Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just ask for the money?

213 replies

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 07:42

I feel like I probably am being unfair. My parents never really worked full time or with any need due to inheritance. They have two homes owned outright and two mortgages buy to lets which are income for them now they are officially retired. They do not have a lot of income and I understand the inheritance has always gone into the properties.

Anyway I’ve had a tough year. They’ve helped me out in the past and I do have the odd 500 quid every so often which I know is very generous. I have recently gone through a separation and my mortgage is 1,100. I could look at moving but obviously comes with it’s own issues like being near dc school and having stamp duty ready which I don’t. I was going to ask if they would give me an amount to reduce the repayments as mortgage is coming up for renewal. Around 50k would reduce then to 780 a month which would be a big help. I’ve checked new interest rates etc.

would this be insanely cheeky? Is it unfair to even ask? I am struggling with the mental stress of being single with dc (yes I have maintenance). It just feels so stressful. What would you do?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 19/12/2023 09:00

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 08:27

@Camorra i don’t know but if parents have money they generally help dc? I know I would with mine

But you've said they're asset rich not cash rich. Where would they get 50k from?

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 09:00

@Z1hun have about 220 equity I think. It wouldn’t buy much here, in fact I think the cheapest house that came up recently was 295, and I want to stay due to circumstances, dc need their family around etc.

OP posts:
User1789 · 19/12/2023 09:00

BMW6 · 19/12/2023 07:50

Well they appear to be financially savvy having bought 2 BTL properties, so why not ask their financial advice rather than a hand-out?

That MAY lead to them offering to sell one of the properties to help buy yours, but if they don't offer I certainly wouldn't expect or ask them to do so.

They'd have to sell one as from your OP they don't have £50,000 lying in a bank account, so their rental income would be halved.

OP has made clear they aren't financially savvy, they just inherited a lot of money.

Cornishclio · 19/12/2023 08:59

Your parents are the same generation as we are and if we had that money we would help especially if a lot of their income came from inheritance. We have benefitted from my mums generosity and we help our adult children too but they don't ask. We generally offer but we do discuss finances etc. Can you start a conversation about how you are struggling and see if they offer?

ttcat37 · 19/12/2023 08:58

Wow. This is peak mumsnet entitled CFery!!

You acknowledge that they will never be able to save the money again but would still be happy to take it? How do you expect them to live in their old age? Do you know how much care home fees are? We have a family member with dementia whose fees are £4000 a month for a fairly basic private care home.

What would you do if you didn’t have parents to beg from? Do that instead.

Z1hun · 19/12/2023 08:58

Would you not be affected by early mortgage repayment charge by paying off £50k?

Also I know its not the point but £70k deposit not including anything your ex partner put down and still paying £1.1k /month. how expensive is your house?? Its rhetorical but that does sound like you have alot of equity or at least a sizable house and I know you said you weren't keen on moving but I think it should be an option.

Daffodilsandbees · 19/12/2023 08:57

Onionsmadeofglass · 19/12/2023 08:54

Massive 🙄 at all the posts telling OP she’s pathetic.
Yes, she’s in a very privileged position.
But this is exactly how intergenerational wealth works. It’s not really about old rich relatives dying and leaving fortunes. That’s very rare, there can be a lot of tax to pay on a big inheritance, and it comes too late in late mostly to make much difference to life outcomes.
Financially supporting your children and grandchildren at key moments in their lives can make a big difference to their opportunities and success in life.
OP is not expecting to be totally financially carried by her parents. What she’s thinking of asking for would enable her to keep the status quo for her kids in terms of schools and the home space after a divorce. At a time when rising cost of living is having an impact on everyone and massive personal financial upheaval because of the split with her ex husband, she is looking at needing to downsize and change schools for her kids. She could absolutely do that, and some families would expect her to do that rather than ask for help, and most families would not be in a position to help anyway, but some families would prefer to put that money into the house and keep those kids in their current school and social environment. The money would be going into property investment, so it’s not like it’s disappearing never to be seen again.

This. This is exactly how inter generational wealth works. I would ask for their advice and help. They may say no and that’s ok.

Tinkerbyebye · 19/12/2023 08:56

YABU. You don’t know their full finances and they may need the money to live of. If you are finding it difficult to cover the mortgage there are other options, sell and buy smaller, get a second job, take in a lodger, extend the mortgage period. Look at those first

Viviennemary · 19/12/2023 08:56

It would be an absolute nerve IMHO. If they offer That's different.

user1492757084 · 19/12/2023 08:56

In your unique situation I would discuss the whole issue with your parents.

They might have other helpful suggestions like visiting their financial advisor with them or them purchasing a percentage of your home or all sorts of solutions!

Do a proper budget so that you have your known parameters at the ready.

If they do not want to help that is their choice and you, hopefully, would not hold their attitude against them.

Vinrouge4 · 19/12/2023 08:54

I would ask. They can only say no. Maybe phrase it as having some of your inheritance in advance then they can decide what to do to make it fair for your brother. I wouldn’t resent my children asking.

Onionsmadeofglass · 19/12/2023 08:54

Massive 🙄 at all the posts telling OP she’s pathetic.
Yes, she’s in a very privileged position.
But this is exactly how intergenerational wealth works. It’s not really about old rich relatives dying and leaving fortunes. That’s very rare, there can be a lot of tax to pay on a big inheritance, and it comes too late in late mostly to make much difference to life outcomes.
Financially supporting your children and grandchildren at key moments in their lives can make a big difference to their opportunities and success in life.
OP is not expecting to be totally financially carried by her parents. What she’s thinking of asking for would enable her to keep the status quo for her kids in terms of schools and the home space after a divorce. At a time when rising cost of living is having an impact on everyone and massive personal financial upheaval because of the split with her ex husband, she is looking at needing to downsize and change schools for her kids. She could absolutely do that, and some families would expect her to do that rather than ask for help, and most families would not be in a position to help anyway, but some families would prefer to put that money into the house and keep those kids in their current school and social environment. The money would be going into property investment, so it’s not like it’s disappearing never to be seen again.

Beezknees · 19/12/2023 08:52

kimchio · 19/12/2023 07:53

Ridiculously cheeky. They'll need that for their care home fees. If you can't afford your house do what you'd do without your parents input

Not everyone ends up in a care home. My grandmother lived independently until she died!

IncompleteSenten · 19/12/2023 08:49

So you want them to either give you probably all their savings or perhaps sell or remortgage one of their properties?

That's a very big thing to ask.

You say they don't offer but do hand over money if asked. Do you think this means they don't really want to but feel put on the spot?

Namerequired · 19/12/2023 08:46

Just because they were given money it doesn’t mean you are entitled to it. I can hardly believe you asked them for 40k and now want another 50k.
The way you speak about how they came by the money and their lack of work is off. Their circumstances are different and you haven’t lived their life. Maybe some day you will inherit from them and you will be better off financially. In the meantime live your own life. If they wanted you to have the money, surely they would offer.

zigzag716746zigzag · 19/12/2023 08:46

I think only you know your family’s situation. From your responses you seem to feel entitled to it, possibly even resentful that you don’t already have it, with reference to your boomer parents, how they have never really had to work, and their expensive holidays, your lucky brother who’s in-laws have done more for him than your parents have done for you, etc.

IdealisticCynic · 19/12/2023 08:46

Plsdiscuss · 19/12/2023 08:38

I'm still aghast that some people on MN seem to believe that teaching your child that adults have adult responsibilities, including financial ones, is the wrong thing to do @IdealisticCynic

Child benefit stops aged 18, lessening the household income. That income can be make or break for some families. If an 18 year old is working full time, why on earth would you not take the life learning opportunity to teach your child that they need to pay their way in life, because their contribution could be the difference between keeping their home or losing it.

You're in a very privileged position if you don't have to ask your child to contribute to the household income when they're earning. Recognise this @IdealisticCynic and stop being "aghast". These teetering finances are real life for many many families.

@Lizsrss You know your parents best. Some parents would prefer to be asked outright so they can say yes/no. Some parents would like you to discuss finances with them, so they can decide if they'd like to help. Some parents don't ever want to discuss money and you'll dent your relationship with them by even mentioning it. Only you know which of these your family fits into. I hope you find the right solution for you.

If a child’s income is needed because a family relies on child benefit to run the household, then yes, I understand it. But there are myriad stories on here of people charging their children rent even when they don’t financially need it. That’s what I’m aghast at.

The idea that someone can’t learn to be an adult if not forced to pay their parents an income is utter nonsense. My parents let my DB and I live with them rent free after we finished uni and started work. It allowed us to pay off our debts, build up a deposit and buy homes. We are both financially independent, professional, functioning adults, despite - or perhaps because of - that help. I will do exactly the same for my children. Why wouldn’t I, when I can afford it?

Yes it’s a very lucky position compared to some. But the OP’s parents were lucky too because they inherited the majority of their money. Why on Earth wouldn’t they help their children and grandchildren?

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 08:46

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 08:35

@Youcannotbeseriousreally fair enough, you’re probably a better person than me!! 🤦‍♀️ I just want the best for my dc and know this would make a massive difference

Give your DC the best on your own metit then.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 08:44

@IdealisticCynic not everyone has pots of money to dish out from or can afford to subsidise adult children, and it's quite naive not to understand that concept.

itismytime · 19/12/2023 08:43

Perhaps asking if they could help each month with a £100 or a good shop to help you cover the mortgage because your not going to be able just to move immediately

MintJulia · 19/12/2023 08:42

So this isn't an emergency OP? You haven't been made redundant and struggling to keep a roof over your child's head?

This is just because you fancy an easier life and want what they have.

Where is your self-respect?

Luxell934 · 19/12/2023 08:39

Sorry why do you think you are you entitled to their savings? Your “pretty sure” they have 50k lying around which you seem to think you deserve somehow. I hope they tell you to suck it up and grow up.

Plsdiscuss · 19/12/2023 08:38

I'm still aghast that some people on MN seem to believe that teaching your child that adults have adult responsibilities, including financial ones, is the wrong thing to do @IdealisticCynic

Child benefit stops aged 18, lessening the household income. That income can be make or break for some families. If an 18 year old is working full time, why on earth would you not take the life learning opportunity to teach your child that they need to pay their way in life, because their contribution could be the difference between keeping their home or losing it.

You're in a very privileged position if you don't have to ask your child to contribute to the household income when they're earning. Recognise this @IdealisticCynic and stop being "aghast". These teetering finances are real life for many many families.

@Lizsrss You know your parents best. Some parents would prefer to be asked outright so they can say yes/no. Some parents would like you to discuss finances with them, so they can decide if they'd like to help. Some parents don't ever want to discuss money and you'll dent your relationship with them by even mentioning it. Only you know which of these your family fits into. I hope you find the right solution for you.

neilyoungismyhero · 19/12/2023 08:37

Not helpful I know but how the other half live...sigh

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 19/12/2023 08:37

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 08:35

@Youcannotbeseriousreally fair enough, you’re probably a better person than me!! 🤦‍♀️ I just want the best for my dc and know this would make a massive difference

They’ve already given you £40k so they have already been incredibly generous and. I think you should be able to survive , or do you intend to keep on going back to ask for more and more every time you don’t fancy making it happen yourself?