Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair benefits sanction?

212 replies

Snowymorning · 16/12/2023 21:17

Not a begging post and I’ll make things work but just wanted opinions whether I’ve been unfairly treated. I lost my job about 9 months ago due to cuts at work and I’m currently on Universal Credit and have been looking for work around school hours as I’m a single parent and my daughter is in reception . I was signed up for a back to work programme called Restart. Restart kept booking appointments in at school pick up time even though I had told them I can’t attend at these times. I always let them know and asked to rearrange but they kept doing it. I’ve now been sanctioned by the job centre for not attending two Restart appointments booked in at 3pm and they’ve took £363 off me this month. I just think this is unfair at Christmas time especially as a single mum with a 4 year old. I really don’t have anyone else who could have collected my daughter for me either. Fairly new to area and don’t know anybody who could have. Is this fair for them to have done this?

OP posts:
Beezknees · 17/12/2023 11:57

Smellslikesummer · 17/12/2023 11:45

Most after school clubs are able to accommodate one-off bookings IME, especially since Covid as more parents are WFH and able to nip off to pickup.
Obviously not always the case but then you could also ask another parent to pickup your child in exchange for you picking up theirs another day, or asking a friend etc.

DS's primary didn't as it was so oversubscribed. If you wanted your child to attend you had to commit to a regular slot. The only day they ever had one off spaces was Fridays as it wasn't a popular day.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 17/12/2023 11:45

MonikerBing · 17/12/2023 10:25

There might be many reasons why she is looking for school hours only, including that she believes her daughter needs her around. There might be no or expensive wrap around care. In any case, I don't think the OP was asking whether she was being reasonable looking for school hours work.

Yes OP I think it's grossly unfair that you are being sanctioned for that. The work coach should be supporting you into work, not sanctioning you.

I’m sorry but “believes her daughter needs her around” just doesn’t wash when the daughter also needs to be housed, fed and clothed. I think almost everyone would like to be around more for their kids, but as adults we accept we have a duty to provide for them, even if that means making compromises. There are vanishingly few circumstances where there is no wraparound care available, if not through school than through a local childminder. Expensive or inconvenient maybe, but like many others sometimes you just have to make it work.

My comment is relevant to the OPs post because whilst this sanction is unfair, I think the OP could potentially be further sanctioned if she continues to insist on school hours only work.

Smellslikesummer · 17/12/2023 11:45

Most after school clubs are able to accommodate one-off bookings IME, especially since Covid as more parents are WFH and able to nip off to pickup.
Obviously not always the case but then you could also ask another parent to pickup your child in exchange for you picking up theirs another day, or asking a friend etc.

FestiveFruitloop · 17/12/2023 11:32

Frasers · 17/12/2023 11:11

Thing is if doesn’t matter if people think it’s fair or not. The system is she’s expected to be available for work 30 hours a week and be job hunting for those hours when unemployed. Just like in a job, child care is solely the ops responsibility. This is clearly much more than 2 appts missed, that’s what she was sanctioned for, but it’s obviously been a longer issue, as she says they keep doing it and she keeps telling them she is unavailable and reorganising,so now they have moved to sanctions.

there is no doubt it is hard, but the system is, you need to be available for work 30 hours a week, or spend 30 hours a week intensively job searching. As said, she has likely aapplied for very little, as she wants to only work part time during school hours and term time. And will need to allow for drop off and pick up in that time, so clearly not available to do 30 hours a week. I suspect that’s the real issue here. She is not available and also is not attending mandatory interviews, I doubt every single one inc the ones rearranged were all for 3pm.

None of this addresses what she is supposed to do about picking her DC up though?

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/12/2023 11:27

Frasers · 17/12/2023 11:11

Thing is if doesn’t matter if people think it’s fair or not. The system is she’s expected to be available for work 30 hours a week and be job hunting for those hours when unemployed. Just like in a job, child care is solely the ops responsibility. This is clearly much more than 2 appts missed, that’s what she was sanctioned for, but it’s obviously been a longer issue, as she says they keep doing it and she keeps telling them she is unavailable and reorganising,so now they have moved to sanctions.

there is no doubt it is hard, but the system is, you need to be available for work 30 hours a week, or spend 30 hours a week intensively job searching. As said, she has likely aapplied for very little, as she wants to only work part time during school hours and term time. And will need to allow for drop off and pick up in that time, so clearly not available to do 30 hours a week. I suspect that’s the real issue here. She is not available and also is not attending mandatory interviews, I doubt every single one inc the ones rearranged were all for 3pm.

Work coaches are also meant to be flexible and take into account personal circumstances.

BabyMinnie · 17/12/2023 11:16

somedogsdo · 17/12/2023 00:57

But don't you get most of childcare paid for? I'm not sure of the timescales involved here but if they've given you enough time to arrange childcare and paid for it, why wouldn't you be available for work?

What is the point on commenting on things thay you clearly know nothing about?

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 11:13

Shelovespawpatrol · 17/12/2023 10:14

With a four year old, they would only expect her to work 16 hours per week- dinner lady work, part time shop work, part time admin work, deliveroo driver. There are school hour jobs out there, just few and far between.

That's not correct. It's 30 hours now. 16 hours was only under the old tax credits system.

somedogsdo · 17/12/2023 11:12

To the poster that said OP might wish to be around for her child - I think, unfortunately, she doesn't have this luxury.
I'm not saying it's right. But as a single parent myself, I had to put my son with a (lovely) childminder from 12m and arrange wrap around care when he went to school so that I could work. Although my childcare costs were heavily subsidised through tax credits.

My sister (not a single parent) got to be a SAHM for years.
It's unfair but that's the reality.

I don't think it's realistic to think you can only look for work during school hours. I'm sorry this has happened but presumably you were made aware of the conditions for continuing to receive the benefits and you chose to ignore them. Whether it's fair or not is a different story - it is what it is.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 11:12

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 11:11

If you're unemployed you don't get childcare paid for! You have to be working AND it's paid in arrears even then.

Oh do read the thread,

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 11:11

Frasers · 17/12/2023 09:48

I think she can claim child care as part of uc even though not employed.

If you're unemployed you don't get childcare paid for! You have to be working AND it's paid in arrears even then.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 11:11

Thing is if doesn’t matter if people think it’s fair or not. The system is she’s expected to be available for work 30 hours a week and be job hunting for those hours when unemployed. Just like in a job, child care is solely the ops responsibility. This is clearly much more than 2 appts missed, that’s what she was sanctioned for, but it’s obviously been a longer issue, as she says they keep doing it and she keeps telling them she is unavailable and reorganising,so now they have moved to sanctions.

there is no doubt it is hard, but the system is, you need to be available for work 30 hours a week, or spend 30 hours a week intensively job searching. As said, she has likely aapplied for very little, as she wants to only work part time during school hours and term time. And will need to allow for drop off and pick up in that time, so clearly not available to do 30 hours a week. I suspect that’s the real issue here. She is not available and also is not attending mandatory interviews, I doubt every single one inc the ones rearranged were all for 3pm.

FreeRider · 17/12/2023 11:10

I have a friend who is a DWP Work Coach.

Once you've been referred to Restart, you are supposed to treat it as a job...you have to prove you are actively job searching for 35 hours a week, and prepared to take any job that is offered to you. It will be assumed that you wouldn't be able to leave a job early to pick up your kids on a regular basis, so you can't while you are on Restart. Restart meetings can be classed as mandatory, so missing any can lead to a sanction from the DWP.

FloweryName · 17/12/2023 10:56

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 10:44

The OP has just said that there is no wraparound care.

All I saw in her only post was that she said she didn’t have anyone who could collect her child because she’s new to the area and doesn’t know anyone. That’s not the same thing.

FestiveFruitloop · 17/12/2023 10:56

Namenamchange · 16/12/2023 21:24

Fair

How on earth is this fair, unless you think it's fine for OP to leave her DC standing at the school gates? (In which case, as has been pointed out, she'd be in trouble with social services.)

Nochoiceleft · 17/12/2023 10:56

@Shelovespawpatrol expected hours have increased.

Age between 3 and 12 You will be expected to work up to 30 hours a week, or spend up to 30 hours a week on work-related activities such as applying for jobs.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 10:44

FloweryName · 17/12/2023 10:43

Does your school have after school club and are they aware either way? It seems fair to expect you to use after school club if there is one available but if not I can’t see what else they expect you to do.

The OP has just said that there is no wraparound care.

FloweryName · 17/12/2023 10:43

Does your school have after school club and are they aware either way? It seems fair to expect you to use after school club if there is one available but if not I can’t see what else they expect you to do.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 10:39

The real question is whether this is correct. And under current guidelines it is. UC claimants are required to be available for work, and that includes interviews. If a UC claimant cannot attend an interview, then by definition they aren't available for work. And as we have seen, the system has an outcome for that.

That's nonsense. If you have a dependent to pick up then you can't just not pick them up otherwise you'll have social services on your case.

You obviously think that the DWP has a computer says no approach but in my experience your MP can override this. There should be wiggle room. People are not robots.

Parentofeanda · 17/12/2023 10:39

my friend had this once, couldnt afford her food shop all month because of it and had to get food banks and help from everyone she was devastated as she had worked her whole life from 16 yrs to 35 and had only been on universal credit for 6 months, had to cancel once because her child was ill in hospital, other cancellation was because they kept booking it at school pick up time and her school doesnt do after school care they said she needed to get the father to pick up!! THERE WAS NO FATHER! Bold to presume.

deliciousdevilwoman · 17/12/2023 10:39

Sitters.co.Uk don’t do school pick ups. They look after children in their own homes or in a hotel, if say parents were at a child free wedding reception.
You also have to pay a registration fee due annually, £60.00 (it might have gone up since I last used them) a booking fee to sitters and bookings are a minimum of 3 hrs at £10.50+per hour depending on where you are in the country.
So, this option would not have been viable for the OP.
I agree that the sanction was unfair

VeloHostage · 17/12/2023 10:35

People really need to stop obsessing over "fair". Fairness has nothing to do with the real world, and doubly less in DWP land.

The real question is whether this is correct. And under current guidelines it is. UC claimants are required to be available for work, and that includes interviews. If a UC claimant cannot attend an interview, then by definition they aren't available for work. And as we have seen, the system has an outcome for that.

Restart coaches have very little say in how they dish out appointments. Their main concern is to evidence the claimants they are assigned have complied with the Restart conditions, or the provider (ultimately the DPW in the guise of SERCO) will want their money back.

Personally I think it's a cruel system which enriches government chums at the expense of vulnerable people. However I realise that's not a popular view these days.

The only practical advice to the OP is to conform to the system. Which is probably less than helpful, but really the only way. The are no grounds for appeal because the system has been designed in a fairytale world of perfect childcare which has been politically promised. And we should all know that political promises trump reality.

Folk can probably tell I am glad I no longer work in that field.

Dacadactyl · 17/12/2023 10:34

PepperIsHere · 17/12/2023 10:29

You're missing a whole lot, as it happens. Firstly, any clue as to the reality of the STRESS of trying to survive on a benefit, nevermind with a young child, and secondly, how freaking time consuming it is to a. look after a child, look for work, manage all the demands issued by appallingly inefficient got departments issuing paltry benefits, and b. the devastating and way out of proportion nightmare that sanctions cause.

Yes, I don't know what it's like to manage like this, that's true.

I do just want to say that there are plenty of people struggling in the same manner who do work. While that is also wrong, I do think that if you are claiming benefits, there should be some understanding that "he who pays the piper calls the tune", just in the same way a boss does.

That being said, I do have sympathy for the OP (as I said in the 3rd post on the thread) and I hope she gets the sanction lifted.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 10:34

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 10:32

I still think the job centre are deliberately asking the OP to come at school pick up time so that she finds it hard and so that they can sanction her.

Yes, potentially they are making a point and there is a wider issue here about the amount of roles op is applying for.

RaininSummer · 17/12/2023 10:33

Ask for a mandatory reconsideration as if you did ask them to rearrange the times with plenty of notice then you have been reasonable. However with a 4 year old you are expected to seek 30 hours of work now and use childcare for this. Restart kicks in after 9 months unemployment so you do need to broaden your work parameters it seems.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 10:32

I still think the job centre are deliberately asking the OP to come at school pick up time so that she finds it hard and so that they can sanction her.