Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if her if she will cook me halal meat for Christmas?

224 replies

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 21:47

So I’m celebrating Christmas with a friend and it’s just gonna be the two of us as my partner is spending time with his nana 200 miles away. We’ve decided on turkey and chicken or lamb and chicken, AIBU to ask that the chicken or lamb is halal for me? I’ll be buying the meat and it’s our shared rented home from before I met my partner.

OP posts:
FlamingBlue · 19/12/2023 15:12

I boycott halal meat because of the non-stunning so don't buy meat takeaways and wouldn't eat your halal meat.

Oakbeam · 19/12/2023 15:20

Surely you’d just buy halal? A roasted halal turkey looks identical to a non-Halal turkey?

Then it doesn’t matter what you buy. No one will be any the wiser.

BestBadger · 19/12/2023 15:54

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 04:59

The point I did make is that halal and non-halal isn't the same, and never will be.

I don't want or need halal as much as someone else does want or need it.

No you're not. I clearly stated that a non halal turkey and a halal turkey, from Tesco, is exactly the same, aside from the blessing. The only possible objection you can have to their halal over non halal is the Muslim blessing. Why would I need to ask a Muslim what the difference is?

BestBadger · 19/12/2023 15:59

Just have a homemade nutroast, no slaughter & no offended priests or deities.

abominablesnowman · 19/12/2023 16:21

All they have to do is use any meat and say it's halal. You won't know the difference. I think I read that that's the case with a significant number of meats labelled 'halal' anyway.

zaazaazoo · 19/12/2023 16:22

@Unexpectedlysinglemum
Halal method of killing animals is seen by people who care about animal rights as a more painful death as they die by having their throat slit they are not stunned first, so for a second or two they will experience awful pain if killed in halal way, in comparison to the non halal way.

There is so much misinformation out there.

This post is just incorrect. Most halal slaughter involves stunning the animal. All Australian and NZ meat for example must be stunned. It is the law. Halal slaughter then differs from non halal by use of a single cut to the throat by a Muslim butcher whilst reciting a prayer. The animal is killed away from other animals. Non halal meat can be slaughtered by any butcher and no prayer. Slaughter is by electrocution or bolt gun. It is done in a line up with other animals present. There is a lot of panic and distress.

Traditional slaughter is not less painful. Both are stunned but in non halal slaughterhouses, it is all fine in front of animals and out to be slaughtered. It is a horrible environment.

AgnesX · 19/12/2023 16:23

I personally wouldn't have a problem (most of the takeaways locally are halal so it would be hypocritical otherwise).

If she does have an issue suggest you bring your own and she gets hers.

shitsuit23466 · 19/12/2023 16:40

If you care about animal rights, just be a vegetarian.

Idg this "oh I only eat it if they are killed nicely"

I doubt the animals want to die.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 16:55

BestBadger · 19/12/2023 14:08

By your own logic then, buying exclusively stunned halal would increase the demand for stunned halal over non-stunned.

In the absence of any logical reason, you're making it look like your objection to halal is simply because it's too Muslimy.

Not sure your point?
I don't want to create artificial demand for a religious product.
That's my choice.
I'm not objecting to anyone else practicing their religion or buying appropriate food though.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 16:57

BestBadger · 19/12/2023 15:54

No you're not. I clearly stated that a non halal turkey and a halal turkey, from Tesco, is exactly the same, aside from the blessing. The only possible objection you can have to their halal over non halal is the Muslim blessing. Why would I need to ask a Muslim what the difference is?

They're not the same.
One is labeled halal, for those requiring halal.
While I respect other's right to choose that, I don't want it.

Dutch1e · 19/12/2023 19:56

GarlicMaybeNot · 18/12/2023 09:30

I've slaughtered my dinner - once, if wringing a hen's neck counts - but if I had to hunt it, I'd be hungry for a long time 😂 Quite impressed that you can, though.

I'm impressed you've wrung a chicken's neck!

I sometimes get the feeling that most of the hand-wringing over animal welfare is done by hands that have never wrung the necks of the animal that will feed their kids that day.

Don't get me wrong, I'm an immigrant to Europe so most of my 'hunting' is now for yellow stickers!

But I do internally roll my eyes when any meat-eater has great philosophical objections without ever having worked in a slaughterhouse, or spent time on a farm, or even been truly hungry with access to good hunting.

I've been all three, so I don't eat meat every week. It just shouldn't be that easy.

BestBadger · 19/12/2023 20:58

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 16:55

Not sure your point?
I don't want to create artificial demand for a religious product.
That's my choice.
I'm not objecting to anyone else practicing their religion or buying appropriate food though.

Just Islamic produce, or do you avoid Easter eggs & hot cross buns?

Ofcourseshecan · 19/12/2023 21:13

AlbatrosStrike · 17/12/2023 23:10

But how do you know that? The animals are not able to tell us.

Maybe they’re too distracted by the prayer on the loudspeaker to notice the bloke with the stun gun and the knife. Who knows.

It’s not about the prayers. It’s that halal doesn’t require that the animal is stunned before having its throat cut. So the animal can spend minutes struggling in pain and terror before dying.

UK animal welfare laws require animals to be stunned before slaughter, but halal and kosher butchery get an exemption. There should be no exemptions from laws against unnecessary cruelty to animals.

AlbatrosStrike · 19/12/2023 21:33

Ofcourseshecan · 19/12/2023 21:13

It’s not about the prayers. It’s that halal doesn’t require that the animal is stunned before having its throat cut. So the animal can spend minutes struggling in pain and terror before dying.

UK animal welfare laws require animals to be stunned before slaughter, but halal and kosher butchery get an exemption. There should be no exemptions from laws against unnecessary cruelty to animals.

You have totally missed the point of my comment.

If you think that living a miserable life in some factory farm only to be killed by a stun gun is some epitome of animal welfare, be careful not to fall from your high horse.

A simple google search will tell you that most halal slaughter in the UK involves stunning first anyway.

But again, my point was that we don’t know really if one method is better than the other. I think that neither being shot in the head (which is what a stun gun does) nor having one’s throat slit sounds particularly nice.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 19/12/2023 22:22

BestBadger · 19/12/2023 20:58

Just Islamic produce, or do you avoid Easter eggs & hot cross buns?

Stop clutching straws.

GreekDogRescue · 25/12/2023 17:58

00100001 · 18/12/2023 21:02

they absolutely are stunned in the UK. but you don't want to hear that it seems.

but you carry on, I'm sure you only eat high welfare, organic locally produced meat.

What exactly do you mean by ‘high welfare meat’?
Have you been to an abattoir recently?
Are you another one who thinks some kind of stone age ritual transforms having your neck slit into a spiritual experience?

Corblimeys · 25/12/2023 18:48

If i ate meat i wd only eat highwelfe meat . There is no way i wd cook halal meat .
maybe just have a veggie meal together. Unless of course halal does not uoset ot bother your friend.

Closerandcloser · 25/12/2023 20:07

Boomarang · 17/12/2023 21:59

Not ASD here and I have the same question 🤷‍♀️

The power of Google will provide you with this insight

Sorry I can’t remove the hyperlink, therefore you will have to google halal slaughter. As the photograph might be objectionable to people here.

therealcookiemonster · 25/12/2023 22:38

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:14

I'm not Muslim but I have hunted and slaughtered my dinner. Everyone who eats meat should.

Personally I prefer halal, if I'm understanding it correctly: death must be delivered by hand, not by machine. And it must be a clean cut across the jugular or similar, to ensure that as little blood as possible remains in the meat (meaning that death is fast and painless).

Am I on the right track? If so, YANBU.

exactly. misunderstanding of halal slaughter has become pervasive as papers such as the daily fail push their anti muslim/anti immigrant agenda.
for an animal to be truly halal... it must be firstly reared with kindness, then it cannot be slaughtered if pregnant, it cannot be slaughtered in front of other animals. it must be calmed and held gently and then the cut must be with an extremely sharp blade with one single incision (by someone very well trained) severing the carotid and jugular, stopping blood flow to the brain and an immediate loss of consciousness. if an animal is hunted, it must still die by the incision and not slowly in distress (in which case it becomes halal).

anyone who thinks stunning is humane, need to do some research. its pretty horrific and doesn't always work.

truly halal meat is pretty hard to find, especially chicken. i try to stick to ethically reared animals which are slaughtered in the best possible way, but it is not always accessible. the bigger problem is that we need more free range, organic, sustainably reared meat for everyone - including people who eat halal or kosher.

ps people who talk about their hatred of halal slaughter, please know kosher slaughter is the same except they read different prayers, they absolutely do not accept stunning as far as i know. and if you are going to shout about how much you hate halal slaughter, why don't you do the same with kosher? maybe because it's not socially acceptable to be anti semitic (and nor should it be) but less unacceptable to be islamophobic.

therealcookiemonster · 25/12/2023 22:45

abominablesnowman · 19/12/2023 16:21

All they have to do is use any meat and say it's halal. You won't know the difference. I think I read that that's the case with a significant number of meats labelled 'halal' anyway.

this is sadly very true. a lot of Muslim businesses sell non halal meat as halal. thankfully Muslims believe they are rewarded or punished according to their intentions. so if someone eats non halal food in error, it is not classed as a sin.

Teder · 25/12/2023 23:17

therealcookiemonster · 25/12/2023 22:38

exactly. misunderstanding of halal slaughter has become pervasive as papers such as the daily fail push their anti muslim/anti immigrant agenda.
for an animal to be truly halal... it must be firstly reared with kindness, then it cannot be slaughtered if pregnant, it cannot be slaughtered in front of other animals. it must be calmed and held gently and then the cut must be with an extremely sharp blade with one single incision (by someone very well trained) severing the carotid and jugular, stopping blood flow to the brain and an immediate loss of consciousness. if an animal is hunted, it must still die by the incision and not slowly in distress (in which case it becomes halal).

anyone who thinks stunning is humane, need to do some research. its pretty horrific and doesn't always work.

truly halal meat is pretty hard to find, especially chicken. i try to stick to ethically reared animals which are slaughtered in the best possible way, but it is not always accessible. the bigger problem is that we need more free range, organic, sustainably reared meat for everyone - including people who eat halal or kosher.

ps people who talk about their hatred of halal slaughter, please know kosher slaughter is the same except they read different prayers, they absolutely do not accept stunning as far as i know. and if you are going to shout about how much you hate halal slaughter, why don't you do the same with kosher? maybe because it's not socially acceptable to be anti semitic (and nor should it be) but less unacceptable to be islamophobic.

Edited

I agree with your last paragraph 100% and especially your last sentence. That said the halal debate comes up more often because you’re extremely unlikely to inadvertently eat Kosher meat. It is not anywhere near as available in (non Kosher) takeaways and supermarkets, the labelling is clear so you’d be hard pushed to accidentally purchase a kosher chicken and the meat is more expensive. The Jewish population is considerably smaller and communities congregate in certain areas, so some people may be even less likely to come across a Kosher butcher, for example.

sleepsuitbag · 25/12/2023 23:46

All2Well · 17/12/2023 21:51

Our household is made up of practicing Muslims and not. We do one halal dish and one non halal meat dish for people who refuse to eat halal, it's a lot of faff (and I'm the cook) but it's important to respect both lots of people.

Bit weird when majority of meat is halal, just not labelled it

MandyCandy · 25/12/2023 23:56

https://www.willowbrookfarm.co.uk/

There is a lovely farm here that supplies good quality halal meat and they actually practice proper halal butchery. I don't eat meat often but when I do, I source it from here.

Farm | Willowbrook Farm | Hampton Gay

The first Halal & Tayib Farm in the UK. Farming naturally and sustainably, without chemicals or pesticides of any kind.

https://www.willowbrookfarm.co.uk

therealcookiemonster · 25/12/2023 23:58

MandyCandy · 25/12/2023 23:56

https://www.willowbrookfarm.co.uk/

There is a lovely farm here that supplies good quality halal meat and they actually practice proper halal butchery. I don't eat meat often but when I do, I source it from here.

I use them too! their goose is superb. :-)

Hill Farm finest and that fat cow is also good.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page