Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To see a lot of couples in this situation

693 replies

Whatyoutryingtodo · 17/12/2023 09:00

I see quite a few couples I know irl who've been together several years, engaged, own a house and have children, but no wedding plans made.
They've often been engaged for several years too but don't have any plans to get married, and say stuff like they'll 'get round to it at some point'.

Just curious as to why this happens quite a lot, not judging as I myself am unmarried and childless due to no interested suitors!

I think people will say that the man has everything he needs so why bother marrying her... Sometimes I wonder why people consider marriage more of a commitment than children? At least with marriage you can divorce, even if it's expensive and stressful, children you're tied for life.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheHateIsNotGood · 17/12/2023 17:34

I think it's more a shift in attitude caused by the decrease in probable 'security' from making life choices, of any kind, which can shift the existing precarious balances that many people now experience, moreso the majority of working and child-bearing age people now, although not explicity set within age boundaries. I'm 61 (unmarried) so I am qualified to notice the changes.

For about 20 or so years it was about women exerting their independence, now with seemingly pure equality (not so much in real time) as culture has yet to catch up, many women are running on fresh air, meanwhile many men are trying to find where they stand, with cultural expectations that mainly consider that they should 'provide'. Best intentions and all that...

Now, everyone's done up like a kipper so mostly all hands on deck, marriage probably seems an unnecessary and frivolous expenditure of time and money.

TurnthePotatoes · 17/12/2023 17:30

Obbydoo · 17/12/2023 17:20

OP asks a question not in any way relevant to him/her, there is no AIBU and then is never seen again. Shouldn't Mumsnet clamp down on posts that are so blatantly someone conducting research? Surely people have a right to know they are contributing to research and what their opinions are being used for?

Nope. Anything you post on a public forum and be used by anyone. If you're so precious about how your 'opinions' are used - don't post.
Furthermore, debate about this can only be a good thing!

The issues here around isn't around the choices themselves it's about making informed decisions. All power to people like @grayhairdontcare who have thought about it, decided to remain unmarried and gotten the appropriate protections in place. But the PP who didn't know how far-ranging the benefits were, or think it's 'just a piece of paper' well this thread might educate them.

In 2023 there's no stigma (except among maybe uber-religious people) against living together and even having kids unmarried. So marriage isn't about the relationship between two people. It's about them declaring it to the State. Still, so much waffle about costing money, a big useless ceremony etc etc. That isn't its primary purpose!

grayhairdontcare · 17/12/2023 17:24

@crispynight I've never been married and I am extremely well financially protected.
We own everything 50 /50 . We have the same in death benefits for each othe.
The same wills. The same amounts in pensions.
I'm failing to see how a wedding would have made me more protected?

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 17/12/2023 17:23

@crispynight I’ve just priced up our local registry office - £400!!!!! Just for the bit of paper and an office for 10-15 minutes. That is a lot for some. Do they do last minute cancellation deals?

crispynight · 17/12/2023 17:22

@grayhairdontcare you are financially more protected.

Obbydoo · 17/12/2023 17:20

OP asks a question not in any way relevant to him/her, there is no AIBU and then is never seen again. Shouldn't Mumsnet clamp down on posts that are so blatantly someone conducting research? Surely people have a right to know they are contributing to research and what their opinions are being used for?

grayhairdontcare · 17/12/2023 17:19

@crispynight unless the bride & groom are religious I honestly don't see the point.

crispynight · 17/12/2023 17:18

@grayhairdontcare it doesn't have to cost a lot or be religious. I understand why some people would want it to cost a lot.

grayhairdontcare · 17/12/2023 17:15

@Snippysocks or maybe they don't feel the need to spend time and money on an outdated ceremony that means nothing to anyone that isn't deeply religious

crispynight · 17/12/2023 17:14

@SerenityNowInsanityLater this

WhichIsItWendy · 17/12/2023 17:01

TurnthePotatoes · 17/12/2023 15:21

Well this makes perfect sense. You don't want to marry. So you aren't engaged. Because an engagement is a 'plan to marry'. Fine.
OP is talking about people who are engaged, BUT have no plans to marry. Making the 'engagement' meaningless. What is it? Just some sweet words and a piece of jewellery.
having kids, sharing a property, marriage these are all concrete ties. I could be 'engaged' to a random tomorrow by telling him we should marry and him saying yes. We then go our separate ways never to meet again but I can still claim I'm 'engaged'..

Of course, people can do what they like but I do wonder what people think being engaged means. If you're not going to prioritise a wedding then why get engaged?

Sadly I see a lot of women getting a 'shut up' ring. I always say if a man wanted to do something he'd do it.

Edited

I got a ring because it's pretty, beautiful in fact. And I wanted the extra commitment at the time, something to show we love each other enough to get married - without actually wanting to get married!

I have no intentions to marry. Both of us have been on the fence all of the 15 years we've been (happily) together.

We've since had multiple children and both working up the career ladder. We plod along nicely with no need for marriage, it's very low on my list of priorities!

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 16:58

TurnthePotatoes · 17/12/2023 16:55

I do think there could be more legislation to protect parents, whatever else I think about the US they're far stricter with child maintenance. And, the system aside, our society could do far more to educate people, IMO info about marriage should be given out in maternity appointments. So many people still think for example common law gives them rights.

We could certainly make more effort with enforcement of child maintenance. You're not wrong there. I think that should exist separately to the legislative position about partners, though, because not all parents were in a relationship.

TurnthePotatoes · 17/12/2023 16:55

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 16:49

They are indeed!

Basically, whatever system we have, some people will manage to fall foul of it. They won't opt in, or opt out, or go to the registry office. Because they don't know, or they don't get round to it. So it's a choice about which group to screw over for the benefit of others.

I do think there could be more legislation to protect parents, whatever else I think about the US they're far stricter with child maintenance. And, the system aside, our society could do far more to educate people, IMO info about marriage should be given out in maternity appointments. So many people still think for example common law gives them rights.

TurnthePotatoes · 17/12/2023 16:51

CatMadam · 17/12/2023 16:40

@TurnthePotatoes it’s not a civil partnership, that’s what I meant.

That still makes no sense. Nobody is being forced into anything, unlike what you're proposing to do with your 'legal protection for SAHM'.
I'm presuming this 'legal protection' involves a fair share of the assets accrued by the other party... which... wait for it.. marriage gives! Or even a civil partnership.

Why do we need new laws etc for that which already has a solution solely because you have some vague ideas of 'partnership'?

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 16:49

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 17/12/2023 16:45

I agree. Plenty of people want to live together without any legal ties for various valid reasons eg wanting to protect their finances for any children they don't share with their partner.

Plus of course the "opt in" system you mention already exist. That's what marriage/civil partnerships are.

They are indeed!

Basically, whatever system we have, some people will manage to fall foul of it. They won't opt in, or opt out, or go to the registry office. Because they don't know, or they don't get round to it. So it's a choice about which group to screw over for the benefit of others.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 17/12/2023 16:45

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 16:16

The difficulty with the argument that people shouldn't be forced into marriage is that if you change the law to treat cohabitants like spouses legally and want it to have any teeth, that means other people's choices get taken away. You force people who want to live together but not have that legal contract to lose one of those things. It is possible to have an opt in model, but that's not going to achieve all the things people want it to achieve.

I agree. Plenty of people want to live together without any legal ties for various valid reasons eg wanting to protect their finances for any children they don't share with their partner.

Plus of course the "opt in" system you mention already exist. That's what marriage/civil partnerships are.

CatMadam · 17/12/2023 16:41

nopuppiesallowed · 17/12/2023 13:59

I've always suspected that unmarried couples living together might, subconsciously, just be waiting for someone better to come along....No public legal commitment might mean no indepth commitment to the relationship at all. Scary...

Or they just don’t want to get married?

ClareBlue · 17/12/2023 16:40

There seems to be two themes on this thread. Reasons not to be married, all seems valid and reasonable, and reasons not to get married after getting engaged. Most saying other priorities.
So, those that not engaged but still not married. Did you think that by getting engaged you were going to be married in, say, 2 years or did you genuinely have no plans to be married, just engaged.
It would be interesting as to why you actually got engaged if you had no intention of planning to get married. I always thought you git engaged after agreeing to get married and it was that period before. 2 years max. But obviously not for another of people.

CatMadam · 17/12/2023 16:40

@TurnthePotatoes it’s not a civil partnership, that’s what I meant.

crispynight · 17/12/2023 16:37

I wouldn't have felt safe getting pregnant not being married. Things can and do go wrong with relationships. Women have a lot more to lose than men. The way society views women and mothers makes them less likely to be the main earner.

My husband is the main earner. We had twins and childcare was too expensive. Also, I wanted to be there for them as babies and toddlers, and part time until they started school. It felt natural to me.

Obviously my career suffered but it's not a competition. I now want to put my foot down career wise.

I just feel women have more power in a marriage. My opinion.

scoobydoo1971 · 17/12/2023 16:35

I wouldn't get married as I don't believe in it. It can be easy to get a divorce, it can tie you to someone legally and financially, and is based around some religious ideas that I do not relate to. This is a personal choice, and I appreciate other people have different beliefs and marry for a variety of religious, cultural, family and financial reasons. There is no judgement from me for those who choose to marry, as they are free to make their own choice in life. I have had three marriage proposals off boyfriends in the past decade, and refused all. It was clear that marriage was important to them, and resulted in the end of our relationship. I believe marriage was the deal breaker because I am wealthy, and they were not. They were not deadbeats either, but we are not matched in terms of assets and that felt like a huge risk to take. I believe they were trying to secure their future through a marriage. This is not strictly in the gold digger/ cocklodger way of things as they were fond of me, but the last man pointed out that if we lived together in my house, then I could kick him out at any time and he would have no security for his retirement. My argument was that it was my money, and for my children. I didn't see a future with any of these men as I would always be wondering if they were hanging out for a wedding band, and the legal rights that go along with that. In terms of the last suitor, it wasn't my fault his ex-wife took him to the cleaners in the divorce settlement, or that his business was struggling post-covid. On the face of it, a wedding and marriage are nice, and perhaps reflect a statement to society about the union of two people. However, I have seen too many people come out of a bad marriage penniless, fighting over child custody or who gets the sofa, and bitter to ever risk it.

TrashedSofa · 17/12/2023 16:28

It was either keep my maiden name, father’s surname, which caused teasing for much of my childhood and would have crude jokes made here as well or take my husband’s name which is benign.

Call yourself whatever you want, but this is a double standard. Either you swapped your own name for your husband's, or you swapped your dad's for your FILs.

AgathaAllAlong · 17/12/2023 16:28

I'm in this position. When DP proposed I thought he meant it, but he's resisted any attempt to actually plan. I think if i did it all for him he would be happy, but i want to marry someone who actually is enthusiastic, not who will do it if no effort. It annoys me because I had no interest in marriage but was happy enough to do it. Now it just feels like he wants the pressure of people asking when he'll propose off him without following through but breaking it off and returning the ring would feel childish and dramatic.

Since the proposal my salary has increased and our relationship has taken a dive so I don't want to marry him.

phoenixrosehere · 17/12/2023 16:26

Silverfoxlady · 17/12/2023 15:08

… I might also be a little bit of a feminist on this one too, I think.

Why are women so happy to give up their surname? I get angry just thinking about it. It feels like wiping out my own family history, just because I would be getting married. To be ‘owned and labelled’ by someone.

I decided to give my children both surnames, there is no way I carry them for 9 months and give them my partner’s name only. I hope there would be a little of me in there too.

I now plenty of women out there happy to take their husband’s name, but I think I am in the minority who feel resentful.

Why are women so happy to give up their surname?

It was either keep my maiden name, father’s surname, which caused teasing for much of my childhood and would have crude jokes made here as well or take my husband’s name which is benign. My mother kept her surname but has issues with it too where people assume she made a mistake and try to correct it.

I had actually considered keeping my surname despite this but my father really angered me to the point that I said yep, I’ll take my husband’s name. Even if DH and I divorce, I would keep his surname.

Ap24 · 17/12/2023 16:25

We got married for financial and legal reasons. Our wedding was small and cheap. We had always planned on having children and like the extra security in that respect.

But is it really worth it for everyone? I seriously doubt that. If you have no assets or savings them I'm not sure to the upside?