Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just ask for the money?

213 replies

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 07:42

I feel like I probably am being unfair. My parents never really worked full time or with any need due to inheritance. They have two homes owned outright and two mortgages buy to lets which are income for them now they are officially retired. They do not have a lot of income and I understand the inheritance has always gone into the properties.

Anyway I’ve had a tough year. They’ve helped me out in the past and I do have the odd 500 quid every so often which I know is very generous. I have recently gone through a separation and my mortgage is 1,100. I could look at moving but obviously comes with it’s own issues like being near dc school and having stamp duty ready which I don’t. I was going to ask if they would give me an amount to reduce the repayments as mortgage is coming up for renewal. Around 50k would reduce then to 780 a month which would be a big help. I’ve checked new interest rates etc.

would this be insanely cheeky? Is it unfair to even ask? I am struggling with the mental stress of being single with dc (yes I have maintenance). It just feels so stressful. What would you do?

OP posts:
bonzaitree · 19/12/2023 09:46

You can ask and they can say « no »

You could say « look this money will come to me in inheritance eventually. Write me out the will for £50k and I can have the money now when I really need it. »

Baffledandalarmed · 19/12/2023 09:46

TBH I’m not sure why you are faffing about.

You’ve already asked them for £40K before and clearly had no issue doing it. Why the bother over £50K? You’ve already proven you’re a cheeky git, so why change now?

IMO you’re an adult. Act like it. Don’t ask for the bank of mummy and daddy to help make your life easier. If you were on the breadline I might be a bit more sympathetic, but you’re not from everything you’ve said. You just want it a bit easier

CharlotteBog · 19/12/2023 09:45

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 08:30

@Passingthethyme they wouldn’t offer, I had to ask when I was looking to buy my first house. They are the boomer generation and definitely didn’t understand why I needed help with a deposit! But they helped when I explained. For context I am a massively hard worker and always have been, when they contributed 40k I had already saved 35k and I was 22.

Are they a bit dim? How can they not be aware of how much things have changed for the generation below them?

You don't sound like a very close family the way you talk.

I think it will be hard for people to advise on here, because to wonder whether to ask your parents for 50K or not is very far outside most people's experiences.

Somepeoplearesnippy · 19/12/2023 09:44

My sister was in a similar situation about 6 years ago when she needed £70k to buy her ex husband out and reduce her mortgage. She asked to borrow that amount from us. She works part-time on minimum wage and is a full time career for her disabled adult child so what she was calling a loan would actually have been a gift.

My instant response was "sorry, we don't have that sort of money to lend' which was 100% the truth. DH and I had that amount saved but it wasn't saved to become a long term loan to a sibling. It was saved to help our DC with future house purchases and give us a comfortable retirement. Happily my sister accepted this without rancour. I don't know what alternative arrangements she made but her ex has been bought out and she still lives in the property.

Nosleepforthismum · 19/12/2023 09:40

Sorry OP but I cannot imagine asking my parents for 50k to make my life easier. You’re not even asking for it as a loan with any intention of paying it back. I have parents and in-laws who are wealthy and 50k would also make a huge difference in our mortgage repayments and improve our lives. However, their money is theirs. It’s not mine or my DH’s. My feeling of being privileged comes from the security of knowing they would step in in an emergency but other than that we support ourselves as adults with our own children.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 19/12/2023 09:39

It sounds to me that they probably don't have this amount of money to give you as they have put their savings into the property . Certainly worth asking - but it's a lot of money and in all likeliness if they had had any thoughts of helping you financially they would have done it before making the property investment.

Menomeno · 19/12/2023 09:39

Onionsmadeofglass · 19/12/2023 09:29

? No you absolutely shouldn’t be bankrolling her further.
I don’t understand the link with the OP?
You could charge her market rent for her room and put anything above the actual costs to you or anything above what you need to make your household finances work into a savings account for her so she has a rental deposit when she wants to move out.
You could help her set up a standing order of a hundred or two per month from her main account into her savings account the day after she’s paid so she starts building up savings instead of wasting 1000 pounds a month on stuff.

Sorry, thought I’d quoted @IdealisticCynic saying she’s “aghast” at parents charging their children rent, but I must have just replied 🤦🏻‍♀️. Believe me, I’ve tried to encourage her to save but there’s always a reason why she can’t this month (according to her).

LolaSmiles · 19/12/2023 09:37

Regardless I know 50k is a lot and previously I was given 40k when I bought my first home 8 years ago. It is not unusual with our friends/relatives to hand over this sort of money so I don’t think 50k is an insane amount but I don’t want to put them in an awkward position either

You've had £40,000 given to you and now you want to ask for another £50,000 because you'd rather have a smaller mortgage?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 19/12/2023 09:37

There is no way I would ask my elderly parents, who don't have a massive income, for £50k. If they offered it I think it would be fine to accept, but they haven't offered, because they don't have lots of cash sitting spare.

I also think it would cause them great anxiety to know that their adult child needs this level of support from them.

DottieMoon · 19/12/2023 09:36

It is not unusual with our friends/relatives to hand over this sort of money so I don’t think 50k is an insane amount but I don’t want to put them in an awkward position either

Crikey! You say is it insanely cheeky and unfair.....YES IT IS! But form the above that you wrote, it doesn't actually sound like to think it is. I wouldn't dream of asking. You made your bed so lie in it.

HerMammy · 19/12/2023 09:35

@Jeezypeepers
Not on the same scale, during covid my Sils business was struggling, I gave him £10k l, I wasn't going to see their business collapse and my DD struggle. That's what families do

IdealisticCynic · 19/12/2023 09:32

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 08:44

@IdealisticCynic not everyone has pots of money to dish out from or can afford to subsidise adult children, and it's quite naive not to understand that concept.

Agreed. I fully understand asking children to pay rent when it’s the only way to manage. That’s the whole family pulling together to maintain a home.

But that’s clearly not the OP’s parents’ position. Nor is it the position of lots of people who post on MN regarding their children paying them rent even though their mortgages are paid off or they have lots of money. Why not let your kids save for their own home and pay off their student debts? Isn’t helping one’s family the point of having money?

CecilyP · 19/12/2023 09:32

£50,000 sounds crazy. What they are more likely to agree to is the difference of what you can afford and what you will have to pay, eg 300 per month for a year eg £3,600. I know I’d do that for a child who was struggling. Unless of course they’re loaded!

FiveShelties · 19/12/2023 09:31

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 09:27

@FiveShelties wasn’t an intentional drip feed.

Thanks for the replies. Think I will ask if they could help at all and not put a figure on it.

You originally mentioned how you had been given the odd 500!

laclochette · 19/12/2023 09:31

I'm from a family where I would only ask my parents for money if the situation was desperate, like I was going to lose my home... but I've lived long enough and seen enough to know that different families have different cultures. Some of my friends, for example, come from families where the idea of "the family" is much stronger than the sense of the individuals within the family, and that means a lot more giving and sharing within a family than I'm used to. Whereas a lot of people here, including me, come from much more individualistic families. Neither is right or wrong. We are all different!

OP, rather than asking for the money outright, I would ask your parents if you can sit down and talk through your finances with them, because your separation has left you stressed and wondering what the right move for you and your family is now. I'd try to be truly open to working through different ways forward in that conversation - they may have other valuable suggestions, suggestions that aren't giving you £50k outright but which might still help you. A loan, for example, or they put in £50k but a portion of the value of your home is ringfenced in their name for when you eventually sell it; who knows what else. Or they may give you £50k! But you've leapt to one solution here. Your parents sound both financially savvy, and caring/supportive. Why not talk through your worries with them and see if you can work it out, together, rather than leaping to one conclusion alone, and presenting them with a demand.

TheHolyGrailSpeaks · 19/12/2023 09:30

If you do, perhaps wait until the divorce has been finalised in case exDH becomes entitled to any of it.

Elpheba · 19/12/2023 09:29

I don’t think this is unreasonable at all. The money will eventually come to you and they may not realise how much you are paying on your mortgage etc or that 50k (as an example) would make such a difference to your monthly outgoings.
I would ask, making it very clear there is no pressure or expectation, and show the calculations and what a difference it would make. And pps acting all horrified at the thought- her parents are only in this incredibly comfortable situation having hardly had to work themselves due to inheritance so if I were them I would want to help where I could.

Onionsmadeofglass · 19/12/2023 09:29

Menomeno · 19/12/2023 09:18

My kids didn’t go to uni, so were working ft from 18 (apprenticeships). After 12 months they were all earning a proper, decent wage. Am I wrong to charge keep? My dd19 pays £180 a month. £65 of that covers her phone bill. The rest goes toward the extra food that she asks me to buy specifically for her (on top of the normal weekly family shop which she also benefits from), her daily hour-long showers and to repay money she’s borrowed from me in the past. Is it unreasonable to say that if she wants to spend an hour in the shower that she pays for it? Or if she wants expensive snacks she pays for them?

Her keep money doesn’t come close to covering her costs but it’s important for her to start to realise that she is responsible for herself, she’s not a child any more. She has well over £1000 a month left after paying her keep and has zero savings. And you think I should be bankrolling her further? No thank you!

? No you absolutely shouldn’t be bankrolling her further.
I don’t understand the link with the OP?
You could charge her market rent for her room and put anything above the actual costs to you or anything above what you need to make your household finances work into a savings account for her so she has a rental deposit when she wants to move out.
You could help her set up a standing order of a hundred or two per month from her main account into her savings account the day after she’s paid so she starts building up savings instead of wasting 1000 pounds a month on stuff.

Growlybear83 · 19/12/2023 09:29

LightToTheWorld · 19/12/2023 09:07

This thread is a late entrant for the "most shocking thing you've ever read on MN" thread 😂

That's exactly what I've been thinking!

morningtoncrescent62 · 19/12/2023 09:29

As the parent of adult children, I hope they would ask me in this situation. I don't have anything like as much to spare as your parents: if I did, I would rather hand over the money than watch either of my children struggling. Could you open the conversation by asking for some help, saying that reducing your mortgage significantly would make a big difference to you, and seeing what they're willing to offer? That way if 50k is too much of a stretch for them at the moment, they could perhaps offer something lower which would still make a difference to you, but not put them in a potentially awkward position?

Jeezypeepers · 19/12/2023 09:27

@HerMammy exactly. People in Britain are so weird about money; in my community it would be totally normal for wealthy adult parents to help out their struggling children and grandchildren in this way and they’d be happy to do so (as, like with OPs parents, they also benefited from this set up previously)

And those who say their ‘pride’ would stop them asking their own parents for money I think that’s crackers! You’d rather force your children to live in poverty or move away from their support network than ask your mum for a help? Do you think your mum and dad would want to see you struggle when they could make an easier life for their child and grandchild? I would want my kids to tell me how to help them, and if could afford it I’d absolutely do so. Especially had I also benefited from older relatives in this way.

Such a fucking race to the bottom on here sometimes.

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 09:27

@FiveShelties wasn’t an intentional drip feed.

Thanks for the replies. Think I will ask if they could help at all and not put a figure on it.

OP posts:
pinkyredrose · 19/12/2023 09:27

They've already given you 40k and that's not enough? Are you an only child? If not have they given your siblings the same amount?

FiveShelties · 19/12/2023 09:26

Excellent drip with the fact you have already had 40K OP.

anythinginapinch · 19/12/2023 09:24

TeeBee · 19/12/2023 09:18

Wowsers! I've never asked my parents for as much as £50!!! Unreal.
And I do love it when people pull the 'I'm a single mother' card. Me too, so what? My pride wouldn't allow me to ask others for handouts.

Since when was asking loving parents for help, the same as asking for a handout?

Yes ask your parents.