Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if her if she will cook me halal meat for Christmas?

224 replies

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 21:47

So I’m celebrating Christmas with a friend and it’s just gonna be the two of us as my partner is spending time with his nana 200 miles away. We’ve decided on turkey and chicken or lamb and chicken, AIBU to ask that the chicken or lamb is halal for me? I’ll be buying the meat and it’s our shared rented home from before I met my partner.

OP posts:
Noorandapples · 18/12/2023 09:07

Yabu to open up a conversation about halal meat on mumsnet, you should have said kosher, then there would be less awful replies

swuahies · 18/12/2023 08:58

Because the way they kill the meat can be considered more cruel than if it’s killed in the non-halal way. It’s not uncommon for meat eaters to not eat halal.

It doesn't matter how many posters have made this point over & over (& over) That's not what the post is about and in this case it's a completely irrelevant point.

OP has said her friend DOES EAT HALAL MEAT on other days of the year. Therefore I really don't see the issue with her eating it in Christmas Day???

There is not need for another post about how SOME people aren't comfortable eating halal. It's doesn't apply here!!!!

ruby1957 · 18/12/2023 08:50

BrightLightTonight · 17/12/2023 22:21

Halal meat is cruel to the animals - I would never buy it and would refuse to have it in my house.

Absolutely - and that point of view should be respected by those who seem not to understand it.
I am a vegetarian (and eat fish only) - my conscience tells me to take this stand.

I do object to the fact that often meat is halal without it being labelled as such.
Since halal meat is important to those who require to eat only halal - it should be clearly labelled for them to be sure.

Caterpillarsleftfoot · 18/12/2023 08:47

millymollymoomoo · 17/12/2023 22:04

animaks killed by halal methods are not stunned prior to slaughter, something the rspca strongly object to. That’s why many non Muslims object and don’t want to eat it, aside from any religious/prayer aspect

It's horrible and cruel and shouldn't be allowed.

Ginmonkeyagain · 18/12/2023 08:46

I've witnessed halal and non halal slaughter. There isn't really a huge difference. They key is of the person doing it is well trained and quick. As people say halal usually demands higher cleanliess and welfare. My dad used to sell some sheep to a halal butcher and he and his iman used to come and inspect the farm abd sheep while they were alive.

If you object to slaughtering animals - don't eat meat full stop.

Sodndashitall · 18/12/2023 08:42

Not sure I understand at all.
You buy the meat, you buy halal. She eats halal as you know because she's happy to eat halal takeaway etc.
The meat tastes the same ! You can't tell whether a chicken has been slaughtered halal or non halal when eating. So the only objection is the principle. She doesn't object. You want halal. You're buying the meat.

What's the actual problem

SarcasmAndCoffee · 18/12/2023 08:38

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 22:16

If the animal is stunned and only dies when it’s slaughtered then it’s permissible, but if it dies as a result of being stunned or any violent death then it’s not halal and cannot be eaten. That’s the current ruling as far as I’m aware.

It is cruel. During the process in which the animal has to go through to be considered a halal kill, the animal has its throat slit and then is left to bleed out and die. It isn’t a humane way of killing. I purposely refuse halal meat for this reason

ActDottie · 18/12/2023 08:35

SpringleDingle · 17/12/2023 21:56

Why would non-Muslims have an issue with halal? Am I missing something? They kill the animal differently and pray over it don’t they? How does that make it something non-Muslims wouldn’t eat? I am genuinely asking (ASD so maybe the answer is obvious to the rest of the world!)

Because the way they kill the meat can be considered more cruel than if it’s killed in the non-halal way. It’s not uncommon for meat eaters to not eat halal.

I don’t eat meat as I personally believe there is no non-cruel way to kill and animal. But I know some people disagree with the way halal meat is killed. I think it is not stunned beforehand or something.

OP I’d be checking that they are happy for halal meat. If they are then just buy halal given you are the meat buyer anyway.

Cubic · 18/12/2023 08:15

Is she a Christian or actively practicing? She may eat halal at other times of the year for ease but at Easter and Christmas not want meat blessed for another faith.

I'm vegetarian, I find it easiest to just eat the veg and skip the meat (potatoes/ parsnips roasted on their own, no meat in the sprouts, gravy or stuffing etc) rather than have an alternative to turkey. It's only one meal if your friend celebrates as part of her religion maybe just let her have this?

If she isn't religious and you're just celebrating for tradition/ fun you need to just talk to her. I wouldn't assume one way or the other but I wouldn't stress about it, it's just one meal. If there is an issue why not have a meatless alternative to save making two main dishes when there is only two of you, just for ease. Then nobody gets offended/ upset and you can just enjoy each others company. I hope you have a great day.

arewedoneyet · 18/12/2023 08:09

I would never knowingly eat halal meat on animal welfare grounds.

vanillaredbushtea · 18/12/2023 08:09

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 23:11

That’s true, this is our first actual Christmas together where we are both celebrating it and her cooking it. Usually my partner brings me in an Asian style roast and she goes to her family but this year my partner is away and my friend is only celebrating new year’s eve with her family so we’ve got christmas Day together and she wants to make something traditional so obviously I just wanted to check. Since me and her share a house, I buy her non halal meat anyways and she does cook me halal stuff that she does eat as well so hopefully shouldn’t be an issue

If you live with her can you not just ask her in person and talk to her?!

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 18/12/2023 07:54

I refuse to buy or cook halal meat on principle, so would refuse your request.

I wouldn't mind you buying, cooking and bringing it along though, so you had something acceptable for you to eat.

Hope you can work something out.

SallyWD · 18/12/2023 07:42

millymollymoomoo · 17/12/2023 22:04

animaks killed by halal methods are not stunned prior to slaughter, something the rspca strongly object to. That’s why many non Muslims object and don’t want to eat it, aside from any religious/prayer aspect

65% of animals killed for halal meat are stunned in the UK. So the halal meat is more likely to come from an animal that's been stunned, than not.
Also the whole point of halal is that animals are raised with higher welfare standards and their treatment is more humane. It's not a the black and white issue some people think it is (I.e. Some people think halal = cruel, non-halal = good)

swuahies · 18/12/2023 00:01

If she eats halal on other days of the year, she obviously doesn't have an issue with how the animals are slaughtered. It's not something you'd only feel differently about on Christmas Day??

If she never ate halal or had previously mentioned having an issue with the morality of it, I'd see why you were thinking along these lines.

What specifically did she say when you asked? That might help us understand!

00100001 · 17/12/2023 23:59

I'll bet 99% of those people claiming that halal is cruel, happily eat barn eggs, free range, non organic meat, heavily processed meat etc. eat new Zealand lamb that was live transported to Asia and slaughtered there... Happily drinks cows milk made for supermarkets etc etc etc

They don't give a shit about the animal when it's alive, bit now all of a sudden they care about how it's slaughtered? Even though UK halal meat is stunned the same as any other meat.

It's just an excuse to be racist and hide behind animal welfare.

GiveUsACoffee · 17/12/2023 23:43

For all those saying Halal meat is cruel, the alternative isn't exactly a walk in the park. If cruelty to animals is a concern, we should all be looking at what we're serving, Christmas or not.

QueenBitch666 · 17/12/2023 23:41

Just cook vegetarian food. Problem solved and no murder and hypocrisy involved Grin

Naddd · 17/12/2023 23:39

Truth hurts

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:39

WillowCraft · 17/12/2023 23:33

Not really.
The throat is always cut by hand . The difference is whether the animal is stunned first . Stunning is usually by a captive bolt for cattle and sheep so they are shot in the head, but not far enough to actually kill. It is via electric current for chickens I believe although not actually seen that.

It takes a good while for a cow to bleed to death as they have an alternative internal blood supply to the brain. They carry on mooing and struggling for a few minutes. Sheep are quicker but certainly neither quick nor painless. If captive bolt is done right it should be a painless death. (Needs correct aim.though, doesn't always happen).

The amount of blood left behind should not differ as the heart keeps beating until death in both cases, it's only the brain activity that is different, hence why some halal can be prestunned.

The halal ones I saw were in a developing country abattoir with no hoist for the cattle. They were tied up by the legs lying horizontally. They may die quicker if hung head down. Not seen halal done here but I expect they would have machinery to lift the animal for this purpose.

Sounds pretty similar to the abbatoir I spent time in as a youngster in Australia. It wasn't halal, just a lot of ugly deaths. Mass-meat is never pretty is it.

WillowCraft · 17/12/2023 23:33

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:14

I'm not Muslim but I have hunted and slaughtered my dinner. Everyone who eats meat should.

Personally I prefer halal, if I'm understanding it correctly: death must be delivered by hand, not by machine. And it must be a clean cut across the jugular or similar, to ensure that as little blood as possible remains in the meat (meaning that death is fast and painless).

Am I on the right track? If so, YANBU.

Not really.
The throat is always cut by hand . The difference is whether the animal is stunned first . Stunning is usually by a captive bolt for cattle and sheep so they are shot in the head, but not far enough to actually kill. It is via electric current for chickens I believe although not actually seen that.

It takes a good while for a cow to bleed to death as they have an alternative internal blood supply to the brain. They carry on mooing and struggling for a few minutes. Sheep are quicker but certainly neither quick nor painless. If captive bolt is done right it should be a painless death. (Needs correct aim.though, doesn't always happen).

The amount of blood left behind should not differ as the heart keeps beating until death in both cases, it's only the brain activity that is different, hence why some halal can be prestunned.

The halal ones I saw were in a developing country abattoir with no hoist for the cattle. They were tied up by the legs lying horizontally. They may die quicker if hung head down. Not seen halal done here but I expect they would have machinery to lift the animal for this purpose.

showmethegin · 17/12/2023 23:29

I have no time at all for people that eat meat but get in a froth about halal meat. If you read about what goes on in a non halal abattoir you would understand. They aren't stroked to death.

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:25

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 23:15

Yes that’s right

Then you should buy what suits you. It's quite lovely of you to give this so much thought but it's almost like the vegan vs non-vegan meal... a non-vegan can eat a vegan dinner but it doesn't work the other way around.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 23:25

Naddd · 17/12/2023 23:23

If your that bothered about animal welfare, then don't bloody eat them.

You're rude.

Naddd · 17/12/2023 23:23

If your that bothered about animal welfare, then don't bloody eat them.

WillowCraft · 17/12/2023 23:22

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/12/2023 22:41

Halal method of killing animals is seen by people who care about animal rights as a more painful death as they die by having their throat slit they are not stunned first, so for a second or two they will experience awful pain if killed in halal way, in comparison to the non halal way.

They die from bleeding to death and it takes quite a long time. Ten minutes for cattle. Less for sheep but more than 2 seconds. Not sure about poultry, not seen them killed

Some halal is prestunned so that wouldn't apply.

Mind you stunning can go wrong too. There's no such thing as a pain free stress free death in a commercial slaughterhouse, by any method

(Not a vegetarian so no axe to grind here, just spent a fair bit of time in slaughterhouses for work)