Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think sister needs to explore different parenting styles... Should I suggest changes?

103 replies

MacarenaMacarena · 19/12/2023 01:59

My dear sister is lovely, but I feel the way she treats her DS(9) is not helping him develop and mature. Some of the things that concern me are

  1. Regularly sleeping with him in his bed (I dread the reaction when he let's this slip at school).
  2. Regularly back tracking on rules or instructions - I feel he would really benefit from consistency rather than ruling the roost with threat of tantrums.
  3. Generally having low expectations of ability and behaviour... Eg toys aimed at younger children, baby talk etc. He seems to restrict his interactions to this younger level (less challenging?)
He's way behind at school, has no resilience and has a very negative attitude to homework/learning/being given helpful advice about how to do anything... Quite abrupt and impatient, and missing out on so many opportunities to discover more about the world. (eg "I don't want you to tell me what the equator/marsupial/delta is in this cartoon, I just want to watch it, don't interrupt") (he does have a rewind on the remote!) I'd like to encourage my dear sister to explore some new parenting techniques, but I realise this is not my business, and I could offend her by suggesting anything. I suppose lots of children grow up perfectly delightful and successful whatever parenting styles they are exposed to - unfortunately my nephew does not seem on track to be doing so well at this rate. I really want to drop some pebbles in the pond to help her... What would MN recommend?
OP posts:
ImustLearn2Cook · 19/12/2023 02:10

Undermining your sister’s parenting would be the worst thing that you could do.

Undermining parents (especially in front of the child/ren or in a way that they notice is detrimental and has very negative impacts on children.

Bite your tongue, keep your opinion to yourself and respect that while your sister’s parenting style differs from yours (or what you imagine yours would be) she knows her own child better than you do.

If you want to be helpful just be a positive role model and a supportive auntie and a good sister.

Sleepydoor · 19/12/2023 02:10

"I'd like to encourage my dear sister to explore some new parenting techniques, but I realise this is not my business, and I could offend her by suggesting anything."

I think you've answered your own question beautifully.

Alex Drake · 19/12/2023 02:07

Leave her to parent her own child?

9yrs is still fairly young. My DS is 11yrs now and would balk at the thought of sharing a bed with his parents now, but would have happily jumped in beside us at 9yrs.

Likewise, at 9 yrs my DS would choose to watch cartoons on TVnow he's all about stranger things and the Big Bang theory, with all the questions that go along with these.

Why are you so concerned about your nephew?