Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools stereotyping autism.

60 replies

Beenpo · 18/12/2023 17:26

Does anyone else find their autistic DCs school stereotypes them? It’s almost as though mine has an autistic child’s checklist and ascribes it to all ASD students.

The reason I post is because I have a 9 year old who is autistic (Asbergers type) and has ADHD. I often find his mainstream school gives him stereotypical autistic traits or blames ‘autism’ in inappropriate situations.

For example, one of my DCs strengths is that they are very flexible and adaptable. They do not mind routine change, if anything we are all a little chaotic in our family (I have ADHD). Today, my DC was upset as something had happened with their friends at school. When the class teacher spoke to me about it, they kept insisting that my DC was upset and reacted in the way they had because ‘Christmas was coming up which is unsettling for autistic people.’ The teacher couldn’t tell me what the actual situation was that had occurred with my DC and their friends, they just kept saying ‘you know your DC’s struggles, it’s that time of year.’

My DC is incredibly happy go lucky,
flexible, adaptable… can’t wait for Christmas and New Year!!

On another occasion they blamed routine change on mufti day for my DCs upset, when actually another child had been mean to them.

Does anyone else find this an issue with their child’s school or other people?

OP posts:
Sproutier · 19/12/2023 01:00

This sounds like quite a fundamental thing that teachers need to know about him. I would expect anyone who works with him regularly to have read some sort of short profile about him that summarises his needs, triggers, strengths, and any agreed adjustments. Ours are written by the SENCo, based on notes we provided and a couple of handover meetings, and built on over time as teachers figured out what didn't work and fed back to SENCo.

Some school cultures are more open to listening than others. Some of my child's best teachers have been very early in their careers. They have been excellent because they care so much and really listen. But a school can do a lot to meet the child's needs better by ensuring there is accurate, up to date info about them moving up the school with them.

TheWalkingDeadly · 18/12/2023 23:08

Im not sure. Yes all dc are different.
And having a dual diagnosis would make a child quite different to either asd or adhd.
Although in this situation my asd/adhd dc does struggle with xmas. But i dont think its the change of routine as thst doesnt bother her generally.
It is
The extra activities so walks/seeing santa/fayre/singing so extra tiredness
Overexcitement for xmas day
Sort of the change at school to be 'fun' but its not because its a change. Its likely because maybe she doesnt like the endless films they watch etc
But huge issue and its referred to be pp - the fact other NT? Kids are less well behaved tired ill and overexcited. So they are more likely to misbehave and set dd off or distract etc.

Youbcould see after halloween at an activity dd friend was clearly overtired /too much sugar etc andcwas like a 10/10 hyper really set the whole club off and including dd who was becoming more hyper.

The adhd and asd a pretty different as i would expect an adhd child to have friends maybe have conflict and arguments. But equally could be shy.
Vs asd
some kids are not interested in others
Some interested but only while with other kids so happy alone
More likely than adhd to talk at people not pick up on others trying to walk away
Only want to talk about something they are interested in
Not want to go to clubs they arent interested - less likely to follow a friend there. Would quit even if friend still going.

Though inattentive adhd could seem away with the fairies and more interested in own interests.

Since going to secondary irs been clear that environment makes a huge difference. Even change of environment but not because of the change itself but because it has removed all dc crutch (her one friend) do its now clear she cant/wont make new friends. Not one frieǹd so far in her class. So the asd traits really showing. Adhd less so as shes not going to chat through lesson (like she was at a club) as no friends...
Secondary is in some ways more predictable as you have the timetable.
Again moving a set was a big issue not the change but it was really noisy. A lot of work missed and a lot of pressure. Teacher had no idea of sen either.

Oh and the insomnia around xmas and birthdays (which i get too) doesnt help behaviour.

August85 · 18/12/2023 23:06

And if a children copes well in different situations, can handle transitions, plays nicely, etc, then why do they have the diagnosis?

I’ve worked with a lot of diagnosed autistic children and ALL of them struggled noticeably more than the majority of their peers with these things - hence being diagnosed with autism! Are you aware that the DSM-V threshold for diagnosis actually reflects quite a significant level of need? It’s worth reading some up-to-date research about masking too.

QuestBloomingdale · 18/12/2023 22:51

Shpeech · 18/12/2023 17:58

For this very well articulated reason, I don't think labels or diagnosis are always right for someone.
Autism "traits" don't seem to exist as all cases are so different and this lazy teaching, putting children into different boxes, ruling out other reasons, can be dangerous and unhelpful.
From my experience, it used to explain away a lot of different situations.
And if a children copes well in different situations, can handle transitions, plays nicely, etc, then why do they have the diagnosis?

I agree. I thought the same thing. I know there are other aspects but the umbrella term really shouldn't apply to everyone whether they meet 3 or 10 of the criteria.

Beenpo · 18/12/2023 22:48

@YourTruthorMine That’s interesting. I have ADHD but lots of autistic ‘traits’. I haven’t met many people who have been diagnosed with ADHD or autism who don’t have lots of ‘traits’ of the other diagnosis. I wonder if they will ever merge them?

@HeBeaverandSheBeaver I agree, it helps ‘balance’ my DC’s autism. Interestingly, when they were taking ADHD medication, not only did their ADHD symptoms all but disappear but so did their autism. Unfortunately they had to discontinue taking them as it had too much of an effect on appetite.

OP posts:
Zoflorabore · 18/12/2023 22:48

My son was diagnosed in 2011 when he was 8 and our borough told us that he probably would have been diagnosed with Asperger’s but they had stopped using the term. Interestingly, the borough we are next to were still using Asperger’s at the time and many people identify as having AS. He was diagnosed with ASD but was then changed to ASC as condition apparently sounded better than disorder.

my 12 year old daughter was diagnosed last month. We still live in the same borough. Her diagnosis was ASD.
they couldn’t be more different from each other if they tried. My son is extremely sociable but his life skills are lacking. My daughter is extremely independent, can cook, has excellent life skills but hates social situations and making friends.

schools don’t have enough funding to train their teachers enough about autism and it’s co-morbidities. There is so much information to take in and a class teacher has 30 children to cater for. I found that both of mine were let down a bit by their ( same ) primary and I had to advocate for them a lot. Im not blaming the teachers
fot this though. there simply aren’t enough hours in the day and enough money in the pot.

FranticallyFrank · 18/12/2023 22:43

Your child’s teacher is with them all day so it could well be that they are seeing things at school that you don’t see at home. It happens frequently.

School is sometimes the first place that concerns about neurodiversity are raised. Sometimes parents have noticed a few things but it hasn’t been the problem at home that it might be at school.

Behaviour that is a bit tricky at home can be catastrophic at school, eg most children can be defiant at times, but at school can follow rules designed to keep them safe. An ND child cannot follow these rules at school and becomes a danger to themselves, eg attempting to leave the school premises.

elliejjtiny · 18/12/2023 22:42

The problem with having an autism diagnosis is that it's a really common condition and so everyone knows someone who has it and a lot of people think that makes them an expert. We were told that ds2 couldn't possibly have autism from aged 2 to aged 11 because he had friends. At age 11 he changed schools and they said they thought he could have autism. They did a referral and we are still waiting for an appointment with the paediatrician and he is 15 now. They think it will be another 7 months wait.

Zooeyzo · 18/12/2023 22:42

School always say this to me too and I think errr OK not really. My boy is very laid back and as long as he knows what's going to happen even if it's 5 mins before he's fine.
All I've heard this past two weeks is unsettled because of Christmas. But in reality he had worms 😂

HeBeaverandSheBeaver · 18/12/2023 22:34

Yes my dd is adhd and asd

She is ok with change except holidays She likes to be at home however she like xmas
Birthdays. Theatre cinema
Shopping centres and so on

She hates food she feels is unsafe. School. Demands
Planes, small talk too many questions long car journeys

I believe her adhd helps her in a lot of ways. It kind of balances out her asd. Until it all gets too much.

Hotpinkangel19 · 18/12/2023 22:32

DragonMama3 · 18/12/2023 21:27

Asperger's is not used - long story. It got replaced with High Functioning Autism.

But many have an Aspergers diagnosis and prefer to use it. It hasn't been out of use that long.

YourTruthorMine · 18/12/2023 22:25

If you are an autistic individual that copes well with change and is happy go lucky and flexible, then you'll likely get diagnosed with ADHD.

I am one of those people. I believe ADHD is autism

BestZebbie · 18/12/2023 22:17

I suspect that training hasn't kept up with advances in understanding of the variety of needs, also, e.g: going through a visual timetable of the whole day's plan at 8.45am with a demand-avoidant child is not going to improve anyone's experience of getting through that long list of demands...

Hankunamatata · 18/12/2023 22:03

Some of my dc love Xmas and are adaptable however their resilience does become much lower leading up to Xmas. Things they would usually shrug off like unkind comments do seem to hit home more.

August85 · 18/12/2023 21:55

Sunflower8848 · 18/12/2023 21:33

Doesn’t it make you question the whole social concept of “autism”?

No, why on earth would it? In autism research it is widely recognised that while there are common autistic traits, this doesn't mean every autistic person has them all (as the saying goes, if you've met one autistic person, you've met one autistic person). To be diagnosed as autistic you have to meet a certain threshold in certain key areas, but these are by no means the same for everyone. What OP is encountering is a widespread ignorance of what autism actually looks like - many people's idea of autism is still basically Rainman. On my PGCE we barely covered neurodiversity in one afternoon; many teachers are still woefully under-informed about it unless they've had specific training.

Fionaville · 18/12/2023 21:52

Shpeech · 18/12/2023 17:58

For this very well articulated reason, I don't think labels or diagnosis are always right for someone.
Autism "traits" don't seem to exist as all cases are so different and this lazy teaching, putting children into different boxes, ruling out other reasons, can be dangerous and unhelpful.
From my experience, it used to explain away a lot of different situations.
And if a children copes well in different situations, can handle transitions, plays nicely, etc, then why do they have the diagnosis?

My child handles transitions well and changes in routine. However he bounds around stimming and spinning, talks to himself (echolalia) and has a low comprehension level. He has classic autism (special school) anybody watching him from a mile away would spot the traits. It is a spectrum in that some of his peers love to hug, any time, any place, anywhere. Whereas he's not a hugger, unless he instigates it. Some of his peers hate suprises and change. He quite likes them usually. Nobody can say 'autistic people don't like this' because its such a spectrum.

Shinyandnew1 · 18/12/2023 21:44

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 18/12/2023 18:45

I am being grumpy I admit, but rather than starting a thread about 1 teacher in 1 school you have decided it is schools in general!

Then moan about stereotyping and over generalisation.

Completely agree here!

TwiddlingMyToes · 18/12/2023 21:44

Sunflower8848 · 18/12/2023 21:33

Doesn’t it make you question the whole social concept of “autism”?

What do you mean by this?

TwiddlingMyToes · 18/12/2023 21:43

I totally understand what you mean and I find the same. But I choose to view it that they're trying to be understanding and inclusive. We've had teachers who won't take his difficulties into account at all and have dismissed him as just naughty, so I'd probably rather they go too fat the other way and at least they're trying 🤷

bellac11 · 18/12/2023 21:39

DragonMama3 · 18/12/2023 21:27

Asperger's is not used - long story. It got replaced with High Functioning Autism.

It certainly is used for people whose diagnosis is Asperger's, thank you

DragonMama3 · 18/12/2023 21:35

autism spectrum condition acc to paed consultant

Beenpo · 18/12/2023 21:33

@DragonMama3 I know, high functioning autism isn’t used either. It’s just autism spectrum disorder. I added the term ‘Asperger’s’ as without the clarification, just using ‘autism’ tends to create confusion and people don’t understand level of need, struggles, lack of learning disabilities etc.

OP posts:
Sunflower8848 · 18/12/2023 21:33

Doesn’t it make you question the whole social concept of “autism”?

DragonMama3 · 18/12/2023 21:27

Asperger's is not used - long story. It got replaced with High Functioning Autism.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 18/12/2023 18:45

I am being grumpy I admit, but rather than starting a thread about 1 teacher in 1 school you have decided it is schools in general!

Then moan about stereotyping and over generalisation.