Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To see a lot of couples in this situation

693 replies

Whatyoutryingtodo · 17/12/2023 09:00

I see quite a few couples I know irl who've been together several years, engaged, own a house and have children, but no wedding plans made.
They've often been engaged for several years too but don't have any plans to get married, and say stuff like they'll 'get round to it at some point'.

Just curious as to why this happens quite a lot, not judging as I myself am unmarried and childless due to no interested suitors!

I think people will say that the man has everything he needs so why bother marrying her... Sometimes I wonder why people consider marriage more of a commitment than children? At least with marriage you can divorce, even if it's expensive and stressful, children you're tied for life.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Dixiechickonhols · 19/12/2023 09:13

If I was in the engaged and not married camp with a couple of small children I’d be wanting to be 100% clear in where I’d be legally if he left today, if he died in a car crash tonight, if he left in 20 years.
If the answer is don’t know..find out. If the answer is I’m screwed then seriously think about the £127 marriage option and do the party later.

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 09:06

Dixiechickonhols · 19/12/2023 08:58

It’s not always a choice though. If you have a child with a disability or Sen who can’t access mainstream schooling or childcare your ‘choice’ isn’t a choice. The vast majority of carers in these circumstances are women.
Only women are affected by birth injuries and health issues triggered by pregnancy.

True. Although I guess marriage could then happen in the event of one of those (fairly unlikely things) happening.

I don't think it would be good advice to say that all woman should get married, just incase they have a disabled child or become disabled in childbirth. Whereas years ago it would be good advice for most woman to get married before kids, because they nearly all then because financially dependent.

Here4thechocs · 19/12/2023 09:05

SgtJuneAckland · 17/12/2023 09:30

We got married before having DC because I wanted a nice family wedding and I have a large family, it's fine to just do registry office on your own but it wasn't what I wanted. I knew after DC any unnecessary spending on my wants would be at the bottom of my priorities so got married first. We also bought our house before DC beefeater it's much more difficult to save once you have them, we both took second jobs while saving for a deposit for example.

It was never about financial security for me as I earn well on my own, I don't understand women who put their own careers on the back burner and do most of the childcare while their DP builds their own career and financial stability without marrying though, you see it so many times on here, when with no freedom and feel they can't leave because he holds all the financial cards

Absolutely. I don’t get it either. The DC are OURS, not mine alone.

Handing your entire life over ( how I see it ) to someone else is never something that makes sense to me. As someone whose education was solely funded by my mother , though married to my dad ( still married ) , I often wonder what direction my life would have taken, had my mom not had her own money; her own career. It’s safe to say this shaped my thinking about women & jobs/carrers, even whilst raising a family.

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 09:02

'You end up with millions of disenchanted men who see marriage as the ultimate trap'

For most of the woman I know it's the opposite way around! This idea that men are the breadwinners / stand to lose more in a divorce is very outdated?

Foxface21 · 19/12/2023 09:02

I never said they did.

RiderofRohan · 19/12/2023 09:01

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 08:53

And as we know, it being normal is the best reason to do anything

Didn't say it was. But people do what is normalised to them. Watched a show about an estate in Scunthorpe where most people have kids by the age of 16, many of them planned. Obviously this isn't the best but it's normalised and people form their approach to life around this.

Dixiechickonhols · 19/12/2023 08:58

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 08:42

Yes true marriage is probably a good idea for SAHPs.

But what I mean is in the past women often didn't have a choice to be a SAHP or not. Now it is a choice.

It’s not always a choice though. If you have a child with a disability or Sen who can’t access mainstream schooling or childcare your ‘choice’ isn’t a choice. The vast majority of carers in these circumstances are women.
Only women are affected by birth injuries and health issues triggered by pregnancy.

millymog11 · 19/12/2023 08:58

"Marriage is a financial contract, like an insurance policy, no more no less. Like an insurance policy it's financially life-saving if you need it but a dangerous white elephant if you don't."

"No one really wants to attend a vow renewal so you get one chance to have your day"

I think the problem we have in the UK (as with other things) is that in 2023 we have become this increasingly confused and directionless society where critical parts of society (for the purpose of influencing important and life changing moments in individuals lives) are still dictated by principles and influences which do not have any bearing whatsoever on peoples day to day lives. So you end up with this ridiculous confusion and mish-mash of outcomes to satisfy wildly different and contradictory belief systems.

Take deciding principles in divorce courts - the principle of "no fault divorce" (i.e. you can get a divorce without (broadly) proving infidelity, desertion or unreasonable behaviour with associated rules about a minimum period of separation before being able to apply only came into force in April 2022. And what that tells you is that judges who decide divorce caselaw (which trickles down and influences the man on the street) are still influenced by an archaic mix of religious principles around marriage which cloud the on the ground needs of the vulnerable involved (children, mainly but also and often the wife/mother of those children) whilst at the same time those people are keen to keep people who make legislation and seek votes happy (usually men and those men have often been through multiple divorces themselves so partisan) so the same divorce decisions are strongly influenced by the "clean break" principle (i.e. you can leave with your assets and money because we totally agree you were utterly tricked and trapped by this women and the children you are now saddled with.

Its a confused mess and it does not work. It is unclear and totally unworkable for the man in the street. You end up with millions of disenchanted men who see marriage as the ultimate trap and millions of women who spend decades of their life just thinking about a big party, a big ring and getting pregnant (and none of the practicalities or real cost of any of that).

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 08:53

RiderofRohan · 19/12/2023 08:49

Depends on your social circle. It's not normal within mine to be have kids outside marriage. Almost all my friends and wider social circle get married then have kids. One friend got pregnant but had a shotgun wedding within a few months, before the baby was here. I guess it's just normalised for some people and not others.

Edited

And as we know, it being normal is the best reason to do anything

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 08:53

I get the inheritance tax thing, but surely that's an argument for doing it later in the relationship anyway, once the risk of dying starts to outweigh the risk of getting divorced 😂

RiderofRohan · 19/12/2023 08:49

Depends on your social circle. It's not normal within mine to be have kids outside marriage. Almost all my friends and wider social circle get married then have kids. One friend got pregnant but had a shotgun wedding within a few months, before the baby was here. I guess it's just normalised for some people and not others.

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 08:45

In the past it was very much a thing that was advantageous for woman as they were expected to give up their jobs after kids.

Ilikepinacoladass · 19/12/2023 08:42

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 08:06

@Ilikepinacoladass

Woman don't need to be married anymore, it's not like in the past where they become financially dependent on their husband and needed to be married for security

Well, qualification is needed. Some women really do need to be married. SAHMs need to be married as a matter of priority. For most working women and women with assets it's a bad idea. The problem is most women don't understand whether marriage is a good thing or a bad thing for them and don't understand where they sit on this spectrum of financial need.

That's where the lack of education is a problem and all the obsession with weddings and "special days".

Yes true marriage is probably a good idea for SAHPs.

But what I mean is in the past women often didn't have a choice to be a SAHP or not. Now it is a choice.

hjytrjulykuyh · 19/12/2023 08:39

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 08:32

It's very sad that people have been culturally conditioned to assume marriage equals a wedding and that the wedding has to be expensive and large. You can get married for a couple hundred quid. You don't have to wear anything specific. You don't have to have anyone there barring a couple witnesses. It's signing a legal contract, the 'romance' and party side is secondary.

Yep. Yet still we have 20+ pages of people wanging on about how they can’t afford it.

Lets put this in perspective: it’s a couple of hundred quid now versus half a million quid in the future.

The 'but weddings are so expensive we can't afford to get married!' works very well for men who want all the trappings of married life and family life without any actual commitment to supporting their partner. If DH had pulled that on me I'd have said 'gosh you're so right, I agree, let's not bother with anything fancy. Register office is perfect let's get it booked'. We spent £400. Including the rings, an afternoon tea after, the ceremony and my dress.

Same with the whole theatre around engagement rings. They don't have to cost much, the 'however many months salary' was dreamt up by a marketing company to flog more jewellery. You don't even need one! Mine was just over a hundred quid, I loved it and it looks just as lovely years later. And if it falls apart at some point who cares, we'll get another that looks similar. I didn't like the idea of spending money we really needed for the house/baby etc. on jewellery, nor would I have felt comfortable wearing it everywhere if I was afraid of losing something so expensive.

Mornusting · 19/12/2023 08:38

Toomuchtrouble4me · 19/12/2023 08:35

If he’s been living there for a significant time he can have half anyway.,

Not true.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 19/12/2023 08:35

If he’s been living there for a significant time he can have half anyway.,

LaurieStrode · 19/12/2023 08:35

Very well said, @Thepeopleversuswork

Can't believe the "my special day" bullshit that's still out there.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 08:32

It's very sad that people have been culturally conditioned to assume marriage equals a wedding and that the wedding has to be expensive and large. You can get married for a couple hundred quid. You don't have to wear anything specific. You don't have to have anyone there barring a couple witnesses. It's signing a legal contract, the 'romance' and party side is secondary.

Yep. Yet still we have 20+ pages of people wanging on about how they can’t afford it.

Lets put this in perspective: it’s a couple of hundred quid now versus half a million quid in the future.

hjytrjulykuyh · 19/12/2023 08:26

I'm astonished that more people don't realise that having a child with someone is no commitment to that other person beyond co-parenting. You both commit to the child, it says nothing about one another. Similarly, a mortgage. That's a commitment you both make to the bank, not one another, beyond being liable for each other's payments. Marriage is the only commitment you actually make to each other that directly ties into your relationship as partners. Just look at how many people have children with a donor, or with a platonic friend (quite common in LGBT circles), or buy property with family.

It's very sad that people have been culturally conditioned to assume marriage equals a wedding and that the wedding has to be expensive and large. You can get married for a couple hundred quid. You don't have to wear anything specific. You don't have to have anyone there barring a couple witnesses. It's signing a legal contract, the 'romance' and party side is secondary.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 08:23

Angrycat2768 · 19/12/2023 08:17

Agree. All this Bridezilla stuff is horrifically harmful to women. It allows people to think that a wedding is the happy ever instead of the start of a marriage, which is a legal contract, nothing more. Being a SAHM is risky at the best of times, but being wholly dependent on an adult who has no responsibility for you when you have children to support is asking for trouble.

Edited

Yep. And when you read this thread you realise how astonishingly financially and legally illiterate so many women are.

Historically marriage was by far the best and simplest way to protect yourself. This is no longer automatically the case but still people frame it in the most outdated way.

The amount of women sleepwalking into financial self harm through a poor understanding of marriage is genuinely frightening.

Dixiechickonhols · 19/12/2023 08:20

Having a child is a legal and financial commitment to the child. Unfortunately lots of women think it’s a commitment to them and act to their detriment eg unmarried sahm with no income, living in his house etc.
I definitely view marriage as an insurance policy.
When I married I had no need to - I worked ft, earned same as him, same profession with good prospects.
5 years later I was in a totally different position - pregnancy had triggered a serious health condition and I had a child with a disability. I ended up working pt for years. Women are the ones who suffer birth injuries and usually end up carers if a child is born with a disability.
We didn’t split but if we had that ‘piece of paper’ would have ensured house split and pension split factored this in. Without a marriage contract there’s no mechanism for that.

burnoutbabe · 19/12/2023 08:18

People know they can do the cheapest wedding ceremony.

But they probably want something a bit nicer. And to invite sone guests, parents and sone others. And then host them to sone food as they have travelled. Probably buy a nice outfit so they look good as they share the news / photos for memories.
If they are not doing it strictly to tie up legal paperwork, then you probably want a nice day and that costs sone money (say 2-3k) so it gets put off.

No one really wants to attend a vow renewal so you get one chance to have your day. So you want to get that right, for you, and not rush that decision (again assuming no sudden reason to marry asap)

So long term engaged, probably want a nice wedding and don't want to do the £100 version.

(And I mean a small nice wedding, not 70 at a country house).

Angrycat2768 · 19/12/2023 08:17

Agree. All this Bridezilla stuff is horrifically harmful to women. It allows people to think that a wedding is the happy ever instead of the start of a marriage, which is a legal contract, nothing more. Being a SAHM is risky at the best of times, but being wholly dependent on an adult who has no responsibility for you when you have children to support is asking for trouble.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 08:06

@Ilikepinacoladass

Woman don't need to be married anymore, it's not like in the past where they become financially dependent on their husband and needed to be married for security

Well, qualification is needed. Some women really do need to be married. SAHMs need to be married as a matter of priority. For most working women and women with assets it's a bad idea. The problem is most women don't understand whether marriage is a good thing or a bad thing for them and don't understand where they sit on this spectrum of financial need.

That's where the lack of education is a problem and all the obsession with weddings and "special days".

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2023 07:57

VolvoFan · 18/12/2023 21:05

Just picture it. For one day; the dress, the tuxedo/suit, the family, the friends, the cake, the photographer (always vet those and never cheap out with them), the happiness, the feeling like a princess in your beautiful dress and the sight of your soulmate in a nice tuxedo or suit, the exchange of vows (you can customise these), the rings and the bride taking the groom's name (yes, this is optional).

None of this is going to break the bank. It is indeed a nice little earner because everyone has to make a living, especially with how expensive everything is now.

Are men and women really so disinterested in the magic of their own wedding day? Men and women, particularly women, literally dream about this stuff when they're children. And to brush off weddings as 'circuses' imo is crude.

Of course you only marry if you both know you want to spend the rest of your lives together, and it's not a decision to be taken lightly as it's a huge commitment. The same holds true for having children together. Marriage takes work and it can be hard going, just like becoming a parent. If you love each other to make babies together, there is no question on the worth of being married.

This is not me saying people absolutely should get married or else. This is not me getting angry at people for choosing to not get married or for not prioritising marriage, I just don't for even one second buy into this notion that marriage is outdated, trite and pointless. But inevitably I'm old-fashioned and from the 1950s with internalised misogyny or some similar nonsense 🙄

steps down from soapbox

I'm sorry @VolvoFan you are not the worst offender but I think this sort of nonsense about weddings has a lot to answer for and is a large part of the reason why people don't understand marriage and make such poor, life-crippingly poor, decisions about it.

The miasma of Disneyfication around your "special day" and all that is so entrenched that most people get completely hypnotised and can't see past the white dresses and the table plans and all the rest of it. This is not what's important about marriage.

Marriage is a financial contract, like an insurance policy, no more no less. Like an insurance policy it's financially life-saving if you need it but a dangerous white elephant if you don't.

If you don't work or plan to stop work it's absolutely essential. If you work and particularly if you earn more than your partner it's nearly always a disaster. I know women who have been properly shafted by not being married. For my part if I got married to my partner my daughter could stand to lose everything.

But as PPs have pointed out most people know astonishingly little about the legal rights and responsibilities that marriages bestows. As the long litany of horror stories on here shows. This should absolutely be taught in schools and it should in my view by mandatory education as part of any marriage preparation.

The more people witter on about white dresses and cakes and everlasting love the less they understand this. So please for the love of God can we all understand, and teach our daughters, that marriage is not about love or white dresses or rings or napkins or best man's speeches or engagement or anything else. Its about money and how not to get shafted by your domestic arrangements.

Swipe left for the next trending thread