Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just ask for the money?

213 replies

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 07:42

I feel like I probably am being unfair. My parents never really worked full time or with any need due to inheritance. They have two homes owned outright and two mortgages buy to lets which are income for them now they are officially retired. They do not have a lot of income and I understand the inheritance has always gone into the properties.

Anyway I’ve had a tough year. They’ve helped me out in the past and I do have the odd 500 quid every so often which I know is very generous. I have recently gone through a separation and my mortgage is 1,100. I could look at moving but obviously comes with it’s own issues like being near dc school and having stamp duty ready which I don’t. I was going to ask if they would give me an amount to reduce the repayments as mortgage is coming up for renewal. Around 50k would reduce then to 780 a month which would be a big help. I’ve checked new interest rates etc.

would this be insanely cheeky? Is it unfair to even ask? I am struggling with the mental stress of being single with dc (yes I have maintenance). It just feels so stressful. What would you do?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/12/2023 13:25

IdealisticCynic · 19/12/2023 08:18

They have 4 properties! I know my parents would be fine if I asked and would likely give me the money even if it meant selling one of their properties to help me and their grandchildren out. I know I would absolutely do the same for my DC. We don’t really understand the point of money, if not to help out your children.

But if I’ve learned anything from MN, it’s that not all families behave like ours - for us children, even adult children, are always the priority. Frankly, I’m still aghast at how many people ask their children to pay rent once they hit 18.

Only you know your parents and how they would react to you asking though. Given that they are in their excellent financial position as a result of inheritance rather than their own work, I would hope they would be more understanding.

I agree with this.

It sounds like they have a low income day to day but have capital.

This is inherited wealth so in a way family money. It really needs to be invested in a way that means it carries on to the next generation, not just enables one generation never to work.

1mabon · 19/12/2023 13:22

You've got a blooming cheek.

Pinky2121 · 19/12/2023 13:14

I would sell and source a less expensive property. If children have to walk a little further to school -good for their health. Or maybe catch a bus. Helping out is one thing expecting them to solve your problem is another. Have to find another way to live within your means.

gentlemum · 19/12/2023 13:09

I think this is not the best place to ask if you're being unreasonable as I think most people would say feel it's crazy to ask your parents for so much money. From your subsequent replies you've already been given £40,000 plus all the £500 here and there over the last year. I think it's clear you're living a life beyond your means and that is the root the problem. As an adult, and a role model for your children, you should be changing your life to live more independently rather than asking for huge amounts of money.

horseyhorsey17 · 19/12/2023 12:52

Grammarnut · 19/12/2023 12:24

Why is it fair that they should hand over what they inherited? They should be investing it for their future, which is likely to include care costs as they age. There seems to be some objection to having an inheritance which I do not understand. If you inherit something it becomes yours, unless it is an entailed inheritance which is in trust (which they would not be able to give away anyway). The OP is not entitled to that inheritance in any way and they have already had 40k. I am a baby boomer, and have given money for deposits and understand the need, but I also know that I struggled as a young person and so did my contemporaries. Mortgages were outrageously expensive (15% in the mid-80s) and we mostly did not have parents who could lend, let alone give, deposits. Struggle to buy a house, to get started in your job is universal and happens to every generation. Family helps if it can, but mostly it cannot and expecting aging parents (who, not have never, according to OP, needed to work - you should try running BTL - which seems to be a bone of contention) to cut their income in later life is not just cheeky, it is selfish.

Where does it say she's a young person? She could be in her 40s. Statistically (and obviously speaking generally) every generation born from the late 70s onwards has been financially worse off than their parents.

My mum, as a single parent, bought a 3-bed house in Cheltenham in 1979 on a part-time dentist's salary. Yes mortgages were higher but houses were WAY cheaper, especially as a percentage of salary. It was normal for entire households to be comfortably supported on one salary up until at least the end of the 80s. That hasn't been the case for years now. I just don't think the baby boom generation gets this, as this isn't something they've experienced themselves. My parents certainly never have. They think my (slightly above average) salary means I am comfortably off, as they were at my age, but unfortunately, with two teenagers and a mortage etc, it very much does not!

Grammarnut · 19/12/2023 12:24

WhichIsItWendy · 19/12/2023 08:31

Given they've had a MASSIVE step up due to a generous relative, I think it's fair enough to ask if they're willing to pay on the favour and help you out a little (and a lot less than they received).

If they say no, then they say no, but it's hardly cheeky to ask, especially when they've had a huge helping hand in the past that's enabled an easy lifestyle.

Why is it fair that they should hand over what they inherited? They should be investing it for their future, which is likely to include care costs as they age. There seems to be some objection to having an inheritance which I do not understand. If you inherit something it becomes yours, unless it is an entailed inheritance which is in trust (which they would not be able to give away anyway). The OP is not entitled to that inheritance in any way and they have already had 40k. I am a baby boomer, and have given money for deposits and understand the need, but I also know that I struggled as a young person and so did my contemporaries. Mortgages were outrageously expensive (15% in the mid-80s) and we mostly did not have parents who could lend, let alone give, deposits. Struggle to buy a house, to get started in your job is universal and happens to every generation. Family helps if it can, but mostly it cannot and expecting aging parents (who, not have never, according to OP, needed to work - you should try running BTL - which seems to be a bone of contention) to cut their income in later life is not just cheeky, it is selfish.

DriftingDora · 19/12/2023 12:20

IdealisticCynic · 19/12/2023 08:18

They have 4 properties! I know my parents would be fine if I asked and would likely give me the money even if it meant selling one of their properties to help me and their grandchildren out. I know I would absolutely do the same for my DC. We don’t really understand the point of money, if not to help out your children.

But if I’ve learned anything from MN, it’s that not all families behave like ours - for us children, even adult children, are always the priority. Frankly, I’m still aghast at how many people ask their children to pay rent once they hit 18.

Only you know your parents and how they would react to you asking though. Given that they are in their excellent financial position as a result of inheritance rather than their own work, I would hope they would be more understanding.

'Frankly, I’m still aghast at how many people ask their children to pay rent once they hit 18'. It's called learning about how life works, that you need to pay rent, mortgage, bills. It's amazing what people can learn from the experience - and it has the added bonus of helping them to develop a mature and responsible outlook and not sound like an entitled ass by assuming everyone's mummy and daddy have the wherewithal/would be fine about bailing them out....

notlucreziaborgia · 19/12/2023 12:20

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 19/12/2023 10:25

OP isn’t struggling. She’d just like an easier life.

similar to PP who gave money to save sons business. The OP int losing her house, she just wants to pay less.

So?

notlucreziaborgia · 19/12/2023 12:19

I don’t think it’s cheeky tbh. It depends on your relationship with your parent, and you know them better than anyone here does OP.

It doesn’t matter that other people can’t ask their parents, or that their parents wouldn’t be able to help if they did. That doesn’t mean that you can’t, or that your parents aren’t. You’re not obliged to suck it up in solidarity!

Princessfluffy · 19/12/2023 12:10

They are your parents and you are struggling. It's fine to ask them for money.

Be prepared that they may say no and if so try to respect their decision, especially if it would leave them struggling themselves to help you. Maybe there are a range of things they could do to help you.

ManateeFair · 19/12/2023 12:04

Well, yes, 'Can I have fifty grand?' is indeed cheeky.

But you presumably understand the dynamic with your parents better than the rest of us, and presumably have an idea of how the request might be received. And also how you'd feel if they said no, which they'd obviously be more than entitled to do.

However, you presumably don't know what they've actually got sitting in the bank. They own properties but that doesn't mean they've got lump sums of cash hanging around that they don't need.

skyeisthelimit · 19/12/2023 12:04

OP, YANBU. There are hundreds of threads on here about how parents should help their DC and not charge them rent, or help them through Uni, or with a house deposit.

Your parents are fortunate to be in those circumstance. I wouldn't ask them for a sum of money, but explain your situation and ask if there is any way that they could help you. They could lend/give you the money (for mortgage purposes it would have to be a gift though). They could buy a share of the house. There are several options, but they could have other implications, so they should take legal advice.

When my XH left, I was several K short of the amount that I needed to re-mortgage to stay here. I asked my brother to come on the mortgage with me, or if they could borrow and lend it to me, (I could afford it as had been paying far more on previous mortgage), but him and my parents chose to gift me the money (he inherits the family business, so on paper will end up with far more than me and I have understood this since childhood).

I WFH and by them helping me to keep my property, it meant that I also kept my office, and was also one less disruption for DD who was only 4 when her father walked out. It enabled me to build my business up and to be able to provide for me and DD.

Any decent parent, who has the funds, would probably want to help their DC out.

As you say their wills can reflect whatever they do, so that your brother still gets an equal share.

My parents took the view that it was better to help me when I really needed it, rather than leave me money when they go, which would be several years down the line.

bookworm1982 · 19/12/2023 11:54

OP isn’t struggling. She’d just like an easier life.

Pretty sure being a single mum to DC is a struggle.

chiwowowa · 19/12/2023 11:52

Pointless to ask on here. British people can be extremely tied to the idea that they are a super independent lone wolf type and never had a penny of help so you have to do the same or you are a loser - this attitude seems to be super intense on Mumsnet.
I always find those types are the most likely to conveniently forget help they have had, like free childcare from relatives, private schooling or a relative doing most of the DIY on their house at cost price, or winning £20k - nope they'll tell you they did it all themselves. 😂
I agree with the posters saying that inherited wealth should be looked after for the next generation, ideally not frittered away on luxuries or by not working.
And also with the posters who say family should want to help each other where they can financially to make life better for all.

bookworm1982 · 19/12/2023 11:50

I do not think it's unreasonable to ask your parents for help if they are well off and you are not. I would do anything to help my children out, within reason, and would feel sad if they felt they couldn't talk to me about it.

Myself and most of my friends have been helped out by our parents in one way or another, be it small or large. My mum would do anything to help me if I was in a difficult situation.

They might not have the money of course, and I wouldn't just go right in and say 'can I have 50k?' but absolutely talk to them about it. Ask what they can do to help.

Good luck xxx

Grammarnut · 19/12/2023 11:44

Lizsrss · 19/12/2023 08:25

They definitely have at least 50k lying around, maxed out premium bonds and lots of savings account etc but what I meant was they have little income so can’t add to the savings if that makes sense? As for how much savings they have, I have no idea beyond the premium bonds and other general accounts that they use for holidays, which cost at least 5k a time. Regardless I know 50k is a lot and previously I was given 40k when I bought my first home 8 years ago. It is not unusual with our friends/relatives to hand over this sort of money so I don’t think 50k is an insane amount but I don’t want to put them in an awkward position either

They have already given you 40k. It is not your money but theirs'. I wish I lived in social circles where giving a DC 50k was normal. How do you think the rest of us manage?

IMustDoMoreExercise · 19/12/2023 11:39

Please ask them. The worst thing that can happen is that they say no.

HeraSyndulla · 19/12/2023 11:35

IndecentFeminist · 19/12/2023 11:06

Depends on your relationship. I could happily ask mine and they wouldn't resent it. They'd feel comfortable to say no with no issues, similarly if they had access to it they'd want to help.

I agree, very much depends on your relationship.

You wouldn't have to ask my father twice, not that I ever have or have needed to, but there would be no point speaking to my mother. She would just go into one on being irresponsible and stupid.

inamarina · 19/12/2023 11:32

Jeezypeepers · 19/12/2023 09:27

@HerMammy exactly. People in Britain are so weird about money; in my community it would be totally normal for wealthy adult parents to help out their struggling children and grandchildren in this way and they’d be happy to do so (as, like with OPs parents, they also benefited from this set up previously)

And those who say their ‘pride’ would stop them asking their own parents for money I think that’s crackers! You’d rather force your children to live in poverty or move away from their support network than ask your mum for a help? Do you think your mum and dad would want to see you struggle when they could make an easier life for their child and grandchild? I would want my kids to tell me how to help them, and if could afford it I’d absolutely do so. Especially had I also benefited from older relatives in this way.

Such a fucking race to the bottom on here sometimes.

I agree. If it could be possible to maintain stability for the children (especially after a divorce), why not even ask?
Fwiw, my own parents were never in the position to give me such amounts of money, but I know other families where parents paid off their adult children’s mortgage (both children working, so definitely not entitled or lazy) or offered 100 grand towards a deposit.
My MIL is financially more than stable without having had worked since getting married. She helps us and my husband’s siblings out occasionally - not with huge sums, but it’s still very welcome.

Grammarnut · 19/12/2023 11:32

TrickyD · 19/12/2023 11:03

MrsSkylerWhite

‘Very few people have to worry about inheritance tax’

Actually quite a lot do, including us.

That's true enough but most of us cannot dish out 6 figure sums (that's anything over 100k) to their DSs out of income. We would have to sell property. You are being a little patronising here, because the houses owned by the OP's parents are their retirement nest-egg and selling any of it to the benefit of the OP (who is not in dire straits, but just unhappy to have to pay out a high mortgage and essentially is asking for a cut of what they assume will be their inheritance anyway) will reduce their income. They are entitled to do whatever they wish with what they inherited and what they invested, including not leaving it to the OP but to Battersea Dogs' Home. The OP does not appear to understand this, sounding as if they feel entitled to this money and that they have a right to know what their parents did with the 'inheritance' as if blowing it on world cruises would have been inappropriate!

Spirallingdownwards · 19/12/2023 11:31

They have already provided you with a deposit

Their savings are probably there to be their rainy day funds while using their BTL income to live off day to day. If they are still mortgaged as mortgage isn't deductible anymore and they will pay tax on the full amount of rent that doesn't generate much income.

The fact they take £5k only for their holidays suggests they have planned sensibly for their retirement and that there isn't just spare cash around.

Finally stamp duty is only payable upon completion so in theory you could borrow to cover this if you are downsizing or moving to a cheaper area.

We have been generous with our own kids by way of deposits too but having paid these in our minds that is now done and any other money is earmarked for us for potentially 25 years plus of life post retirement and the expenses that will inevitably arise.

LikeAFriend · 19/12/2023 11:16

soemptyinside · 19/12/2023 10:57

Are you missing the point that the parents are retired?

The four houses are funding their retirement - the passive rental income is effectively the equivalent of a pension.

Also, once an inheritance is inherited... it becomes that person's money. People choose who to leave their money to, and that's OK.

If the person who died wanted the OP to have the money, they'd have left the money to the OP.

Retired from what??? They’ve never worked! 2 houses are funding the retirement leaving them with just the 2 homes they haven’t earned for themselves. Fair enough if that was the intention of the original person who earned the money and left it to them, but I think it would be pretty hypocritical of the parents to insist the OP makes her own way when they didn’t.

Grammarnut · 19/12/2023 11:14

You can talk to them about your situation and what you can do. You really cannot ask for 50k which they may not have (i.e. asset rich, cash poor). It is their money and they are entitled to help you or not, as they choose. But if you ask for 50k and they say no, for whatever reason, that is going to sour your relationship. You are a grown up and need to sort your own finances. If your mortgage is unaffordable then you will have to move - or take a lodger, perhaps? As you say, moving is a real hassle so another option is to talk to your lender about the financial situation, there are ways to reduce your payments by deferment, for example. Things will improve.

horseyhorsey17 · 19/12/2023 11:09

I don't think you can ask for them just to give you £50K if they don't have much income themselves, as they'd be better off investing that so they do get some income from it, but maybe an interest free loan?

If they've got tons of cash, I'd ask for the money. But having said that, I've never asked for money so actually I probably wouldn't! When I split up with my husband, I applied for (and got) a better, higher paying job so that I'd have more money. Is that an option?

IndecentFeminist · 19/12/2023 11:06

Depends on your relationship. I could happily ask mine and they wouldn't resent it. They'd feel comfortable to say no with no issues, similarly if they had access to it they'd want to help.

Swipe left for the next trending thread