Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told off for not praying

85 replies

Coffeeandcatsforlife · 18/12/2023 16:58

my son goes to a regular non religious mainstream primary school and he’s told me the head teacher was shouting at the year 3 children who weren’t praying in assembly. I asked what exactly he meant thinking maybe they were playing up but apparently it’s just not putting hands together to pray. We’re from an atheist family so praying isn’t something we do. Is she right to reprimand not praying? Surely not? My son is year 6 and wasn’t praying just sat quietly but as he’s year 6 and at back wasn’t spotted.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 18/12/2023 21:21

Soapboxqueen · 18/12/2023 18:04

A child shouldn't be told off for not praying.

However if your child is in year 6 and most likely at the back, he might not have seen why they were told off. Many children can't resist trying to get the attention of their friends while they think nobody else is looking. Disruption that would be very obvious to an adult at the front and can spread to lots of other children very quickly.

There are no non-religious schools, as all have to have an act of daily collective workshop which is broadly Christian in nature. Most get around this by choosing themes such as being kind and helping others which can be done in a non-religious way but are still essentially Christian (as well as relevent in other religions too).

Parents can opt out of these by not having their children in assemblies.

Most schools (around here) seem to not have daily assemblies anymore anyway so not sure where this 'collective worship' is meant to happen.

Libertyy · 18/12/2023 21:18

In primary this was a non issue. The kids either bowed their head with their eyes averted or they held their hands in accordance to Christianity, Islam, Sikhism etc

UndertheCedartree · 18/12/2023 21:16

SecondHandFurniture · 18/12/2023 17:43

It is correct, though technically daily "Worship". This is why all of us who went to English, NI and Welsh state primaries for the last 50ish years know all the words to Shine Jesus Shine.

My DD doesn't. And in fact I don't think I ever sang that at school, I sung it at church. When I was at school we had the Mormons coming in and doing songs with us. I remember singing 'he's got the whole world in his hand'.

MadeOfAllWork · 18/12/2023 21:05

Schools are required to do a daily act of worship. That doesn’t mean prayers.

As said above this can be a conversation about kindness or sharing etc. and singing secular songs.

StuffLoriThangs · 18/12/2023 19:49

what rubbish. I refuse to believe he was messing about.

I remember getting told off by a teacher for not holding my hands “properly” to pray and she made a big thing about it in front of the class. It has really stuck with me. I didn’t think it really mattered, because I was praying and we were supposed to be doing it with our eyes shut. In truth, she just didn’t like me

I think the teacher is BU. and in your position I would be writing to the school to say as much. People can be respectful but it goes both ways.

hitherandhither · 18/12/2023 19:49

Benibidibici · 18/12/2023 17:47

We don't enforce hands together but we do expect respect for all religions so quiet sitting and listening with heads bowed to use the time to focus and reflect.

Why do you ask them to bow their heads?

Bowing the head is a sign of obeisance, its immediately deferential and a sign of submission. Its really disrespectful of you to ask atheist children to make an act of submission to a deity they don't believe in.

@Benibidibici so they can quietly reflect on their own actions. Bowing their heads stops them trying to catch each others eyes and misbehave whilst others are praying. There are no consequences for not bowing their heads if they choose not to. They are spoken to if they do misbehave during prayer or mock it though.

I'm not religious and I have no problem with this.

UndertheCedartree · 18/12/2023 19:48

donquixotedelamancha · 18/12/2023 17:06

I (atheist) teach at a religious school, everyone puts their hands together and bows their heads when we pray. I think that's a reasonable expectation to show respect for others beliefs.

There are no state non-religious schools in the UK, most schools default to the state religion (CofE). All schools are required by law to perform prayers every day.

Lots of high schools don't do daily prayers but it's still the norm in most primaries.

They're required? Really? They never said prayers at my DD's primary school. She's at a RC high school and they say the school prayer every morning.

tencent · 18/12/2023 19:42

Apologies @crummi , I read the wiki page but there was nothing specific about Estyn, only Ofsted. My post was responding to a previous poster who questioned the need for schools to provide collective worship and I was just pointing out that it was a requirement in Wales. It might be that the OP is in England, in which case it may not be relevant. I taught for 20 years in Wales up until 2016, and religion played a big role in daily education, with Christian worship certainly being at the forefront. Anyway, that's a debate for another day!

Vintageport · 18/12/2023 19:29

SerendipityJane · 18/12/2023 19:25

Surely if you pray wrong it won't work ?

Well, technically it’s worse to worship or take communion with the wrong intentions or for the wrong reasons than it is not to do it at all… so enforced praying doesn’t make theological sense.

NaughtybutNice77 · 18/12/2023 19:28

I don't think anyone should be obliged to place their hands together as if in prayer. Pretty much anyone would know what this gesture signifies. If you're not praying you shouldn't be forced to do it anymore than you should be obliged to make the sign of the cross or bow to Mecca.
You should however stand still and quiet.

crummi · 18/12/2023 19:25

tencent · 18/12/2023 19:11

@crummi I wouldn't be able to say about Ofsted, having never taught in England, but having gone through several school inspections in Wales, Estyn have indeed checked on it in the past. I haven't taught for several years now though, so happy to be corrected by anyone with more recent experience.

Well that's why I linked the wiki page, which sums it all up nicely. It hasn't been inspected by Ofsted since 2004. Many schools were non compliant even then.

SerendipityJane · 18/12/2023 19:25

Surely if you pray wrong it won't work ?

whatsappdoc · 18/12/2023 19:19

At one of the community primary schools I taught in the HT asked all the children who weren't praying to sit quietly with their hands in their laps. But the rest were expected to chant the prayers line by line after the HT. It was horrible. Very cult like. Staff were expected to pray as well. (I didn't).
Other primary schools never mentioned god at all, unless they were church schools and even then some only said prayers if the vicar was leading the assembly.

tencent · 18/12/2023 19:11

@crummi I wouldn't be able to say about Ofsted, having never taught in England, but having gone through several school inspections in Wales, Estyn have indeed checked on it in the past. I haven't taught for several years now though, so happy to be corrected by anyone with more recent experience.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 18/12/2023 19:09

2dogsandabudgie · 18/12/2023 17:03

Normally with adults it's a mark of respect whether you're an atheist or not to bow your head if you find yourself in a setting where you are asked to pray, say at a funeral. Children wont automatically know this so they are usually asked to put their hands together. I really couldn't get worked up over this.

Not necessarily.
If you don't pray then you don't have to do anything that looks like praying - it's fine to just sit quietly.

Passingthethyme · 18/12/2023 19:08

2dogsandabudgie · 18/12/2023 17:03

Normally with adults it's a mark of respect whether you're an atheist or not to bow your head if you find yourself in a setting where you are asked to pray, say at a funeral. Children wont automatically know this so they are usually asked to put their hands together. I really couldn't get worked up over this.

Agree with this. I'm technically another religion (but actually atheist), I have no issue 'praying' if others are, it's just showing respect

Vintageport · 18/12/2023 19:06

donquixotedelamancha · 18/12/2023 17:06

I (atheist) teach at a religious school, everyone puts their hands together and bows their heads when we pray. I think that's a reasonable expectation to show respect for others beliefs.

There are no state non-religious schools in the UK, most schools default to the state religion (CofE). All schools are required by law to perform prayers every day.

Lots of high schools don't do daily prayers but it's still the norm in most primaries.

Putting your hands together is a sign of worship- no one in the uk is obliged to worship any God in any situation. That includes children.

The most the school can (or should) enforce is sitting still and quiet and not distracting other pupils. That is enough respect to show.

crummi · 18/12/2023 18:57

tencent · 18/12/2023 17:39

I'm an ex teacher in Wales @Catza and the requirement is that 'schools must provide collective worship daily for all registered pupils' . From Estyn, which is like OFSTED https://www.estyn.gov.wales/system/files/2020-07/NIA%2520Supplementary%2520guidance%2520-%2520collective%2520worship_0.pdf . However, parents can request their child be excused and there is no legal requirement for those under the age of five. I have taught in several schools where children were reprimanded for not praying - not by me I hasten to add, I have no belief.

Ofsted don't enforce this, so most non-faith schools don't bother. See here for details: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_worship_in_schools

Collective worship in schools - Wikipedia

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collective_worship_in_schools

BodyKeepingScore · 18/12/2023 18:45

donquixotedelamancha · 18/12/2023 17:06

I (atheist) teach at a religious school, everyone puts their hands together and bows their heads when we pray. I think that's a reasonable expectation to show respect for others beliefs.

There are no state non-religious schools in the UK, most schools default to the state religion (CofE). All schools are required by law to perform prayers every day.

Lots of high schools don't do daily prayers but it's still the norm in most primaries.

Surely it's disrespectful to an atheist to be expected to play along with a prayer if it contradicts their own beliefs though? Respect would be sitting in silence, not partaking in prayer gestures?

SyntacticalVortex · 18/12/2023 18:41

BTW OP please don't go into the school saying "my yr6 son thought he saw a yr3 getting told off unfairly, please can you clarify the situation for me" because they won't, that incident is actually none of your business. Just tell your son he should sit quietly and respectfully whilst others are praying and that's it. If he personally got 'told off for not praying' then fine, raise it with the school.

If you are actually concerned about the school policy on prayer and expectations of behaviour for non Christians, look for the policy on their website or send a general inquiry about it. That's all.

CandyCaneLane0 · 18/12/2023 18:29

Kids were always told off for not praying when I was at primary school, even back then I thought it was odd to be forced to do it

SyntacticalVortex · 18/12/2023 18:26

Most non-christian schools do NOT do daily prayers (I've worked in several different ones). They do assemblies on kindness, building friendships, adhering to the school values, celebrating achievement etc. In my last school the children sang one of a rotation of pop songs around wholesome / aspirational themes at the start/end of assemblies. S club7 Reach For The Stars was a favourite. No prayers or hymns in sight.

willWillSmithsmith · 18/12/2023 18:22

2dogsandabudgie · 18/12/2023 17:03

Normally with adults it's a mark of respect whether you're an atheist or not to bow your head if you find yourself in a setting where you are asked to pray, say at a funeral. Children wont automatically know this so they are usually asked to put their hands together. I really couldn't get worked up over this.

Certainly not. I’ll stand quietly but I’m not going to bow my head thank you very much.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 18/12/2023 18:15

@donquixotedelamancha is right - it is required that there is a daily act of worship that is broadly Christian in nature. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/collective-worship-in-schools

Whether individual schools actually do it or not is another matter (and I personally don't think they should!) but I definitely remember in the 90s reciting the lord's prayer in every assembly.

Collective worship in schools

Guidance for local-authority-maintained schools on providing a daily act of collective worship.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/collective-worship-in-schools

AllAroundMyCat · 18/12/2023 18:05

@donquixotedelamancha

No. The majority of schools do not do daily prayers and aren't obliged to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread