Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To see a lot of couples in this situation

693 replies

Whatyoutryingtodo · 17/12/2023 09:00

I see quite a few couples I know irl who've been together several years, engaged, own a house and have children, but no wedding plans made.
They've often been engaged for several years too but don't have any plans to get married, and say stuff like they'll 'get round to it at some point'.

Just curious as to why this happens quite a lot, not judging as I myself am unmarried and childless due to no interested suitors!

I think people will say that the man has everything he needs so why bother marrying her... Sometimes I wonder why people consider marriage more of a commitment than children? At least with marriage you can divorce, even if it's expensive and stressful, children you're tied for life.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CatholicLass · 17/12/2023 16:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

VolvoFan · 17/12/2023 16:20

It does seem silly to me. Weddings needn't be expensive either. And getting married is easy-peasy. It's the memory that counts, not the bells and whistles.

I did it the right way, in my opinion. I got married, got a house and then tried to start a family. That last thing... the making babies bit... hasn't gone to plan so far, but we're not giving up.

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 16:16

The difficulty with the argument that people shouldn't be forced into marriage is that if you change the law to treat cohabitants like spouses legally and want it to have any teeth, that means other people's choices get taken away. You force people who want to live together but not have that legal contract to lose one of those things. It is possible to have an opt in model, but that's not going to achieve all the things people want it to achieve.

LaurieStrode · 17/12/2023 16:14

Well stated, @Zone2NorthLondon !

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 17/12/2023 16:13

Everyone has their own opinions and their own choices. I am just stamping my feet at my own personal frustrations. Don't mind me.

Fair enough!

Zone2NorthLondon · 17/12/2023 16:13

CatMadam · 17/12/2023 14:54

Wanting fairness isn’t ’expecting preferential treatment.’ People shouldn’t be forced into marriage/partnership just because the law
hasn’t caught up with the times.

What are you seeking a Sahm special protection,CP & marriage is available to all inc SAHM. There is No specific unfairness towards SAHM as a group. If a SAHM (stupidly) gives up work and is financially dependent, that is her unwise decision. No one should be forced into a marriage or a CP I wholeheartedly agree. However, if one chooses not to avail oneself of existing protection then you do so knowing it’s potentially risky. It’s ludicrous to suggest create a special category of protection for women who give up work and stay home because some feel potentially vulnerable. If one wants or needs financial autotomy you don’t give up work to stay home,dependent on a man

mathanxiety · 17/12/2023 16:12

threelittlescones · 17/12/2023 09:44

I've been engaged to my partner since February 2020. Tbh I thought we would absolutely be married by now. We've made very little progress with any planning.

We have 3 kids under 5. We're exhausted. We're on a tight budget. But if I'm being honest, it comes down to the fact I'm quite overweight and don't want to be fat on my wedding day. We plan to have a proper health kick after Christmas.

Why not have a quick registry wedding?

You can lose the weight and throw a party afterwards.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 17/12/2023 16:12

Why are women so happy to give up their surname? I get angry just thinking about it. It feels like wiping out my own family history, just because I would be getting married. To be ‘owned and labelled’ by someone.

I'm not defined by my husband's surname any more than I was by my father's (to which I had no particular attachment, in spite of having no issues with my father!). My family history still exists and is just the same whatever I choose to call myself.

Admittedly, I'm a lot more of a feminist now than I was when I got married, and the idea of women being compelled to take their husband's name would make me angry too. But I can't bring myself to be fussed about the choice I made - I guess I just don't feel very strongly about surnames. My husband doesn't 'own' me and he wouldn't have remotely minded if I'd kept my name.

MrsMurphyIWish · 17/12/2023 16:11

I’m a feminist and changed my surname as 1. my surname doesn’t define me 2. My inherited surname is way cooler than my birth surname (which is so common!) 3. I am not owned by my husband - if you knew me IRL you would laugh that me being a “Mrs” means I have submitted to the patriarchy 4. Using feminism as an excuse to not marrying is as far a fem thing you can do. Marriage is a CONTRACT that will PROTECT both parties.

Rainyday4321 · 17/12/2023 16:11

baffles me. But then we were engaged and married within 5 months. Being engaged is not actually a thing- it might feel warm and fuzzy but it doesn’t mean anything in the cold light of day.

i don’t think marriage matters in any ethical way- but it is actually a contract with consequences, as a good friend of mine who is separating from her partner after 4 children is currently finding out (to her cost).

generally I think the reason people don’t get married, and have kids first, is that blokes are hedging their bets.🤷🏻‍♀️

Silverfoxlady · 17/12/2023 16:11

ectoone · 17/12/2023 16:05

Why are women so happy to give up their surname?

I had no attachment to it.

I get angry just thinking about it.

You don't have to do it. But you don't need to be angry for other people's choices.

It feels like wiping out my own family history, just because I would be getting married.

That's a bit weird though because the history of your family exists regardless of your name. I was happy to disassociate- I even changed my first name although not on marriage, I had already done that. Sadly my family history does still exist. I focused on building my own family unit though and while I did change my name to that of DH, it could have been any name really - it just didn't occur to me way back to think of a new one.

To be ‘owned and labelled’ by someone.

I mean if you want to call a surname a label I guess if you keep your original surname you are just labelled as your family a gen back rather than the one you created?

You are right - was ranting, but it comes hand in hand with what my DP and his family were expecting when we got together and the frustration I felt. They were shocked when I gave my children both of our names, but came to accept it over time. It was a personal statement about how I felt.

Everyone has their own opinions and their own choices. I am just stamping my feet at my own personal frustrations. Don't mind me.

mathanxiety · 17/12/2023 16:11

Marriage involves giving a woman rights to money, assets, the family home.

grayhairdontcare · 17/12/2023 16:11

I've been with my DP for over 30 years.
I've never wanted to get married.
Honestly can't see the point and I've never been to a wedding that's not been dull!
We have everything legal and the children have never had a problem with it .
I've just never fancied wasting the money on an outdated ceremony

Bowbobobo · 17/12/2023 16:09

I have more assets than my DP so I don’t want to marry him - as we both have adult DC it’s important to stick with what’s mine is mine (and my DC’s) and what’s his is his (and his DC’s). Therefore we haven’t got engaged. I don’t understand being engaged for years and years, if you want to marry then do it already! And if you don’t want to marry, don’t get engaged.

Mummyofbananas · 17/12/2023 16:07

I've been engaged for years- we just can't afford a wedding. I own my house and there's not enough savings or anything for it to matter if we split. We would both like to get married it's just not viable at the moment.

Justgorgeous · 17/12/2023 16:07

The last 3 couples i knew in this situation the guy was having an affair and just waiting to make his move.

ectoone · 17/12/2023 16:05

Why are women so happy to give up their surname?

I had no attachment to it.

I get angry just thinking about it.

You don't have to do it. But you don't need to be angry for other people's choices.

It feels like wiping out my own family history, just because I would be getting married.

That's a bit weird though because the history of your family exists regardless of your name. I was happy to disassociate- I even changed my first name although not on marriage, I had already done that. Sadly my family history does still exist. I focused on building my own family unit though and while I did change my name to that of DH, it could have been any name really - it just didn't occur to me way back to think of a new one.

To be ‘owned and labelled’ by someone.

I mean if you want to call a surname a label I guess if you keep your original surname you are just labelled as your family a gen back rather than the one you created?

Silverfoxlady · 17/12/2023 15:59

Wanderpeg · 17/12/2023 15:47

We chose a new surname when we got married. It wasn’t an anagram or mix of our original ones, we just chose one we both loved.

That is lovely! I really like that idea.

Silverfoxlady · 17/12/2023 15:49

HarlequinsPants and SpringViolet,

Thank you both for the honest feedback - so much better than the Google search I did!

Wow, that has made me think…

We don’t own a house, but I might one day inherit one from my father. Which poses the question about my partner and children inheriting it one day if something happens to me.

…. Also, it makes me think about who will pull the plug if something serious happens? Or if something happens to him? Would I be allowed to see him in hospital. I was thinking about that with my latest higher-risk pregnancy.

I guess a £300 registry office marriage might help after all… I feel a discussion with DP coming on 🤔

babyproblems · 17/12/2023 15:49

I think often the woman gets bored waiting and young men don’t feel any responsibility to get married these days as they can have the perks of marriage without actually doing the wedding or marriage contract bit. Personally if I ever have a daughter I’d 100% encourage her to get married before kids because so so many women are vulnerable with children and the lack of security marriage brings. It’s what protects most women legally in the event of divorce etc and whilst some might think this is outdated the truth is that women carry most of the joke workload and lose out when they have a family on pensions and earnings; at least marriage offers some stake and recognises the woman’s vulnerability to an extent. I think some women now also buy into the idea that marriage is outdated but truthfully I think this is ignorant of the real cost of children to women.

Wanderpeg · 17/12/2023 15:47

Silverfoxlady · 17/12/2023 15:08

… I might also be a little bit of a feminist on this one too, I think.

Why are women so happy to give up their surname? I get angry just thinking about it. It feels like wiping out my own family history, just because I would be getting married. To be ‘owned and labelled’ by someone.

I decided to give my children both surnames, there is no way I carry them for 9 months and give them my partner’s name only. I hope there would be a little of me in there too.

I now plenty of women out there happy to take their husband’s name, but I think I am in the minority who feel resentful.

We chose a new surname when we got married. It wasn’t an anagram or mix of our original ones, we just chose one we both loved.

LaurieStrode · 17/12/2023 15:41

SnowflakeSparkles · 17/12/2023 15:37

Haven't RTFT but I'm in this situation. It's purely down to finances.

Perhaps it's stupid and romantic of me but I don't want to just get legally married, even if it's a registry office job I want to have semblance of a ceremony and with 3 young kids on one wage it's just not a financial priority.

My partner and I both want to get married when our lives are a bit less chaotic and I have lost a few pounds and feel more confident in a wedding dress ha.

I think a fair few people of my generation are in this complacent state. Marriage is definitely not a mandatory prerequisite to settling down and starting a family anymore.

Whose wage is supporting your family? Yours, I hope, for your sake.

Otherwise you are SAHM to three offspring and have zero security should your children's father decide tomorrow that he wants to walk away. After three kids, why do you need the fanfare of a "wedding" ? It's not as though it's a big life stage transition at that point.

SnowflakeSparkles · 17/12/2023 15:37

Haven't RTFT but I'm in this situation. It's purely down to finances.

Perhaps it's stupid and romantic of me but I don't want to just get legally married, even if it's a registry office job I want to have semblance of a ceremony and with 3 young kids on one wage it's just not a financial priority.

My partner and I both want to get married when our lives are a bit less chaotic and I have lost a few pounds and feel more confident in a wedding dress ha.

I think a fair few people of my generation are in this complacent state. Marriage is definitely not a mandatory prerequisite to settling down and starting a family anymore.

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 15:32

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 17/12/2023 15:30

Just to add, when people split up, those ‘what if’ agreements you came to during the relationship quite often go out the window when the rage and heartache come in.

Definitely. If you're not making the decision because of religious or ideological convictions or whatever, as some do, it should be about whether you prefer the legal position for married or unmarried couples at the end of the relationship. Whether that's splitting up or death.

SpidersAreShitheads · 17/12/2023 15:31

I’ve been with DP 14 years. We got engaged just before COVID. No firm plans to marry at the moment but it’s something we both want to do. And we will. We’ve recently moved house and in the middle of renovations, plus we have two autistic DC that will struggle with a wedding. DS in particular (aged 14 yrs) thinks that if we get married we’ll move to another country and leave him! No idea where he’s got this idea from as I’ve only spent one night away from him his entire life - and that was when he was a baby and my dad was in hospital dying!

Getting engaged doesn’t feel pointless to me. The fact that DP loves me enough to have asked means a lot. Even without an actual wedding, it’s a symbol that we’re both committed to each other. He’s not one for empty words or meaningless gestures either, so it’s very special to me.

I honestly couldn’t give a toss if other people think it’s stupid to be engaged without setting a firm date - they’re entitled to their opinion. We will only have a tiny wedding - just us and the DC as they won’t manage anything else - but I would like a nice dress! 😂 I’d like to lose a bit of chub ideally before we marry so when all this house stuff is over we might see where we’re at. Who knows?! We will do it when the time is right for us.