Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools stereotyping autism.

60 replies

Beenpo · 18/12/2023 17:26

Does anyone else find their autistic DCs school stereotypes them? It’s almost as though mine has an autistic child’s checklist and ascribes it to all ASD students.

The reason I post is because I have a 9 year old who is autistic (Asbergers type) and has ADHD. I often find his mainstream school gives him stereotypical autistic traits or blames ‘autism’ in inappropriate situations.

For example, one of my DCs strengths is that they are very flexible and adaptable. They do not mind routine change, if anything we are all a little chaotic in our family (I have ADHD). Today, my DC was upset as something had happened with their friends at school. When the class teacher spoke to me about it, they kept insisting that my DC was upset and reacted in the way they had because ‘Christmas was coming up which is unsettling for autistic people.’ The teacher couldn’t tell me what the actual situation was that had occurred with my DC and their friends, they just kept saying ‘you know your DC’s struggles, it’s that time of year.’

My DC is incredibly happy go lucky,
flexible, adaptable… can’t wait for Christmas and New Year!!

On another occasion they blamed routine change on mufti day for my DCs upset, when actually another child had been mean to them.

Does anyone else find this an issue with their child’s school or other people?

OP posts:
Gran0laG1rl · 18/12/2023 18:35

Shpeech

You indicate a lot of ignorance re autism.

Gran0laG1rl · 18/12/2023 18:34

I have autism and adhd as do my children. I am adaptable however if my bucket is full I am
more likely to get overwhelmed by things.

So yes your son may have been upset over a fallout and not Christmas however if there was no Christmas he may have been better at handling it.

Shpeech · 18/12/2023 17:58

For this very well articulated reason, I don't think labels or diagnosis are always right for someone.
Autism "traits" don't seem to exist as all cases are so different and this lazy teaching, putting children into different boxes, ruling out other reasons, can be dangerous and unhelpful.
From my experience, it used to explain away a lot of different situations.
And if a children copes well in different situations, can handle transitions, plays nicely, etc, then why do they have the diagnosis?

Fionaville · 18/12/2023 17:38

Yes 100%! They used to say my DS couldn't take part in the school nativity or Easter parade etc, because it would upset his routine too much which would make him stressed. Which was absolute nonsense. He's never struggled with routine change, especially for something enjoyable! Funnily enough, when he started special school they all took part in the nativity and were often doing things that weren't part of their routine. Mainstream schools use stereotypical behaviours as an excuse due lack of time, funding and support.

WrittenInBlue · 18/12/2023 17:37

As the parent of a DC with ASD who is not adaptable, at all, I can constantly met with utter shock from his teachers that he still has ASD and is still not adaptable. Every time. So it goes both ways 😀

NeverDropYourMooncup · 18/12/2023 17:34

It's the NT kids that the phrase 'It's that time of year' apply to at work. No problems at all with any ND children, not when you've got over a thousand over excitable and over tired young people to manage for another few days.

Beenpo · 18/12/2023 17:34

@dnasurprise it is very frustrating. I feel as though they aren’t looking at my DC as an individual, or understanding when / why they are upset or struggling, or listening to me, it’s just blaming a stereotypical ‘autistic trait’ whether they actually has that issue or not…

OP posts:
CanaryCanary · 18/12/2023 17:34

Yes, it’s the easiest answer for them when they’re rushed and have 30 other kids to think about. Sometimes you just have to politely correct them. Hopefully you have a report or diagnosis letter that sets out what his strengths are, then you can refer them back to it.

Psychoticbreak · 18/12/2023 17:33

I have asd and adhd and am adaptable too. Christmas does not bother me and while I am atheist and do not do religion I just enjoy my kids getting spoiled. You would think they would be more open minded and not shove everyone on the spectrum as the same. Ignorance.

dnasurprise · 18/12/2023 17:30

yes we have had similar, my autistic son is also really adaptable and flexible about most things.