Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not allow 17 year old DS to visit his boyfriend on NYE

266 replies

hulas · 18/12/2023 18:41

My DS is 17 and openly gay, he turns 18 in August and is in his first year of college. He's been in a relationship with another boy since September. Boyfriend lives an hour and half away on the train but they've met multiple times, I haven't spoken to him very much as he's autistic, but he seems to make DS happy.

Boyfriend turns 19 on NYE and DS has asked/told me he's going to visit him either on the train or I can take him to the train station (he didn't ask, just assumed!).

There would be alcohol involved and DS is easily led and the boyfriend doesn't seem very sensible so I've said no (id also be giving him the money for the train)

He's said how unfair I am and that he hates me etc etc and now I'm wondering if I'm BU in saying no. WWYD?

OP posts:
CantFindMyMarbles · 19/12/2023 19:15

He’s 17. Meeting someone off the internet he’s met a couple of times….been in a relationship for a few months. I think it’s fair enough to be concerned but you can’t ban him. I’d just sit him down and have a conversation with him….explain your concerns and the risks.

Nononsensemumsy · 19/12/2023 19:09

YABVU my 17 year old DS would go regardless. He’s practically a grown up, I know it’s hard letting go, but that’s your problem not his.

bananamangoes · 19/12/2023 19:03

You will push him away! You have to let him go a bit

Clarabell77 · 19/12/2023 18:56

What will you do in 8 months when he’s 18?

MeandT · 19/12/2023 18:34

For what it's worth, I spent NYE when I was 17 3 continents away from my parents and yes, there was both alcohol and sex.

So what?

azlazee1 · 19/12/2023 18:33

If he were away at college he would be making his own plans without any approval from you. Anyone in college is a young adult starting to live their own life. Time to start cutting the cord.

laylababe5 · 19/12/2023 18:32

He's nearly an adult. Show him you trust him by letting him go. NYE is a big deal to teenagers. If he's not in by curfew he gets a relevant punishment and knows about it in advance (e.g. can't go on next 3 nights out).

Amista77 · 19/12/2023 18:31

OP, I'm afraid your teens going out and getting stupidly drunk and you worrying about them is part of the course. Although your DS is BU in not working and spending money on things he can't afford (which is also part of the course for many kids) you are also BU in trying to control his behaviour. You can make the new year a chance to change things for both of you - loads of food advice by PPs.

MrsMiddleMother · 19/12/2023 18:30

Wow the responses on this thread would be VERY different if this was a 17 year old girl!

OP I would say no too! 1. Making you pay for him to see his long distance bf is a joke. 2. Not trusting him or his bf to be sensible and they'll be 1.5 hours away. I'd be concerned too. When he's 18 and working he can do what he likes, until then he's a child.

saffy2 · 19/12/2023 18:20

They both sound like very normal 17/18 year olds to me. I regularly got so drunk I vomited and then continued drinking when I was at 6th form and uni, age 17-21. It’s not big or clever, but it’s very very normal. I wasn’t not sensible (am renowned in my family for being the sensible one!) and I was not easily led! I’m very strong minded. It’s just quite a normal way to learn about alcohol.
I learned my limits and changed the way I drink as I got older. As will these two young men.

in my opinion you have no right to stop him, he is practically an adult. And you should be very grateful that he has told you his plans. He doesn’t need to ask your permission.

Middleagedspreadisreal · 19/12/2023 17:39

You do know he's been very, very drunk before now?

boyohboys · 19/12/2023 15:17

On the job refusal thing, I had this so stopped giving ANY money whatsoever as I realised lunch & bus money was saved for socialising which meant zero motivation to get a job. I got a pre-loaded bus pass and made sure there was always plenty for packed lunch & definitely no pocket money for helping out round the house. IMO that's what you do with younger children to try and instil a work ethic so that ship has long-since sailed and by 17 he should be helping round the house AND have a PT job. (my 17 year old is a lazy sod and house stuff is still a bit of a battle but he does at least have a job now and knows if he wants a lift anywhere that refusal to do basic chores does not inspire favours!)

Dutch1e · 19/12/2023 14:50

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 19/12/2023 13:00

Manipulating and controlling much

How so?

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 19/12/2023 13:00

Dutch1e · 19/12/2023 10:33

I think this might be a good time to embark on an 8-month crash course in adulthood to help both of you break out of the negative cycle you've inadvertently become caught in.

In your shoes my first step would probably be to sit down and say "I owe you an apology for treating you as a little boy and I won't do it any more. You're a capable young man with the skills to earn your own money and make your own arrangements. I won't pry into your plans beyond the usual courtesies of letting each other know if we will be coming home late or tomorrow or whatever. With that in mind, I'm happy to give you one last bit of cash to tide you over until your first paycheck, and I won't be available as a taxi/housekeeper/secretary etc. It's unhealthy for us both. I'll supply the roof over your head and the food in the kitchen, the rest is up to you."

If he wastes his time stropping about it then so be it, you don't need to take the bait beyond sympathetic understanding murmurs.

Manipulating and controlling much

Dutch1e · 19/12/2023 10:33

I think this might be a good time to embark on an 8-month crash course in adulthood to help both of you break out of the negative cycle you've inadvertently become caught in.

In your shoes my first step would probably be to sit down and say "I owe you an apology for treating you as a little boy and I won't do it any more. You're a capable young man with the skills to earn your own money and make your own arrangements. I won't pry into your plans beyond the usual courtesies of letting each other know if we will be coming home late or tomorrow or whatever. With that in mind, I'm happy to give you one last bit of cash to tide you over until your first paycheck, and I won't be available as a taxi/housekeeper/secretary etc. It's unhealthy for us both. I'll supply the roof over your head and the food in the kitchen, the rest is up to you."

If he wastes his time stropping about it then so be it, you don't need to take the bait beyond sympathetic understanding murmurs.

Canisaysomething · 19/12/2023 10:05

He’s going to be 1.5 hours away by train staying the night with a guy he’s only ever had a long distance relationship with since September.

I wouldn’t even recommend an adult friend do this let alone someone who only turned 17 a few months ago. He doesn’t know this man enough to be doing this, he is putting himself in a very vulnerable situation.

This would be totally different if this man lived locally.

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 19/12/2023 09:58

hulas · 19/12/2023 08:58

He refuses to get a job, I still give him money for lunches at college etc but most the time he doesn't buy lunch, I also give him money for helping around the house. When he asks for more, I don't give it him. But he often lies and says he didn't spend it

I think posters are missing where I said he will be an hour and half away so it isn't as easy as picking him up again which is making me worry more. I'm not blaming his boyfriend if DS drinks too much but as I said in a PP I suspect DS would drink a lot to show off and try to impress his boyfriend and if they're both drunk they won't have anyone looking out for them.

Of course you can pick him up . He is your son and if he got in trouble 1.5hrs would be nothing.
You are going to have to let go OP

He can’t make good choices if he doesn’t get the freedom to do so or to learns form his mistakes.

pontipinemum · 19/12/2023 09:56

@hulas whilst I don't think you can tell him what to do I 100% understand why you would worry. Where are they planning to stay? Surely he isn't coming home that night. I don't think it is unreasonable to want to know where your 17 yr old will be spending the night.

The money thing though, he needs to understand if he wants to act and be treated like an adult he needs to earn his own money like an adult. At 17 I was working in the local corner shop.

MikeRafone · 19/12/2023 09:36

He refuses to get a job.

Then he needs to be treated like a 7 year old and make his packed lunch each day or go hungry. He wants to buy lunch then he needs to get a job and earn some money. He wants a lift 80 miles away then he needs to be buying petrol or paying train fare

hulas · 19/12/2023 08:58

He refuses to get a job, I still give him money for lunches at college etc but most the time he doesn't buy lunch, I also give him money for helping around the house. When he asks for more, I don't give it him. But he often lies and says he didn't spend it

I think posters are missing where I said he will be an hour and half away so it isn't as easy as picking him up again which is making me worry more. I'm not blaming his boyfriend if DS drinks too much but as I said in a PP I suspect DS would drink a lot to show off and try to impress his boyfriend and if they're both drunk they won't have anyone looking out for them.

OP posts:
shreddednips · 19/12/2023 08:30

He's 17, he's too old to need your permission to go. You'd be totally reasonable to have a conversation with him about safe drinking etc but he's old enough to decide whether he goes or not. At that age it wouldn't have occurred to me to ask my parents if I could go, I'd just let them know that was what I was doing so they knew where I was.

Expecting you to bankroll his activities is another matter regardless of his NYE plans. He needs to get a part-time job to fund train tickets/going out but in your shoes, I would pay for this occasion if I could afford it as it will otherwise look as if you're only saying it to prevent him from spending time with his boyfriend- and it's not like he has time to get a job and get paid before the party.

You need to set boundaries around what you will and won't pay for and have an expectation that he covers his own costs when he wants to go to a party, so he needs an income. So in your situation, I'd sit him down and explain that after this party, he needs to start being responsible for getting himself to and from bf's house and paying for his ticket.

TwoShades1 · 19/12/2023 08:29

I really can’t the see the big issue here? The only problems I see is that he should have asked nicely if you were able to drive/pay for train. And ideally he should be more responsible with money so he can afford trips like this. But that’s not something that can really be fixed or changed between now and new year.

RandomButtons · 19/12/2023 08:28

Did you actually do anything different at 17?

Or are you actually not ok with your son being gay? Saying “openly gay” makes me wonder if you’re not actually comfortable with his sexuality.

He’s 17. Of course he wants to drink and be with his boyfriend. Perfectly normal. Who cares if he throws up? You won’t have to clear it up.

boyohboys · 19/12/2023 08:17

Still not sure why ds doesn't have a job at 17 and you're giving him money for video games or whatever he decides to spend it on then getting overly involved in his spending habits. I have a 17 year old and constantly worry (he's a risk taker and party boy - very different but still a source of constant angst) and you need to help him become independent - if he wants to get somewhere he gets a bus or train and if he needs money he'll need to find and keep get a job. you're doing him no favours op.

Goodlard · 19/12/2023 07:23

Obviously if you wait until he is 18 all these problems will just disappear, he will change over night and everything will be fine.

If you're worried about your nearly 18 year old in a big city, then when is this going to change?

You also seem to be blaming his BF if he drinks to much etc? Why?

Swipe left for the next trending thread