not allowed to so he shouldn't be either. She is a bit controlling in other ways too.

Ellie1015 · 19/12/2023 09:15

I am sure for most people it will be lots of individual decsions throughout pregnancy. Even when a big statement like the one you mention is made it will moat likely change throughout.

Likely they aren't buying a bottle of wine to share in weekly shop anymore as not appealing for dh to drink it himself. If he is going on a night out with friends she would probably be happy for him to have a drink.

Most couples I know stop completely when very close to due date and naturally cut back the rest of the time but would still drink when out for dinner or out with friends.

ActDottie · 19/12/2023 09:13

Mehhh up to the couple on question. If the partner is happy with it then fair enough.

Im 36 weeks now and wouldn’t want my husband to drink but that’s just because I’m paranoid baby will be coming soon and he’ll need to drive me to hospital.

Whatafustercluck · 19/12/2023 09:13

I haven't voted but dh cut down on alcohol considerably when I was pregnant. It wasn't so much that I struggled with not drinking alcohol - I didn't. I've just always found it really hard being around drunk people when I'm sober. Dh respected how I felt and was very sensible about his intake and didn't get drunk. We went to Glastonbury when i was pregnant with my eldest and he enjoyed a few drinks but didn't go mad. When you're a couple you make sacrifices for one another. One partner volunteering and respecting the other is entirely different though to the other partner insisting. Got to say though, I chose to be with dh because he's considerate and sensitive to my feelings. Not sure I'd feel that way if he chose to get ratted repeatedly while I was pregnant and became his taxi driver.

CostelloJones · 19/12/2023 09:11

We went on an all inclusive holiday to Antigua when I was 18 weeks with our first - paid an absolute fortune before I knew I was pregnant. Our agreement was DH could drink as much as he liked and do all the activities to make up for the fact I couldn’t 😂

I was quite jealous of the excursions he went on that I couldn’t, but it seemed silly for him to waste the opportunity.

I made up for it in spa time and Tiramisu so we were cool haha

TheBirdintheCave · 19/12/2023 09:08

My husband isn't drinking right now* because I'm pregnant. I didn't ask him to, it's just what he sees as fair. He still has cheeses I can't eat but would draw the line at eating a rare steak in front of me 😂

*Not that we were big drinkers anyway, just enjoyed a cider at the weekend.

AhBiscuits · 19/12/2023 09:03

It depends who made the decision not to drink, him or her.

Everley · 19/12/2023 09:00

@Beezknees I completely agree. I think if one half of a couple is struggling with addiction or similar, in any situation, the other partner should support that in any way possible.

Onionsmadeofglass · 19/12/2023 08:59

I think it can be a lovely show of solidarity from the partner. I don’t think it’s something you can dictate as a pregnant woman but I do think it’s sweet.
My partner never offered but he did stop smoking which was much more important to me as it could actually have an impact on the developing baby and obviously on the newborn’s safety once they arrived.

Mrsttcno1 · 19/12/2023 08:59

I’m currently pregnant and DH still has a drink, neither of us are big drinkers really but he still has his nights out etc while I’ve been pregnant. The only caveat though is we have agreed he will stop drinking completely from about 6 weeks before my due date so that if there was ever a “mad dash to the hospital” he can drive me there and is sober to support me/baby if needed.

LolaSmiles · 19/12/2023 08:57

Is this the logical conclusion of couples announcing "we're pregnant"?

Snarking aside, the non-pregnant member of the relationship doesn't need to stop drinking, unless there's some huge backstory.

If the pregnant woman's attitude and outlook to alcohol is such that she's upset, angry and irritated at the thought of her partner having a beer or a glass of wine because she can't, I'd question her relationship with alcohol before the pregnancy as well.

theduchessofspork · 19/12/2023 08:57

Neither - it’s up to them

It’s not that unusual for one half of a couple to be supportive by dumping drinking or eating healthily when the other is on a health kick

Clarinet1 · 19/12/2023 08:55

I think it’s fine if a couple decide together that this how they will show solidarity through an important time in their life as a partnership. However, if their lives usually revolve around drinking, that is not healthy. For some people staying sober during a pregnancy might
be enough to get them back on a better footing though; The same might apply to smoking.
Also, it might not be for the whole of the pregnancy; I remember a work Christmas do where the boss’s wife was about 36-37 weeks (she wasn’t at the do) but he wasn’t drinking in case he had to drive her to the hospital.

Torganer · 19/12/2023 08:53

Are they doing this for everything (rare meats, soft unpasteurised cheeses, etc.)? Each to their own I guess, but it does sound controlling.

ThePoshUns · 19/12/2023 08:53

If it's his choice then fine.
If not sounds rather controlling.

NotToYou · 19/12/2023 08:52

It's up to them really. I didn't care if DH had a drink while I was pregnant, but tbh I barely drink anyway so it wasn't massively different to normal for me.