Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unfair benefits sanction?

212 replies

Snowymorning · 16/12/2023 21:17

Not a begging post and I’ll make things work but just wanted opinions whether I’ve been unfairly treated. I lost my job about 9 months ago due to cuts at work and I’m currently on Universal Credit and have been looking for work around school hours as I’m a single parent and my daughter is in reception . I was signed up for a back to work programme called Restart. Restart kept booking appointments in at school pick up time even though I had told them I can’t attend at these times. I always let them know and asked to rearrange but they kept doing it. I’ve now been sanctioned by the job centre for not attending two Restart appointments booked in at 3pm and they’ve took £363 off me this month. I just think this is unfair at Christmas time especially as a single mum with a 4 year old. I really don’t have anyone else who could have collected my daughter for me either. Fairly new to area and don’t know anybody who could have. Is this fair for them to have done this?

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 17/12/2023 12:53

There are ways round it tho @Soontobe60

I know 2 working mums whose childcare fell through last minute (one with a days notice and one with less than a week). Both kids in reception, no childcare available locally, no family locally. Neither in jobs where "my childcare fell through" would wash. Both married and whose husbands also can't just not be in work.

They used the class WhatsApp groups to communicate and another mum picked up for them until they could sort more permanent childcare.

OP, this may be something to look into. If you have a class WhatsApp group it can be invaluable. Also, you could use the school run to get to know other parents so that you start to build a network in your new area.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:53

Soontobe60 · 17/12/2023 12:45

tell me what person who’s already on UC can afford to £10+ an hour for emergency childcare?

Sure, I don’t disagree, but the point is, the rule is she needs to be available for work. Just as plenty of people in employment can’t afford child care, Keeping fighting on mumsnet isn’t going to change that.

TwilightSkies · 17/12/2023 12:52

What lack of childcare?

It’s fair enough she doesn’t have childcare to attend the appointment. But that doesn’t mean she cant pay for proper childcare if she was to get a job.

Soontobe60 · 17/12/2023 12:45

Frasers · 17/12/2023 10:04

Actually you can usually. Organize a baby sitter for a couple of hours who can do pick up.

https://www.sitters.co.uk/

tell me what person who’s already on UC can afford to £10+ an hour for emergency childcare?

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/12/2023 12:41

TwilightSkies · 17/12/2023 12:38

Benefit Sanctions are basically a punishment for being Poor. They do nothing to help.people into work at all.

Not always. Maybe this will give OP the push to get a job instead of hanging round waiting for a ‘fits within school hours’ job. I just don’t think it’s a good enough reason to choose to stay unemployed.

I think a lack of childcare or family to help is a pretty good reason actually.

PepperIsHere · 17/12/2023 12:38

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:06

It’s not rubbish, far from it, the poster specifically said it maybe expensive or inconvenient, and it’s absolutely true. For a very rare meeting, say once a month, the op absolutely can find child care.

No she can't, she already explained that. Stop making things up. Your unwillingness to imagine that people's lives may be different to your own is remarkable.

TwilightSkies · 17/12/2023 12:38

Benefit Sanctions are basically a punishment for being Poor. They do nothing to help.people into work at all.

Not always. Maybe this will give OP the push to get a job instead of hanging round waiting for a ‘fits within school hours’ job. I just don’t think it’s a good enough reason to choose to stay unemployed.

girlfriend44 · 17/12/2023 12:28

Benefit Sanctions are basically a punishment for being Poor. They do nothing to help.people into work at all.

MonikerBing · 17/12/2023 12:25

YaWeeFurryBastard · 17/12/2023 11:45

I’m sorry but “believes her daughter needs her around” just doesn’t wash when the daughter also needs to be housed, fed and clothed. I think almost everyone would like to be around more for their kids, but as adults we accept we have a duty to provide for them, even if that means making compromises. There are vanishingly few circumstances where there is no wraparound care available, if not through school than through a local childminder. Expensive or inconvenient maybe, but like many others sometimes you just have to make it work.

My comment is relevant to the OPs post because whilst this sanction is unfair, I think the OP could potentially be further sanctioned if she continues to insist on school hours only work.

erm I think you'll find that there is a massive shortage of wraparound care in this country. look here just 26% of local authorities have sufficient wrap around care And even more is unaffordable to someone on benefits (and fwiw, although UC is meant to cover 85% of childcare costs - (which incidentally she's not entitled to until she's actually started work), in very few places does it actually cover 85%.

The question of choice is a different issue.

And yes the sanction is not only unfair, but it's wrong. work coaches are actually meant to take account of childcare issues etc, but in this case they haven't.

https://www.coram.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Coram-Childcare-Survey-2022.pdf

rorret · 17/12/2023 12:23

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 12:12

I was made redundant in July and the lovely work coach made appointments for me during school hours even though my DS is 15 and comes home from school by himself! Some just seem to like being awkward for the sake of it.

The op is on a different scheme though, due to being unemployed for a longer period, so different rules apply.

CHRIS003 · 17/12/2023 12:21

Do you have a written record of the conversations regarding appointment changes - if so you can maybe appeal the decision

Tomatoketchupred · 17/12/2023 12:19

thing is, You need to be working with a child of 4. You’re not likely to find a job that fits in school hours alone, with the travel to and from work and the school ect, and make the amount uc will ask of you. Find a job, and find childcare like everyone else does. Sorry I’m being blunt, do feel for you losing that money right before Christmas but, they have to have these rules. Although, I do think they could have probably done these appointments in school hours, a bit picky of them. You can apply for a hardship payment.

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 12:16

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:13

What are you trying to do? Factually she can find child care for a couple of hours if she wishes, if maybe expensive, hugely inconvenient, involve a whole day, but she can do it for occasional needs.

IF she can afford it. Benefits are a pittance and she may not have the spare cash!

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 12:14

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 12:12

I was made redundant in July and the lovely work coach made appointments for me during school hours even though my DS is 15 and comes home from school by himself! Some just seem to like being awkward for the sake of it.

Maybe they get bonuses for applying sanctions? It wouldn't surprise me.

I hope the OP takes our advice to contact her MP.

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 12:14

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/12/2023 12:11

Maybe blame the absent father than OP. It is also discrimination against single mothers because a couple can have one parent not working and not need to work because the other one earns enough to meet the couples threshold.

I don't see an issue if a mum wants to stay at home and use benefits until school age. Childcare is expensive and getting less available.

I agree and I'd be happy for my taxes to pay for it. I'm a lone working parent and the early years were stressful enough. There is much sympathy for struggling SAHMs who have husbands but the single SAHMs are called lazy despite doing ALL the parenting alone.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:13

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 12:08

OP has just moved to the area. Where I live, child minders are booked up fully. I know this because I have several friends who are child minders. What is more is that they require you to book a minimum number of hours per week for it to work for them financially.

What are you trying to do? Factually she can find child care for a couple of hours if she wishes, if maybe expensive, hugely inconvenient, involve a whole day, but she can do it for occasional needs.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:12

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/12/2023 12:11

Maybe blame the absent father than OP. It is also discrimination against single mothers because a couple can have one parent not working and not need to work because the other one earns enough to meet the couples threshold.

I don't see an issue if a mum wants to stay at home and use benefits until school age. Childcare is expensive and getting less available.

I have not blamed the op. Did you quote the wrong post? I explained the system. And I don’t know the op, I don’t know if the father is absent, alive, in another country, a sperm donor. No clue.

Beezknees · 17/12/2023 12:12

I was made redundant in July and the lovely work coach made appointments for me during school hours even though my DS is 15 and comes home from school by himself! Some just seem to like being awkward for the sake of it.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/12/2023 12:11

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:00

I agree, these days you only get to not work and be there for your child if you can afford it, or are registered as a carer. It is a luxury. It isn’t a lifestyle choice benefits will pay for. You need to work and provide. Benefits will not provide that luxury for you.

We can agree or disagree, all we like, but that’s the beginning and end of it, you are given time, now nearly approx 3.5 years all in, with 9 months unemployed, 1 year restart, 18 months post that, before benefits are stopped or forced into mandatory employment and placed. But not engaging in mandatory meetings or making yourself available for work during that process, not intensively searching for qork, not searching for work 30 hours a week and evidencing that, , will result in sanctions very very quickly , and possibly even full withdrawal of benefits. And that’s what you agree to, to get the benefits.

Maybe blame the absent father than OP. It is also discrimination against single mothers because a couple can have one parent not working and not need to work because the other one earns enough to meet the couples threshold.

I don't see an issue if a mum wants to stay at home and use benefits until school age. Childcare is expensive and getting less available.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 12:08

OP has just moved to the area. Where I live, child minders are booked up fully. I know this because I have several friends who are child minders. What is more is that they require you to book a minimum number of hours per week for it to work for them financially.

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:06

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 12:03

I'm not being 'patronising'. You said 'there are vanishingly few circumstances where wraparound care isn't available' which is rubbish. Not everyone has the same circumstances as you.

It’s not rubbish, far from it, the poster specifically said it maybe expensive or inconvenient, and it’s absolutely true. For a very rare meeting, say once a month, the op absolutely can find child care.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 12:03

I'm not being 'patronising'. You said 'there are vanishingly few circumstances where wraparound care isn't available' which is rubbish. Not everyone has the same circumstances as you.

YaWeeFurryBastard · 17/12/2023 12:01

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 11:58

My comment is relevant to the OPs post because whilst this sanction is unfair, I think the OP could potentially be further sanctioned if she continues to insist on school hours only work.

What you don't seem able to appreciate is that you can only get financial support for childcare once you have a job. Not before. So it makes sense that you would be able to work over school pick up once you have a job, because at that point you'd be able to claim support for childcare.

Um, I do appreciate that and I have clearly said the sanction seems unfair. Obviously it’s unfair since the OP can’t be expected to commit to regular childcare when she doesn’t yet know her hours. Please read my posts before trying to be patronising 🙄

Frasers · 17/12/2023 12:00

YaWeeFurryBastard · 17/12/2023 11:45

I’m sorry but “believes her daughter needs her around” just doesn’t wash when the daughter also needs to be housed, fed and clothed. I think almost everyone would like to be around more for their kids, but as adults we accept we have a duty to provide for them, even if that means making compromises. There are vanishingly few circumstances where there is no wraparound care available, if not through school than through a local childminder. Expensive or inconvenient maybe, but like many others sometimes you just have to make it work.

My comment is relevant to the OPs post because whilst this sanction is unfair, I think the OP could potentially be further sanctioned if she continues to insist on school hours only work.

I agree, these days you only get to not work and be there for your child if you can afford it, or are registered as a carer. It is a luxury. It isn’t a lifestyle choice benefits will pay for. You need to work and provide. Benefits will not provide that luxury for you.

We can agree or disagree, all we like, but that’s the beginning and end of it, you are given time, now nearly approx 3.5 years all in, with 9 months unemployed, 1 year restart, 18 months post that, before benefits are stopped or forced into mandatory employment and placed. But not engaging in mandatory meetings or making yourself available for work during that process, not intensively searching for qork, not searching for work 30 hours a week and evidencing that, , will result in sanctions very very quickly , and possibly even full withdrawal of benefits. And that’s what you agree to, to get the benefits.

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 11:58

My comment is relevant to the OPs post because whilst this sanction is unfair, I think the OP could potentially be further sanctioned if she continues to insist on school hours only work.

What you don't seem able to appreciate is that you can only get financial support for childcare once you have a job. Not before. So it makes sense that you would be able to work over school pick up once you have a job, because at that point you'd be able to claim support for childcare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread